Nophoto 130

Bake My Day

Green Bay , WI

LOCATION

Green Bay, WI US
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Wedding Cake

REVIEWS

4.8
out of 5.0
4.7/5.0
4.7/5.0
5.0/5.0
4.5/5.0
4.9/5.0
Sort by
Default vendor profile pic
Brianna
Wedding:
10/4/2014
4.4/5.0
Two weeks before the wedding, I found out that our baker wasn't allowed to bring cake into our venue d/t not having a bakery license. I wasn't familiar with any bakeries in Green Bay, so I called the first one that showed up on google- Bake my Day. Joan answered the phone and immediately said that she would be able to help us out. She had me email her some photos of cakes that I liked and she called me back within the hour and we designed our wedding cake over the phone. Most of the cakes that I really loved were made with fondant and Joan said that she wasn't able to do fondant. I felt like $575 for a cake for 150 people was kind of a lot of money for a buttercreme frosted cake, but I am very thankful for the immediate response and service that Joan provided me. The cake did look very nice. One of my wedding coordinators came up to us and stated that our cake was the best compared to the other 2 weddings that were going on that day. The vanilla cake was my favorite! In order to get $50 back, we had to take back the cake plate and stand, which was easy enough, but one of the last things we wanted to worry about. Joan was nice enough to give us her home address since the bakery was closed on the day were leaving Green Bay to go back home 3 hours away. Thanks Bake My Day!
Two weeks before the wedding, I found out that our baker wasn't allowed to bring cake into our venue d/t not having a Read more...
Two weeks before the wedding, I found out that our baker wasn't allowed to bring cake into our venue d/t not having a bakery license. I wasn't familiar with any bakeries in Green Bay, so I called the first one that showed up on google- Bake my Day. Joan answered the phone and immediately said that she would be able to help us out. She had me email her some photos of cakes that I liked and she called me back within the hour and we designed our wedding cake over the phone. Most of the cakes that I really loved were made with fondant and Joan said that she wasn't able to do fondant. I felt like $575 for a cake for 150 people was kind of a lot of money for a buttercreme frosted cake, but I am very thankful for the immediate response and service that Joan provided me. The cake did look very nice. One of my wedding coordinators came up to us and stated that our cake was the best compared to the other 2 weddings that were going on that day. The vanilla cake was my favorite! In order to get $50 back, we had to take back the cake plate and stand, which was easy enough, but one of the last things we wanted to worry about. Joan was nice enough to give us her home address since the bakery was closed on the day were leaving Green Bay to go back home 3 hours away. Thanks Bake My Day! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Ryan
Wedding:
6/15/2013
3.6/5.0
The cake tasted very good. The design on our cake was not very creative we allowed the designer to do whatever around a fish theme and all there she had were some small fish on the side.
The cake tasted very good. The design on our cake was not very creative we allowed the designer to do whatever around a Read more...
The cake tasted very good. The design on our cake was not very creative we allowed the designer to do whatever around a fish theme and all there she had were some small fish on the side. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
jordonknier
Wedding:
9/17/2011
4.8/5.0
Had a unique cake decoration that Bake My Day recreated for us with ease. Cake was fresh.
Had a unique cake decoration that Bake My Day recreated for us with ease. Cake was fresh.
Had a unique cake decoration that Bake My Day recreated for us with ease. Cake was fresh. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Nicole
Wedding:
9/10/2011
5.0/5.0
I brought in two photos, one of a three tiered cake and one from my grandmother's wedding cake. They did an amazing job of combining the two and making them in our wedding colors. They matched the buttercream frosting to our bridesmaid dresses and I brought in the ribbon and cake topper and our florist delivered the flowers right to the bakery.

They have so many flavors and they are all delicious!

They are the most affordable in Green Bay and were so great to work with.

We got so many compliments on how good the cake was and where we got the cake.

Worth every penny!
I brought in two photos, one of a three tiered cake and one from my grandmother's wedding cake. They did an amazing job of Read more...
I brought in two photos, one of a three tiered cake and one from my grandmother's wedding cake. They did an amazing job of combining the two and making them in our wedding colors. They matched the buttercream frosting to our bridesmaid dresses and I brought in the ribbon and cake topper and our florist delivered the flowers right to the bakery.

They have so many flavors and they are all delicious!

They are the most affordable in Green Bay and were so great to work with.

We got so many compliments on how good the cake was and where we got the cake.

Worth every penny! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
bpophal
Wedding:
7/31/2010
5.0/5.0
We were very pleased with how our cake turned out. We asked for a 3 tier square cake with butter cream frosting. However, we wanted the frosting to be smooth so that it had a fondant look. I dropped off ribbon and flowers to be placed on the cake and told them to place them how they'd like. They did a fantastic job and I got so many compliments on how great our cake looked.

Our cake was made to serve 225 people and it only cost us a grand total of $370 (there was a $50 fee added on originally that you got back when you brought back the cake board). In addition to the 3 tier cake, we had a sheet cake in the back.

The one thing I loved about their cakes was the different flavors you could have. Every wedding I've gone to has had lemon poppyseed, white, chocolate, etc. We ended up choosing orange, cherry, and amaretto. Every single flavor was absolutely awesome, specifically the cherry. I would highly recommend it!
We were very pleased with how our cake turned out. We asked for a 3 tier square cake with butter cream frosting. However, Read more...
We were very pleased with how our cake turned out. We asked for a 3 tier square cake with butter cream frosting. However, we wanted the frosting to be smooth so that it had a fondant look. I dropped off ribbon and flowers to be placed on the cake and told them to place them how they'd like. They did a fantastic job and I got so many compliments on how great our cake looked.

Our cake was made to serve 225 people and it only cost us a grand total of $370 (there was a $50 fee added on originally that you got back when you brought back the cake board). In addition to the 3 tier cake, we had a sheet cake in the back.

The one thing I loved about their cakes was the different flavors you could have. Every wedding I've gone to has had lemon poppyseed, white, chocolate, etc. We ended up choosing orange, cherry, and amaretto. Every single flavor was absolutely awesome, specifically the cherry. I would highly recommend it! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Katie
Wedding:
5/2/2009
5.0/5.0
This cake was absolutely to die for! Great taste. Great service. Joan was so easy to work with and very helpful when deciding how big of a cake to get based upon the guest list! Reasonable prices for such a delicious product! Thank you!
This cake was absolutely to die for! Great taste. Great service. Joan was so easy to work with and very helpful when Read more...
This cake was absolutely to die for! Great taste. Great service. Joan was so easy to work with and very helpful when deciding how big of a cake to get based upon the guest list! Reasonable prices for such a delicious product! Thank you! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
CHUCK
Wedding:
7/4/2008
5.0/5.0
THE MOST DELICIOUS, MOIST, YUMMY CAKE I HAVE EVER TASTED. THE ICING WAS SMOOTH AS SILK.
THE MOST DELICIOUS, MOIST, YUMMY CAKE I HAVE EVER TASTED. THE ICING WAS SMOOTH AS SILK.
THE MOST DELICIOUS, MOIST, YUMMY CAKE I HAVE EVER TASTED. THE ICING WAS SMOOTH AS SILK. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Stephanie
Wedding:
5/17/2008
5.0/5.0
These folks are exceptionally easy to work with!!!
These folks are exceptionally easy to work with!!!
These folks are exceptionally easy to work with!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Sharon
Wedding:
4/12/2008
5.0/5.0
Bake My Day did a great job on our cake. Their price is reasonable and the cake was beautiful. After tasting many other cakes at a couple of wedding shows here in Green Bay, I can honestly say their cakes taste better than everyone else's. I would highly recommend the lemon poppyseed... Fantastic!
Bake My Day did a great job on our cake. Their price is reasonable and the cake was beautiful. After tasting many other Read more...
Bake My Day did a great job on our cake. Their price is reasonable and the cake was beautiful. After tasting many other cakes at a couple of wedding shows here in Green Bay, I can honestly say their cakes taste better than everyone else's. I would highly recommend the lemon poppyseed... Fantastic! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
emd1212
Wedding:
9/9/2006
4.8/5.0
The cake was delicious. There are so many flavors and so many designs to choose from. Bake My Day's prices are very affordable. They have over 35 years of experience.
The cake was delicious. There are so many flavors and so many designs to choose from. Bake My Day's prices are very Read more...
The cake was delicious. There are so many flavors and so many designs to choose from. Bake My Day's prices are very affordable. They have over 35 years of experience. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for Bake My Day
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww logo
Nophoto 220