220x220_1377117117430-carters-creative-catering
Carters Creative Catering
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
 
13 Reviews
Address:
808 West 35th Street
Loveland, CO US 80538 (map)
Phone:
970-612-0234
Categories:
 
 
 
4.7 
(4.7/5.0)
 
Quality of Service 
(4.5/5.0)
 
Responsiveness 
(4.7/5.0)
 
Professionalism 
(4.7/5.0)
 
Value 
(4.7/5.0)
 
Flexibility 
Sort
 
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
 
4.9 out of 5.0
Holly did an excellent job on our cake - and it was DELICIOUS!!! She is a great value & does excellent work!
Services Used: Catering
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Sara
Wedding:
6/29/2013
 
5.0 out of 5.0
We really wanted to have a custom menu of Italian and Korean food. Most places quoted us an insanely high cost and then tried to get us to do one of their premade menus. Carter's had no problem with our menu choices and were very affordable! They also were able to have spaghetti for us. Something we were told was impossible by other companies. Everything tasted great and was perfect. Our guests kept telling us how wonderful the food was!

Carter's also did our cake. We had four different flavors and it was so good that we had none left over! Holly did a great job with both the taste and presentation. It was perfect. Would definitely recommend Carter's!
Services Used: Catering
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
 
4.0 out of 5.0
I thought Holly and her husband were very professional and good to work with. However I was a bit disappointed as I heard some of my guests had frozen food or was cold. They were a bit understaffed as well. The food was extremely full of garlic but was also very yummy. Just was disappointed in hearing our guests were served frozen food. Again, it was great service and decent food.
Services Used: Catering
Carters Creative Catering responded with the following comments:

I am not sure which wedding this was or date? I apologize for any frozen or cold food on Carters Creative Caterings behalf. I am really sad to hear this not knowing which wedding this was. We always try to correct anything that is wrong immediately and would have done so had of we known anything about this. Once again I am apologetic for this and by no means is this typical. We have 10 reviews on here and of those ten weddings this is one of many thousands we have personally performed. The staffing issue since I do not know what wedding this is, is hard to say this is someone opinion and we staff accordingly to size of the events. Many events are staffed depending on budgetary needs of our clients, as well as type of service they are looking for.

Please note we cook most food on site and bring minimally cooked food with us in order to make sure we are giving our clients the best food hot off the grill, stove, or oven Meal. We check temperatures before putting food out and also have hot boxes to hold hot food in to keep it at temperature during the buffet.

Once again we are not sure who this is and if you would like to contact us personally we will make attempts to right this with you.

Our sincere apology! Thanks for still an above average review!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Rachel
Wedding:
8/25/2012
 
3.0 out of 5.0
Carters Creative Catering ran out of food at my wedding. We did not have extra people attend and the owner cut the Prim Rib. Out of 94 people about 15 went without Prim Rib and potatoes, including the grooms Mother. I was very disappointed that they did not reach out to me and apologies for their mistake. I feel there is no excuse when I didn't go over my guest count and they cut the meat themselves.
The quality of food they put out is wonderful and I was so excited to have them as part of my wedding. I am unfortunately disappointed with the outcome.
Services Used: Catering
Carters Creative Catering responded with the following comments:

Carter's Creative Catering took responsibility that night and apologized to the few people whom did not get Prime rib. In all due respect our guest count was less then the number of people whom attended, and they were not charged for the extra people. There was plenty of food and we did not run out of food. Only prime rib which will never happen again! Carter's Creative Catering did reach out and offer some compensation to them but it was refused! Carters Creative Catering is truly sorry and this will not happen again.
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
 
4.7 out of 5.0
The amount of food we got for the price was amazing. The owner and staff were friendly and professional. We also got our cake/cupcakes thru Carter's and we got so many compliments from our guests. We are thinking of getting a birthday cake from them in the future (it was that good).
Services Used: Catering
130x130_sq_1326340994083-232323232fp73454vq773476257wsnrcg347574655348vq0mrj
Catarina
Wedding:
7/21/2012
 
5.0 out of 5.0
Okay so Holly and Eric were AWESOME! They took care of everything and are so flexible! They were so nice with everything. It all looked smelled and tasted great! they even package leftovers and let you take it home! (most caterers said they wouldn't do it or you would have to pay extra!) They definately helped make my night Great!
Services Used: Catering
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Chelsea
Wedding:
5/27/2012
 
5.0 out of 5.0
Eric and Holly were great. They were very flexible on meeting times and were always very friendly. They were more than happy to work with our budget and were willing to make absolutely anything we wanted them to make. They were very professional and the food was excellent. We have already had a few engaged couples that were at our wedding ask for their contact information because they loved the food. I would highly recommend them to any bride looking for friendly caterers with awesome food!
Services Used: Catering
Carters Creative Catering responded with the following comments:

Chelsea we had fun working with you! Thank you for passing our information to your friends. Referrals are exactly what we like. Your friends will receive a 10% on food costs when they let us know that you referred them. We appreciate your great review!!
Eric and Holly
130x130_sq_1395792020136-avata
Megan
Wedding:
4/28/2012
 
5.0 out of 5.0
Eric and has wife were wonderful! Very helpful with choosing the menu and flexible as well. He is a FABULOUS cook! The food was perfect. Service was perfect! And excellent pricing to top it off. If I ever have another event I will be calling Carters!!
Services Used: Catering
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Misty
Wedding:
8/2/2011
 
5.0 out of 5.0
They did everything I needed them to do and more. I loved the fact that they took my budget and made it work great. They are the greatest
Services Used: Catering
130x130_sq_1296580676922-kipre7563
Kelly
Wedding:
4/30/2011
 
4.8 out of 5.0
These guys rock, they are extremely flexible, affordable, and their food is awesome!
Services Used: Catering
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for Carters Creative Catering
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww_logo