130x130_sq_1317354469691-birchtreebarkcakephoto

Cake Fiction

Long Valley , NJ
CONTACT US
CONTACT US

LOCATION

The Barn at 11 East Mill Road
Long Valley, NJ US 07853 (map)

PHONE

862-205-9035

WEBSITE

View website
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.

ABOUT US

Wedding cakes, groom's cakes, cupcake displays and favors by experienced international pastry chef Paula Tosonotti. Call to book a tasting at our new Union NJ boutique cakery, or special... Read more
Wedding cakes, groom's cakes, cupcake displays and favors by experienced international pastry chef Paula Tosonotti. Call to book a tasting at our new Union NJ boutique cakery, or special consultations available in South Orange NJ. Read less
Wedding Cake

PHOTOS

130x130_sq_1283124509406-birchtreebarkcakephoto
130x130_sq_1310180524555-magentaorchidsweddingcakewithsnowflakes
130x130_sq_1310180256734-damaskcakewithchandeliersandredroses
130x130_sq_1310180218498-cymbidiumorchidspurpleweddingcake
130x130_sq_1310180689354-whiteweddingcakewithpeonybouquets
130x130_sq_1283124561359-violetandbluehydrangeasweddingcake
130x130_sq_1283124606453-purewhitebowcake
130x130_sq_1283124658469-ivoryweddingcakewithdahlias
130x130_sq_1283124704250-peacockfeathersandrosesweddingcake
130x130_sq_1283124771781-newyankeestadiumretirementcake
130x130_sq_1283124807953-lamborghinimurcielagogroomscake
130x130_sq_1283124847156-indianweddingcakewithgarnetreddetails
130x130_sq_1283124925625-img1883blueweddingcakewithhydrangeabouquet
130x130_sq_1283124986250-poppiesandliliesweddinganniversarycake
130x130_sq_1310180292707-fallweddingcakewithchrysanthemumsanddahlias
130x130_sq_1310180368523-fashionshopaholiccake
130x130_sq_1310180474541-guccihandbagandboxbridalshowercake
130x130_sq_1310180603429-seashellsandcattleyaorchidsweddingcake
130x130_sq_1310180630261-steinwaygrandpianogroomscake
130x130_sq_1310180723689-yellowrosebowlweddingcake
130x130_sq_1310181390419-gaudiinspiredmosaicweddingcake
130x130_sq_1310181455939-louboutinshoecake
130x130_sq_1310181514361-quiltedivoryweddingcakewithcallalillies
130x130_sq_1310181551520-whiteranunculusflowersweddingcake
130x130_sq_1356060764836-drumsetweddingcake

INFO FOR WEDDING CAKE

Besides cakes, what other types of desserts do you provide?
Cookies, Cupcakes, Groom's Cake
What additional services do you provide?
Consultations, On-site Delivery, On-site Setup, Pickup, Tastings
What dietary needs can you accommodate?
Gluten Free, Lactose Free, Organic, Vegan
Do you provide customary cakes, such as Croquembouche?
Yes
Are you licensed by the state health department?
Yes
Do you offer private tastings or open house tastings?
We offer tastings by appointment, either at our Cake Boutique and Commercial Kitchen in Union NJ, or in South Orange NJ.
What are your tasting hours?
Monday-Thursday Daytime, Evenings and Weekends - Prior appointment is required.
Describe how you price, such as by slice or by tier, for your cakes?
Minimum price $250, and then prices are per serving based on number of guests.
Do you offer custom cakes, or do you work with pre-designed styles?
All of our cakes are custom and made to order. To help with the creative spark, we encourage our customers to bring to a consultation any photos, fabric swatches, color cards, invitations or any items you would want to incorporate in the design.
What (if any) special ingredients, such as fresh fruits or farm-fresh butter, do you use in your cakes?
All our cakes, creams, buttercreams and fillings are made from scratch. We use the best quality ingredients eg. Belgian chocolate, real Madagascar vanilla beans, imported French essences and extracts, fresh fruit etc.
On average, how far in advance of the event do you prepare the cake?
We bake the cake the day before an event, although elements such as sugar flowers and sculpted figurines have to be made a week in advance.
How many cakes do you schedule for a typical weekend?
Typically 4-6, to guarantee our attention to detail for every cake and to be able to give you personal attention during delivery and set up.
Will you work with the client's florist to garnish the cake?
Yes we can, and we can also recommend a trusted local florist if you prefer.
What (if any) cake accessories, such as a cake stand or cake cutter, do you rent out?
We have several (round and square) beautiful and ornate silver cake stands, as well as clear acrylic cupcake stands that make a great display.
Do you offer delivery? If yes, how much is your average delivery fee?
Yes, we do. Free delivery within a 5 mile radius, otherwise we charge $1 per mile to the venue with a $20 minimum. We have delivered as far afield as CT, PA and Long Island NY.

REVIEWS

5.0
out of 5.0
5.0/5.0
5.0/5.0
5.0/5.0
4.9/5.0
5.0/5.0
Sort by
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Colin
Wedding:
10/12/2013
5.0/5.0
I would give my highest recommendation to Cake Fiction. Quite simply, Paula created a work of art for my groom's cake - I was even hesitant to have it cut up and eaten because it looked so good. I gave her a very complicated three-layer design and she did not say "no" to any of my ideas. She produced exactly what I wanted, delivered it on time, and, as a bonus, the cake tasted incredible. I plan to use Cake Fiction again for any fancy party that comes up - they are a joy to work with.
I would give my highest recommendation to Cake Fiction. Quite simply, Paula created a work of art for my groom's cake - I Read more...
I would give my highest recommendation to Cake Fiction. Quite simply, Paula created a work of art for my groom's cake - I was even hesitant to have it cut up and eaten because it looked so good. I gave her a very complicated three-layer design and she did not say "no" to any of my ideas. She produced exactly what I wanted, delivered it on time, and, as a bonus, the cake tasted incredible. I plan to use Cake Fiction again for any fancy party that comes up - they are a joy to work with. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
M
Wedding:
7/20/2013
5.0/5.0
1 YEAR UPDATE: My husband and I unwrapped our cake for our 1st Anniversary. What we heard from so many friends was that this was a moment of great disappointment on their Anniversary. However, Cake Fiction did not fail us. The cake was left in the fridge for a few hours to defrost and WOW. It was as good 1 year later as our wedding night. Thank you for continuing to add to our wedding celebration! We can't wait to come back for another celebration cake!

Paula at Cake Fiction created the most appealing and delicious cake for our wedding in New York City. Guests were out of their chairs all through dinner taking pictures, not of the happy couple, but our cake. No one could get over the color match between the cake and the dresses/tuxes all from a simple sample swatch we gave Cake Fiction. It was truly unbelievable. Besides looking amazing, the taste was out of this world. It was the only item of the evening that I left the dance floor to enjoy, and finish. I have been to over 20 weddings in the past 2 years and this was the only cake I have enjoyed. The planning process was not only delicious but entertaining as well. We had the opportunity to try all of the flavor combinations as well as discuss different design elements and see sketches, pictures and samples. We made a change to our design a few weeks before the big day and within 48 hours we had an emailed sketch of our change for approval. The end result, a cake we thought was only a dream. Thank you Paula for such a great addition to our special day. We look forward to the next big event to come back in for a design appointment.
1 YEAR UPDATE: My husband and I unwrapped our cake for our 1st Anniversary. What we heard from so many friends was that Read more...
1 YEAR UPDATE: My husband and I unwrapped our cake for our 1st Anniversary. What we heard from so many friends was that this was a moment of great disappointment on their Anniversary. However, Cake Fiction did not fail us. The cake was left in the fridge for a few hours to defrost and WOW. It was as good 1 year later as our wedding night. Thank you for continuing to add to our wedding celebration! We can't wait to come back for another celebration cake!

Paula at Cake Fiction created the most appealing and delicious cake for our wedding in New York City. Guests were out of their chairs all through dinner taking pictures, not of the happy couple, but our cake. No one could get over the color match between the cake and the dresses/tuxes all from a simple sample swatch we gave Cake Fiction. It was truly unbelievable. Besides looking amazing, the taste was out of this world. It was the only item of the evening that I left the dance floor to enjoy, and finish. I have been to over 20 weddings in the past 2 years and this was the only cake I have enjoyed. The planning process was not only delicious but entertaining as well. We had the opportunity to try all of the flavor combinations as well as discuss different design elements and see sketches, pictures and samples. We made a change to our design a few weeks before the big day and within 48 hours we had an emailed sketch of our change for approval. The end result, a cake we thought was only a dream. Thank you Paula for such a great addition to our special day. We look forward to the next big event to come back in for a design appointment. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jennifer
Wedding:
6/15/2013
5.0/5.0
Paula was very professional and very kind. My wedding cake was not only beautiful but tasted great. I would recommend this bakery to anyone. Thank you for such a great cake and great service.

Regards,

Jennifer Lopez
Paula was very professional and very kind. My wedding cake was not only beautiful but tasted great. I would recommend this Read more...
Paula was very professional and very kind. My wedding cake was not only beautiful but tasted great. I would recommend this bakery to anyone. Thank you for such a great cake and great service.

Regards,

Jennifer Lopez Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1373034645660-0152
Sharon Rene
Wedding:
6/15/2013
5.0/5.0
Our wedding cake looked exactly like the picture I gave to Cake fiction and it tasted great too! We had a great time at the cake tasting as well! Thanks to you "Cake fiction" for making my Wedding day!
Our wedding cake looked exactly like the picture I gave to Cake fiction and it tasted great too! We had a great time at Read more...
Our wedding cake looked exactly like the picture I gave to Cake fiction and it tasted great too! We had a great time at the cake tasting as well! Thanks to you "Cake fiction" for making my Wedding day! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
5.0/5.0
I came across cake fiction through a random google search of vendors in my area - and I could not be happier that I did. Paula was responsive and helpful from day one. I pitched my many ideas to her and she helped me figure out what I wanted it, sketched out the idea on a notepad, and somehow a few months later turned our brainstormed creation into a beautiful reality. People are still talking about what a different and gorgeous cake I had and I will certainly recommend Cake Fiction to anyone who needs a cake, or baked goods, for any occasion. I can't wait until the next time I get to work with this establishment. It is simply the best!
I came across cake fiction through a random google search of vendors in my area - and I could not be happier that I did. Read more...
I came across cake fiction through a random google search of vendors in my area - and I could not be happier that I did. Paula was responsive and helpful from day one. I pitched my many ideas to her and she helped me figure out what I wanted it, sketched out the idea on a notepad, and somehow a few months later turned our brainstormed creation into a beautiful reality. People are still talking about what a different and gorgeous cake I had and I will certainly recommend Cake Fiction to anyone who needs a cake, or baked goods, for any occasion. I can't wait until the next time I get to work with this establishment. It is simply the best! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default
Shannon
Wedding:
11/24/2012
5.0/5.0
Paula made my husband the most amazing groom's cake!!! My husband and I love the tv show Castle and Paula was able to make two cakes out of pieces from the show ... the book she made looked so real no one believed it was cake until we cut it!! The cakes taste even better then they looked. Truly amazing!! I can't wait to have another event to be able to use Paula again!!!
Paula made my husband the most amazing groom's cake!!! My husband and I love the tv show Castle and Paula was able to make Read more...
Paula made my husband the most amazing groom's cake!!! My husband and I love the tv show Castle and Paula was able to make two cakes out of pieces from the show ... the book she made looked so real no one believed it was cake until we cut it!! The cakes taste even better then they looked. Truly amazing!! I can't wait to have another event to be able to use Paula again!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
danielle
Wedding:
10/26/2012
5.0/5.0
Paula and her partner at Cake Fiction were AMAZING, and were part of one of our favorite parts of our wedding; the cake of our dog/fur-baby! Everyone was a pleasure to work with from our first consulation, and everything went so smooth. Paula responded promptly to all e-mails, and the day of I didn't worry about anything. My cake was on the cake table at the reception, front and center, looking fabulous!! Everyone commented how great it was. The cake testing was yummy, but I have to admit we loved the cake so much we couldn't bring ourselves to cut into it at the wedding! I would definetely reccomend Cake Fiction for anyone looking for a unique addition to their wedding everyone will be talking about! Especially dog-lovers :)
Paula and her partner at Cake Fiction were AMAZING, and were part of one of our favorite parts of our wedding; the cake of Read more...
Paula and her partner at Cake Fiction were AMAZING, and were part of one of our favorite parts of our wedding; the cake of our dog/fur-baby! Everyone was a pleasure to work with from our first consulation, and everything went so smooth. Paula responded promptly to all e-mails, and the day of I didn't worry about anything. My cake was on the cake table at the reception, front and center, looking fabulous!! Everyone commented how great it was. The cake testing was yummy, but I have to admit we loved the cake so much we couldn't bring ourselves to cut into it at the wedding! I would definetely reccomend Cake Fiction for anyone looking for a unique addition to their wedding everyone will be talking about! Especially dog-lovers :) Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Akua
Wedding:
9/23/2012
5.0/5.0
Paula and her husband were very attentive t what I wanted in a cake and they delivered a spectacular wedding cake. the best wedding cake I have ever eaten. All our guests loved it and just so you know how good the cake was....there was no cake left to take home.
Paula and her husband were very attentive t what I wanted in a cake and they delivered a spectacular wedding cake. the Read more...
Paula and her husband were very attentive t what I wanted in a cake and they delivered a spectacular wedding cake. the best wedding cake I have ever eaten. All our guests loved it and just so you know how good the cake was....there was no cake left to take home. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Mike
Wedding:
9/2/2012
5.0/5.0
Paula and Simon are amazing to work with! We pretty much picked them out of the good ol yellow pages and boy oh boy were we excited we found them. We walked into their store with an idea of a drum cake, tier cakes are a bit overdone that's why we looked and Paula. Paula quickly said "why not do the whole drum set? I've done one before." Then we had the tasting, Paula told us her cakes have a proper "cake to icing ratio." The bites were perfect. We told her what flavors we were looking for and she steered us in the right direction.

Paula contacted me a couple of times after our first meeting to ask me specific, detailed questions about how a real drum set looks because she wanted to get it perfect. She included drum sticks, cymbals, and even a foot pedal for the bass drum, all made of fondit. We sent her sentimental images that we wanted on our drum set cake, she didn't hesitate, simply replied "no problem." I wouldn't be writing this if it wasn't perfect. Our drum set cake was one of the most commented items at our wedding by our guests. In a few places where people could write the happy couple words of advice people "your cake is AMAZING!"

They're really amazing people with a truly artistic vision, just walk into their store and you'll see what I mean. I'd include a picture of the cake here but I can't find where to do it. Have them make your cake, you won't be disappointed.
Paula and Simon are amazing to work with! We pretty much picked them out of the good ol yellow pages and boy oh boy were Read more...
Paula and Simon are amazing to work with! We pretty much picked them out of the good ol yellow pages and boy oh boy were we excited we found them. We walked into their store with an idea of a drum cake, tier cakes are a bit overdone that's why we looked and Paula. Paula quickly said "why not do the whole drum set? I've done one before." Then we had the tasting, Paula told us her cakes have a proper "cake to icing ratio." The bites were perfect. We told her what flavors we were looking for and she steered us in the right direction.

Paula contacted me a couple of times after our first meeting to ask me specific, detailed questions about how a real drum set looks because she wanted to get it perfect. She included drum sticks, cymbals, and even a foot pedal for the bass drum, all made of fondit. We sent her sentimental images that we wanted on our drum set cake, she didn't hesitate, simply replied "no problem." I wouldn't be writing this if it wasn't perfect. Our drum set cake was one of the most commented items at our wedding by our guests. In a few places where people could write the happy couple words of advice people "your cake is AMAZING!"

They're really amazing people with a truly artistic vision, just walk into their store and you'll see what I mean. I'd include a picture of the cake here but I can't find where to do it. Have them make your cake, you won't be disappointed. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Katie
Wedding:
7/21/2012
5.0/5.0
I ordered a DeLorean Time Machine groom/birthday cake to surprise my H with at the reception (DH is obsessed with Back to the Future). Paula, the owner, designed the cake, and I really loved working with her. We were all so impressed with how it came out. The detail of the cake was incredible! Her pricing is also very fair.
I ordered a DeLorean Time Machine groom/birthday cake to surprise my H with at the reception (DH is obsessed with Back to Read more...
I ordered a DeLorean Time Machine groom/birthday cake to surprise my H with at the reception (DH is obsessed with Back to the Future). Paula, the owner, designed the cake, and I really loved working with her. We were all so impressed with how it came out. The detail of the cake was incredible! Her pricing is also very fair. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bg14
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
5.0/5.0
I ordered my grooms cake and it was as beautiful and delicious. Some guests mentioned they liked the grooms cake more than the wedding cake, which was made by another bakery.
I ordered my grooms cake and it was as beautiful and delicious. Some guests mentioned they liked the grooms cake more than Read more...
I ordered my grooms cake and it was as beautiful and delicious. Some guests mentioned they liked the grooms cake more than the wedding cake, which was made by another bakery. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
bassbonebride
Wedding:
11/4/2011
5.0/5.0
I wanted to surprise my husband with a groom’s cake at the rehearsal dinner, although I let him pick the flavors since I didn’t want him to miss out on the fun of a tasting! And OMG what a tasting, Paula has the most delicious cake and buttercream pairings. I wanted a cake in the shape of a Scrabble board, with letters spelling out all of my husband’s favorite things. She was wonderful to work with and easily translated my vision into a yummy reality. Highly recommend, I will certainly be contacting her again for future events!
I wanted to surprise my husband with a groom’s cake at the rehearsal dinner, although I let him pick the flavors since I Read more...
I wanted to surprise my husband with a groom’s cake at the rehearsal dinner, although I let him pick the flavors since I didn’t want him to miss out on the fun of a tasting! And OMG what a tasting, Paula has the most delicious cake and buttercream pairings. I wanted a cake in the shape of a Scrabble board, with letters spelling out all of my husband’s favorite things. She was wonderful to work with and easily translated my vision into a yummy reality. Highly recommend, I will certainly be contacting her again for future events! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
trubtold
Wedding:
5/14/2011
5.0/5.0
I love Cake Fiction cakes. They provided me with a baby shower cake and my wedding cake. Both of the cakes was delicious and gorgeous. If your looking for a cake for any affair here is the place to go. I will recommend Cake Fiction to all my friends.
I love Cake Fiction cakes. They provided me with a baby shower cake and my wedding cake. Both of the cakes was delicious Read more...
I love Cake Fiction cakes. They provided me with a baby shower cake and my wedding cake. Both of the cakes was delicious and gorgeous. If your looking for a cake for any affair here is the place to go. I will recommend Cake Fiction to all my friends. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1289490207559-img0022c
LARANODA
Wedding:
4/29/2011
5.0/5.0
ALL I CAN SAY IS OMG... PAULA AND SIMON WERE AWESOME.. I WENT FORMY CAKE TASTING, SHE HAS EXOTIC FLAVORS...I FELT LIKE I WAS ON THE SHOW CAKE BOSS.. SHE HAS A VARIETY OF DISPLAYS AND BOOKS.. HOWEVER SHE ALLOWED ME TO TELL HER MY CAKE VISION AS SHE SKETCHED MY DREAM CAKE
SHE ALSO WAS VER FLEXIBLE AS FAR AS PYMNTS AS WELL.. I LIVE OUT OF TOWN SO I WAS ALLOWED TO MAKE PYMNTS VIA TELEPHONE BY CREDIT AND DEBIT CARD.. THE CAKE WAS BEAUTIFUL, PRICE WAS AFFORDABLE AND CAKE WAS DELICIOUS...THANK YOU PAULA FOR CONTRIBUTING TO MY SPECIAL DAY!!!
ALL I CAN SAY IS OMG... PAULA AND SIMON WERE AWESOME.. I WENT FORMY CAKE TASTING, SHE HAS EXOTIC FLAVORS...I FELT LIKE I Read more...
ALL I CAN SAY IS OMG... PAULA AND SIMON WERE AWESOME.. I WENT FORMY CAKE TASTING, SHE HAS EXOTIC FLAVORS...I FELT LIKE I WAS ON THE SHOW CAKE BOSS.. SHE HAS A VARIETY OF DISPLAYS AND BOOKS.. HOWEVER SHE ALLOWED ME TO TELL HER MY CAKE VISION AS SHE SKETCHED MY DREAM CAKE
SHE ALSO WAS VER FLEXIBLE AS FAR AS PYMNTS AS WELL.. I LIVE OUT OF TOWN SO I WAS ALLOWED TO MAKE PYMNTS VIA TELEPHONE BY CREDIT AND DEBIT CARD.. THE CAKE WAS BEAUTIFUL, PRICE WAS AFFORDABLE AND CAKE WAS DELICIOUS...THANK YOU PAULA FOR CONTRIBUTING TO MY SPECIAL DAY!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Danes983
Wedding:
12/31/2010
5.0/5.0
I found Cake Fiction by seearching online. One of my BM and I went to check out this place and it ended up being a house hold business. We met with Paula who is the owner and baker. Her house and kitchen were awesome with fake cakes displayed as well as serious mixers, ovens, the works. This was no rinky dink operation. I wanted a poker table cake for 30 people with my husband and I sitting at the table. This cake looked and tasted amazing. Everyone was raving saying how awesome it was. If you are looking for your wedding cake or a specialty cake for something call Paula at Cake Fiction. I know I will be calling her again.
I found Cake Fiction by seearching online. One of my BM and I went to check out this place and it ended up being a house Read more...
I found Cake Fiction by seearching online. One of my BM and I went to check out this place and it ended up being a house hold business. We met with Paula who is the owner and baker. Her house and kitchen were awesome with fake cakes displayed as well as serious mixers, ovens, the works. This was no rinky dink operation. I wanted a poker table cake for 30 people with my husband and I sitting at the table. This cake looked and tasted amazing. Everyone was raving saying how awesome it was. If you are looking for your wedding cake or a specialty cake for something call Paula at Cake Fiction. I know I will be calling her again. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
jshave
Wedding:
8/7/2010
5.0/5.0
Paula provided top notch service and was wonderful to work with. Her design was one of a kind and my guests could not stop talking about how beautiful the cake was. It tasted great and was fresh. Thank you so much!
Paula provided top notch service and was wonderful to work with. Her design was one of a kind and my guests could not stop Read more...
Paula provided top notch service and was wonderful to work with. Her design was one of a kind and my guests could not stop talking about how beautiful the cake was. It tasted great and was fresh. Thank you so much! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Laura
Wedding:
6/5/2010
5.0/5.0
Paula was absolutely amazing! So sweet and did a fantastic job on our wedding cake! The cake was so good, after we defrosted it on our one year wedding anniversary, it was STILL delicious!! I highly recommend Cake Fiction!!
Paula was absolutely amazing! So sweet and did a fantastic job on our wedding cake! The cake was so good, after we Read more...
Paula was absolutely amazing! So sweet and did a fantastic job on our wedding cake! The cake was so good, after we defrosted it on our one year wedding anniversary, it was STILL delicious!! I highly recommend Cake Fiction!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Michelle
Wedding:
5/9/2009
5.0/5.0
In every way, our experience with Cake Fiction was exceptional. Not only did our cake look beautful on our wedding day, but it tasted great. Customarily, no one eats the cake - this was not the case at our wedding. Many guests commented on how wonderful it was. And, all along the way, we had a lovely experience with Paula who added a wonderful personal touch to the tasting and overall experience.
In every way, our experience with Cake Fiction was exceptional. Not only did our cake look beautful on our wedding day, Read more...
In every way, our experience with Cake Fiction was exceptional. Not only did our cake look beautful on our wedding day, but it tasted great. Customarily, no one eats the cake - this was not the case at our wedding. Many guests commented on how wonderful it was. And, all along the way, we had a lovely experience with Paula who added a wonderful personal touch to the tasting and overall experience. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1322886164901-kd2ppz01
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
4.9/5.0
We used Paula because our venue has a relationship with her. Her portfolio features a wide range of beautiful and intricate designs, from classic to whimsical (my husband was particularly delighted by the UFC Octagon she had made for a birthday party).

She was a true sweetheart through the entire process... We told her our vision (a mosaic design, inspired by Park Güell in Barcelona, cascading down tiered rounds), and we were confident she'd do a great job. But we didn't expect it to look like something Gaudí himself would have created had he baked cakes.

Wedding cake is never going to taste like it's fresh out of the oven (after all, it takes hours to decorate, and it has to be chilled). But Paula's cake came close ... absolutely delicious. We decided on almond pound cake and amaretto filling, which goes great with coffee. But she also offers intriguing fillings like dulce de leche (she's from Argentina, so she knows her DDL) and chocolate orange. We enjoyed those at the tasting.

It was more than we expected to spend on cake - even with the discount she gives for weddings at our venue - but it was so perfect. Paula truly is an artist - not only visually, but also when it comes to taste.
We used Paula because our venue has a relationship with her. Her portfolio features a wide range of beautiful and Read more...
We used Paula because our venue has a relationship with her. Her portfolio features a wide range of beautiful and intricate designs, from classic to whimsical (my husband was particularly delighted by the UFC Octagon she had made for a birthday party).

She was a true sweetheart through the entire process... We told her our vision (a mosaic design, inspired by Park Güell in Barcelona, cascading down tiered rounds), and we were confident she'd do a great job. But we didn't expect it to look like something Gaudí himself would have created had he baked cakes.

Wedding cake is never going to taste like it's fresh out of the oven (after all, it takes hours to decorate, and it has to be chilled). But Paula's cake came close ... absolutely delicious. We decided on almond pound cake and amaretto filling, which goes great with coffee. But she also offers intriguing fillings like dulce de leche (she's from Argentina, so she knows her DDL) and chocolate orange. We enjoyed those at the tasting.

It was more than we expected to spend on cake - even with the discount she gives for weddings at our venue - but it was so perfect. Paula truly is an artist - not only visually, but also when it comes to taste. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1286859549402-dscf5247
MMneilson
Wedding:
5/15/2010
4.9/5.0
Paula worked with us from day one to design our cake. On top, of that she also did a grooms cake which was a replica of the new Yankee Stadium. It was incredible. People are still talking about it. Her prices were excellent and her cake was amazing!!!
Paula worked with us from day one to design our cake. On top, of that she also did a grooms cake which was a replica of Read more...
Paula worked with us from day one to design our cake. On top, of that she also did a grooms cake which was a replica of the new Yankee Stadium. It was incredible. People are still talking about it. Her prices were excellent and her cake was amazing!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jeremy
Wedding:
5/31/2014
4.8/5.0
The cake was tremendous and Paula was very easy to work with. We happened to live nearby to her old location so we simply walked in, and made an appointment for tasting the following weekend. There were so many incredible choices and combinations and they were all terrifically done. Paula provides some suggested/popular combinations but we actually went with a choice we came up with on our own and it was great!
The cake was tremendous and Paula was very easy to work with. We happened to live nearby to her old location so we simply Read more...
The cake was tremendous and Paula was very easy to work with. We happened to live nearby to her old location so we simply walked in, and made an appointment for tasting the following weekend. There were so many incredible choices and combinations and they were all terrifically done. Paula provides some suggested/popular combinations but we actually went with a choice we came up with on our own and it was great! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
4.8/5.0
I asked Paula to make a groom's cake for my October wedding as a surprise for my husband-to-be. Paula created a Vespa cake with a side car, and in the side car was a pug wearing aviator glasses. It was pure art! Paula was fantastic to work with and made the process enjoyable and easy as she was responsive, flexible, and enthusiastic about the project. The groom's cake was one of the biggest hits of our wedding - people were taking pictures and couldn't believe this cake! We had it on display during the cocktail hour and next to the wedding cake during the reception. I hope to have another opportunity to work with Paula and the folks at Cake Fiction down the road as it was a great experience all around.
I asked Paula to make a groom's cake for my October wedding as a surprise for my husband-to-be. Paula created a Vespa cake Read more...
I asked Paula to make a groom's cake for my October wedding as a surprise for my husband-to-be. Paula created a Vespa cake with a side car, and in the side car was a pug wearing aviator glasses. It was pure art! Paula was fantastic to work with and made the process enjoyable and easy as she was responsive, flexible, and enthusiastic about the project. The groom's cake was one of the biggest hits of our wedding - people were taking pictures and couldn't believe this cake! We had it on display during the cocktail hour and next to the wedding cake during the reception. I hope to have another opportunity to work with Paula and the folks at Cake Fiction down the road as it was a great experience all around. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Suma
Wedding:
12/30/2010
4.8/5.0
You can't go wrong with Cake Fiction. Paula and Simon are amazing. Our wedding cake was a work of art and it tasted even better.
You can't go wrong with Cake Fiction. Paula and Simon are amazing. Our wedding cake was a work of art and it tasted even Read more...
You can't go wrong with Cake Fiction. Paula and Simon are amazing. Our wedding cake was a work of art and it tasted even better. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake

MAP

 
The Barn at 11 East Mill Road, Long Valley, NJ 07853 See On Map
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for Cake Fiction
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww_logo
 
220x220_1317354469691-birchtreebarkcakephoto