Nophoto 130

Ben Garelick Jewelers

Williamsville , NY

LOCATION

Williamsville, NY US

WEBSITE

View website
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Jewelry

REVIEWS

5.0
out of 5.0
5.0/5.0
5.0/5.0
5.0/5.0
5.0/5.0
4.9/5.0
Sort by
Default vendor profile pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
My Fiance and I went shopping for engagement rings and Ben Garelick was the last jewelry shop we stopped at. It was by far the best experience out of all the shops we had been too. We were greeted right away and they gave us time to walk around and browse without feeling pressured or hovering over us. Then Peter Sr. came down and asked what I liked. I was more into the vintage styled pieces, which they had a great selection of. So after I narrowed it down to two rings he really let me take a closer look with the microscope. I told him I really loved Oval shaped diamonds, so he brought out different loose oval diamonds in different sizes. We were also able to take a closer look at them. All of their diamonds are GIA certified and came with the certificate when you bought it, which was extremely important to us. That way we knew exactly what diamond we were buying. Overall, Peter Sr. was amazing and extremely accommodating and helpful. I got the ring of my dreams and can't wait to go back and get our wedding bands!
My Fiance and I went shopping for engagement rings and Ben Garelick was the last jewelry shop we stopped at. It was by far Read more...
My Fiance and I went shopping for engagement rings and Ben Garelick was the last jewelry shop we stopped at. It was by far the best experience out of all the shops we had been too. We were greeted right away and they gave us time to walk around and browse without feeling pressured or hovering over us. Then Peter Sr. came down and asked what I liked. I was more into the vintage styled pieces, which they had a great selection of. So after I narrowed it down to two rings he really let me take a closer look with the microscope. I told him I really loved Oval shaped diamonds, so he brought out different loose oval diamonds in different sizes. We were also able to take a closer look at them. All of their diamonds are GIA certified and came with the certificate when you bought it, which was extremely important to us. That way we knew exactly what diamond we were buying. Overall, Peter Sr. was amazing and extremely accommodating and helpful. I got the ring of my dreams and can't wait to go back and get our wedding bands! Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default vendor profile pic
Private User
Wedding:
7/9/2016
5.0/5.0
So my engagement ring was very hard to match, and I really wanted my ring to look unique. This place had some amazing designs, and there were so many to choose from! the service was very friendly, and dealt with me going back and forth between different options. In the end I choose an amazing ring & their service is amazing! Got my ring in no time, and we also ended up getting my husbands ring there as well. Such great variety for mens rings as well!
So my engagement ring was very hard to match, and I really wanted my ring to look unique. This place had some amazing Read more...
So my engagement ring was very hard to match, and I really wanted my ring to look unique. This place had some amazing designs, and there were so many to choose from! the service was very friendly, and dealt with me going back and forth between different options. In the end I choose an amazing ring & their service is amazing! Got my ring in no time, and we also ended up getting my husbands ring there as well. Such great variety for mens rings as well! Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default vendor profile pic
Maria
Wedding:
9/5/2015
5.0/5.0
Ben Garelick Jewelers was great! My (now) husband and I were looking for a specific ring and couldn't find it in the DC area where we live. We went to stores in Maryland and Virginia and not only did they not carry it, they couldn't even it order it.

I found out that the ring brand was carried at Ben Garelick and was so happy, since I'm from and was getting married in Buffalo. I emailed them and they were very responsive and helpful and they had in the ring in store! They put it on hold for me as I was coming to Buffalo in a few days. In person they were also wonderful. We also got the best price on the ring compared to anywhere else we looked. I love love love the ring. Highly recommend!
Ben Garelick Jewelers was great! My (now) husband and I were looking for a specific ring and couldn't find it in the DC Read more...
Ben Garelick Jewelers was great! My (now) husband and I were looking for a specific ring and couldn't find it in the DC area where we live. We went to stores in Maryland and Virginia and not only did they not carry it, they couldn't even it order it.

I found out that the ring brand was carried at Ben Garelick and was so happy, since I'm from and was getting married in Buffalo. I emailed them and they were very responsive and helpful and they had in the ring in store! They put it on hold for me as I was coming to Buffalo in a few days. In person they were also wonderful. We also got the best price on the ring compared to anywhere else we looked. I love love love the ring. Highly recommend! Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default vendor profile pic
Melissa
Wedding:
5/15/2015
5.0/5.0
Loved working with Peter Sr. at Ben Garelick!! He is very helpful and kind. He helped us feel at ease in that we would be taken care of. I will definitely be returning! Thank you, Peter!!!

Also, the staff there are very professional and quick! Kate helped me figure out what to engrave on my husband's wedding band and was very patient and understanding. Thank you, Kate!!
Loved working with Peter Sr. at Ben Garelick!! He is very helpful and kind. He helped us feel at ease in that we would be Read more...
Loved working with Peter Sr. at Ben Garelick!! He is very helpful and kind. He helped us feel at ease in that we would be taken care of. I will definitely be returning! Thank you, Peter!!!

Also, the staff there are very professional and quick! Kate helped me figure out what to engrave on my husband's wedding band and was very patient and understanding. Thank you, Kate!! Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default vendor profile pic
Jennifer
Wedding:
11/5/2012
5.0/5.0
I have purchased from this business for many years. Peter Sr is amazing and is always attentive to my needs and wants. He listens to what I have to say about my desires, presents beautiful jewelry, provides his advice and is not pushy. I can honestly say that he is a gentleman jeweler.
I have purchased from this business for many years. Peter Sr is amazing and is always attentive to my needs and wants. He Read more...
I have purchased from this business for many years. Peter Sr is amazing and is always attentive to my needs and wants. He listens to what I have to say about my desires, presents beautiful jewelry, provides his advice and is not pushy. I can honestly say that he is a gentleman jeweler. Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Wwnetwork 128
Dycha
Wedding:
6/26/2010
4.8/5.0
Outstanding selection and superior service and quality. We purchased some items as gifts and everyone's eyes popped. The looks were priceless. Very satisfied and would return as the need arises. Christopher Dycha
Outstanding selection and superior service and quality. We purchased some items as gifts and everyone's eyes popped. The Read more...
Outstanding selection and superior service and quality. We purchased some items as gifts and everyone's eyes popped. The looks were priceless. Very satisfied and would return as the need arises. Christopher Dycha Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
130x130 sq 1232207118640 img 1912
Nicole
Wedding:
8/29/2009
4.9/5.0
My engagement ring is beautiful. It is a simon G which was discontinued but they had one made for me. I get so many compliments on it!
My engagement ring is beautiful. It is a simon G which was discontinued but they had one made for me. I get so many Read more...
My engagement ring is beautiful. It is a simon G which was discontinued but they had one made for me. I get so many compliments on it! Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default vendor profile pic
Monalisa
Wedding:
6/6/2009
5.0/5.0
Ben Garelick came highly recommended by my brother-in-law. My husband & I went there to look at engagement rings & learn more about diamonds. When we entered the showroom we were treated like guests instead of customers. Champagne & sweets were served as we browsed. I finally told my husband that the setting didn't matter it was a quality diamond that I wanted. So he went back & talked to Pete Jr & on Christmas Eve the question was popped in church with a beautiful marquis diamond solitaire. When it came time to pick out the bands we went back to Ben Garelick's who were having a sale before their renovation. We picked out two very beautiful rings & put them on layaway. Everytime we went into the showroom to pay on our rings Pete Jr. or Pete Sr. cleaned my engagement ring. The service we recieved at Ben Garelick's was superb.
Ben Garelick came highly recommended by my brother-in-law. My husband & I went there to look at engagement rings & learn Read more...
Ben Garelick came highly recommended by my brother-in-law. My husband & I went there to look at engagement rings & learn more about diamonds. When we entered the showroom we were treated like guests instead of customers. Champagne & sweets were served as we browsed. I finally told my husband that the setting didn't matter it was a quality diamond that I wanted. So he went back & talked to Pete Jr & on Christmas Eve the question was popped in church with a beautiful marquis diamond solitaire. When it came time to pick out the bands we went back to Ben Garelick's who were having a sale before their renovation. We picked out two very beautiful rings & put them on layaway. Everytime we went into the showroom to pay on our rings Pete Jr. or Pete Sr. cleaned my engagement ring. The service we recieved at Ben Garelick's was superb. Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Bg5
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
5.0/5.0
My family has been going to Ben Garelick's for years, so there was no doubt that my engagement ring and our bands would be purchased there. They have a beautiful selection and the staff is wonderful. They go above and beyond for their customers!
My family has been going to Ben Garelick's for years, so there was no doubt that my engagement ring and our bands would be Read more...
My family has been going to Ben Garelick's for years, so there was no doubt that my engagement ring and our bands would be purchased there. They have a beautiful selection and the staff is wonderful. They go above and beyond for their customers! Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default vendor profile pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
5.0/5.0
I got my engagement ring from Ben Garelick and we will soon get our wedding rings. This was by far the best jeweler I found! the staff is always friendly, courteous, and they really work with you on price and finding something perfect!
I got my engagement ring from Ben Garelick and we will soon get our wedding rings. This was by far the best jeweler I Read more...
I got my engagement ring from Ben Garelick and we will soon get our wedding rings. This was by far the best jeweler I found! the staff is always friendly, courteous, and they really work with you on price and finding something perfect! Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for Ben Garelick Jewelers
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww logo
Nophoto 220