130x130_sq_1375822499566-gumpaste-flower-cascade-email

Bethel Bakery

Bethel Park , PA
CONTACT US
CONTACT US

LOCATION

5200 Brightwood Road
Bethel Park, PA US 15102 (map)

PHONE

412-835-6658

WEBSITE

View website
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.

ABOUT US

Bethel Bakery is a family owned bakery that has been baking special memories for over 58 years. With our signature French Buttercream icing, moist cake, and high quality service, we are... Read more
Bethel Bakery is a family owned bakery that has been baking special memories for over 58 years. With our signature French Buttercream icing, moist cake, and high quality service, we are greatly recognized as "The Cake Place." We offer dessert cakes, individual cakes, and cakes for all occasions, however, wedding cakes enable us to become part of a very special occasion. We have cake styles from simple, elegant, and traditional to whimsical and fun. Having graciously attended thousands of wedding celebrations, we look forward to the opportunity of being a part of yours.





Contact us today! 412-835-6658 ext 4 wedding@bethelbakery.com Read less
Wedding Cake

PHOTOS

130x130_sq_1375821856955-gumpaste-flower-cascade-email
130x130_sq_1375819176637-diamonds-and-pearls-email
130x130_sq_1375819210077-dsc0041
130x130_sq_1375822218144-ombre---fondant-email
130x130_sq_1375819324179-glitz-and-glamour-email
130x130_sq_1375819366673-hannah-purple-flowers
130x130_sq_1375820936797-dsc0081
130x130_sq_1375822189997-ombre-buttercream
130x130_sq_1375819567366-mia-white-background
130x130_sq_1375819481294-lacey2email
130x130_sq_1375819715529-moonlight-email
130x130_sq_1375819746510-pristine-album
130x130_sq_1375820040603-small-splendor-scrollwork---gold
130x130_sq_1375822389398-skyline-email
130x130_sq_1375819901762-dsc0036
130x130_sq_1375820239195-trinity-email
130x130_sq_1375820290918-ashley-email
130x130_sq_1375820315448-dsc0103
130x130_sq_1375820389810-claire-3-tier
130x130_sq_1375820408762-classic
130x130_sq_1375820450230-elizabeth
130x130_sq_1375820515182-glitz-and-glamour-3-tier
130x130_sq_1375820575538-glitz-glamour-and-mini-rose
130x130_sq_1375820644014-hannah-email
130x130_sq_1375820665808-helena
130x130_sq_1375820715097-mia-blue-scroll-collage
130x130_sq_1375820735153-mia-new-fall
130x130_sq_1375820797359-peacock2
130x130_sq_1375820834870-ruffled-email
130x130_sq_1375820848904-sienna-4-tier
130x130_sq_1375820891311-snowflake
130x130_sq_1375819986030-stardust-email
130x130_sq_1375821014539-dsc0061
130x130_sq_1375821139572-julianna-email
130x130_sq_1375821178533-roses-overall
130x130_sq_1375821272074-rosalina-email
130x130_sq_1375821289411-mia-gold-background-email
130x130_sq_1375821376771-anna
130x130_sq_1375821645902-buttercream-rosette-email
130x130_sq_1375822204249-ombre-design-in-all-white-email
130x130_sq_1375821681118-flower-garden2
130x130_sq_1375821771842-fondant-hearts
130x130_sq_1375821834300-glitz-and-glamour-royal-blue-1
130x130_sq_1375821902142-dsc0092
130x130_sq_1375819538211-dsc0112
130x130_sq_1375821994002-lacey-pink-and-grey
130x130_sq_1375822239419-dsc0137
130x130_sq_1375822125640-dsc0014
130x130_sq_1375822291693-pretty-petals-email
130x130_sq_1375822304652-twice-as-nice-email
130x130_sq_1375822332182-mia
130x130_sq_1375822392711-white-choc-curls-email
130x130_sq_1375822412556-ring-of-roses-email
130x130_sq_1375822398701-splendor-small-scroll-email
130x130_sq_1375822422224-timeless-round-square-email
130x130_sq_1353014181490-groomscakewithstrawemail
130x130_sq_1353014183817-groomscaketraditional
130x130_sq_1353014054034-dsc0022
130x130_sq_1353014078985-baseballtopemail
130x130_sq_1353014097740-crabsandandbeer
130x130_sq_1353014138462-hoagiecake
130x130_sq_1353014162872-golftheme2tier
130x130_sq_1352477464303-dsc0008
130x130_sq_1352477466389-dsc0028
130x130_sq_1352477462923-dsc0031
130x130_sq_1352477465389-dsc0032

INFO FOR WEDDING CAKE

Besides cakes, what other types of desserts do you provide?
Cookies, Cupcakes, Dessert Buffet, Groom's Cake, Pastries
What additional services do you provide?
Consultations, On-site Delivery, On-site Setup, Pickup, Tastings
Do you provide customary cakes, such as Croquembouche?
Yes
Are you licensed by the state health department?
Yes

REVIEWS

4.8
out of 5.0
4.8/5.0
4.9/5.0
4.9/5.0
4.7/5.0
4.9/5.0
Sort by
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Amanda
Wedding:
8/30/2014
5.0/5.0
Bethel Bakery created my dream cake! Our consultation was so easy. All I needed was to show a few ideas that I had, and they were able to find a way to make it work. I really did not even think that I would love the way the cake looked as much as I did. It fit my "peaches and countryside" theme perfectly. It also tasted amazing. It was so fluffy and not too rich to where it felt heavy and nauseating. It was so good that I definitely did not care about my lactose intolerance on my wedding day and made sure to have two pieces. Thank you Bethel!
Bethel Bakery created my dream cake! Our consultation was so easy. All I needed was to show a few ideas that I had, and Read more...
Bethel Bakery created my dream cake! Our consultation was so easy. All I needed was to show a few ideas that I had, and they were able to find a way to make it work. I really did not even think that I would love the way the cake looked as much as I did. It fit my "peaches and countryside" theme perfectly. It also tasted amazing. It was so fluffy and not too rich to where it felt heavy and nauseating. It was so good that I definitely did not care about my lactose intolerance on my wedding day and made sure to have two pieces. Thank you Bethel! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for your sweet and kind review! It was a pleasure working with you, too, and we couldn't be more thrilled that you enjoyed the look and taste of your cake! Congratulations and best wishes!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Emily
Wedding:
8/16/2014
5.0/5.0
Bethel Bakery was very helpful with any questions we had during our cake decision making process. They offered suggestions about what would be best for the cake included in our wedding package. The cake tasting was amazing! The cakes were so delicious, we had a really hard time picking just one! We loved that the cakes are made with three batters so we got to include all our favorites! Our cake was beautiful!
Bethel Bakery was very helpful with any questions we had during our cake decision making process. They offered suggestions Read more...
Bethel Bakery was very helpful with any questions we had during our cake decision making process. They offered suggestions about what would be best for the cake included in our wedding package. The cake tasting was amazing! The cakes were so delicious, we had a really hard time picking just one! We loved that the cakes are made with three batters so we got to include all our favorites! Our cake was beautiful! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kristen
Wedding:
8/9/2014
5.0/5.0
The team at Bethel Bakery was incredible to work with and they truly made the perfect cake. They worked with me to find the perfect icing color since I wanted a royal blue. They were also extremely flexible because I changed the design multiple times until it was perfect. The staff was very nice and they created a beautiful cake that we received many compliments on. The almond wedding cake with strawberry filling was delicious!! I would strongly recommend them for any occasion!
The team at Bethel Bakery was incredible to work with and they truly made the perfect cake. They worked with me to find Read more...
The team at Bethel Bakery was incredible to work with and they truly made the perfect cake. They worked with me to find the perfect icing color since I wanted a royal blue. They were also extremely flexible because I changed the design multiple times until it was perfect. The staff was very nice and they created a beautiful cake that we received many compliments on. The almond wedding cake with strawberry filling was delicious!! I would strongly recommend them for any occasion! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for your glowing review! We very much appreciate your kind words and appreciate being included in your big day! Congratulations and best wishes!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lindsay
Wedding:
8/2/2014
5.0/5.0
The detail work on my cake was incredible and more than I ever expected! And it was delicious!! I would recommend them to anyone!
The detail work on my cake was incredible and more than I ever expected! And it was delicious!! I would recommend them to Read more...
The detail work on my cake was incredible and more than I ever expected! And it was delicious!! I would recommend them to anyone! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Laura
Wedding:
7/26/2014
5.0/5.0
Our cake could not have been more perfect! It was gorgeous. We had a three layered mia cake with crystal banding with three different batters and two different fillings. Every single person said how much they LOVED our cake. So many compliments on how good it tasted and how good it looked. I highly recommend Bethel Bakery to make your wedding cake. Book them!
Our cake could not have been more perfect! It was gorgeous. We had a three layered mia cake with crystal banding with Read more...
Our cake could not have been more perfect! It was gorgeous. We had a three layered mia cake with crystal banding with three different batters and two different fillings. Every single person said how much they LOVED our cake. So many compliments on how good it tasted and how good it looked. I highly recommend Bethel Bakery to make your wedding cake. Book them! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
Since we were both in Florida at the time of planning, we were only going to be in the Pittsburgh area during Thanksgiving and they did a great job accommodating us for our tasting. Best of all, the cupcakes were delivered on time and absolutely delicious on our wedding day. Couldn't have asked for better.
Since we were both in Florida at the time of planning, we were only going to be in the Pittsburgh area during Thanksgiving Read more...
Since we were both in Florida at the time of planning, we were only going to be in the Pittsburgh area during Thanksgiving and they did a great job accommodating us for our tasting. Best of all, the cupcakes were delivered on time and absolutely delicious on our wedding day. Couldn't have asked for better. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for your kind review! We are so happy that you enjoyed the cupcakes and are thrilled to have been a part of your special day!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jody
Wedding:
7/11/2014
5.0/5.0
Best choice for wedding cakes!! Very flexible in providing the exact cake and design that you want!!! Prompt and reliable delivery with friendly service!!
Best choice for wedding cakes!! Very flexible in providing the exact cake and design that you want!!! Prompt and reliable Read more...
Best choice for wedding cakes!! Very flexible in providing the exact cake and design that you want!!! Prompt and reliable delivery with friendly service!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for your sweet review! We are so happy that you enjoyed your wedding cake and are thrilled to have been a part of your special day!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lisa
Wedding:
6/25/2014
5.0/5.0
We had a special cake designed for our wedding, and Bethel Bakery did a top-notch job of bringing the design to fruition. They were timely, pleasant, and the design artist was outstanding. The cake was also very delicious!
We had a special cake designed for our wedding, and Bethel Bakery did a top-notch job of bringing the design to fruition. Read more...
We had a special cake designed for our wedding, and Bethel Bakery did a top-notch job of bringing the design to fruition. They were timely, pleasant, and the design artist was outstanding. The cake was also very delicious! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Meredith
Wedding:
5/31/2014
5.0/5.0
We ordered 6 dozen gourmet cupcakes and a two-layer wedding cake from Bethel Bakery. The cupcakes were out of this world and they were extremely flexible on the look of the cake. I wanted something very rustic and not overdone and they delivered. Deliciously.

We ordered Turtle, Raspberry Lemonade, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Red Velvet, Tirimisu and Key Lime cupcakes. Our guests went nuts. They couldn't stop talking about them.

The cake was an almond batter with a raspberry and chocolate filling. I had it smashed in my face pretty scandalously, but licked it all off without complaining. SO GOOD.
We ordered 6 dozen gourmet cupcakes and a two-layer wedding cake from Bethel Bakery. The cupcakes were out of this world Read more...
We ordered 6 dozen gourmet cupcakes and a two-layer wedding cake from Bethel Bakery. The cupcakes were out of this world and they were extremely flexible on the look of the cake. I wanted something very rustic and not overdone and they delivered. Deliciously.

We ordered Turtle, Raspberry Lemonade, Chocolate Peanut Butter, Red Velvet, Tirimisu and Key Lime cupcakes. Our guests went nuts. They couldn't stop talking about them.

The cake was an almond batter with a raspberry and chocolate filling. I had it smashed in my face pretty scandalously, but licked it all off without complaining. SO GOOD. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for your thoughtful and kind review! We are so glad that you liked the gourmet cupcakes; and while we are sad to hear about the cake being scandalously pushed on to your face - we feel that if it had to happen at least it was a delicious moment to have with your husband! :) Hope to see you soon!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
My daughter's wedding was held at the Wyndham Grand Downtown Pittsburgh. Part of the package was the wedding cake thru Bethel Bakery. She opted for cupcakes and Bethel Bakery worked with her to have a small cake for cutting and then cupcakes for the guests as dessert. They delivered exactly as we requested right down to the decorations on each cupcake! The cupcakes were beautifully decorated and were so moist and tasty! Absolutely wonderful job well done!!!!
My daughter's wedding was held at the Wyndham Grand Downtown Pittsburgh. Part of the package was the wedding cake thru Read more...
My daughter's wedding was held at the Wyndham Grand Downtown Pittsburgh. Part of the package was the wedding cake thru Bethel Bakery. She opted for cupcakes and Bethel Bakery worked with her to have a small cake for cutting and then cupcakes for the guests as dessert. They delivered exactly as we requested right down to the decorations on each cupcake! The cupcakes were beautifully decorated and were so moist and tasty! Absolutely wonderful job well done!!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

We couldn't be happier to have been part of your family's big day! Thank you for sharing your experience! We very much appreciate your excellent review and look forward to creating beautiful and tasty treats for you and your family in the future!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Private User
Wedding:
5/23/2014
5.0/5.0
Excellent and very easy to work with.
Excellent and very easy to work with.
Excellent and very easy to work with. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you so much your positive review! We very much appreciate you taking the time to share your experience and were honored to be a part of this special occasion! We hope to see you soon!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Courtney
Wedding:
5/17/2014
5.0/5.0
We had Bethel Bakery do our cake for our wedding in May. Our colors were peach and gold and they pulled off the cake perfectly! It was gorgeous and so delicious! The colors matched our other items perfectly! They were so nice and helpful throughout the whole process! Loved it!
We had Bethel Bakery do our cake for our wedding in May. Our colors were peach and gold and they pulled off the cake Read more...
We had Bethel Bakery do our cake for our wedding in May. Our colors were peach and gold and they pulled off the cake perfectly! It was gorgeous and so delicious! The colors matched our other items perfectly! They were so nice and helpful throughout the whole process! Loved it! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Amanda
Wedding:
5/17/2014
5.0/5.0
I would highly recommend Bethel Bakery for any of your cake needs. We used them for our wedding and I couldn't be happier. The tasting went smoothly, and they were very helpful at helping choose flavor combinations. They accommodated requests for different filling and were very pleasant to work with. Our cake tasted amazing and looked beautiful. It turned out better than I had expected, and my expectations were high. They come with my highest recommendation.
I would highly recommend Bethel Bakery for any of your cake needs. We used them for our wedding and I couldn't be happier. Read more...
I would highly recommend Bethel Bakery for any of your cake needs. We used them for our wedding and I couldn't be happier. The tasting went smoothly, and they were very helpful at helping choose flavor combinations. They accommodated requests for different filling and were very pleasant to work with. Our cake tasted amazing and looked beautiful. It turned out better than I had expected, and my expectations were high. They come with my highest recommendation. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for sharing your experience of working with us! We strive for excellence and are so happy to hear that you loved your cake and we exceeded your expectations! We look forward to seeing you soon!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lauren
Wedding:
5/10/2014
5.0/5.0
my wedding cake was both beautiful and yummy! my guests could not stop raving about it!
my wedding cake was both beautiful and yummy! my guests could not stop raving about it!
my wedding cake was both beautiful and yummy! my guests could not stop raving about it! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for the very nice review! We are so pleased to have been part of your special day! Congratulations and best wishes!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Julie
Wedding:
4/26/2014
5.0/5.0
Our cake was amazing. The only thing my husband wanted was a cinnamon toast cake. We had had the flavor at an out of town wedding years prior and that was all that he could talk about and swore that we would have that same kind of cake at our wedding. When I approached Bethel Bakery about it, they were a little take aback by the request, but said that they would try their best, but they had never created that mix before. When we arrived at the bakery for our taste testing, they had the cinnamon toast cake made!!! It was phenomenal and we chose it as one of our batters. Everyone at the wedding raved about how different and wonderful it was. We can't wait for our one year anniversary where we can bust out that top tier and eat our cinnamon toast cake again! Bethel Bakery also provided us with lots of delicious cookies for our cookie table.
Our cake was amazing. The only thing my husband wanted was a cinnamon toast cake. We had had the flavor at an out of town Read more...
Our cake was amazing. The only thing my husband wanted was a cinnamon toast cake. We had had the flavor at an out of town wedding years prior and that was all that he could talk about and swore that we would have that same kind of cake at our wedding. When I approached Bethel Bakery about it, they were a little take aback by the request, but said that they would try their best, but they had never created that mix before. When we arrived at the bakery for our taste testing, they had the cinnamon toast cake made!!! It was phenomenal and we chose it as one of our batters. Everyone at the wedding raved about how different and wonderful it was. We can't wait for our one year anniversary where we can bust out that top tier and eat our cinnamon toast cake again! Bethel Bakery also provided us with lots of delicious cookies for our cookie table. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jessica
Wedding:
4/5/2014
5.0/5.0
My cake was beautiful and it tasted great. I got so many complements on it
My cake was beautiful and it tasted great. I got so many complements on it
My cake was beautiful and it tasted great. I got so many complements on it Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Jessica, Thank you for your kind review! We were honored to be a part of your special day! Best wishes and congratulations!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kara
Wedding:
3/29/2014
5.0/5.0
Bethel Bakery was recommended to us by one of my bridesmaids who was married last December as well as our florist. I called Bethel Bakery around Valentine's Day to see if it was even possible to order a cake for a March 29th wedding. My phone call was returned promptly with a list of available dates to come in for a tasting. When we walked into the bakery, we were immediately greeted and taken into a small room where we reviewed cake style, flavors and prices. Everything we tried was fantastic and was almost impossible to make a decision! I left the filling flavors to my husband (since he has the sweet tooth!) and went with chocolate and raspberry in an almond cake covered with their signature buttercream frosting that looked like fondant!! I was definitely impressed by that part.

We had not one slice of extra cake after the wedding and our guests were continuously asking where we got our cake. Cake, service and delivery were outstanding.
Bethel Bakery was recommended to us by one of my bridesmaids who was married last December as well as our florist. I Read more...
Bethel Bakery was recommended to us by one of my bridesmaids who was married last December as well as our florist. I called Bethel Bakery around Valentine's Day to see if it was even possible to order a cake for a March 29th wedding. My phone call was returned promptly with a list of available dates to come in for a tasting. When we walked into the bakery, we were immediately greeted and taken into a small room where we reviewed cake style, flavors and prices. Everything we tried was fantastic and was almost impossible to make a decision! I left the filling flavors to my husband (since he has the sweet tooth!) and went with chocolate and raspberry in an almond cake covered with their signature buttercream frosting that looked like fondant!! I was definitely impressed by that part.

We had not one slice of extra cake after the wedding and our guests were continuously asking where we got our cake. Cake, service and delivery were outstanding. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Kara, Thank you for the outstanding review! We strive for excellence and are so pleased to hear of your experience! We will be sure to pass on your kind words to our staff and decorators! Thanks again and we look forward to seeing you soon!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kristin
Wedding:
3/1/2014
5.0/5.0
Delicious!! We're not big cake people, but it was very, very good! We did an almond flavored batter with raspberry filling. The team was very prompt to respond to emails, and easy to work with.
Delicious!! We're not big cake people, but it was very, very good! We did an almond flavored batter with raspberry Read more...
Delicious!! We're not big cake people, but it was very, very good! We did an almond flavored batter with raspberry filling. The team was very prompt to respond to emails, and easy to work with. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Christina
Wedding:
12/14/2013
5.0/5.0
I had no issues with them and my cake was beautiful and arrived in one piece what more could I ask for? When we went for the consultation the lady was super friendly.
I had no issues with them and my cake was beautiful and arrived in one piece what more could I ask for? When we went for Read more...
I had no issues with them and my cake was beautiful and arrived in one piece what more could I ask for? When we went for the consultation the lady was super friendly. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Meghan
Wedding:
12/14/2013
5.0/5.0
The cake was gorgeous and delicious!! The staff was friendly, professional, and willing to work with my busy schedule!
The cake was gorgeous and delicious!! The staff was friendly, professional, and willing to work with my busy schedule!
The cake was gorgeous and delicious!! The staff was friendly, professional, and willing to work with my busy schedule! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
joanna
Wedding:
11/9/2013
5.0/5.0
Our cake was everything we expected from Bethel Bakery. It was decorated absolutely perfectly and we could not be more pleased! It was delicious and gorgeous and the staff there is so wonderful to work with! They truly gave us am amazing wedding experience!
Our cake was everything we expected from Bethel Bakery. It was decorated absolutely perfectly and we could not be more Read more...
Our cake was everything we expected from Bethel Bakery. It was decorated absolutely perfectly and we could not be more pleased! It was delicious and gorgeous and the staff there is so wonderful to work with! They truly gave us am amazing wedding experience! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Private User
Wedding:
11/2/2013
5.0/5.0
We had a 4 tier wedding cake from Bethel Bakery. Their french buttercream is amazing! The almond/ raspberry cake was beautiful and tasted great too.

Ordering the cake was an easy process. You have a relaxed tasting at the bakery, and then you can order then or come back and order at a later time. Payments are easily made over the phone.

I also ordered a surprise groom's cake. It was chocolate/peanut butter and so amazingly decorated, and all of our guests loved it. If you have an idea, Bethel Bakery can bring it to life in cake!
We had a 4 tier wedding cake from Bethel Bakery. Their french buttercream is amazing! The almond/ raspberry cake was Read more...
We had a 4 tier wedding cake from Bethel Bakery. Their french buttercream is amazing! The almond/ raspberry cake was beautiful and tasted great too.

Ordering the cake was an easy process. You have a relaxed tasting at the bakery, and then you can order then or come back and order at a later time. Payments are easily made over the phone.

I also ordered a surprise groom's cake. It was chocolate/peanut butter and so amazingly decorated, and all of our guests loved it. If you have an idea, Bethel Bakery can bring it to life in cake! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Celeste
Wedding:
10/12/2013
5.0/5.0
Bethel Bakery was awesome to have as our wedding cake vendor! Not only was the cake beautiful and delicious, but the employees made everything so easy for us. They took care of everything and we had no problems. I would use them for every occasion!
Bethel Bakery was awesome to have as our wedding cake vendor! Not only was the cake beautiful and delicious, but the Read more...
Bethel Bakery was awesome to have as our wedding cake vendor! Not only was the cake beautiful and delicious, but the employees made everything so easy for us. They took care of everything and we had no problems. I would use them for every occasion! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1357913855631-pic1
Jenn
Wedding:
10/11/2013
5.0/5.0
Bethel Bakery is a class act all the way. We decided to change our cake to a more "fall" themed one and they did a beautiful job with the flowers and decorations. Even better than that is the cake is FANTASTIC!! i highly recommend the almond batter with the raspberry filling, although i didn't get a piece on my wedding day LOL. They are a great business to work with and i would recommend them in a heartbeat!
Bethel Bakery is a class act all the way. We decided to change our cake to a more "fall" themed one and they did a Read more...
Bethel Bakery is a class act all the way. We decided to change our cake to a more "fall" themed one and they did a beautiful job with the flowers and decorations. Even better than that is the cake is FANTASTIC!! i highly recommend the almond batter with the raspberry filling, although i didn't get a piece on my wedding day LOL. They are a great business to work with and i would recommend them in a heartbeat! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
The cake was beautiful and delicious. It arrived at the venue in perfect condition and everyone we worked with was very nice and helpful.
The cake was beautiful and delicious. It arrived at the venue in perfect condition and everyone we worked with was very Read more...
The cake was beautiful and delicious. It arrived at the venue in perfect condition and everyone we worked with was very nice and helpful. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
Absolutely delicious and beautiful
Absolutely delicious and beautiful
Absolutely delicious and beautiful Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Amy
Wedding:
9/20/2013
5.0/5.0
The cake and cupcakes provided were delicious and beautiful!!
The cake and cupcakes provided were delicious and beautiful!!
The cake and cupcakes provided were delicious and beautiful!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Sally
Wedding:
9/7/2013
5.0/5.0
The cake was delicious! We chose to have our displayed 3-tier wedding cake as the yellow cake with pumpkin spice filling, and our backup cakes as the white almond cake with butter-creme icing/filling. The cake was very moist, and was decorated exactly how we wanted it. The staff was very easy to work with and very accommodating to any requests. Also, the cake stand that we rented from the bakery was beautiful! We've received so many compliments on the cake look, taste, and the display. Thank you!
The cake was delicious! We chose to have our displayed 3-tier wedding cake as the yellow cake with pumpkin spice filling, Read more...
The cake was delicious! We chose to have our displayed 3-tier wedding cake as the yellow cake with pumpkin spice filling, and our backup cakes as the white almond cake with butter-creme icing/filling. The cake was very moist, and was decorated exactly how we wanted it. The staff was very easy to work with and very accommodating to any requests. Also, the cake stand that we rented from the bakery was beautiful! We've received so many compliments on the cake look, taste, and the display. Thank you! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Sally, Thank you very much for your review! Your wonderful remarks are certainly appreciated and will be shared with our staff. We also appreciate that you had us be a part of your special day!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jennifer
Wedding:
9/6/2013
5.0/5.0
The cake was beautiful and delicious. Staff was very friendly. I didn't learn this until much later but apparently something bumped the cake and made one of the flowers fall off which greatly disrupted the icing. Bethel Bakery was contacted and they rushed right back to the venue and fixed it before the reception started. I never would have known if my sister hadn't told me months later.
The cake was beautiful and delicious. Staff was very friendly. I didn't learn this until much later but apparently Read more...
The cake was beautiful and delicious. Staff was very friendly. I didn't learn this until much later but apparently something bumped the cake and made one of the flowers fall off which greatly disrupted the icing. Bethel Bakery was contacted and they rushed right back to the venue and fixed it before the reception started. I never would have known if my sister hadn't told me months later. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Private User
Wedding:
9/6/2013
5.0/5.0
Fabulous and easy to deal with. The cake was delicious and beautiful. I cannot recommend Bethel Bakery any higher than "exceeds" expectations!
Fabulous and easy to deal with. The cake was delicious and beautiful. I cannot recommend Bethel Bakery any higher than Read more...
Fabulous and easy to deal with. The cake was delicious and beautiful. I cannot recommend Bethel Bakery any higher than "exceeds" expectations! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Marisa
Wedding:
8/17/2013
5.0/5.0
Our wedding cake and groom's cake were truly spectacular. We had a four-tiered square and round cake with the "dots and swirls" design. The cake was absolutely gorgeous! Not to mention, the almond batter & raspberry filling were just perfect. The groom's cake, which was an Air Force emblem, was marble cake with peanut butter filling. It was perfect in every way! We are so glad we booked Bethel Bakery for our wedding!
Our wedding cake and groom's cake were truly spectacular. We had a four-tiered square and round cake with the "dots and Read more...
Our wedding cake and groom's cake were truly spectacular. We had a four-tiered square and round cake with the "dots and swirls" design. The cake was absolutely gorgeous! Not to mention, the almond batter & raspberry filling were just perfect. The groom's cake, which was an Air Force emblem, was marble cake with peanut butter filling. It was perfect in every way! We are so glad we booked Bethel Bakery for our wedding! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Marisa, Thank you very much for your wonderful comments! We truly appreciate it but most of all, we appreciate being a part of your wedding day!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Faith
Wedding:
7/13/2013
5.0/5.0
Bethel Bakery did a fabulous job on our wedding cake. The cake not only looked exactly like I wanted, but it tasted great, too!
Bethel Bakery did a fabulous job on our wedding cake. The cake not only looked exactly like I wanted, but it tasted great, Read more...
Bethel Bakery did a fabulous job on our wedding cake. The cake not only looked exactly like I wanted, but it tasted great, too! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
5.0/5.0
Tasted great even a year after the wedding!
Tasted great even a year after the wedding!
Tasted great even a year after the wedding! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Happy Anniversary! Thank you for sharing your experience!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Christa
Wedding:
6/15/2013
5.0/5.0
Bethel bakery did an outstanding job with our wedding cake. They are extremely friendly and happy to make your wedding cake everything you dreamed it would be. Not only is it beautiful, but it is delicious too!
Bethel bakery did an outstanding job with our wedding cake. They are extremely friendly and happy to make your wedding Read more...
Bethel bakery did an outstanding job with our wedding cake. They are extremely friendly and happy to make your wedding cake everything you dreamed it would be. Not only is it beautiful, but it is delicious too! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Christa, Thank you very much for your wonderful remarks! We truly appreciate it and, most of all, thank you for letting us be a part of your special day!
130x130_sq_1370539804170-getting-ready-13
Jamie
Wedding:
6/1/2013
5.0/5.0
We chose Bethel Bakery for our wedding cake and could not be happier! It looked gorgeous and tasted even better! We had almond cake with a layer of mango filling and a layer of raspberry filling. Honest to God most delicious cake I have ever tasted. If you go with Bethel Bakery you and your guests will NOT be disappointed!
We chose Bethel Bakery for our wedding cake and could not be happier! It looked gorgeous and tasted even better! We had Read more...
We chose Bethel Bakery for our wedding cake and could not be happier! It looked gorgeous and tasted even better! We had almond cake with a layer of mango filling and a layer of raspberry filling. Honest to God most delicious cake I have ever tasted. If you go with Bethel Bakery you and your guests will NOT be disappointed! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for the nice review. We are so happy that you were pleased with your wedding cake. The mango filling with the almond cake is delicious!

Sweet Regards
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Maria
Wedding:
7/15/2006
5.0/5.0
We had a beatiful cake in the shape of a wedding gown. We got to save it and eat the top for our first anniversary...it still was delicious!
We had a beatiful cake in the shape of a wedding gown. We got to save it and eat the top for our first anniversary...it Read more...
We had a beatiful cake in the shape of a wedding gown. We got to save it and eat the top for our first anniversary...it still was delicious! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
5.0/5.0
My cake was gorgeous! The cake was delicious. They are the BEST!
My cake was gorgeous! The cake was delicious. They are the BEST!
My cake was gorgeous! The cake was delicious. They are the BEST! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for such a nice review. We are happy that you were so pleased with your wedding cake!

Sweet Regards
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kris
Wedding:
5/11/2013
5.0/5.0
Ever since I was a little girl I wanted my wedding cake from Bethel Bakery , It was beautiful they did not disappoint .
I would highly recommend them for your wedding cake, or any occasion you may need a bakery for.
Ever since I was a little girl I wanted my wedding cake from Bethel Bakery , It was beautiful they did not disappoint . Read more...
Ever since I was a little girl I wanted my wedding cake from Bethel Bakery , It was beautiful they did not disappoint .
I would highly recommend them for your wedding cake, or any occasion you may need a bakery for. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for the nice review! We are so happy that we were able to make a childhood dream come true, and that everything was perfect for your special day.
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
5.0/5.0
Great to work with. Everything was exactly how we wanted. Delicious and beautiful!
Great to work with. Everything was exactly how we wanted. Delicious and beautiful!
Great to work with. Everything was exactly how we wanted. Delicious and beautiful! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for the nice review! We are so glad that everything was exactly how you wanted it.

Sweet Regards
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Julia
Wedding:
4/27/2013
5.0/5.0
I had a Bethel Bakery cake and cookies at my wedding reception- 100% happy with everything!!!
I had a Bethel Bakery cake and cookies at my wedding reception- 100% happy with everything!!!
I had a Bethel Bakery cake and cookies at my wedding reception- 100% happy with everything!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for the great review! We are so happy that you were so pleased with our special occasion cookies.

Sweet Regards
130x130_sq_1336059344950-flowers16
Natalie
Wedding:
11/24/2012
5.0/5.0
The wedding cake was delicious! They did a great job.
The wedding cake was delicious! They did a great job.
The wedding cake was delicious! They did a great job. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for the nice review! We are so glad that you enjoyed the cake so much!

Sweet Regards
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Dana
Wedding:
11/9/2012
5.0/5.0
A wedding cake from Bethel Bakery was included in our package with the reception at the Sheraton at Station Square. Bethel Bakery was great to work with from start to finish! The cake tasting was a lot of fun! They were very helpful in working with us on the design that we wanted and for the price that we wanted! (We received a "credit" amount to use from the package with the Sheraton and were responsible for any extras that exceeded that "credit." We didn't want to go far beyond that credit and so the staff was very helpful in working with us). The cake was beautiful and exactly what I always dreamed of! On top of the beauty of it, it was absolutely delicious! Many guests went to ask my parents where the cake was from because it's the best they ever had! We also ordered some cookies from them for the "cookie table" Could not have asked for better!
A wedding cake from Bethel Bakery was included in our package with the reception at the Sheraton at Station Square. Bethel Read more...
A wedding cake from Bethel Bakery was included in our package with the reception at the Sheraton at Station Square. Bethel Bakery was great to work with from start to finish! The cake tasting was a lot of fun! They were very helpful in working with us on the design that we wanted and for the price that we wanted! (We received a "credit" amount to use from the package with the Sheraton and were responsible for any extras that exceeded that "credit." We didn't want to go far beyond that credit and so the staff was very helpful in working with us). The cake was beautiful and exactly what I always dreamed of! On top of the beauty of it, it was absolutely delicious! Many guests went to ask my parents where the cake was from because it's the best they ever had! We also ordered some cookies from them for the "cookie table" Could not have asked for better! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for the great reivew. It is always nice to hear that everything was great and that you were happy with the service. We are happy that you were please with us being in your wedding package!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
5.0/5.0
Our cake was phenomenal. It wasnt a traditional wedding cake but a tastefully done 3 tiered halloween design cake. Beautiful. I gave them my idea and told them I wanted it festive but not at all "creepy". I couldn't of been happier. I let the bakery take the reigns at most of the design and it was amazing. They were wonderful to meet and deal with and the cake was absolutely delicious. I was also very pleased with the price.
Our cake was phenomenal. It wasnt a traditional wedding cake but a tastefully done 3 tiered halloween design cake. Read more...
Our cake was phenomenal. It wasnt a traditional wedding cake but a tastefully done 3 tiered halloween design cake. Beautiful. I gave them my idea and told them I wanted it festive but not at all "creepy". I couldn't of been happier. I let the bakery take the reigns at most of the design and it was amazing. They were wonderful to meet and deal with and the cake was absolutely delicious. I was also very pleased with the price. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you so much for the review! We are so glad to hear that you were so happy with your cake!

Sweet Regards
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
5.0/5.0
My cake was beautiful ! It was exactly what I wanted and they matched the color I wanted. Great Job.
My cake was beautiful ! It was exactly what I wanted and they matched the color I wanted. Great Job.
My cake was beautiful ! It was exactly what I wanted and they matched the color I wanted. Great Job. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

We are so happy that you were pleased with your cake. We appreciate the nice comment!

Sweet Regards
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Amanda
Wedding:
10/20/2012
5.0/5.0
Everyone loved the mango filling in my blue/white wedding cake! These cakes are the best cakes EVER! Don't go anywhere else!
Everyone loved the mango filling in my blue/white wedding cake! These cakes are the best cakes EVER! Don't go anywhere Read more...
Everyone loved the mango filling in my blue/white wedding cake! These cakes are the best cakes EVER! Don't go anywhere else! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

THANK YOU, the mago is one of the most popular cake fillings! We are so happy that you were pleased with your cake. Thank you for the nice review.

Sweet Regards
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
5.0/5.0
Bethel staff were all very friendly. I had a few very specific/special requests and they were really flexible and willing to accommodate anything. I would highly recommend this vendor!
Bethel staff were all very friendly. I had a few very specific/special requests and they were really flexible and willing Read more...
Bethel staff were all very friendly. I had a few very specific/special requests and they were really flexible and willing to accommodate anything. I would highly recommend this vendor! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for your feedback, we are glad to hear that you had a great experience with us. It was our pleasure to be a part of your big day.

Sweet Regards
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Cheryl
Wedding:
8/18/2012
5.0/5.0
The staff at Bethel Bakery provided us with the most delicious wedding cake I have ever tasted. The flavors of Orange Creamsicle and Mango filling were perfect, and the cake looked so beautiful!! I will definitely be recommending Bethel Bakery to all of my friends.

Thank You for making our day so special.
The staff at Bethel Bakery provided us with the most delicious wedding cake I have ever tasted. The flavors of Orange Read more...
The staff at Bethel Bakery provided us with the most delicious wedding cake I have ever tasted. The flavors of Orange Creamsicle and Mango filling were perfect, and the cake looked so beautiful!! I will definitely be recommending Bethel Bakery to all of my friends.

Thank You for making our day so special. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

You are very welcome! We are glad to hear that you were pleased with the cake that we made for your sepcial day was such a hit. Thank you for the nice comment!

Sweet Regards
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Laura
Wedding:
6/23/2012
5.0/5.0
We actually got our cake for free with the reception package through our venue. We met with a wedding coordinator from the bakery and the process was very smooth. We picked just the basic cake that was included with our package, but could have upgraded if we wanted to.
The cake was super moist and delicious. Everyone commented on how good it was.
We actually got our cake for free with the reception package through our venue. We met with a wedding coordinator from the Read more...
We actually got our cake for free with the reception package through our venue. We met with a wedding coordinator from the bakery and the process was very smooth. We picked just the basic cake that was included with our package, but could have upgraded if we wanted to.
The cake was super moist and delicious. Everyone commented on how good it was. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for your comment! We are very happy that everything worked out with your wedding package. We were very happy to be a part of your special day.

Sweet Regard
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Ashlea
Wedding:
6/2/2012
5.0/5.0
Everyone loved our cake. Bethel Bakery was very easy to work with and everyone was very nice. Our cake was vanilla almond batter with raspberry filling. It was delicious. They matched my cake design perfectly. I would recommend them and plan to use them for other occasions in the future.

Wedding 8/16/13
Everyone loved our cake. Bethel Bakery was very easy to work with and everyone was very nice. Our cake was vanilla almond Read more...
Everyone loved our cake. Bethel Bakery was very easy to work with and everyone was very nice. Our cake was vanilla almond batter with raspberry filling. It was delicious. They matched my cake design perfectly. I would recommend them and plan to use them for other occasions in the future.

Wedding 8/16/13 Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Beckie
Wedding:
5/19/2012
5.0/5.0
I had the best experience here at this bakery. The wedding coordinator was great. My husband and I went sampled so many different types of cakes and fillings. This bakery is with out a doubt the closest thing you are going to get the best home made icing that is displayed so beautifully on a wedding cake. They have so many options for cakes to chose from or you can bring in a picture of one you found that you like and will make it that way. I do not care where you live you need to go there and meet with them and sample their product. It will sell itself.
I had the best experience here at this bakery. The wedding coordinator was great. My husband and I went sampled so many Read more...
I had the best experience here at this bakery. The wedding coordinator was great. My husband and I went sampled so many different types of cakes and fillings. This bakery is with out a doubt the closest thing you are going to get the best home made icing that is displayed so beautifully on a wedding cake. They have so many options for cakes to chose from or you can bring in a picture of one you found that you like and will make it that way. I do not care where you live you need to go there and meet with them and sample their product. It will sell itself. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Amanda
Wedding:
5/12/2012
5.0/5.0
Bethel bakery made my cake not only beautiful but tasty too. The cake was on time and turned out exactly how I wanted
Bethel bakery made my cake not only beautiful but tasty too. The cake was on time and turned out exactly how I wanted
Bethel bakery made my cake not only beautiful but tasty too. The cake was on time and turned out exactly how I wanted Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
jessCmassachusetts
Wedding:
4/19/2012
5.0/5.0
Bethel Bakery did my cake and 67 dozen cookies for our cookie table for our wedding last weekend at LeMont. The cake looked so beautiful, and guests have been raving about how moist the cake was and how delicious the cookies were. They must have been delicious, because only a few dozen were left over!
Bethel Bakery did my cake and 67 dozen cookies for our cookie table for our wedding last weekend at LeMont. The cake Read more...
Bethel Bakery did my cake and 67 dozen cookies for our cookie table for our wedding last weekend at LeMont. The cake looked so beautiful, and guests have been raving about how moist the cake was and how delicious the cookies were. They must have been delicious, because only a few dozen were left over! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
yeonhee83
Wedding:
4/14/2012
5.0/5.0
Cake is delicious and was really affordable.
Cake is delicious and was really affordable.
Cake is delicious and was really affordable. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1318884128376-fbavatar2037285
Michelle
Wedding:
10/1/2011
5.0/5.0
We had a groomsmen cake (decorated as a tuxedo and the cake was marble with butter cream filling) and a wedding cake. First off, My father made the comment that the tuxedo cake was the most beautifully decorated cake he had ever seen. Unfortunately, he was the only one who saw it because it was soon dismantled in the back and served by The Summit Inn. I truly wish it had been on display because Bethel Bakery did such a fabulous job. My wedding cake was also very beautiful. Out of all my pre-wedding activities, choosing the wedding cake was by far the most fun. Best bakery I have ever and will ever use!
We had a groomsmen cake (decorated as a tuxedo and the cake was marble with butter cream filling) and a wedding cake. Read more...
We had a groomsmen cake (decorated as a tuxedo and the cake was marble with butter cream filling) and a wedding cake. First off, My father made the comment that the tuxedo cake was the most beautifully decorated cake he had ever seen. Unfortunately, he was the only one who saw it because it was soon dismantled in the back and served by The Summit Inn. I truly wish it had been on display because Bethel Bakery did such a fabulous job. My wedding cake was also very beautiful. Out of all my pre-wedding activities, choosing the wedding cake was by far the most fun. Best bakery I have ever and will ever use! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1270495186243-1000311
Aubrey
Wedding:
10/1/2011
5.0/5.0
The cake looked wonderful! Just how I pictured it! And it was yummy!
The cake looked wonderful! Just how I pictured it! And it was yummy!
The cake looked wonderful! Just how I pictured it! And it was yummy! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Dina
Wedding:
9/24/2011
5.0/5.0
Bethel Bakery created an absolutely beautiful cake that everyone at the wedding was amazed by. They were extremely organized, professional and easy to work with in the planning phase. The cake itself was actual BETTER on the wedding day, than we had at the tasting! We received compliments from many guests and we are so thrilled we chose such as class act for our special day. They may not be the cheapest bakery in town, but as the saying goes, you get what you pay for. If you want exceptional service and a quality, delicious wedding cake, you CANNOT GO WRONG WITH BETHEL BAKERY!!!!!
Bethel Bakery created an absolutely beautiful cake that everyone at the wedding was amazed by. They were extremely Read more...
Bethel Bakery created an absolutely beautiful cake that everyone at the wedding was amazed by. They were extremely organized, professional and easy to work with in the planning phase. The cake itself was actual BETTER on the wedding day, than we had at the tasting! We received compliments from many guests and we are so thrilled we chose such as class act for our special day. They may not be the cheapest bakery in town, but as the saying goes, you get what you pay for. If you want exceptional service and a quality, delicious wedding cake, you CANNOT GO WRONG WITH BETHEL BAKERY!!!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
westover525
Wedding:
9/10/2011
5.0/5.0
We went to Bethel with only a thought in mind of how we wanted our cake to look. We couldnt find examples or anything else to give them just pieced looks from a bunch of different cakes. Needless to say we were worried about the outcome.

However when we walked into the room and saw the cake for the first time it was breathtaking. It was the picture in our mind actually created. Let alone from the look the taste was fantastic. This is by far in our opinion the best bakery in Pittsburgh.
We went to Bethel with only a thought in mind of how we wanted our cake to look. We couldnt find examples or anything else Read more...
We went to Bethel with only a thought in mind of how we wanted our cake to look. We couldnt find examples or anything else to give them just pieced looks from a bunch of different cakes. Needless to say we were worried about the outcome.

However when we walked into the room and saw the cake for the first time it was breathtaking. It was the picture in our mind actually created. Let alone from the look the taste was fantastic. This is by far in our opinion the best bakery in Pittsburgh. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
tinkynchazzie
Wedding:
9/10/2011
5.0/5.0
The cake was amazing. And they decorated it exactly how we wanted it.
The cake was amazing. And they decorated it exactly how we wanted it.
The cake was amazing. And they decorated it exactly how we wanted it. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
adiehl81
Wedding:
8/27/2011
5.0/5.0
Tastefully beautiful cakes!! Such nice people to work with! The cake was exactly what I wanted.
Tastefully beautiful cakes!! Such nice people to work with! The cake was exactly what I wanted.
Tastefully beautiful cakes!! Such nice people to work with! The cake was exactly what I wanted. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Katie
Wedding:
7/9/2011
5.0/5.0
Our wedding cake from Bethel Bakery was gorgeous. We have gotten birthday cakes from Bethel for years, and its my father in laws absolute favorite cake, so there was no question where we were going for our wedding cake. I was just as impressed with the simple design as I was with the quality and taste of the cake. You can't go wrong with Bethel Bakery!
Our wedding cake from Bethel Bakery was gorgeous. We have gotten birthday cakes from Bethel for years, and its my father Read more...
Our wedding cake from Bethel Bakery was gorgeous. We have gotten birthday cakes from Bethel for years, and its my father in laws absolute favorite cake, so there was no question where we were going for our wedding cake. I was just as impressed with the simple design as I was with the quality and taste of the cake. You can't go wrong with Bethel Bakery! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Bethany
Wedding:
7/2/2011
5.0/5.0
They do lovely work! We had white cake with alternating layers of mango and cookies and cream fillings. People loved it!
They do lovely work! We had white cake with alternating layers of mango and cookies and cream fillings. People loved it!
They do lovely work! We had white cake with alternating layers of mango and cookies and cream fillings. People loved it! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jennifer
Wedding:
7/2/2011
5.0/5.0
Our wedding cake was absolutely gorgeous and exactly what we envisioned! Everyone raved about how delicious it was. We had almond white cake with raspberry and chocolate between the layers....yum! The staff at Bethel Bakery was extremely nice and easy to work with. Can't wait to eat the top teir on our anniversary!!
Our wedding cake was absolutely gorgeous and exactly what we envisioned! Everyone raved about how delicious it was. We had Read more...
Our wedding cake was absolutely gorgeous and exactly what we envisioned! Everyone raved about how delicious it was. We had almond white cake with raspberry and chocolate between the layers....yum! The staff at Bethel Bakery was extremely nice and easy to work with. Can't wait to eat the top teir on our anniversary!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jessica
Wedding:
7/2/2011
5.0/5.0
I grew up eating Bethel Bakery for every birthday that I can remember, and knew I needed a Bethel Bakery wedding cake. It was included with our reception site package and were able to chose from a selection of designs. We went with the white cake and mango filling. Great for a summer wedding and their signature butter cream icing is the best! The cake was perfect and lived up to expectations. It looked wonderful and tasted even better!! Can't wait to eat the top layer on our year anniversary!
I grew up eating Bethel Bakery for every birthday that I can remember, and knew I needed a Bethel Bakery wedding cake. It Read more...
I grew up eating Bethel Bakery for every birthday that I can remember, and knew I needed a Bethel Bakery wedding cake. It was included with our reception site package and were able to chose from a selection of designs. We went with the white cake and mango filling. Great for a summer wedding and their signature butter cream icing is the best! The cake was perfect and lived up to expectations. It looked wonderful and tasted even better!! Can't wait to eat the top layer on our year anniversary! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jessica
Wedding:
6/25/2011
5.0/5.0
I can recognize a Bethel Bakery cake by how it looks since they've been at almost every social function I've ever been to in the South Hills. Our cake was fun and awesome and apparently delicious, although I only got a small bite of it when we were doing the cake cutting. (Wedding's are busy!) It was easy and an enjoyable experience to pick the design out, it got there in one piece and everybody loved it. It was one of them most expensive items we got though, but I think it was a better value than the limo!
I can recognize a Bethel Bakery cake by how it looks since they've been at almost every social function I've ever been to Read more...
I can recognize a Bethel Bakery cake by how it looks since they've been at almost every social function I've ever been to in the South Hills. Our cake was fun and awesome and apparently delicious, although I only got a small bite of it when we were doing the cake cutting. (Wedding's are busy!) It was easy and an enjoyable experience to pick the design out, it got there in one piece and everybody loved it. It was one of them most expensive items we got though, but I think it was a better value than the limo! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
gopens22
Wedding:
5/21/2011
5.0/5.0
Perfect Cake and Cookies. I recommend the Mango filling, yum!
Perfect Cake and Cookies. I recommend the Mango filling, yum!
Perfect Cake and Cookies. I recommend the Mango filling, yum! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
missy5580
Wedding:
4/16/2011
5.0/5.0
My cake was beautiful and tasted wonderful. The consultation was fun and I was really pleased with their service.
My cake was beautiful and tasted wonderful. The consultation was fun and I was really pleased with their service.
My cake was beautiful and tasted wonderful. The consultation was fun and I was really pleased with their service. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anthony
Wedding:
11/6/2010
5.0/5.0
Bethel Bakery... what can I say, they are the best :)
Bethel Bakery... what can I say, they are the best :)
Bethel Bakery... what can I say, they are the best :) Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Maberton
Wedding:
10/10/2010
5.0/5.0
Excellent service from tasting to delivery! We went with cupcakes for our wedding and Bethel Bakery delivered on time. Everything was perfect and we heard from our guest how much the loved them! Definitely recommend them for any wedding or event!
Excellent service from tasting to delivery! We went with cupcakes for our wedding and Bethel Bakery delivered on time. Read more...
Excellent service from tasting to delivery! We went with cupcakes for our wedding and Bethel Bakery delivered on time. Everything was perfect and we heard from our guest how much the loved them! Definitely recommend them for any wedding or event! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1264547720944-fbavatar1269363776
Justine
Wedding:
8/7/2010
5.0/5.0
We really didn't have a choice about going with Bethel Bakery because the cake was included with our reception hall. But, even if I did have a choice we still would have went with them! Our wedding cake was so delicious. It looked so beautiful. We got so many compliments on it. We also got our cake topper from them. I just call and order it over the phone and they bring it with the cake! I have dealt with Bethel Bakery since I graduated high school. We almost didn't wait to eat the top of our cake, but we are. I highly recommend Bethel Bakery for any occasion!
We really didn't have a choice about going with Bethel Bakery because the cake was included with our reception hall. But, Read more...
We really didn't have a choice about going with Bethel Bakery because the cake was included with our reception hall. But, even if I did have a choice we still would have went with them! Our wedding cake was so delicious. It looked so beautiful. We got so many compliments on it. We also got our cake topper from them. I just call and order it over the phone and they bring it with the cake! I have dealt with Bethel Bakery since I graduated high school. We almost didn't wait to eat the top of our cake, but we are. I highly recommend Bethel Bakery for any occasion! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
k77songbird
Wedding:
8/7/2010
5.0/5.0
I grew up in Bethel Park, and so I knew long before I even got engaged that my wedding cake would come from Bethel Bakery. They were so great to work with, and all of the cakes we tasted were so delicious- It was hard to choose. We went with the white cake with mago filling and buttercream icing, so delicious. The cake was a bit pricey, but well worth it. All of our guests raved about how beuatiful and delicious the cake was. Thank you Bethel Bakery!
I grew up in Bethel Park, and so I knew long before I even got engaged that my wedding cake would come from Bethel Bakery. Read more...
I grew up in Bethel Park, and so I knew long before I even got engaged that my wedding cake would come from Bethel Bakery. They were so great to work with, and all of the cakes we tasted were so delicious- It was hard to choose. We went with the white cake with mago filling and buttercream icing, so delicious. The cake was a bit pricey, but well worth it. All of our guests raved about how beuatiful and delicious the cake was. Thank you Bethel Bakery! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lisa
Wedding:
6/26/2010
5.0/5.0
It's Bethel Bakery - what else needs to be said??!!!! In case you DO need more - their cake is the best you will find anywhere!! Our wedding cake was GORGEOUS and DELICIOUS!!! White cake with mango filling - perfect for a summer wedding! I can't wait to enjoy the top tier on our anniversary! In addition to the cake, the staff is easy to work with, very accommodating and very pleasant.
It's Bethel Bakery - what else needs to be said??!!!! In case you DO need more - their cake is the best you will find Read more...
It's Bethel Bakery - what else needs to be said??!!!! In case you DO need more - their cake is the best you will find anywhere!! Our wedding cake was GORGEOUS and DELICIOUS!!! White cake with mango filling - perfect for a summer wedding! I can't wait to enjoy the top tier on our anniversary! In addition to the cake, the staff is easy to work with, very accommodating and very pleasant. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
michellem1218
Wedding:
2/27/2010
5.0/5.0
Bethel Bakery gave us the most beautiful and delicious wedding cake that we could have asked for! We received so many compliments on our cake from our family and friends! We had a winter wedding and our theme was snowflakes and pine cones. They put both on the cake and it was so georgous!
Bethel Bakery gave us the most beautiful and delicious wedding cake that we could have asked for! We received so many Read more...
Bethel Bakery gave us the most beautiful and delicious wedding cake that we could have asked for! We received so many compliments on our cake from our family and friends! We had a winter wedding and our theme was snowflakes and pine cones. They put both on the cake and it was so georgous! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Unknown2010
Wedding:
2/13/2010
5.0/5.0
I couldnt ask for a better cake for my daughters wedding!! It melt in our mouth, it was fresh and beautiful!!
I couldnt ask for a better cake for my daughters wedding!! It melt in our mouth, it was fresh and beautiful!!
I couldnt ask for a better cake for my daughters wedding!! It melt in our mouth, it was fresh and beautiful!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
kittenaria
Wedding:
11/7/2009
5.0/5.0
Bethel Bakery was fabulous in working with us to create the perfect cake for our budget. The end product was breathtaking, not to mention delicious! We received many compliments on the presentation & flavor.

The only issue we ran into whatsoever was with the cake topper.. they have rather strict requirements for size and weight of the topper, so that the integrity of the cake isn't damaged by what you're putting on top. We couldn't find any toppers we liked within the requirements. But when we found one that was pretty close, they were willing to take a look at it and let us know if they could work around it. They could! They also pretty closely matched our hard-to-replicate wedding colors.

Highly recommended!
Bethel Bakery was fabulous in working with us to create the perfect cake for our budget. The end product was breathtaking, Read more...
Bethel Bakery was fabulous in working with us to create the perfect cake for our budget. The end product was breathtaking, not to mention delicious! We received many compliments on the presentation & flavor.

The only issue we ran into whatsoever was with the cake topper.. they have rather strict requirements for size and weight of the topper, so that the integrity of the cake isn't damaged by what you're putting on top. We couldn't find any toppers we liked within the requirements. But when we found one that was pretty close, they were willing to take a look at it and let us know if they could work around it. They could! They also pretty closely matched our hard-to-replicate wedding colors.

Highly recommended! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
_meganORSI__
Wedding:
10/25/2009
5.0/5.0
Bethel Bakery gave us the most beautiful cake. I'm an artist so I had to have my hand in designing every part of the wedding. Our cake was no exception. Bethel Bakery was great with accommodating my design preferences and the cake came out beautifully!

What I really liked, was in the days leading up to our wedding, they were working on designing for the cake. Bethel Bakery CALLED ME and told me they had a concern with the color ribbon I wanted on the cake (chocolate brown). That they've had problems in the past with it darkening in areas from the butter cream. She made a suggestion to darken the ribbon and I used her suggestion. I just thought it was WONDERFUL that she called to ask me what I thought! VERY CONSIDERATE.

The cake was beautiful. It matched the theme of the wedding PERFECTLY. Oh, and it tasted pretty damn good too ;-)
Bethel Bakery gave us the most beautiful cake. I'm an artist so I had to have my hand in designing every part of the Read more...
Bethel Bakery gave us the most beautiful cake. I'm an artist so I had to have my hand in designing every part of the wedding. Our cake was no exception. Bethel Bakery was great with accommodating my design preferences and the cake came out beautifully!

What I really liked, was in the days leading up to our wedding, they were working on designing for the cake. Bethel Bakery CALLED ME and told me they had a concern with the color ribbon I wanted on the cake (chocolate brown). That they've had problems in the past with it darkening in areas from the butter cream. She made a suggestion to darken the ribbon and I used her suggestion. I just thought it was WONDERFUL that she called to ask me what I thought! VERY CONSIDERATE.

The cake was beautiful. It matched the theme of the wedding PERFECTLY. Oh, and it tasted pretty damn good too ;-) Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lauren15
Wedding:
10/17/2009
5.0/5.0
They made the most beautiful cake that actually tasted delicious. Many wedding cakes look beautiful but dont taste good. Our guests loved the cake and though it was gorgeous! They were also reasonably priced.
They made the most beautiful cake that actually tasted delicious. Many wedding cakes look beautiful but dont taste good. Read more...
They made the most beautiful cake that actually tasted delicious. Many wedding cakes look beautiful but dont taste good. Our guests loved the cake and though it was gorgeous! They were also reasonably priced. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Perrotta13
Wedding:
10/3/2009
5.0/5.0
Our wedding cake was amazing! They were very willing to change the design to what we wanted, and it taste AMAZING!
Our wedding cake was amazing! They were very willing to change the design to what we wanted, and it taste AMAZING!
Our wedding cake was amazing! They were very willing to change the design to what we wanted, and it taste AMAZING! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
gidgetteg
Wedding:
10/3/2009
5.0/5.0
We LOVED our cake! You can not beat the reputation that this vendor has. We chose to use them after we ate thier cake at another friend's wedding. They were easy to deal with (we did our planning long distance) and very friendly and professional. Our guests were so impressed on our cake!!
We LOVED our cake! You can not beat the reputation that this vendor has. We chose to use them after we ate thier cake at Read more...
We LOVED our cake! You can not beat the reputation that this vendor has. We chose to use them after we ate thier cake at another friend's wedding. They were easy to deal with (we did our planning long distance) and very friendly and professional. Our guests were so impressed on our cake!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
pggirl09
Wedding:
8/8/2009
5.0/5.0
the wedding cake was part of the Sheraton Station Square package and it was an excellent cake!!!!!! Everyone loved it.
the wedding cake was part of the Sheraton Station Square package and it was an excellent cake!!!!!! Everyone loved it.
the wedding cake was part of the Sheraton Station Square package and it was an excellent cake!!!!!! Everyone loved it. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kaitlin
Wedding:
7/11/2009
5.0/5.0
Everyone commented about how beautiful and delicious our weddign cake was! I loved our filling/cake so much that I got a cake in the same flavor for my birthday. We also got cookies for our cookie wedding which again were amazing. There were people at the cookie table all night!
Everyone commented about how beautiful and delicious our weddign cake was! I loved our filling/cake so much that I got a Read more...
Everyone commented about how beautiful and delicious our weddign cake was! I loved our filling/cake so much that I got a cake in the same flavor for my birthday. We also got cookies for our cookie wedding which again were amazing. There were people at the cookie table all night! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
DeAnna
Wedding:
7/4/2009
5.0/5.0
Cathy did my wedding cake and I also had them do my grooms cake. They were the most incredible cakes I've ever had. It was decorated so nicely, and she even worked with me on letting me bring in my own ribbon to use.
I can not wait till my 1 year anniversary to dip into the top layer
Cathy did my wedding cake and I also had them do my grooms cake. They were the most incredible cakes I've ever had. It was Read more...
Cathy did my wedding cake and I also had them do my grooms cake. They were the most incredible cakes I've ever had. It was decorated so nicely, and she even worked with me on letting me bring in my own ribbon to use.
I can not wait till my 1 year anniversary to dip into the top layer Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
lori12400
Wedding:
5/9/2009
5.0/5.0
Since I've been eating Bethel Bakery cakes and pastries all my life, it was a no-brainer to book Bethel Bakery for my wedding. I booked about 3 months before my wedding. I went on several appointments to try to get ideas about what I wanted for my cake and in each of the appointments they were very professional and gave me some good ideas on how to get exactly want I wanted. They do one appointment with cake-tasting. The other appointments were mostly for me as I had a hard time figuring out which design I wanted as all of their designs are beautiful! The craftsmanship of their cakes and the flavors of their cake are far more superior to a few other bake shops that I went to in the area.

When I saw my cake on wedding day, I was blown away! It was so amazing and flawless. It looked like fondant, but it was buttercream! It was more beautiful in person than the photo I saw of it on their website. I chose the Ring of Roses cake. Kudos, to their bakers. And the taste was incredibly delicious. All of my guests were delighted that they were eating Bethel Bakery cake!

I highly recommend them for wedding cake...and groom's cake...and bridal shower cake (it was mango filled - yum!) and for wedding cookies which I've eaten in the past.
Since I've been eating Bethel Bakery cakes and pastries all my life, it was a no-brainer to book Bethel Bakery for my Read more...
Since I've been eating Bethel Bakery cakes and pastries all my life, it was a no-brainer to book Bethel Bakery for my wedding. I booked about 3 months before my wedding. I went on several appointments to try to get ideas about what I wanted for my cake and in each of the appointments they were very professional and gave me some good ideas on how to get exactly want I wanted. They do one appointment with cake-tasting. The other appointments were mostly for me as I had a hard time figuring out which design I wanted as all of their designs are beautiful! The craftsmanship of their cakes and the flavors of their cake are far more superior to a few other bake shops that I went to in the area.

When I saw my cake on wedding day, I was blown away! It was so amazing and flawless. It looked like fondant, but it was buttercream! It was more beautiful in person than the photo I saw of it on their website. I chose the Ring of Roses cake. Kudos, to their bakers. And the taste was incredibly delicious. All of my guests were delighted that they were eating Bethel Bakery cake!

I highly recommend them for wedding cake...and groom's cake...and bridal shower cake (it was mango filled - yum!) and for wedding cookies which I've eaten in the past. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bg5
Amanda
Wedding:
5/1/2009
5.0/5.0
Bethel Bakery provided our cake through the Sheraton. I was very pleased with the design, and especially the taste! They provided plenty of samples at our tasting and everything else was effortless on my part - a great vendor to work with, they have this down!
Bethel Bakery provided our cake through the Sheraton. I was very pleased with the design, and especially the taste! They Read more...
Bethel Bakery provided our cake through the Sheraton. I was very pleased with the design, and especially the taste! They provided plenty of samples at our tasting and everything else was effortless on my part - a great vendor to work with, they have this down! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Elizabeth
Wedding:
9/13/2008
5.0/5.0
Amazing. Simply amazing. So many choices, so flexible for what you want, and willing to create something new if they don't have exactly what you want. The cake was beautiful, and I actually had a cake from them at my bridesmaid luncheon, and they were able to put the charms into the cake for us while they were baking it. They were truly helpful and I loved my cake.
Amazing. Simply amazing. So many choices, so flexible for what you want, and willing to create something new if they don't Read more...
Amazing. Simply amazing. So many choices, so flexible for what you want, and willing to create something new if they don't have exactly what you want. The cake was beautiful, and I actually had a cake from them at my bridesmaid luncheon, and they were able to put the charms into the cake for us while they were baking it. They were truly helpful and I loved my cake. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
tiltnwirl
Wedding:
6/7/2008
5.0/5.0
They worked with us for hours until we designed the perfect cake. They're extremely patient and willing to put every ounce of effort into making sure that you are 110% satisfied. Our cake turned out perfect and was one of the best things about our wedding was seeing the cake!
They worked with us for hours until we designed the perfect cake. They're extremely patient and willing to put every ounce Read more...
They worked with us for hours until we designed the perfect cake. They're extremely patient and willing to put every ounce of effort into making sure that you are 110% satisfied. Our cake turned out perfect and was one of the best things about our wedding was seeing the cake! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Karen
Wedding:
5/24/2008
5.0/5.0
The cake was so gorgeous it looked fake. It was amazing, we had a marble cake with cookies and cream filling and it's all everyone could talk about!
The cake was so gorgeous it looked fake. It was amazing, we had a marble cake with cookies and cream filling and it's all Read more...
The cake was so gorgeous it looked fake. It was amazing, we had a marble cake with cookies and cream filling and it's all everyone could talk about! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
megdc
Wedding:
3/15/2008
5.0/5.0
Our cake was beautiful and delicious. It was completely effortless working with Bethel Bakery! I can't say enough great things!
Our cake was beautiful and delicious. It was completely effortless working with Bethel Bakery! I can't say enough great Read more...
Our cake was beautiful and delicious. It was completely effortless working with Bethel Bakery! I can't say enough great things! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Erin
Wedding:
11/10/2007
5.0/5.0
The wedding cake was just beautiful and I received many comments about how good it tasted. Bethel Bakery dyed the icing flowers to match the bridesmaid dress color and delivered it to my reception hall. They were very responsive to my questions and if I had to do it over again, without hesitation I would order the cake from them.
The wedding cake was just beautiful and I received many comments about how good it tasted. Bethel Bakery dyed the icing Read more...
The wedding cake was just beautiful and I received many comments about how good it tasted. Bethel Bakery dyed the icing flowers to match the bridesmaid dress color and delivered it to my reception hall. They were very responsive to my questions and if I had to do it over again, without hesitation I would order the cake from them. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Amy
Wedding:
10/13/2007
5.0/5.0
Cake turned out beautifully. They don't have very many options in styles, but the cakes taste awesome! We had marble with raspberry filling. Incredible!!! You can get creative with your style though. We put black ribbon arond the bottom of the tiers and had burgundy dotted swiss on the cake. Our cake topper was made up of 3 red calla lilies and silver wire all around them...turned out gorgeous!
Cake turned out beautifully. They don't have very many options in styles, but the cakes taste awesome! We had marble with Read more...
Cake turned out beautifully. They don't have very many options in styles, but the cakes taste awesome! We had marble with raspberry filling. Incredible!!! You can get creative with your style though. We put black ribbon arond the bottom of the tiers and had burgundy dotted swiss on the cake. Our cake topper was made up of 3 red calla lilies and silver wire all around them...turned out gorgeous! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kristin
Wedding:
10/13/2007
5.0/5.0
Delicious and beautiful cake. Only bakery you would ever need.
Delicious and beautiful cake. Only bakery you would ever need.
Delicious and beautiful cake. Only bakery you would ever need. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
5.0/5.0
The people who work there are very friendly.
They work with you on whatever you want.
Loved tasting the different varieties.
Our cake was beautiful and delicious.
The people who work there are very friendly.
They work with you on whatever you want.
Loved tasting the different Read more...
The people who work there are very friendly.
They work with you on whatever you want.
Loved tasting the different varieties.
Our cake was beautiful and delicious. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Olivia
Wedding:
9/22/2007
5.0/5.0
I've always loved Bethal Bekary and was more then happy to use them for my wedding. The cake was lovely, exactly what my husband and I wanted and everyone loved it.
I've always loved Bethal Bekary and was more then happy to use them for my wedding. The cake was lovely, exactly what my Read more...
I've always loved Bethal Bekary and was more then happy to use them for my wedding. The cake was lovely, exactly what my husband and I wanted and everyone loved it. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
chocolategem
Wedding:
9/22/2007
5.0/5.0
I have grown up on Bethel Bakery and I vowed that they would do my wedding cake. The cake was wonderful. I designed it myself and they followed it to a T - from the aqua shimmery icing to the 5 different flavors. yes they are a little on the pricey side, but the service and flavor is great. I do have one suggestion - they need to up the variety of styles and available flavors because our society has really progressed in this area. warning - If you are looking for something truly funky and are not able to design it yourself you should look elsewhere because they tend to be on the more elegant/classic side.
I have grown up on Bethel Bakery and I vowed that they would do my wedding cake. The cake was wonderful. I designed it Read more...
I have grown up on Bethel Bakery and I vowed that they would do my wedding cake. The cake was wonderful. I designed it myself and they followed it to a T - from the aqua shimmery icing to the 5 different flavors. yes they are a little on the pricey side, but the service and flavor is great. I do have one suggestion - they need to up the variety of styles and available flavors because our society has really progressed in this area. warning - If you are looking for something truly funky and are not able to design it yourself you should look elsewhere because they tend to be on the more elegant/classic side. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Robin
Wedding:
9/8/2007
5.0/5.0
The cake was beautiful AND delicious! I would definitely recommend this company.
The cake was beautiful AND delicious! I would definitely recommend this company.
The cake was beautiful AND delicious! I would definitely recommend this company. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Carrie
Wedding:
3/10/2007
5.0/5.0
The cake was sooo good! I recommend the mango filling. It doesn't overpower the cake and make its taste lighter and more refreshing. The bakery is very clean and bright and everyone I spoke to there was super nice.
The cake was sooo good! I recommend the mango filling. It doesn't overpower the cake and make its taste lighter and more Read more...
The cake was sooo good! I recommend the mango filling. It doesn't overpower the cake and make its taste lighter and more refreshing. The bakery is very clean and bright and everyone I spoke to there was super nice. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Stefanie
Wedding:
9/16/2006
5.0/5.0
We had a red velvet wedding cake that was just amazing! The frosting wasn't hard and gross like most wedding cakes and the customized it to exactly what we wanted. We were very happy!
We had a red velvet wedding cake that was just amazing! The frosting wasn't hard and gross like most wedding cakes and the Read more...
We had a red velvet wedding cake that was just amazing! The frosting wasn't hard and gross like most wedding cakes and the customized it to exactly what we wanted. We were very happy! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
icicle44
Wedding:
9/16/2006
5.0/5.0
The cake was beautiful and tasted fantastic!! They created exactly what I wanted - simple & elegant.
The cake was beautiful and tasted fantastic!! They created exactly what I wanted - simple & elegant.
The cake was beautiful and tasted fantastic!! They created exactly what I wanted - simple & elegant. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Adrienne
Wedding:
5/25/2013
5.0/5.0
Bethel Bakery has always been my favorite bakery. No one else even comes close to their buttercream icing. But we decided to do something a little different and get cupcakes for our wedding. It was the best idea we ever had. We had 13 different flavors of cupcakes, and they were a huge hit. People loved having a variety. I had to fight to get the last Tiramisu cupcake! Many of our guests commented that taking cupcakes home was better than favors. Everything we picked was absolutely delicious and looked beautiful displayed on the stand.
Bethel Bakery has always been my favorite bakery. No one else even comes close to their buttercream icing. But we decided Read more...
Bethel Bakery has always been my favorite bakery. No one else even comes close to their buttercream icing. But we decided to do something a little different and get cupcakes for our wedding. It was the best idea we ever had. We had 13 different flavors of cupcakes, and they were a huge hit. People loved having a variety. I had to fight to get the last Tiramisu cupcake! Many of our guests commented that taking cupcakes home was better than favors. Everything we picked was absolutely delicious and looked beautiful displayed on the stand. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for the great review. We are so happy that you were pleased with our wedding cupcakes! What a great idea to have them as favors.

Sweet Regards
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jackie
Wedding:
7/4/2014
4.9/5.0
Our wedding cake was amazing and delicious from Bethel Bakery! So many guests commented on how good it was and we can't wait to have it again for our 1 year!
Our wedding cake was amazing and delicious from Bethel Bakery! So many guests commented on how good it was and we can't Read more...
Our wedding cake was amazing and delicious from Bethel Bakery! So many guests commented on how good it was and we can't wait to have it again for our 1 year! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for your positive review and kind words! We are happy to have been a part of your special day and can't wait to see you soon!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Leina
Wedding:
6/14/2014
4.9/5.0
Hands down one of the things that our guests were raving about the most was our wedding cake from Bethel Bakery. My husband and I had gone to a tasting at another place previously to coming to Bethel Bakery, but once we tasted Bethel Bakery, our minds were immediately set. We worked with Holly along the way and she was extremely knowledgeable and patient as we asked her 500 questions about cake. For our wedding cake we chose the white almond batter with vanilla bean and raspberry filling and buttercream frosting. It was AMAZING. Seriously the best cake I have ever tasted. We went with the Hannah design and had our monogram added to the second layer. The final product was like something out of a storybook. The cake was absolutely gorgeous. We received so many compliments not only on how delicious it was, but also how it was stunning to look at. I will definitely be recommending Bethel Bakery to others, and am now a customer for life.
Hands down one of the things that our guests were raving about the most was our wedding cake from Bethel Bakery. My Read more...
Hands down one of the things that our guests were raving about the most was our wedding cake from Bethel Bakery. My husband and I had gone to a tasting at another place previously to coming to Bethel Bakery, but once we tasted Bethel Bakery, our minds were immediately set. We worked with Holly along the way and she was extremely knowledgeable and patient as we asked her 500 questions about cake. For our wedding cake we chose the white almond batter with vanilla bean and raspberry filling and buttercream frosting. It was AMAZING. Seriously the best cake I have ever tasted. We went with the Hannah design and had our monogram added to the second layer. The final product was like something out of a storybook. The cake was absolutely gorgeous. We received so many compliments not only on how delicious it was, but also how it was stunning to look at. I will definitely be recommending Bethel Bakery to others, and am now a customer for life. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
4.9/5.0
I worked with Katlyn and Christine, both whom were very professional. Katlyn was very helpful and patient when my family overwhelmed her with questions. They were able to work with my requests and always returned a prompt reply to my e-mails/calls. The cake turned out absolutely beautiful and was equally as delicious! I would certainly recommend this bakery.
I worked with Katlyn and Christine, both whom were very professional. Katlyn was very helpful and patient when my family Read more...
I worked with Katlyn and Christine, both whom were very professional. Katlyn was very helpful and patient when my family overwhelmed her with questions. They were able to work with my requests and always returned a prompt reply to my e-mails/calls. The cake turned out absolutely beautiful and was equally as delicious! I would certainly recommend this bakery. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jenna
Wedding:
3/22/2014
4.9/5.0
Our wedding cake was exactly as we ordered it and looked beautiful! Every time we worked with the staff they were very professional.
Our wedding cake was exactly as we ordered it and looked beautiful! Every time we worked with the staff they were very Read more...
Our wedding cake was exactly as we ordered it and looked beautiful! Every time we worked with the staff they were very professional. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
4.9/5.0
Bethel Bakery did an amazing job on our cake. It was delicious and looked exactly as requested. Our florist added the flowers but overall it was perfect. We had chocolate/raspberry filling covered in chocolate fondant. My only wish was that they had a more fudge filling to choose but the chocolate buttercream still tasted great. We wished we had more time at the wedding to eat it!
Bethel Bakery did an amazing job on our cake. It was delicious and looked exactly as requested. Our florist added the Read more...
Bethel Bakery did an amazing job on our cake. It was delicious and looked exactly as requested. Our florist added the flowers but overall it was perfect. We had chocolate/raspberry filling covered in chocolate fondant. My only wish was that they had a more fudge filling to choose but the chocolate buttercream still tasted great. We wished we had more time at the wedding to eat it! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lisa
Wedding:
6/2/2012
4.9/5.0
The cake from Bethel Bakery was delicious! The design of how my wedding turned out was great! I loved how it was designed. Great to work with in the planning process!
The cake from Bethel Bakery was delicious! The design of how my wedding turned out was great! I loved how it was designed. Read more...
The cake from Bethel Bakery was delicious! The design of how my wedding turned out was great! I loved how it was designed. Great to work with in the planning process! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
acl142
Wedding:
1/9/2010
4.9/5.0
Awesome cake - got soooooo many complements on it. Not only beautiful, but tasty as well. Had several guests comment, this is the first Wedding cake we have ever had that actually tastes good.

Got the almond batter with Raspberry filling. Amazing. Timeless design, with ribbon (bakery worked with me for ribbon that matched my centerpieces) and got flowers from florist to compliment because sugar flowers would not show up in hot pink.

Awesome!
Awesome cake - got soooooo many complements on it. Not only beautiful, but tasty as well. Had several guests comment, this Read more...
Awesome cake - got soooooo many complements on it. Not only beautiful, but tasty as well. Had several guests comment, this is the first Wedding cake we have ever had that actually tastes good.

Got the almond batter with Raspberry filling. Amazing. Timeless design, with ribbon (bakery worked with me for ribbon that matched my centerpieces) and got flowers from florist to compliment because sugar flowers would not show up in hot pink.

Awesome! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Tracy
Wedding:
9/20/2008
4.9/5.0
Our wedding cake from Bethel Bakery was absolutely beautiful!! We were so impressed at our reception when we saw the cake for the first time! We chose white cake with the mango filling. So delicious and Bethel was so helpful when it came to chosing sizes and designs!! Highly reccomend for any ocasion!
Our wedding cake from Bethel Bakery was absolutely beautiful!! We were so impressed at our reception when we saw the cake Read more...
Our wedding cake from Bethel Bakery was absolutely beautiful!! We were so impressed at our reception when we saw the cake for the first time! We chose white cake with the mango filling. So delicious and Bethel was so helpful when it came to chosing sizes and designs!! Highly reccomend for any ocasion! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Cristina
Wedding:
7/28/2007
4.9/5.0
The cake was delicious, I use Bethel Bakery for every special occassion. I ended up changing my cake a couple of weeks before and they didn't get mad or charge me for changing it or anything. Awesome service.
The cake was delicious, I use Bethel Bakery for every special occassion. I ended up changing my cake a couple of weeks Read more...
The cake was delicious, I use Bethel Bakery for every special occassion. I ended up changing my cake a couple of weeks before and they didn't get mad or charge me for changing it or anything. Awesome service. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
hypotica321
Wedding:
10/20/2006
4.9/5.0
Bethel Bakery has been a staple for my family for as long as I can remember. Every birthday or special event that happened throughout my life has been celebrated with a cake from Bethel Bakery, so there was no question as to where my wedding cake was coming from. Their selection was not as extensive as I would have hoped but their eagerness to create the perfect cake for me was welcomed. I had a very simple cake but there were specific details that I was most focusod on, including the fine pattern on each of the layers. They were 100% receptive of my ideas and had the technology needed for me to get specific information to them as I was planning my wedding from Virginia. They are wonderful and I can't tell you how many compliments I got on my cake!!
Bethel Bakery has been a staple for my family for as long as I can remember. Every birthday or special event that happened Read more...
Bethel Bakery has been a staple for my family for as long as I can remember. Every birthday or special event that happened throughout my life has been celebrated with a cake from Bethel Bakery, so there was no question as to where my wedding cake was coming from. Their selection was not as extensive as I would have hoped but their eagerness to create the perfect cake for me was welcomed. I had a very simple cake but there were specific details that I was most focusod on, including the fine pattern on each of the layers. They were 100% receptive of my ideas and had the technology needed for me to get specific information to them as I was planning my wedding from Virginia. They are wonderful and I can't tell you how many compliments I got on my cake!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Marsha
Wedding:
5/30/2014
4.8/5.0
Loved the cake. Tasted as great as it looked
Loved the cake. Tasted as great as it looked
Loved the cake. Tasted as great as it looked Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Megan
Wedding:
5/17/2014
4.8/5.0
Beautiful. delicious. Everything I could hope my wedding cake would be on my wedding day...for a great price!
Beautiful. delicious. Everything I could hope my wedding cake would be on my wedding day...for a great price!
Beautiful. delicious. Everything I could hope my wedding cake would be on my wedding day...for a great price! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Shaun
Wedding:
10/13/2012
4.8/5.0
We only needed a small cake for the top tier of our cupcake "tower", but the cake looked wonderful and tasted delicious.
We only needed a small cake for the top tier of our cupcake "tower", but the cake looked wonderful and tasted delicious.
We only needed a small cake for the top tier of our cupcake "tower", but the cake looked wonderful and tasted delicious. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Amanda
Wedding:
5/31/2008
4.8/5.0
I loved our cake from Bethel Bakery. It tasted great and looked great as well. They made the cake to look exactly as I had imagined it. I thought the prices were a little expensive, but with very few vendors in the area, they can get away with the cost. I was also a little annoyed that they would not put my cake topper on my cake before the guests arrived and I had to do it myself later. They gave very specific requirements for the cake topper that I was sure to meet. Overall, I found it to be a very easy and pleasant experience working with Bethel Bakery. I would recommend them to brides-to-be. A quick tip: Go for a smaller version of your wedding cake and buy the cheaper look alike sheet cakes to serve your guests.
I loved our cake from Bethel Bakery. It tasted great and looked great as well. They made the cake to look exactly as I had Read more...
I loved our cake from Bethel Bakery. It tasted great and looked great as well. They made the cake to look exactly as I had imagined it. I thought the prices were a little expensive, but with very few vendors in the area, they can get away with the cost. I was also a little annoyed that they would not put my cake topper on my cake before the guests arrived and I had to do it myself later. They gave very specific requirements for the cake topper that I was sure to meet. Overall, I found it to be a very easy and pleasant experience working with Bethel Bakery. I would recommend them to brides-to-be. A quick tip: Go for a smaller version of your wedding cake and buy the cheaper look alike sheet cakes to serve your guests. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Deenie
Wedding:
5/20/2006
4.8/5.0
They will make whatever you want as long as you are willing to pay for it. I had a 3 tier chocolate cake with buttercream icing covered in coconut. As far as I can remember, it did cost extra for coconut but it was what we wanted and Declicious!
They will make whatever you want as long as you are willing to pay for it. I had a 3 tier chocolate cake with buttercream Read more...
They will make whatever you want as long as you are willing to pay for it. I had a 3 tier chocolate cake with buttercream icing covered in coconut. As far as I can remember, it did cost extra for coconut but it was what we wanted and Declicious! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kiki
Wedding:
10/22/2005
4.8/5.0
Our wedding cake was fabulous. They have so many choices but I mostly wanted something simple and elegant. I was especially impressed with our personal baker. We met with her and told her what we wanted. We got to try several samples, which was fun. And she was very responsive to our requests. We indicated that my parents and probably a majority of the wedding guests preferred one flavor while my groom and I liked another that was a little more exotic. She suggested that we have our top layer (our one-year anniversary layer) as the flavor we liked and the rest of the cake be the other one. This worked out well and amazingly that cake one year later was delicious! Also, b/c we had a relatively large number of guests, we decided to do a sheet cake to save on cost. Another great idea. We even ended up doing a groom's cake for my husband--which he loved b/c it had an actual photo of his favorite baseball player on it.
Overall, my experience with Bethel Bakery was fantastic and the cake was yummy. :-)
Our wedding cake was fabulous. They have so many choices but I mostly wanted something simple and elegant. I was Read more...
Our wedding cake was fabulous. They have so many choices but I mostly wanted something simple and elegant. I was especially impressed with our personal baker. We met with her and told her what we wanted. We got to try several samples, which was fun. And she was very responsive to our requests. We indicated that my parents and probably a majority of the wedding guests preferred one flavor while my groom and I liked another that was a little more exotic. She suggested that we have our top layer (our one-year anniversary layer) as the flavor we liked and the rest of the cake be the other one. This worked out well and amazingly that cake one year later was delicious! Also, b/c we had a relatively large number of guests, we decided to do a sheet cake to save on cost. Another great idea. We even ended up doing a groom's cake for my husband--which he loved b/c it had an actual photo of his favorite baseball player on it.
Overall, my experience with Bethel Bakery was fantastic and the cake was yummy. :-) Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Tracie
Wedding:
8/23/2014
4.7/5.0
My wedding cake was beautiful and delicious. I chose 2 designs from bethel bakery and turned them into one and added some of my own ideas. They did everything I asked for creating this cake!
My wedding cake was beautiful and delicious. I chose 2 designs from bethel bakery and turned them into one and added some Read more...
My wedding cake was beautiful and delicious. I chose 2 designs from bethel bakery and turned them into one and added some of my own ideas. They did everything I asked for creating this cake! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for your lovely review! We appreciate your kind words and look forward to working with you again in the future! Congratulations and best wishes!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Amanda
Wedding:
10/12/2013
4.7/5.0
Bethel Bakery provided us with a cake that looked exactly as we wanted it for our big day. It tasted great (almond batter with raspberry filling) and our guests were all very satisfied with the flavor! It is a bit expensive but comparable to surrounding bakeries.
Bethel Bakery provided us with a cake that looked exactly as we wanted it for our big day. It tasted great (almond batter Read more...
Bethel Bakery provided us with a cake that looked exactly as we wanted it for our big day. It tasted great (almond batter with raspberry filling) and our guests were all very satisfied with the flavor! It is a bit expensive but comparable to surrounding bakeries. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Tiffany
Wedding:
5/25/2013
4.7/5.0
The cake tasted amazing! They even gave us a box with instructions on how to preserve our top cake. We used their cake stand and was beautiful. They made everything look amazing. The made flowers out of fondant and were great. The reason I didn't the 5 on quality was when they dropped off my cake at the venue it was leaning. My aunt said something to the delivery guy, he said ok but didn't fixed it. He just left!
The cake tasted amazing! They even gave us a box with instructions on how to preserve our top cake. We used their cake Read more...
The cake tasted amazing! They even gave us a box with instructions on how to preserve our top cake. We used their cake stand and was beautiful. They made everything look amazing. The made flowers out of fondant and were great. The reason I didn't the 5 on quality was when they dropped off my cake at the venue it was leaning. My aunt said something to the delivery guy, he said ok but didn't fixed it. He just left! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
4.7/5.0
The bakery did everything that we wanted. They made individual cakes for 8 tables, and also a tiered cake for us to cut. All for $300. They did exactly what we wanted with type of cake, colors, icing, etc. The only problem we noticed was that the cakes were somewhat dry (we think it was because the venue cut it too soon). It was delicious, and we were very pleased with the cakes!!!
The bakery did everything that we wanted. They made individual cakes for 8 tables, and also a tiered cake for us to cut. Read more...
The bakery did everything that we wanted. They made individual cakes for 8 tables, and also a tiered cake for us to cut. All for $300. They did exactly what we wanted with type of cake, colors, icing, etc. The only problem we noticed was that the cakes were somewhat dry (we think it was because the venue cut it too soon). It was delicious, and we were very pleased with the cakes!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Bride12
Wedding:
10/25/2008
4.7/5.0
The cake was beautiful and delicious, however we had a special design request and ended up being very pricey.
The cake was beautiful and delicious, however we had a special design request and ended up being very pricey.
The cake was beautiful and delicious, however we had a special design request and ended up being very pricey. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Donna
Wedding:
3/8/2014
4.6/5.0
Our cake was not only delicious but it was absolutely beautiful!!! I would recommend Bethel Bakery to anyoe searching for the perfect cake!
Our cake was not only delicious but it was absolutely beautiful!!! I would recommend Bethel Bakery to anyoe searching for Read more...
Our cake was not only delicious but it was absolutely beautiful!!! I would recommend Bethel Bakery to anyoe searching for the perfect cake! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Hi Donna! Thank you for the great review! We were honored to be a part of your special day!
130x130_sq_1382572926205-jhnsn202
Mrs. Katie J
Wedding:
10/12/2013
4.6/5.0
Born and raised in the South Hills of Pittsburgh, Bethel Bakery has always been the "go-to" place for all of my family's special occasions; so choosing them to do our wedding cake was an easy choice!

We chose a four tiered cake with three types of batter and filling; yellow cake with chocolate mousse, yellow cake with butter cream, and white almond cake with strawberry mousse. The cake was not only gorgeous, but delicious! We did decide to have my sister design and build the floral pieces that were attached to the cake, rather than going with the stock design from the bakery, because we wanted our cake flowers to match our wedding flowers; we went with a cymbidium orchid, which most people haven't heard of, let alone regularly put on a cake!

The only thing that we weren't thrilled with about our cake was the price. Our cake was not intricately decorated and was rather simple but it still cost almost $1,000.00. Granted, the cake fed 180 people, but it was a little more expensive than we were expecting for a more simple design.

Also, because we're both from Pittsburgh, a cookie table was a must! We chose about 25 different types of cookies, and had them trayed and delivered with our cake, and everyone loved them! The top-rated cookies of the evening were the cake truffles, buckeyes, lady locks, and the various soft-drop cookies.

Regardless of the price, overall, we absolutely loved using Bethel Bakery for our cake and cookies, and we would definitely recommend them to other couples looking for a beautifully delicious cake!
Born and raised in the South Hills of Pittsburgh, Bethel Bakery has always been the "go-to" place for all of my family's Read more...
Born and raised in the South Hills of Pittsburgh, Bethel Bakery has always been the "go-to" place for all of my family's special occasions; so choosing them to do our wedding cake was an easy choice!

We chose a four tiered cake with three types of batter and filling; yellow cake with chocolate mousse, yellow cake with butter cream, and white almond cake with strawberry mousse. The cake was not only gorgeous, but delicious! We did decide to have my sister design and build the floral pieces that were attached to the cake, rather than going with the stock design from the bakery, because we wanted our cake flowers to match our wedding flowers; we went with a cymbidium orchid, which most people haven't heard of, let alone regularly put on a cake!

The only thing that we weren't thrilled with about our cake was the price. Our cake was not intricately decorated and was rather simple but it still cost almost $1,000.00. Granted, the cake fed 180 people, but it was a little more expensive than we were expecting for a more simple design.

Also, because we're both from Pittsburgh, a cookie table was a must! We chose about 25 different types of cookies, and had them trayed and delivered with our cake, and everyone loved them! The top-rated cookies of the evening were the cake truffles, buckeyes, lady locks, and the various soft-drop cookies.

Regardless of the price, overall, we absolutely loved using Bethel Bakery for our cake and cookies, and we would definitely recommend them to other couples looking for a beautifully delicious cake! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Zoila
Wedding:
7/6/2013
4.6/5.0
A bit pricey but quality of the cake was worth it.
A bit pricey but quality of the cake was worth it.
A bit pricey but quality of the cake was worth it. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Melanie
Wedding:
12/31/2012
4.6/5.0
Choosing a cake was one of the easiest parts of planning my wedding thanks to Bethel Bakery. We did a tasting, picked out our favorite flavors, and chose a decoration from the many pictures and sample displays they had. We weren't even there an hour!! They were a little bit more expensive than some of the other vendors; however, the cake was fresh and delicious, and the details in the decoration were impeccable!!
Choosing a cake was one of the easiest parts of planning my wedding thanks to Bethel Bakery. We did a tasting, picked out Read more...
Choosing a cake was one of the easiest parts of planning my wedding thanks to Bethel Bakery. We did a tasting, picked out our favorite flavors, and chose a decoration from the many pictures and sample displays they had. We weren't even there an hour!! They were a little bit more expensive than some of the other vendors; however, the cake was fresh and delicious, and the details in the decoration were impeccable!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Thank you for the great review. We are so happy that you were pleased with your wedding cake! I'm glad the process was easy and enjoyable for you in a time where things can get crazy!
130x130_sq_1229296243638-621fashionshow174
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
4.6/5.0
The cake was beautiful and delicious. I wish I got more than one bite of it! Because of their excellent reputation they were a bit pricey and we had to settle for a smaller cake to stay within our budget. I still wouldn't change it, though!
The cake was beautiful and delicious. I wish I got more than one bite of it! Because of their excellent reputation they Read more...
The cake was beautiful and delicious. I wish I got more than one bite of it! Because of their excellent reputation they were a bit pricey and we had to settle for a smaller cake to stay within our budget. I still wouldn't change it, though! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
JStz76
Wedding:
5/30/2009
4.6/5.0
We had a fabulous Bethel Bakery cake. The selection process was so easy, and we were able to mix up our tiers with square and round shapes for a fun look. The cake itself was so beautiful and was one of the best wedding cakes I have ever tasted. Fantastic vendor!
We had a fabulous Bethel Bakery cake. The selection process was so easy, and we were able to mix up our tiers with square Read more...
We had a fabulous Bethel Bakery cake. The selection process was so easy, and we were able to mix up our tiers with square and round shapes for a fun look. The cake itself was so beautiful and was one of the best wedding cakes I have ever tasted. Fantastic vendor! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
cawleym
Wedding:
5/30/2009
4.6/5.0
We had a very simple cake and it was done to our liking. I felt that the cake was overpriced, though, who doesn't overprice wedding cakes. I would say that the cake choice was not as tasty as could be, though the appearance of the cake was nice.
We had a very simple cake and it was done to our liking. I felt that the cake was overpriced, though, who doesn't Read more...
We had a very simple cake and it was done to our liking. I felt that the cake was overpriced, though, who doesn't overprice wedding cakes. I would say that the cake choice was not as tasty as could be, though the appearance of the cake was nice. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
bam298
Wedding:
9/6/2008
4.6/5.0
BEAUTIFUL CAKE!!! The groom's cake is awesome as well.
BEAUTIFUL CAKE!!! The groom's cake is awesome as well.
BEAUTIFUL CAKE!!! The groom's cake is awesome as well. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
sunbeam939
Wedding:
7/28/2007
4.6/5.0
This is a mixed-review. On the one hand, they were incredibly friendly, professional, and welcoming. The cake-testing was awesome. However, the flowers on my cake turned out to be the wrong color, and the fillings were also wrong in our top tier. The ONLY thing my husband wanted out of the entire wedding experience was his preferred cake filling, and he didn't get it. So that was disappointing. I thought their price was very affordable, but we also didn't get what we paid for entirely, so . . .
This is a mixed-review. On the one hand, they were incredibly friendly, professional, and welcoming. The cake-testing was Read more...
This is a mixed-review. On the one hand, they were incredibly friendly, professional, and welcoming. The cake-testing was awesome. However, the flowers on my cake turned out to be the wrong color, and the fillings were also wrong in our top tier. The ONLY thing my husband wanted out of the entire wedding experience was his preferred cake filling, and he didn't get it. So that was disappointing. I thought their price was very affordable, but we also didn't get what we paid for entirely, so . . . Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
married
Wedding:
9/3/2006
4.6/5.0
went out of their way to make my wedding cake exactly the way i wanted it
went out of their way to make my wedding cake exactly the way i wanted it
went out of their way to make my wedding cake exactly the way i wanted it Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Ashleigh
Wedding:
6/23/2007
4.5/5.0
Incredibly delicious and original cakes. Couldn't have been happier with the service. They aren't the most inexpensive cakes in the city but if your having a large wedding there are ways to work around it. In the end I had a square three tiered cake but the majority of the guests recieved slices from the birthday cakes we purchased. The cut looks the same but birthday cakes are much less expensive. So if your budget is getting tight opt for a smaller decorative cake and use the birthday cakes as a substitute.
Incredibly delicious and original cakes. Couldn't have been happier with the service. They aren't the most inexpensive Read more...
Incredibly delicious and original cakes. Couldn't have been happier with the service. They aren't the most inexpensive cakes in the city but if your having a large wedding there are ways to work around it. In the end I had a square three tiered cake but the majority of the guests recieved slices from the birthday cakes we purchased. The cut looks the same but birthday cakes are much less expensive. So if your budget is getting tight opt for a smaller decorative cake and use the birthday cakes as a substitute. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
DIANE.. MOTHER OF THE BRIDE....
Wedding:
5/5/2012
4.4/5.0
The Cake was awesome... decotated exactly how my daughter wanted and it was delicious....
The Cake was awesome... decotated exactly how my daughter wanted and it was delicious....
The Cake was awesome... decotated exactly how my daughter wanted and it was delicious.... Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Christie
Wedding:
10/12/2007
4.4/5.0
Every bride says their wedding cake was the most beautiful wedding cake ever. I had numerous guests whom asked if the cake was fake because it "looked too perfect." We selected a three tiered stacked cake with delicate ivy and roses trailing down the sides. It was simple and gorgeous. We had orange and almond flavored cake with buttercream icing. Very delicious! My only pet peeve was that they charged us a $30 delivery fee because we got married on a Friday. But overall, great cake at a great price.
Every bride says their wedding cake was the most beautiful wedding cake ever. I had numerous guests whom asked if the cake Read more...
Every bride says their wedding cake was the most beautiful wedding cake ever. I had numerous guests whom asked if the cake was fake because it "looked too perfect." We selected a three tiered stacked cake with delicate ivy and roses trailing down the sides. It was simple and gorgeous. We had orange and almond flavored cake with buttercream icing. Very delicious! My only pet peeve was that they charged us a $30 delivery fee because we got married on a Friday. But overall, great cake at a great price. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
4.1/5.0
Very friendly and helpful staff. They made the cake exactly as I chose. I did feel that some of the standard designs were limited but the flavor choices were varied and the cake itself was delicious.
Very friendly and helpful staff. They made the cake exactly as I chose. I did feel that some of the standard designs were Read more...
Very friendly and helpful staff. They made the cake exactly as I chose. I did feel that some of the standard designs were limited but the flavor choices were varied and the cake itself was delicious. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
athene9
Wedding:
1/23/2008
4.1/5.0
Everyone is so nice. They really take time to help you find the perfect cake in flavor and design. Highly recomend!!
Everyone is so nice. They really take time to help you find the perfect cake in flavor and design. Highly recomend!!
Everyone is so nice. They really take time to help you find the perfect cake in flavor and design. Highly recomend!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kristina
Wedding:
9/6/2013
4.0/5.0
The cake was perfect!! the colors matched everything else in the wedding. It tasted yummy and everything was conviently taken care of! Delicious!
The cake was perfect!! the colors matched everything else in the wedding. It tasted yummy and everything was conviently Read more...
The cake was perfect!! the colors matched everything else in the wedding. It tasted yummy and everything was conviently taken care of! Delicious! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
John and Marie
Wedding:
3/23/2013
4.0/5.0
Cake was delicious, priced right but one bog problem. It was late arriving. I would recommend them to anyone, but Bethel needs to be more prompt, their excuse was they got lost.......
Cake was delicious, priced right but one bog problem. It was late arriving. I would recommend them to anyone, but Bethel Read more...
Cake was delicious, priced right but one bog problem. It was late arriving. I would recommend them to anyone, but Bethel needs to be more prompt, their excuse was they got lost....... Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

John and Marie, I noticed that you had your wedding on March 23, 2013.? I am very sorry but I do not see that we delivered to the Lemont on that day. Do I have the correct date?
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Amy
Wedding:
11/6/2004
4.0/5.0
The cake was gorgeous and delicious. The woman made us an after hours appointment since my husband and I worked such strange hours. They were very helpful and made my day very special.
The cake was gorgeous and delicious. The woman made us an after hours appointment since my husband and I worked such Read more...
The cake was gorgeous and delicious. The woman made us an after hours appointment since my husband and I worked such strange hours. They were very helpful and made my day very special. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1275864182834-img0046
Tamara
Wedding:
4/28/2012
3.8/5.0
We received our cake as part of the package through our venue. When we went for our taste testing, we felt rushed. They gave me the plate of cake, but I didn't have time to finish savoring the first piece before the lady immediately began telling us about the next one. Then I couldn't remember which was which. I just wonder if our experience would have been better if we hadn't already decided that our cake would be from them. The cake did taste very good though.
We received our cake as part of the package through our venue. When we went for our taste testing, we felt rushed. They Read more...
We received our cake as part of the package through our venue. When we went for our taste testing, we felt rushed. They gave me the plate of cake, but I didn't have time to finish savoring the first piece before the lady immediately began telling us about the next one. Then I couldn't remember which was which. I just wonder if our experience would have been better if we hadn't already decided that our cake would be from them. The cake did taste very good though. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Alicia
Wedding:
3/26/2005
3.7/5.0
The cake was beautiful and delicious, and they were great to work with. Very please.
The cake was beautiful and delicious, and they were great to work with. Very please.
The cake was beautiful and delicious, and they were great to work with. Very please. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Heather
Wedding:
6/24/2007
3.1/5.0
My cake turned out beautifully, but it sure did cost me. I custom designed every detail of the cake, and though one of the colors was slightly off it was recreated beautifully. It was delicious and fun to look at, but much more expensive than a lot of the competition.

If you do go with them make sure you get their butter cream icing. It's what they're known for, and why they are more $$. I had a mixture of fondant and fudge icing on mine and though it looked awesome but I missed the butter cream.
My cake turned out beautifully, but it sure did cost me. I custom designed every detail of the cake, and though one of the Read more...
My cake turned out beautifully, but it sure did cost me. I custom designed every detail of the cake, and though one of the colors was slightly off it was recreated beautifully. It was delicious and fun to look at, but much more expensive than a lot of the competition.

If you do go with them make sure you get their butter cream icing. It's what they're known for, and why they are more $$. I had a mixture of fondant and fudge icing on mine and though it looked awesome but I missed the butter cream. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jennifer
Wedding:
6/22/2013
3.0/5.0
We wanted to have cupcakes instead of a cake for our wedding. After going to all the local cupcake shops around Pittsburgh, we decided on Bethel Bakery. We understood the nature of the business but the woman we worked with wasn't the most pleasant person. We felt as though working in the wedding industry, she would have a friendly, upbeat, and energetic personality. On top of that, they wanted to charge us $200+ to "set-up" the cupcakes. We felt as though we were getting ripped off and luckily our cater was more than happy to do it (for no charge). The cupcakes were good but the customer service, not so much.
We wanted to have cupcakes instead of a cake for our wedding. After going to all the local cupcake shops around Read more...
We wanted to have cupcakes instead of a cake for our wedding. After going to all the local cupcake shops around Pittsburgh, we decided on Bethel Bakery. We understood the nature of the business but the woman we worked with wasn't the most pleasant person. We felt as though working in the wedding industry, she would have a friendly, upbeat, and energetic personality. On top of that, they wanted to charge us $200+ to "set-up" the cupcakes. We felt as though we were getting ripped off and luckily our cater was more than happy to do it (for no charge). The cupcakes were good but the customer service, not so much. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Cassandra
Wedding:
10/19/2013
2.3/5.0
We ordered our cake months before our event. Went in for our final meeting and they has lost our form. Our cake arrived on time at the venue but the top tier was smashed..and they put the smashed part in the front for everyone to see. Needless to say after spending hundreds of dollars on our cake that really pissed me off. Can't say id recommend them for such an important event again.
We ordered our cake months before our event. Went in for our final meeting and they has lost our form. Our cake arrived on Read more...
We ordered our cake months before our event. Went in for our final meeting and they has lost our form. Our cake arrived on time at the venue but the top tier was smashed..and they put the smashed part in the front for everyone to see. Needless to say after spending hundreds of dollars on our cake that really pissed me off. Can't say id recommend them for such an important event again. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bethel Bakery responded with the following comments:

Cassandra, I am very sorry to hear of your disappointment with your wedding cake. As standard procedure, before we leave the reception site, we do take a picture of the wedding cake. I have your cake and I do not see where the top tier was bumped/smashed. Would it be possible if I send you this picture? We would never leave a wedding cake if we saw any imperfections as you have mentioned. If you could please contact me, Christine, at wedding@bethelbakery.com, I would be happy to forward the picture so we can talk further. I look forward to hearing back from you.

MAP

 
5200 Brightwood Road, Bethel Park, PA 15102 See On Map
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for Bethel Bakery
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww_logo
 
220x220_1375822499566-gumpaste-flower-cascade-email