130x130_sq_1394227499550-ashsmit

Atlantic Cake Company, LLC

Kill Devil Hills , NC
CONTACT US
CONTACT US

LOCATION

Kill Devil Hills, NC US 27948 (map)

PHONE

252-489-0522

WEBSITE

View website
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.

ABOUT US

Husband and wife cake designer and bakers who would love to work with you on your special day. We use a Swiss Meringue Buttercream that is smooth and not too sweet. Gluten free and vegan... Read more
Husband and wife cake designer and bakers who would love to work with you on your special day. We use a Swiss Meringue Buttercream that is smooth and not too sweet. Gluten free and vegan cakes are available. Cupcakes are always a fun option! Read less
Wedding Cake

PHOTOS

130x130_sq_1276642262934-dscn0379
130x130_sq_1258241088131-034
130x130_sq_1258241422459-014
130x130_sq_1258241488506-013
130x130_sq_1258241548365-083
130x130_sq_1258241622100-251
130x130_sq_1258241695381-cordell345
130x130_sq_1258306208551-007
130x130_sq_1258306247160-0132
130x130_sq_1258306293379-146
130x130_sq_1258306343754-054
130x130_sq_1258306449395-053
130x130_sq_1276642144341-halloween20093361
130x130_sq_1276642205575-znglwcz1004101752
130x130_sq_1276642227278-details001
130x130_sq_1276642264419-022
130x130_sq_1276642290997-0382
130x130_sq_1276642307544-0122
130x130_sq_1276642320059-047
130x130_sq_1344689628013-hatchcake
130x130_sq_1394495836569-rustic-beac
130x130_sq_1394495853486-navy-cupcake
130x130_sq_1394495921818-
130x130_sq_1394495930304-frui
130x130_sq_1394495939173-lac
130x130_sq_1394495948027-lime
130x130_sq_1341345912030-012
130x130_sq_1341345889753-004
130x130_sq_1341345936621-016
130x130_sq_1341345962351-020
130x130_sq_1341345981553-20120520145603313
130x130_sq_1341345987729-lilycake
130x130_sq_1341345988093-sandcake
130x130_sq_1344689487321-ashsmith
130x130_sq_1344689516213-scaglione

INFO FOR WEDDING CAKE

Besides cakes, what other types of desserts do you provide?
Cookies, Cupcakes, Groom's Cake
What additional services do you provide?
Consultations, On-site Delivery, On-site Setup, Pickup, Tastings
What dietary needs can you accommodate?
Gluten Free, Organic, Vegan
Do you provide customary cakes, such as Croquembouche?
No
Are you licensed by the state health department?
Yes
Do you offer private tastings or open house tastings?
Tastings are by appointment only.
What are your tasting hours?
For the most part 1pm-5pm daily.
Describe how you price, such as by slice or by tier, for your cakes?
Our pricing can be found on our website. www.atlanticcakecompany.com
Does the price include the top tier of the cake?
Yes, but we provide a free anniversary tier for orders exceeding $250. This cake is delivered boxed and ready for the freezer. The top tier is included in the price and the serving count.
On average, how far in advance of the event do you prepare the cake?
We try to provide the freshest cakes possible. As a general rule cakes are prepared 2 days prior to the event.
How many cakes do you schedule for a typical weekend?
We limit ourselves to 3 orders daily.
What (if any) cake accessories, such as a cake stand or cake cutter, do you rent out?
Cupcake stands.
Do you offer delivery? If yes, how much is your average delivery fee?
There is a fee that varies depending on distance. The fee schedule can be found on our website. www.atlanticcakecompany.com

REVIEWS

4.9
out of 5.0
4.9/5.0
4.9/5.0
4.8/5.0
4.9/5.0
5.0/5.0
Sort by
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kristiana
Wedding:
6/21/2014
5.0/5.0
I can never enjoy cake after our wedding because Susan's cakes set the bar incredibly high. Her cakes are absolutely amazing. The cake is moist but not soggy or overwhelmingly moist. I think what really sold us is the icing that she makes. It is a buttercream, however it's not heavy or dense like a traditional buttercream because she uses a merengue base so it's almost like a whipped cream/ buttercream mix. The icing melts in your mouth it is so good!!!

Her key lime is my favorite- I would highly recommend including this one in your cake arrangement. Susan is also the sweetest because my husband didn't get to have any of our cake at the wedding besides the bite he had when we did the cutting, and the cupcakes that were packaged for us were stolen, so I contacted Susan and she baked a dozen cupcakes I could surprise Scott. I wasn't expecting her to be able to do them because She is super busy however she had them done on the same day I had asked. She's amazing.

We did talk to other cake companies before choosing one, but Susan was the most professional and timely. Her pricing is absolutely reasonable as well, you really can't beat the value at all.
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Atlantic Cake Company, LLC responded with the following comments:

Thank you so much for the wonderful review! Sorry the cupcakes were taken (that happened to another bride last year...I guess that's a weird compliment for us) but we were happy to get you some more.
We hope your life together will be as sweet as you are!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Linda
Wedding:
6/8/2014
5.0/5.0
The wedding cake Susan made was one of the most delicious cakes we have ever had. Everyone was talking about the cake for days! We were very pleased with the whole process and even did it completely long distance. Highly recommend Susan.
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Atlantic Cake Company, LLC responded with the following comments:

Thank you for letting us be a part of your special day. We are glad we could make the process simple for you, and that you enjoyed the cake.
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lindsey
Wedding:
5/24/2014
5.0/5.0
I ordered cupcakes for my wedding rather then having a cake. The cake very moist and flavorful. Each cupcake had a different center filling and all were amazing! I was very, very pleased with the cupcakes and they're service!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Atlantic Cake Company, LLC responded with the following comments:

We are so glad to hear you were pleased!! Thank you for choosing Atlantic Cake Company!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lisa
Wedding:
5/17/2014
5.0/5.0
Susan did an amazing job on our wedding cake! It was a three tier cake for 65 people. We received so many compliments from our guests. Not only was it gorgeous, but it tasted delicious!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Atlantic Cake Company, LLC responded with the following comments:

Thank you so much! We love to make people happy on their special days.
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
Delicious cupcakes for our event, would highly recommend Atlantic Cake to other people having event @ OBX!!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Atlantic Cake Company, LLC responded with the following comments:

Thank you for letting us know you were happy with the cupcakes! We love hearing from our brides!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
sarah
Wedding:
5/2/2014
5.0/5.0
Susan was FANTASTIC to work with. We meet her at a coffee shop and right then we just knew that she was the one we wanted to make our wedding cake! She was so down to earth and easy to talk with. Her work speak for its self. The samples we had on out first meeting were absolutely AMAZING!!! We got a 3 teir beach themed cake, with the bottom teir being white cake with strwaberry filling and the top 2 teirs were red velvet cake. We got so many compliments on the cake and we had hardly any left overs. We would defianetly recommed Susan to anyone who wants a outstanding cake, who arrives early, easy to talk with, always returns your call, gives advice to help planning and is just a great individual all together!! Thanks Susan for everything!Love,
GeeJay and Sarah Clark
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Atlantic Cake Company, LLC responded with the following comments:

We were so glad to be part of your special day!! Thank you for the lovely comments.
Default-vendor-profile-pic
GARY
Wedding:
4/21/2014
5.0/5.0
We were married on April 21,2014 on the Pamlico Sound and we had the Atlantic Cake Company make our wedding cake. We live about 7 hours away so being a destination wedding we had to meet with Atlantic Cake Company in October for a cake tasting. We tasted a variety of cakes which were all awesome. It was very hard to pick a favorite. We ended up picking a wonderful chocolate cake with a peanut butter filling and a yellow butter cake with a strawberry filling. EVERYONE at the wedding raved about the cake. I can't tell you how many people came up to us and told us it was the best wedding cake they had ever tasted. It not only tasted wonderful but the cake looked exactly as the picture I had picked. A beached themed cake with beach fencing, shells, and sand perfect. Atlantic Cake Company you were a hit at our wedding and I would highly recommend this company for any occasion, Oh and we also had cupcakes for the children that were there, and there were 2 cupcakes left over and my husband and I ate them the day after the wedding around the pool at our beach house. After we each took the first bite we both looked at each other and said OMG even the cupcakes were the best You guys are the best ever. Debbie and Gary
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Atlantic Cake Company, LLC responded with the following comments:

We are so happy you guys enjoyed everything! It was our pleasure!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Elizabeth
Wedding:
4/13/2014
5.0/5.0
Cupcakes tasted awesome! Everyone at our reception loved them! So easy to work with and provided just what we needed without a lot of notice. Thank you so much!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Atlantic Cake Company, LLC responded with the following comments:

We are so glad we were able to work with you! Best wishes for a wonderful life together!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Chavaleh
Wedding:
4/4/2014
5.0/5.0
Our cake was absolutely stunning and delicious. Susan at Atlantic Cake Company was a pleasure to work with and made the entire process easy for me. She also made cupcakes for our celebration the next day. Almost 100 guests came up to me and asked who made the cupcakes!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Atlantic Cake Company, LLC responded with the following comments:

Thank you so much for the very nice compliments! It was our pleasure to work with you.
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
Atlantic Cake company was excellent in responding to my questions and helping me create the perfect wedding cake for me. I decided on a white cake with raspberry filling and white chocolate frosting along with a dozen chocolate cupcakes with raspberry filling and white chocolate frosting to accommodate my guests. The cake was decorated in a beach them with cookie sand, a fence and white chocolate seashells and the cupcakes were decorated to match the cake. The cake and cupcakes were DELICIOUS! Many comments from the guests that the cake and frosting were very very good. No wedding cake or cupcakes left over confirms it!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Atlantic Cake Company, LLC responded with the following comments:

We are so glad we were able to be part of your special day. Thank you for the nice compliment!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jessica
Wedding:
10/18/2013
5.0/5.0
We chose Atlantic Cake Company to prepare our wedding cake and they did an excellent job. We met with Susan 5 months before the wedding and she was very helpful with helping us decide what we wanted and how much cake was necessary for our small wedding. We ended up changing our mind several times and she was very accomodating to our indecisiveness. She delivered the cake on time and everyting was perfect. We chose the chocolate cake with peanut butter filling and the white chocolate cake with strawberry filling and they were both amazing. Our guests could not stop talking about how delicious the cake was. We kept the top layer for our anniversary cake and we are hoping that it will be just as tasty as it was on our wedding day. We wouold recommend Susan to anyone.
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Atlantic Cake Company, LLC responded with the following comments:

We are so glad to hear you were pleased!!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Maria
Wedding:
10/4/2013
5.0/5.0
We had a one tier cake and a few dozens of cupcakes. We had three flavors chocolate, vanilla, and key lime pie, they were very moist and tasted great! We received many compliments on the cupcakes. I would highly recommend Atlantic Cakes
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Atlantic Cake Company, LLC responded with the following comments:

It was a pleasure to work with you. Glad to hear you enjoyed the cake!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Rachael
Wedding:
9/22/2013
5.0/5.0
I wanted a bit too long to finalize cake for my wedding. Not to worry, I was amazed by the cake from Atlantic Cake Company. With a picture from pinterest, two or three emails and a description - good vanilla, some sort of fruity filling, white clean with crystal dusting sugar, fresh fruit along the tiers, I ended up with a rustic chic cake. Most importantly, it was the best cake I've ever tasted. Almost every guest complemented the cake, even the toddlers loved the fruit. I highly recommend using Atlantic Cake Company!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Atlantic Cake Company, LLC responded with the following comments:

Thanks! So glad to hear it was well received!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Katie
Wedding:
8/23/2013
5.0/5.0
I can not say enough about how amazing our wedding cake was! My husband and I had two different layers of flavors and they were both amazing!! We had so many compliments from our family and friends about the flavor and the moistness of the cake! It looked beautiful, tasted great and I would HIGHLY recommend the Atlantic Cake Company!!!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Alie
Wedding:
5/28/2013
5.0/5.0
Just needed a small 8" tier for the top of our cupcake stand. We got white chocolate cake with strawberry filling and white chocolate buttercream frosting.... It was absolutely amazing. Awesome price and it looked beautiful! very simple but exactly what we wanted and Susan was so easy to get in touch with. Would definitely recommend.
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Stephanie
Wedding:
5/19/2013
5.0/5.0
Atlantic Cake Company was amazing!!! They made the most perfect cake (beach theme) and cupcakes (key lime and vanilla) with very short notice. They were friendly, polite, professional, and everyone raved about the delicious cake!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Megan
Wedding:
5/10/2013
5.0/5.0
Thank you to Susan and Rob from Atlantic Cake Company for providing such amazing cupcakes for my wedding!!! They were quite a hit!! They were both extremely nice people and very accommodating to work with. Great prices too!! I had a variety of 4 different flavors and every single one was excellent!! Thank you again!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Elizabeth
Wedding:
1/19/2013
5.0/5.0
Atlantic Cake Company made the cupcakes for our wedding, and WOW were they incredible. We chose key lime cakes, with a lime curd filling, and buttercream icing. They were so moist, and so delicious. People were seriously stuffing them in their purses! I had people calling me the next day asking who made those amazing cupcakes! I can't say enough about Atlantic Cake Company! Our cake and cupcakes were perfect!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1316715899767-250147763824684287223602684113739376729109n
Kim
Wedding:
10/6/2012
5.0/5.0
Atlantic Cake Company did an amazing job with our wedding cake. They were able to provide a cake exactly to our specifications based on a picture. They were extremely professional in all of the communications. In order to try and accommodate all of our guests we wanted to provide options other than the wedding cake, therefore we decided to provide red velvet cupcakes and Vegan cupcakes for our Vegan guests. Atlantic Cake Company worked closely with us and provided us with all of our requested items.
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Mildred
Wedding:
8/26/2012
5.0/5.0
The cake was amazing. All the guests were ooohing and aaahhing over it. Thank you for the outstanding service and the delicious cake. I would highly recommend Atlantic Cake Company to anyone!!!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Sarah
Wedding:
8/4/2012
5.0/5.0
Everyone is still talking about how great the cupcakes were at our wedding. They looked great and tasted even better!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Elizabeth
Wedding:
7/26/2012
5.0/5.0
Susan and Rob were excellent to work with from start to finish! Their prices are great, yet the quality of their work is amazing. My husband and I are not especially sweet eaters, but our cake and cupcakes were so absolutely delicious they had us both going back for seconds. Very professional, I had no worries about them delivering our cake and setting it up, they came and did it without needing any help from me or my husband. 100% recommend working with Atlantic cake company!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kelly
Wedding:
6/13/2012
5.0/5.0
The BEST wedding cupcakes ever! Our guests commeted on how nice our cupcakes were and they not only tasted wonderful, but they photographed well (LOL). May I recommend the coconut flavored cake with pineapple filling?!!! YUUUUMMMMY!!! We have nothing but GREAT things to say about the Atlantic Cake Company! We are looking forward to celebrating our anniversary down in Corolla again and of course we plan on ordering from them! You will not be disappointed!!!!!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
HeatherHartman
Wedding:
5/20/2012
5.0/5.0
Susan is very sweet and easy to work and communicate with. She is willing to customize the cake so that it is exactly what you want for your special day. Everyone LOVED the way that the cake looked, and tasted! I would highly recommend going with this company for your wedding or other event!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
sanstis
Wedding:
5/18/2012
5.0/5.0
We drove 8 hours for this cake tasting - that's how important the cake was to us! Susan was always willing to help. Hands down the best wedding cake I have ever had. We ordered way too much so we ate it for a week after our honeymoon and can't wait to eat our anniversary tier next year!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
MSG05122012
Wedding:
5/12/2012
5.0/5.0
Our cake was GREAT!! Susan and Rob were great to work with! Many of our guests said our cake was the best wedding cake they had ever had!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jamie
Wedding:
11/19/2011
5.0/5.0
Susan was great to work with! She promised me a wonderful cake and she delivered one! It was so beautiful and helped make the wedding wonderful!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Emily
Wedding:
11/12/2011
5.0/5.0
Susan at The Atlantic Cake Company was a dream to work with. We met with Susan for a tasting and to discuss cake design. She was very professional, the cake we tasted was delicious and the flavor choices were unique (loved the key lime). The cake turned out EXACTLY as we asked design-wise, and it tasted delicious. Many of our guests let us know how much they liked the cake with one family member telling us they had 3 slices. We loved working with Susan, loved the final results, and thought the pricing was very reasonable.
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
sharonwhitleync1
Wedding:
10/15/2011
5.0/5.0
My cousin Susan is the owner of this company. She did the cake for my neice's wedding a year ago. The cake was delicious so I knew she had to do the cake for my daughter. They were able to do the taste testing with multiple choices and decided on three different cakes and fillers. My favorite was the chocolate cake with the peanutbutter filling! We wanted a different cake pan than what she had in stock and she was very willing to do what we requested. The cake was beautiful and it was the best tasting wedding cake I have ever had.
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Colleen Radigan Rose
Wedding:
9/20/2011
5.0/5.0
Sue Rollason was very helpful, and very creative. We met her for a tasting, and she was able to meet on a Sunday to work with our tight window of time in the area. Her cakes for the wedding were beautiful, and very tasty! Everyone was complimenting us on the cakes! I would recommend her for whatever cake needs you have.
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jenna
Wedding:
9/18/2011
5.0/5.0
Susan with Atlantic Cakes was AMAZING! She responded quickly, worked within my budget, and worked with every idea I threw at her. I LOVED my cake...it turned out so unique and I had so many people say how good it was. We got white chocolate cake with a strawberry filling and butter cream frosting and it was so amazing. It was fluffy, and moist and the perfect amount of sweet.

Susan is a very down to Earth woman and was sweet enough to meet up with us the day before the wedding in her home in OBX. Our cake was actually unique because it had a small fishbowl in the middle of it with a beta fish (we got married at a Fishing Pier). It was kind of sprung on her fairly last minute, and she worked with it and it turned out so fun.

We will definitely be going back to her whenever we are in OBX to get white chocolate cupcakes...they are my fav! :)
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
JSC
Wedding:
5/28/2010
5.0/5.0
The cake for our wedding was delicious, even better than we had expected! Susan was incredibly easy to work with, even though we chose an unconventional combination of flavors (Key Lime with Orange Creme). Highly, highly recommended.
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lauren
Wedding:
10/23/2009
5.0/5.0
YUM is all I have to say! Their cake was delicious - most of our guests took 2 pieces at our wedding and Susan was a complete pleasure to work with. We have already decided that whenever we are in Nags Head, we are going to order a cake from her. I highly recommend Atlantic Cake Company :)
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
keshaprim
Wedding:
9/18/2009
5.0/5.0
Susan and her cake was Amazing! Upon meeting her I was not sure what to expect never being married before but she made me feel so comfortable and her cakes just melt in your mouth! It was like a little piece of heaven in your mouth =) She followed up with us throughout the planning and did everything she promised! I will refer her to anyone! And her prices were AFFORDABLE especially for what you get from her! Thanks Susan!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Devin
Wedding:
6/5/2009
5.0/5.0
Atlantic Cakes was wonderful. Our guests commented that we had the best wedding cake design they had ever seen and it was delicious. We can't wait for our 1 year anniversary to have some of our cake again! I'd definitely choose Atlantic Cakes, Susan was profressioinal and affordable.
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
clangston
Wedding:
5/19/2009
5.0/5.0
Susan of Atlantic Cake Company baked and decorated the cake for our May 19th wedding in the Outer Banks, NC. Not only was it beautifully decorated -- better than my high expectations -- but everyone agreed that it was the most delicious, moist cake. I highly recommend working with Atlantic Cake, and can't wait to have the final piece of cake on our anniversary!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
jmleggett
Wedding:
4/25/2009
5.0/5.0
We met with Atlantic Cakes intially for a tasting and to decide on the groom's cake. Their prices were quite reasonable. Their e-mail communication was excellent. We had no worries. The cake was delivered on time. Most important, it was delicious.
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kathy
Wedding:
4/4/2009
4.9/5.0
We enjoyed the graciousness of the Atlkantic Cake Company and the final results were awesome!

Sincerely,
Kathy Bowman Sawyer
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bg9
Jeremy + Carina
Wedding:
6/28/2014
4.8/5.0
We loved our adorable custom wedding cake from Atlantic Cake. They were flexible with a special request we had and delivered exactly what we requested. Wedding cakes are expensive, that's just that, so we got creative and they worked with us to make sure we got the look we wanted but stayed in the budget we needed to. I would highly recommend their services!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Atlantic Cake Company, LLC responded with the following comments:

We were happy to be a part of your day, and glad we could work within your budget. It's nice to hear it was enjoyed!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Devon
Wedding:
9/3/2013
4.8/5.0
I had a one tier beach themed cake with 5 dozen cupcakes. We had two flavors including chocolate truffle with peanut butter filling and white chocolate with strawberry filling.They tasted great and we received many complements on the cupcakes.The only thing was I did ask to have our initials written in brown sugar on the table, but that was not done. No big deal, it looked great and tasted even better. Susan was pleasant and easy to work with.
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Katherine
Wedding:
9/17/2012
4.8/5.0
We ordered a cupcake wedding cake from Atlantic Cake Company and were absolutely thrilled with what we got! The specially decorated bride & groom cupcakes were adorable and just what we wanted. I HIGHLY recommend their truffle cake- it was advertised as "award-winning" so we had high expectations and this cake absolutely delivered! The butter cream icing was deliciously light and understated (ours was raspberry- so good! and pretty) and just right for our outdoor reception. I would absolutely recommend this company to any bride in the OBX.
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
frandunn
Wedding:
9/16/2009
4.8/5.0
The cupcakes I had done for for my wedding cake were absolutely delicious! It turned out exactly like I wanted. And we had plenty for all of my guests and then some! The only thing I noticed, and it was not really an issue at all, the cupcakes were a little smaller than I had imagined. But we never discussed how big they were going to be so that was my own fault. I would highly recommend Atlantic Cake Company... their Key Lime filling is to die for!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Elizabeth
Wedding:
6/27/2014
4.6/5.0
We used ACC for our rehearsal dinner cake and our reception. Susan's cakes are delicious! We had chocolate truffle and chocolate chips with a mousse filling. Everyone loved the cakes, she delivered on time and with a military discount too!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Atlantic Cake Company, LLC responded with the following comments:

We are always honored to work with those who choose to serve our country. Glad to hear the cake was a "sweet" part of your day.
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
4.6/5.0
The cupcakes for our wedding were amazing! We had 4 different flavors which was fun for everyone. Our guests enjoyed being able to mix things up! Chocolate cake with peanut butter filling and buttercream frosting was a definite favorite! :)
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Michael
Wedding:
8/14/2012
4.5/5.0
We chose Atlantic Cake Company before we did the tasting but it turned out great! Susan was very easy to contact and was great at the tasting! We we easily able to change things with our cake a few weeks before and Susan was always helpful. We chose a ribbon design with beach theme and it came out beautiful. Everyone enjoyed the cake and we had plenty extra for the rest of the week, and then our anniversary tier to take home! Our cake was white chocolate in 2 tiers and red velvet in the other and both were great!
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Liza
Wedding:
5/24/2012
3.8/5.0
After ordering our custom rehearsal dinner cake and wedding cake, we feel they were both a good value.
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Atlantic Cake Company, LLC responded with the following comments:

I contacted this bride to see how we could have better met her needs. This is the email we received.
Susan -

I'm sorry for the review. Maybe I took it too seriously, or was too tough of a critic - that's normal for me :)

It seems our 'responsiveness' gauges are different. Most other wedding vendors responded within the same day; you didn't always. But no worries, maybe you had a full plate at the time.

Overall, I would most definitely use Atlantic Cake Company again, and would recommend you to others as a good value. You were flexible with pricing and working with our budget.

I hope this helps.
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jon & Julene
Wedding:
6/11/2014
3.0/5.0
We chose Atlantic Cake Company based on reading several glowing customer reviews as well as their reasonable prices. Ultimately, though, we have learned that you do in fact sometimes "get what you pay for". Image 1 below is the photo included with our cake proposal (though we ordered it in a two-tiered version due to the small size of our wedding). Image 2 is a photo of the cake we received. As you can see, the two hardly resemble each other. We feel that we received a lower quality version of the cake we requested. The white chocolate shells were haphazardly placed all over the cake, rather than delicately placed against the fencing, per the cake from our proposal. Wedding cakes are a main focal point of any wedding day, and we did not feel that our cake was given the time/care to make it as special as the rest of our day.

Another issue that we had was the flavor, or rather the lack of. We ordered one tier key lime with lime curd filling and the other layer was white chocolate with raspberry filling. Both layers tasted more like plain white cake... good white cake, but white cake nonetheless (general consensus). Based on other reviews, we had expected the cake to be much more flavorful. I was also disappointed that the fillings were very minimal, but when I contacted the vendor, she did explain that the icing dam is usually 1-1.5" per tier... the only problem with that explanation is that the icing dam on our cake was more like 2-2.5", leaving only a small area with paper-thin filling.

When I contacted the vendor, she DID respond quickly but I felt somewhat blown off by her response. Overall, I was extremely disappointed in the cake we received. Had I known the cake would have come out so poorly, I would have spent the extra money to go with one of the other companies that I had gotten a quote from. If the price seems to good to be true, it probably is.

http://www.pinterest.com/pin/570479477768761177/

http://www.pinterest.com/pin/570479477771863222/
Services Used: Wedding Cake

MAP

 
Kill Devil Hills, NC 27948 See On Map
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for Atlantic Cake Company, LLC
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww_logo
 
220x220_1394227499550-ashsmit