130x130_sq_1395168000290-dscn0511bw

Frosted Pumpkin

Alpharetta , GA
CONTACT US
CONTACT US

LOCATION

221 Silver Birch CT
Alpharetta, GA US 30004 (map)

PHONE

770-205-7998

WEBSITE

View website
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.

ABOUT US

Our Story

Jeff and Karyn Schwerzler left New York several years ago having sold a thriving specialty cake decorating business for a chance to slow down their hectic pace and... Read more
Our Story

Jeff and Karyn Schwerzler left New York several years ago having sold a thriving specialty cake decorating business for a chance to slow down their hectic pace and start a family. Years later, now living in a suburb north of Atlanta with two young daughters, Jeff and Karyn have taken their culinary talents one step further. As owners of The Frosted Pumpkin Gourmet - they design breathtaking wedding cakes for brides as well as Grooms cakes and special occasion cakes.

Contact us at 770-205-7998 or

Email: frostedpumpkin@me.com Read less
Wedding Cake

PHOTOS

130x130_sq_1250786655001-3
130x130_sq_1250786647658-2
130x130_sq_1250786712189-11
130x130_sq_1395168231504-img063
130x130_sq_1395168293157-frosted
130x130_sq_1395168382517-dscn076
130x130_sq_1395168476726-dscn096
130x130_sq_1395168615860-offset-squarepurple-abstract-flowerswebre
130x130_sq_1395168638471-pipedribbo
130x130_sq_1395168714157-piped-roseteswiss-do
130x130_sq_1395173241223-dscn117
130x130_sq_1395173321722-dscn132
130x130_sq_1395173362533-emily-and-matt-141
130x130_sq_1395173454069-dscn095

INFO FOR WEDDING CAKE

Besides cakes, what other types of desserts do you provide?
Cupcakes, Groom's Cake
What additional services do you provide?
Consultations, On-site Delivery, On-site Setup, Tastings
Do you provide customary cakes, such as Croquembouche?
Yes
Are you licensed by the state health department?
Yes

REVIEWS

4.8
out of 5.0
4.8/5.0
4.8/5.0
4.8/5.0
4.8/5.0
4.9/5.0
Sort by
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Megan
Wedding:
8/16/2014
5.0/5.0
Jeff with the Frosted Pumpkin is truly an artist! Our cake was STUNNING and exactly what we wanted not to mention DELICIOUS! Dozens of guests also said that it was the best wedding cake they had ever tasted! You can't go wrong by hiring the Frosted Pumpkin- They are the very best!
Jeff with the Frosted Pumpkin is truly an artist! Our cake was STUNNING and exactly what we wanted not to mention Read more...
Jeff with the Frosted Pumpkin is truly an artist! Our cake was STUNNING and exactly what we wanted not to mention DELICIOUS! Dozens of guests also said that it was the best wedding cake they had ever tasted! You can't go wrong by hiring the Frosted Pumpkin- They are the very best! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
The most amazing cake ever! Frosted Pumpkin designed and brought to life a cake that was not only artistically beautiful, but delicious as well. The guests are still commenting on it! Job well done!
The most amazing cake ever! Frosted Pumpkin designed and brought to life a cake that was not only artistically beautiful, Read more...
The most amazing cake ever! Frosted Pumpkin designed and brought to life a cake that was not only artistically beautiful, but delicious as well. The guests are still commenting on it! Job well done! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Belen
Wedding:
5/10/2014
5.0/5.0
We were absolutely delighted with the cake made for our wedding by Frosted Pumpkin! It was exactly what we wanted and tasted great. Everyone said they'd never had such a delicious wedding cake. Jefferey was great to work with and met us half way to bring samples of the cake. Also, his pricing is very competitive. So all in all a great experience!
We were absolutely delighted with the cake made for our wedding by Frosted Pumpkin! It was exactly what we wanted and Read more...
We were absolutely delighted with the cake made for our wedding by Frosted Pumpkin! It was exactly what we wanted and tasted great. Everyone said they'd never had such a delicious wedding cake. Jefferey was great to work with and met us half way to bring samples of the cake. Also, his pricing is very competitive. So all in all a great experience! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Nicole
Wedding:
5/10/2014
5.0/5.0
I wanted a non-traditional "naked cake" for our wedding and The Frosted Pumpkin delivered! The Frosted Pumpkin makes THE BEST carrot cake I have ever had. All of their cakes are delicious and Jeff was professional and easy to work with. I would highly recommend The Frosted Pumpkin!
I wanted a non-traditional "naked cake" for our wedding and The Frosted Pumpkin delivered! The Frosted Pumpkin makes THE Read more...
I wanted a non-traditional "naked cake" for our wedding and The Frosted Pumpkin delivered! The Frosted Pumpkin makes THE BEST carrot cake I have ever had. All of their cakes are delicious and Jeff was professional and easy to work with. I would highly recommend The Frosted Pumpkin! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Amy
Wedding:
5/3/2014
5.0/5.0
The Frosted Pumpkin was the perfect vendor to provide our cake! It was beautiful and delicious. Many of our guests raved about the flavor and the frosting! I gave them a of the picture of the exact cake I wanted, and they were able to replicate it to a T. Our venue happened to be on top of a steep hill in the mountains, and they were so diligent about getting the cake there safely! We are so happy that we found Jeff and Karen. Thank you for everything.
The Frosted Pumpkin was the perfect vendor to provide our cake! It was beautiful and delicious. Many of our guests raved Read more...
The Frosted Pumpkin was the perfect vendor to provide our cake! It was beautiful and delicious. Many of our guests raved about the flavor and the frosting! I gave them a of the picture of the exact cake I wanted, and they were able to replicate it to a T. Our venue happened to be on top of a steep hill in the mountains, and they were so diligent about getting the cake there safely! We are so happy that we found Jeff and Karen. Thank you for everything. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
Hands down... Amazing!
I had pictures of cakes I thought I would want to emulate, but when I walked into the studio, the models I saw were a hundred times better and I did not even pull out the pictures as planned.
The cake not only looked glamorous, but tasted great- we can't wait to eat the top layer!
As the bride, I asked for another slice at the reception, and was pleasing when the staff presented me with a huge hunk of a slice. It was so good, I was not even embarrassed about indulging when everyone was watching.
Hands down... Amazing!
I had pictures of cakes I thought I would want to emulate, but when I walked into the studio, Read more...
Hands down... Amazing!
I had pictures of cakes I thought I would want to emulate, but when I walked into the studio, the models I saw were a hundred times better and I did not even pull out the pictures as planned.
The cake not only looked glamorous, but tasted great- we can't wait to eat the top layer!
As the bride, I asked for another slice at the reception, and was pleasing when the staff presented me with a huge hunk of a slice. It was so good, I was not even embarrassed about indulging when everyone was watching. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Staci
Wedding:
12/29/2013
5.0/5.0
Amazing, and delicious!! We loved everything about our cake and our guests thought it was the most delicious cake ever!! Very easy to work with and select our beautiful design!
Amazing, and delicious!! We loved everything about our cake and our guests thought it was the most delicious cake ever!! Read more...
Amazing, and delicious!! We loved everything about our cake and our guests thought it was the most delicious cake ever!! Very easy to work with and select our beautiful design! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Alison
Wedding:
12/21/2013
5.0/5.0
Frosted Pumpkin's cakes are all absolutely delicious! I was amazed at our tasting at how good every single cake tasted! I truly cannot stress that fact enough. The staff was so professional and made the process of choosing a cake surprisingly simple. He did a wonderful job of listening to us and guiding our selection. Our cake gorgeous, and exactly what we wanted. I wouldn't change a thing, and I will continue to use Frosted Pumpkin for future events.
Frosted Pumpkin's cakes are all absolutely delicious! I was amazed at our tasting at how good every single cake tasted! I Read more...
Frosted Pumpkin's cakes are all absolutely delicious! I was amazed at our tasting at how good every single cake tasted! I truly cannot stress that fact enough. The staff was so professional and made the process of choosing a cake surprisingly simple. He did a wonderful job of listening to us and guiding our selection. Our cake gorgeous, and exactly what we wanted. I wouldn't change a thing, and I will continue to use Frosted Pumpkin for future events. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
mary
Wedding:
11/16/2013
5.0/5.0
Jeff was warm and professional and easy to communicate with.
The wedding cake he created for my daughter's wedding was visually stunning, but even better….it was absolutely delicious. I did not get to taste the carrot cake layers, but my sister said that it was incredible. It must have been, because it disappeared. The chocolate layers were luscious and complex. Moist cake, creamy milk chocolate mousse, thick dark chocolate ganache and silky buttercream icing….heaven! I don't remember what the cake cost but it does not matter, it was worth every penny.
Jeff was warm and professional and easy to communicate with.
The wedding cake he created for my daughter's wedding was Read more...
Jeff was warm and professional and easy to communicate with.
The wedding cake he created for my daughter's wedding was visually stunning, but even better….it was absolutely delicious. I did not get to taste the carrot cake layers, but my sister said that it was incredible. It must have been, because it disappeared. The chocolate layers were luscious and complex. Moist cake, creamy milk chocolate mousse, thick dark chocolate ganache and silky buttercream icing….heaven! I don't remember what the cake cost but it does not matter, it was worth every penny. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Private User
Wedding:
11/9/2013
5.0/5.0
Our wedding cake looked and tasted amazing! I would highly recommend Frosted Pumpkin for high quality wedding cake, you will not be disappointed!
Our wedding cake looked and tasted amazing! I would highly recommend Frosted Pumpkin for high quality wedding cake, you Read more...
Our wedding cake looked and tasted amazing! I would highly recommend Frosted Pumpkin for high quality wedding cake, you will not be disappointed! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kristin
Wedding:
10/19/2013
5.0/5.0
Great cupcakes and excellent all around service.
Great cupcakes and excellent all around service.
Great cupcakes and excellent all around service. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Katie
Wedding:
10/5/2013
5.0/5.0
Amazing cake! The whole cake was finished by the end of the night! All of the flavors are so delicious :). I tried many bakers' cakes in ATL and this one was the best!
Amazing cake! The whole cake was finished by the end of the night! All of the flavors are so delicious :). I tried many Read more...
Amazing cake! The whole cake was finished by the end of the night! All of the flavors are so delicious :). I tried many bakers' cakes in ATL and this one was the best! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Laura
Wedding:
10/5/2013
5.0/5.0
My husband and I loved working with Jeffrey from Frosted Pumpkin. Our cake came out beautiful and we were totally blown away. I showed Jeffrey a picture of what I wanted, and he made a few minor suggestions about how he would change the design. He was completely right and on the big day I was beyond thrilled. We had multiple flavors in the different layers because we just couldn't decide which one we wanted. They were all so delicious!! The experience at the tasting was also very positive and all of the cakes were just so tasty.
My husband and I loved working with Jeffrey from Frosted Pumpkin. Our cake came out beautiful and we were totally blown Read more...
My husband and I loved working with Jeffrey from Frosted Pumpkin. Our cake came out beautiful and we were totally blown away. I showed Jeffrey a picture of what I wanted, and he made a few minor suggestions about how he would change the design. He was completely right and on the big day I was beyond thrilled. We had multiple flavors in the different layers because we just couldn't decide which one we wanted. They were all so delicious!! The experience at the tasting was also very positive and all of the cakes were just so tasty. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Brittany
Wedding:
9/30/2013
5.0/5.0
Our cake was delicious and beautiful! Loved meeting them for our tasting. They helped work within our budget to create a cake that was exactly what we wanted. Plus, it tasted amazing. They were so professional and easy to work with. I highly recommend them and will be using them for all our future events.

They even did a custom grooms cake with the Marine Corps logo on it. It was so beautiful!
Our cake was delicious and beautiful! Loved meeting them for our tasting. They helped work within our budget to create a Read more...
Our cake was delicious and beautiful! Loved meeting them for our tasting. They helped work within our budget to create a cake that was exactly what we wanted. Plus, it tasted amazing. They were so professional and easy to work with. I highly recommend them and will be using them for all our future events.

They even did a custom grooms cake with the Marine Corps logo on it. It was so beautiful! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lat
Wedding:
9/7/2013
5.0/5.0
I really have no words for how beautiful my cake was. I met Jeff the first time earlier this year for a tasting and I thought I had the best cake design in mind but after Jeff explained to me some of the flaws with my design and we decided on all round tiers instead of the square round option. I was truly blown away by how stunning my wedding cake was. I couldn't image any other vendor making my wedding cake. I want to thank Frosted Pumpkin for putting in the hard work and making my day extra special. Oh also their cakes are amazing we had lemon, carrot cake and coconut creme!!! YUMMY!!
I really have no words for how beautiful my cake was. I met Jeff the first time earlier this year for a tasting and I Read more...
I really have no words for how beautiful my cake was. I met Jeff the first time earlier this year for a tasting and I thought I had the best cake design in mind but after Jeff explained to me some of the flaws with my design and we decided on all round tiers instead of the square round option. I was truly blown away by how stunning my wedding cake was. I couldn't image any other vendor making my wedding cake. I want to thank Frosted Pumpkin for putting in the hard work and making my day extra special. Oh also their cakes are amazing we had lemon, carrot cake and coconut creme!!! YUMMY!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Suzan
Wedding:
8/24/2013
5.0/5.0
From the moment we had a taste of the their cake at the open house at Wolf Mountain Winery, we were sold. Our wedding cake was excellant and beautiful. We could not be happier with the end product or the owners of the Frosted Pumpkin. Thank you. Suzan and Dominic.
From the moment we had a taste of the their cake at the open house at Wolf Mountain Winery, we were sold. Our wedding cake Read more...
From the moment we had a taste of the their cake at the open house at Wolf Mountain Winery, we were sold. Our wedding cake was excellant and beautiful. We could not be happier with the end product or the owners of the Frosted Pumpkin. Thank you. Suzan and Dominic. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Alexis
Wedding:
8/10/2013
5.0/5.0
Our cake was absolutely BEAUTIFUL and DELICIOUS! We had sooo many people comment on how delicious our cake tasted! We were able to try all of our slices after the wedding and enjoyed every bite. We are looking forward to our one year anniversary to eat the top layer. :) We plan to use them again for our next party!

Alexis & Amit Singh
Our cake was absolutely BEAUTIFUL and DELICIOUS! We had sooo many people comment on how delicious our cake tasted! We were Read more...
Our cake was absolutely BEAUTIFUL and DELICIOUS! We had sooo many people comment on how delicious our cake tasted! We were able to try all of our slices after the wedding and enjoyed every bite. We are looking forward to our one year anniversary to eat the top layer. :) We plan to use them again for our next party!

Alexis & Amit Singh Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Demetric
Wedding:
4/20/2013
5.0/5.0
I want to thank you Jeff for the wonderful cakes that you created. The wedding cake had so much detail and was totally delicious. The groom cake, spider-man cake, was a hit!!! I honestly only ate a couple of pieces but the guys loved it!!! We will definitely use your services again in the future. Thanks again Jeff!!
I want to thank you Jeff for the wonderful cakes that you created. The wedding cake had so much detail and was totally Read more...
I want to thank you Jeff for the wonderful cakes that you created. The wedding cake had so much detail and was totally delicious. The groom cake, spider-man cake, was a hit!!! I honestly only ate a couple of pieces but the guys loved it!!! We will definitely use your services again in the future. Thanks again Jeff!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1337817694559-img7702
Joanne
Wedding:
4/6/2013
5.0/5.0
When our wedding reception venue told us that one restriction was that we could only order our cake from one of two vendors I was a little taken aback. But once we met Jeff at Frosted Pumpkin we could see why they were one of the two! Even though they are located OTP he was able to meet us at their intown office and my then fiance and I were very impressed with his openness to unusual requests (like saying sure he could make my husband's funfetti layer!!) and his creativity with suggestions. We ended up going with a dessert table with a 2 tier cake, cheesecakes, cannolis and cupcakes and it was a hit (and the same price as a single taller cake)! Absolutely check them out if you are sick of the wedding machine and want a little more straight-talk.
When our wedding reception venue told us that one restriction was that we could only order our cake from one of two Read more...
When our wedding reception venue told us that one restriction was that we could only order our cake from one of two vendors I was a little taken aback. But once we met Jeff at Frosted Pumpkin we could see why they were one of the two! Even though they are located OTP he was able to meet us at their intown office and my then fiance and I were very impressed with his openness to unusual requests (like saying sure he could make my husband's funfetti layer!!) and his creativity with suggestions. We ended up going with a dessert table with a 2 tier cake, cheesecakes, cannolis and cupcakes and it was a hit (and the same price as a single taller cake)! Absolutely check them out if you are sick of the wedding machine and want a little more straight-talk. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1357233198503-weddingsunset2
Mary
Wedding:
11/10/2012
5.0/5.0
We could not be happier with our choice to make our weeding and grooms cake. Jeff was so easy to work with and and he accomated all of our request. His cakes are not only beautiful but delcious!!! We received so many compliments on both cakes.
We could not be happier with our choice to make our weeding and grooms cake. Jeff was so easy to work with and and he Read more...
We could not be happier with our choice to make our weeding and grooms cake. Jeff was so easy to work with and and he accomated all of our request. His cakes are not only beautiful but delcious!!! We received so many compliments on both cakes. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Katherine
Wedding:
8/5/2006
5.0/5.0
Oh my goodness, my cake was to die for. It tasted so delicious - just as good as our tasting. They did an outstanding job decorating it just the way I wanted it. People just raved about the cake. We did chocolate with chocolate mouse and chocolate ganache. We also had a grooms cake with lemon filling and it was great too. I highly recommend Jeff and Frost Pumpkin.
Oh my goodness, my cake was to die for. It tasted so delicious - just as good as our tasting. They did an outstanding job Read more...
Oh my goodness, my cake was to die for. It tasted so delicious - just as good as our tasting. They did an outstanding job decorating it just the way I wanted it. People just raved about the cake. We did chocolate with chocolate mouse and chocolate ganache. We also had a grooms cake with lemon filling and it was great too. I highly recommend Jeff and Frost Pumpkin. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jackie
Wedding:
10/13/2012
5.0/5.0
Frosted Pumpkin did such an amazing job on our wedding cake. I had this idea in my head on how I wanted my cake to look like and Jeff made it a reality. It looked so beautiful and it tasted even better. I don’t like carrot cake or and I don’t really care for red velvet but that’s what our wedding cake! That’s how delicious the cakes taste! We sampled a bunch of different types of cakes. Jeff was very professional. We wanted something a little different added to the cake and he made it look wonderful. I think we may order our one year anniversary cake from him since we ended up taking the top layer of the cake on our honeymoon!  We had about 150 people and had a 3 tier cake and the top tier was saved for us! We highly recommend Frosted Pumpkin!

Jackie & Jason 10.13.12
Frosted Pumpkin did such an amazing job on our wedding cake. I had this idea in my head on how I wanted my cake to look Read more...
Frosted Pumpkin did such an amazing job on our wedding cake. I had this idea in my head on how I wanted my cake to look like and Jeff made it a reality. It looked so beautiful and it tasted even better. I don’t like carrot cake or and I don’t really care for red velvet but that’s what our wedding cake! That’s how delicious the cakes taste! We sampled a bunch of different types of cakes. Jeff was very professional. We wanted something a little different added to the cake and he made it look wonderful. I think we may order our one year anniversary cake from him since we ended up taking the top layer of the cake on our honeymoon!  We had about 150 people and had a 3 tier cake and the top tier was saved for us! We highly recommend Frosted Pumpkin!

Jackie & Jason 10.13.12 Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
5.0/5.0
My original cake baker bailed a few weeks before the wedding and Jeff made my cake at the last minute. It was beautiful and DELICIOUS! And I usually don't like wedding cake.
My original cake baker bailed a few weeks before the wedding and Jeff made my cake at the last minute. It was beautiful Read more...
My original cake baker bailed a few weeks before the wedding and Jeff made my cake at the last minute. It was beautiful and DELICIOUS! And I usually don't like wedding cake. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Step007
Wedding:
6/3/2012
5.0/5.0
Jeff at Frosted Pumpkin was fantastic. He was very accommodating and professional with the changes I made last minute and the cake itself was beautiful and delicious! Thank you so much!
Jeff at Frosted Pumpkin was fantastic. He was very accommodating and professional with the changes I made last minute and Read more...
Jeff at Frosted Pumpkin was fantastic. He was very accommodating and professional with the changes I made last minute and the cake itself was beautiful and delicious! Thank you so much! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
mrsf
Wedding:
4/28/2012
5.0/5.0
The Frosted Pumpkin is amazing!! Our cakes was so beautiful and delicious!! They were so moist. We had a hard time choosing what flavor we wanted, so we had three flavors. They are the nicest people and love what they do, and you can tell!
The Frosted Pumpkin is amazing!! Our cakes was so beautiful and delicious!! They were so moist. We had a hard time Read more...
The Frosted Pumpkin is amazing!! Our cakes was so beautiful and delicious!! They were so moist. We had a hard time choosing what flavor we wanted, so we had three flavors. They are the nicest people and love what they do, and you can tell! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1291944886894-dsc00010
Sara
Wedding:
12/18/2011
5.0/5.0
I consider myself something of a cake connoisseur, and Frosted Pumpkin did not disappoint!! People are still asking me about the cake. We had alternating layers of red velvet and coconut, with buttercream icing and it was perfectly delicious! And Jeffrey made me vision for the cake come to life, better than I even expected!
I consider myself something of a cake connoisseur, and Frosted Pumpkin did not disappoint!! People are still asking me Read more...
I consider myself something of a cake connoisseur, and Frosted Pumpkin did not disappoint!! People are still asking me about the cake. We had alternating layers of red velvet and coconut, with buttercream icing and it was perfectly delicious! And Jeffrey made me vision for the cake come to life, better than I even expected! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1324680864618-0047jm00310
Amanda
Wedding:
11/19/2011
5.0/5.0
Thank you so much Jeff and Karen, from Frosted Pumpkin for taking part in the "I-Do Thank You Wedding". My husband Christopher and I can not thank you enough for your graciousness and all of your hard work in providing the beautiful wedding cake for our wedding. It was absolutely breath taking! You truly captured our vision and brought it to life! The cake was also absolutely delicious! I highly recommend any one who needs a wedding cake use Frosted Pumpkin! They are friendly, talented and have great customer service! Thank you so much, and a million more times! Love Always-- Amanda Farrell
Thank you so much Jeff and Karen, from Frosted Pumpkin for taking part in the "I-Do Thank You Wedding". My husband Read more...
Thank you so much Jeff and Karen, from Frosted Pumpkin for taking part in the "I-Do Thank You Wedding". My husband Christopher and I can not thank you enough for your graciousness and all of your hard work in providing the beautiful wedding cake for our wedding. It was absolutely breath taking! You truly captured our vision and brought it to life! The cake was also absolutely delicious! I highly recommend any one who needs a wedding cake use Frosted Pumpkin! They are friendly, talented and have great customer service! Thank you so much, and a million more times! Love Always-- Amanda Farrell Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Paige
Wedding:
10/22/2011
5.0/5.0
I cannot say enough good things about The Frosted Pumpkin! Everyone at our wedding went back for seconds and thirds to try the different flavors we had! To top it off, my husband is a police officer and they did a perfect replica of his badge on the top of his groom's cake! I have had special occasion cakes made by them as well and they are to die for! I always look forward to an occasion that I can get a cake from them! Thank you!!
I cannot say enough good things about The Frosted Pumpkin! Everyone at our wedding went back for seconds and thirds to try Read more...
I cannot say enough good things about The Frosted Pumpkin! Everyone at our wedding went back for seconds and thirds to try the different flavors we had! To top it off, my husband is a police officer and they did a perfect replica of his badge on the top of his groom's cake! I have had special occasion cakes made by them as well and they are to die for! I always look forward to an occasion that I can get a cake from them! Thank you!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lindsey
Wedding:
10/15/2011
5.0/5.0
FANTASTIC!!! Frosted Pumpkin was willing to make us an almond flavored cake, which they don't normally do and it was fabulous! Great customer service and even better cake. The BEST wedding cake I've ever tasted...and I'm not just saying that because it was my wedding.
FANTASTIC!!! Frosted Pumpkin was willing to make us an almond flavored cake, which they don't normally do and it was Read more...
FANTASTIC!!! Frosted Pumpkin was willing to make us an almond flavored cake, which they don't normally do and it was fabulous! Great customer service and even better cake. The BEST wedding cake I've ever tasted...and I'm not just saying that because it was my wedding. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bg5
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
5.0/5.0
Yum yum yum!! We used Frosted Pumpking through a package Evergreen Marriott Conference Resort and we couldn't have been happier. Jeff set up a beautiful tasting for us and helped select flavors and design. The cake was beautiful, and so tasty!! I would definitely recommend him for your event!
Yum yum yum!! We used Frosted Pumpking through a package Evergreen Marriott Conference Resort and we couldn't have been Read more...
Yum yum yum!! We used Frosted Pumpking through a package Evergreen Marriott Conference Resort and we couldn't have been happier. Jeff set up a beautiful tasting for us and helped select flavors and design. The cake was beautiful, and so tasty!! I would definitely recommend him for your event! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Meredith
Wedding:
4/30/2011
5.0/5.0
My cake was beautiful and just how I asked for it to look. I did three layers and each layer had different flavors. It was the best tasting cake I have ever had. Wedding cake can be dry but not Frosted Pumpkin's. I will be using them again for birthdays and other special events.
My cake was beautiful and just how I asked for it to look. I did three layers and each layer had different flavors. It was Read more...
My cake was beautiful and just how I asked for it to look. I did three layers and each layer had different flavors. It was the best tasting cake I have ever had. Wedding cake can be dry but not Frosted Pumpkin's. I will be using them again for birthdays and other special events. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1259882582142-20091031halloween047
kanyamitchell
Wedding:
9/5/2010
5.0/5.0
We are very pleased with our choice to go with Frosted Pumpkin for our wedding cake. They provided us with both a beautiful cake design and some great tasting cake. They delivered as expected and we received wonderful feedback from our guest on all three flavors offered. We strongly recommend them to other couples….
We are very pleased with our choice to go with Frosted Pumpkin for our wedding cake. They provided us with both a Read more...
We are very pleased with our choice to go with Frosted Pumpkin for our wedding cake. They provided us with both a beautiful cake design and some great tasting cake. They delivered as expected and we received wonderful feedback from our guest on all three flavors offered. We strongly recommend them to other couples…. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Ashwee95
Wedding:
8/7/2010
5.0/5.0
My brother and sister in law had used Frosted Pumpkin for their wedding cake and it was the most amazing cake ever. So I knew I had to have it for my wedding. I was a little concerned at first because dumb me forgot to schedule an appointment for a tasting when I came into town (I live in another state and got married in Atlanta). But Jeffrey was able to let me come and get a sampling and from there we picked out our cake. I got SOOOO many compliments on our cake!! I absolutely loved it myself! We had a different flavor for our anniversary topper so we went ahead and had half of it now and will have half of it on our anniversary. The red velvet it to die for! YUM!
My brother and sister in law had used Frosted Pumpkin for their wedding cake and it was the most amazing cake ever. So I Read more...
My brother and sister in law had used Frosted Pumpkin for their wedding cake and it was the most amazing cake ever. So I knew I had to have it for my wedding. I was a little concerned at first because dumb me forgot to schedule an appointment for a tasting when I came into town (I live in another state and got married in Atlanta). But Jeffrey was able to let me come and get a sampling and from there we picked out our cake. I got SOOOO many compliments on our cake!! I absolutely loved it myself! We had a different flavor for our anniversary topper so we went ahead and had half of it now and will have half of it on our anniversary. The red velvet it to die for! YUM! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
KBL819
Wedding:
6/19/2010
5.0/5.0
Frosted Pumpkin makes one of the best cakes I have ever tasted! They are professional and easy to work with. I had several guests at my wedding go out of their way to tell me how delicious my cake was. Thank you, Frosted Pumpkin!
Frosted Pumpkin makes one of the best cakes I have ever tasted! They are professional and easy to work with. I had several Read more...
Frosted Pumpkin makes one of the best cakes I have ever tasted! They are professional and easy to work with. I had several guests at my wedding go out of their way to tell me how delicious my cake was. Thank you, Frosted Pumpkin! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
EWMeloney
Wedding:
6/5/2010
5.0/5.0
We loved our wedding cake and so did our guests. Jeff was willing to work with us to make it exactly what we wanted and it tasted delicious. All of our guests gave us compliments on how beautiful it was as well as how yummy it was.
We loved our wedding cake and so did our guests. Jeff was willing to work with us to make it exactly what we wanted and it Read more...
We loved our wedding cake and so did our guests. Jeff was willing to work with us to make it exactly what we wanted and it tasted delicious. All of our guests gave us compliments on how beautiful it was as well as how yummy it was. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Melissa
Wedding:
5/8/2010
5.0/5.0
All I can say is wow! The cake was absolutely amazing! My husband does not normally eat sugar, but could not get enough of our cake. We liked so many of the flavors at our tasting that we couldn't decide. So we had 3 tiers with 3 different flavors. Yummy!
All I can say is wow! The cake was absolutely amazing! My husband does not normally eat sugar, but could not get enough of Read more...
All I can say is wow! The cake was absolutely amazing! My husband does not normally eat sugar, but could not get enough of our cake. We liked so many of the flavors at our tasting that we couldn't decide. So we had 3 tiers with 3 different flavors. Yummy! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1227728356927-swerve
Courtney
Wedding:
4/17/2010
5.0/5.0
The cake was absolutley beautiful with the cascading pearls. It was elegant and delicious!!! Everyone commented on how stunning it was. Nothing could have been more perfect for my wedding cake.
The cake was absolutley beautiful with the cascading pearls. It was elegant and delicious!!! Everyone commented on how Read more...
The cake was absolutley beautiful with the cascading pearls. It was elegant and delicious!!! Everyone commented on how stunning it was. Nothing could have been more perfect for my wedding cake. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Leslie
Wedding:
4/17/2010
5.0/5.0
Frosted Pumpkin partners with the Evergreen Marriott where I got married. Once we signed the contract, we were able to meet with Jeff and do a tasting and design session for our cake. All of the cake was AMAZING!!!!! Jeff took all my ideas, sketched them out, and we created my perfect cake. I recommend him for everything- even non-wedding events. I've even called him for cakes for a shower I was hosting. Frosted Pumpkin is top-notch and the highest quality of service!
Frosted Pumpkin partners with the Evergreen Marriott where I got married. Once we signed the contract, we were able to Read more...
Frosted Pumpkin partners with the Evergreen Marriott where I got married. Once we signed the contract, we were able to meet with Jeff and do a tasting and design session for our cake. All of the cake was AMAZING!!!!! Jeff took all my ideas, sketched them out, and we created my perfect cake. I recommend him for everything- even non-wedding events. I've even called him for cakes for a shower I was hosting. Frosted Pumpkin is top-notch and the highest quality of service! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Julie
Wedding:
4/10/2010
5.0/5.0
AMAZING!!! They made my wedding cake and a grooms cake, and they were both beautiful and delicious!!! Our guests commented on how pretty the cakes were, and on how good they tasted. Jeff is very professional and easy to deal with. Highly recommended!!
AMAZING!!! They made my wedding cake and a grooms cake, and they were both beautiful and delicious!!! Our guests commented Read more...
AMAZING!!! They made my wedding cake and a grooms cake, and they were both beautiful and delicious!!! Our guests commented on how pretty the cakes were, and on how good they tasted. Jeff is very professional and easy to deal with. Highly recommended!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
jen
Wedding:
4/10/2010
5.0/5.0
AMAZING!!! They made my wedding cake and a grooms cake, and they were both beautiful and tasted great!!! Our guests commented on how pretty the cakes were, and on how good they tasted. Jeff is very professional and easy to deal with. Highly recommended!!
AMAZING!!! They made my wedding cake and a grooms cake, and they were both beautiful and tasted great!!! Our guests Read more...
AMAZING!!! They made my wedding cake and a grooms cake, and they were both beautiful and tasted great!!! Our guests commented on how pretty the cakes were, and on how good they tasted. Jeff is very professional and easy to deal with. Highly recommended!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
bride 032010
Wedding:
3/27/2010
5.0/5.0
our wedding cake looked like art. It was so beautiful! Although we didn't have time to eat cake other than the one bite everyone has told how wonderful it was! We had fun at the tasting and going throught hundreds of pictures to make sure we found the right one! We were very happy with the way our cake turned out :) Thank you FROSTED PUMPKIN!
our wedding cake looked like art. It was so beautiful! Although we didn't have time to eat cake other than the one bite Read more...
our wedding cake looked like art. It was so beautiful! Although we didn't have time to eat cake other than the one bite everyone has told how wonderful it was! We had fun at the tasting and going throught hundreds of pictures to make sure we found the right one! We were very happy with the way our cake turned out :) Thank you FROSTED PUMPKIN! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Frank
Wedding:
1/7/2010
5.0/5.0
Top notch cake service, the decorations were exquisite and the cakes were delicious. Arrangements went smoothly and customer rep was very nice and well mannerd. Everyone at my wedding was asking who provided the cake and the many kids around couldn't stop coming back for more, so that has to say something about this companies service and I will recommend them to anyone who has a Wedding coming up.
Top notch cake service, the decorations were exquisite and the cakes were delicious. Arrangements went smoothly and Read more...
Top notch cake service, the decorations were exquisite and the cakes were delicious. Arrangements went smoothly and customer rep was very nice and well mannerd. Everyone at my wedding was asking who provided the cake and the many kids around couldn't stop coming back for more, so that has to say something about this companies service and I will recommend them to anyone who has a Wedding coming up. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
5.0/5.0
Nothing bad to say here - Jeff was easy to work with, the cake was beautiful, and DELICIOUS!! Everyone commented on how moist & flavorful it was.....just great!
Nothing bad to say here - Jeff was easy to work with, the cake was beautiful, and DELICIOUS!! Everyone commented on how Read more...
Nothing bad to say here - Jeff was easy to work with, the cake was beautiful, and DELICIOUS!! Everyone commented on how moist & flavorful it was.....just great! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Laura
Wedding:
6/27/2009
5.0/5.0
My wedding cake was beautiful and delicious. I chose soft blue buttercream icing with a white vine lattice work of icing on top of the background of blue. The cake tasted homemade (you know... the texture was perfect). The icing was one of the reasons why I chose Frosted Pumpkin. It tasted buttery, smooth, and lightly sweet, not that sickly sweet that many cake makers have.
My wedding cake was beautiful and delicious. I chose soft blue buttercream icing with a white vine lattice work of icing Read more...
My wedding cake was beautiful and delicious. I chose soft blue buttercream icing with a white vine lattice work of icing on top of the background of blue. The cake tasted homemade (you know... the texture was perfect). The icing was one of the reasons why I chose Frosted Pumpkin. It tasted buttery, smooth, and lightly sweet, not that sickly sweet that many cake makers have. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kelly
Wedding:
6/6/2009
5.0/5.0
If you are looking for a cake that is both beautiful AND tastes delicious (which is not always easy to find), then look no further. We went with the raspberry and lemon for our June wedding, and it was so yummy! Everyone raved about it. Our cake was also very pretty, and Frosted Pumpkin was creative in making it look unique. We didn't want just the average looking wedding cake, and they created a very cool "branch" design for our outdoor ceremony. I highly recommend!
If you are looking for a cake that is both beautiful AND tastes delicious (which is not always easy to find), then look no Read more...
If you are looking for a cake that is both beautiful AND tastes delicious (which is not always easy to find), then look no further. We went with the raspberry and lemon for our June wedding, and it was so yummy! Everyone raved about it. Our cake was also very pretty, and Frosted Pumpkin was creative in making it look unique. We didn't want just the average looking wedding cake, and they created a very cool "branch" design for our outdoor ceremony. I highly recommend! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
LHP
Wedding:
4/4/2009
5.0/5.0
Their cake is amazing. So delicious, we had both the coconut and chocolate. Everyone loved it!
Their cake is amazing. So delicious, we had both the coconut and chocolate. Everyone loved it!
Their cake is amazing. So delicious, we had both the coconut and chocolate. Everyone loved it! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
LaineeStidham
Wedding:
3/14/2009
5.0/5.0
To say that I was happy with both the wedding cake and groom's cake would be the understatement of the century. Jeff & Karyn were the easiest, sweetest people to work with. When we first met Jeff, we knew there was no one else for us to work with. He listened to our requests, and also used his experience to help us make final decisions. We were able to get the most beautiful cakes that fit perfectly with the theme of our Black & White wedding. Last, but most importantly, the cakes were so yummy! We still get compliments on all the different flavors of our cakes (chocolate, carrot, raspberry, Mmmm!!) and the beauty of the cakes. It doesn't get better than the Frosted Pumpkin!
To say that I was happy with both the wedding cake and groom's cake would be the understatement of the century. Jeff & Read more...
To say that I was happy with both the wedding cake and groom's cake would be the understatement of the century. Jeff & Karyn were the easiest, sweetest people to work with. When we first met Jeff, we knew there was no one else for us to work with. He listened to our requests, and also used his experience to help us make final decisions. We were able to get the most beautiful cakes that fit perfectly with the theme of our Black & White wedding. Last, but most importantly, the cakes were so yummy! We still get compliments on all the different flavors of our cakes (chocolate, carrot, raspberry, Mmmm!!) and the beauty of the cakes. It doesn't get better than the Frosted Pumpkin! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
jessica82284
Wedding:
10/18/2008
5.0/5.0
Our wedding/grooms cakes were GORGEOUS! Our guests loved them. Jeff was very receptive to our vision for the cakes and made them exactly as we asked. Would definately recommend.
Our wedding/grooms cakes were GORGEOUS! Our guests loved them. Jeff was very receptive to our vision for the cakes and Read more...
Our wedding/grooms cakes were GORGEOUS! Our guests loved them. Jeff was very receptive to our vision for the cakes and made them exactly as we asked. Would definately recommend. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Amy L
Wedding:
8/9/2008
5.0/5.0
Best cake ever!!! Jeff is so wonderful to work with. He'll design exactly what you want and if you are looking for suggestions he'll give you some great ideas and let you know what would work well. Our cake was absolutely delicious. I can't wait for our 1 year anniversary when we get to eat the top!! :)
Best cake ever!!! Jeff is so wonderful to work with. He'll design exactly what you want and if you are looking for Read more...
Best cake ever!!! Jeff is so wonderful to work with. He'll design exactly what you want and if you are looking for suggestions he'll give you some great ideas and let you know what would work well. Our cake was absolutely delicious. I can't wait for our 1 year anniversary when we get to eat the top!! :) Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
kirstensummer
Wedding:
4/26/2008
5.0/5.0
The BEST cake I have ever had. We used them for both our wedding cake as well as the groom's cake. Very unique. We received a ton of compliments regarding how delicious they were. I plan on using them again and again for other events as well!
The BEST cake I have ever had. We used them for both our wedding cake as well as the groom's cake. Very unique. We Read more...
The BEST cake I have ever had. We used them for both our wedding cake as well as the groom's cake. Very unique. We received a ton of compliments regarding how delicious they were. I plan on using them again and again for other events as well! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Brittany
Wedding:
12/29/2007
5.0/5.0
The wedding cake was not only beautiful but it tasted amazing. We got so many compliments on how moist and tasteful it was. We had enough cake for 270 people only 200 people were there and at the end of the night there was not any cake left and still not everyone had any. I have never been to a wedding where all the cake was eaten. I highly recommend Frosted Pumpkin not only for the best wedding cake but the professionalism of the business. Jeff was very responsive and checked into make sure it what I wanted to verified everything, a great vendor to work with, along with amazing work.
The wedding cake was not only beautiful but it tasted amazing. We got so many compliments on how moist and tasteful it Read more...
The wedding cake was not only beautiful but it tasted amazing. We got so many compliments on how moist and tasteful it was. We had enough cake for 270 people only 200 people were there and at the end of the night there was not any cake left and still not everyone had any. I have never been to a wedding where all the cake was eaten. I highly recommend Frosted Pumpkin not only for the best wedding cake but the professionalism of the business. Jeff was very responsive and checked into make sure it what I wanted to verified everything, a great vendor to work with, along with amazing work. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
christmasbride
Wedding:
12/29/2007
5.0/5.0
Jeff and the team at Frosted Pumpkin were absolutely amazing and gave me the wedding cake of my dreams! I went in with a picture of one I had seen in a wedding magazine and what they gave me was exactly what I wanted!!!
Jeff and the team at Frosted Pumpkin were absolutely amazing and gave me the wedding cake of my dreams! I went in with a Read more...
Jeff and the team at Frosted Pumpkin were absolutely amazing and gave me the wedding cake of my dreams! I went in with a picture of one I had seen in a wedding magazine and what they gave me was exactly what I wanted!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
natalieblack07
Wedding:
10/27/2007
5.0/5.0
The cake was beautiful and tasted amazing. I would highly recommend this company to anyone.
The cake was beautiful and tasted amazing. I would highly recommend this company to anyone.
The cake was beautiful and tasted amazing. I would highly recommend this company to anyone. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bg5
Ann
Wedding:
10/6/2007
5.0/5.0
Our wedding cake was phenomenal. During my tasting with Jeff, I had a hard time choosing flavors because they were all so amazing. I showed him a few photos and we discussed the basic idea of what I wanted it to look like, but I could not believe how gorgeous it turned out. I almost didn't want to eat it...but I'm so glad I did. That cake was by far the most delicious cake I have ever eaten. And our guests agreed. I am looking forward to my anniversary just so I can take the top that we saved from the freezer and taste it all over again! Best of all, Jeff was so wonderful to work with! I'm hoping to order all of my family's special event cakes from Frosted Pumpkin.
Our wedding cake was phenomenal. During my tasting with Jeff, I had a hard time choosing flavors because they were all so Read more...
Our wedding cake was phenomenal. During my tasting with Jeff, I had a hard time choosing flavors because they were all so amazing. I showed him a few photos and we discussed the basic idea of what I wanted it to look like, but I could not believe how gorgeous it turned out. I almost didn't want to eat it...but I'm so glad I did. That cake was by far the most delicious cake I have ever eaten. And our guests agreed. I am looking forward to my anniversary just so I can take the top that we saved from the freezer and taste it all over again! Best of all, Jeff was so wonderful to work with! I'm hoping to order all of my family's special event cakes from Frosted Pumpkin. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bg5
A
Wedding:
8/12/2007
5.0/5.0
If you want your cake to come out exactly how you invasion it, you want Jeff at Frosted Pumpkin and his staff to make if for you. It was exactly how I wanted my cake and more. They are truly people who care, and I am speaking from experience. Jeff was the first cake planer I spoke to, but his price was bit more of what I wanted to spend. So I shopped, and went with someone that was in my price range. I can not say how much I regret doing so. Because the day before my wedding day, I had to contact him for help, he was so willing to help me even thought it was after hours. He truly saved my wedding day, and exceeded my expectations.


(With the cost I accrued with Cakes By Darcy, the other cake company, I had to go from a 3 tear to a 2 tear cake: for more info see review i lift on them.)
If you want your cake to come out exactly how you invasion it, you want Jeff at Frosted Pumpkin and his staff to make if Read more...
If you want your cake to come out exactly how you invasion it, you want Jeff at Frosted Pumpkin and his staff to make if for you. It was exactly how I wanted my cake and more. They are truly people who care, and I am speaking from experience. Jeff was the first cake planer I spoke to, but his price was bit more of what I wanted to spend. So I shopped, and went with someone that was in my price range. I can not say how much I regret doing so. Because the day before my wedding day, I had to contact him for help, he was so willing to help me even thought it was after hours. He truly saved my wedding day, and exceeded my expectations.


(With the cost I accrued with Cakes By Darcy, the other cake company, I had to go from a 3 tear to a 2 tear cake: for more info see review i lift on them.) Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jacqulin
Wedding:
6/2/2007
5.0/5.0
I live in Atlanta and I went to all of the popular wedding cake designers, and nothing was clicking for me. There were all very set in their ways, and kept steering me towards carbon copy wedding cakes. I was not at all interested. Also, I wanted carrot cake and I didn't want all of that pound cake that everyone kept feeding me, I wanted something that tasted like the real thing, but they all said it would fall apart if it wasn't pound cake. So, I decided to venture out, and I found my man. I had called a man in Alpharetta to see what his pricing was and get some info, he was wonderful. I got up one morning and decided to drive out to meet him and have a tasting. He brought me into his home with his wife and two children, and he had this little tea set and cake platter all set for me when I got there. It was so good. I could not have been happier with my wedding cake and groom's cake. I have never been to a wedding where people actually liked the cake, but I was complimented all night on my choice!
I live in Atlanta and I went to all of the popular wedding cake designers, and nothing was clicking for me. There were all Read more...
I live in Atlanta and I went to all of the popular wedding cake designers, and nothing was clicking for me. There were all very set in their ways, and kept steering me towards carbon copy wedding cakes. I was not at all interested. Also, I wanted carrot cake and I didn't want all of that pound cake that everyone kept feeding me, I wanted something that tasted like the real thing, but they all said it would fall apart if it wasn't pound cake. So, I decided to venture out, and I found my man. I had called a man in Alpharetta to see what his pricing was and get some info, he was wonderful. I got up one morning and decided to drive out to meet him and have a tasting. He brought me into his home with his wife and two children, and he had this little tea set and cake platter all set for me when I got there. It was so good. I could not have been happier with my wedding cake and groom's cake. I have never been to a wedding where people actually liked the cake, but I was complimented all night on my choice! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jennifer
Wedding:
10/19/2012
5.0/5.0
We had cupcakes for our guests (3 different kinds!) and a small cake for us to cut. Everything was amazing- presentation was beautiful and taste was outstanding. I didn't have time to eat any at the reception, unfortunately, but the owner of the vineyard where we had the wedding packed up a bunch of cupcakes for us and had them waiting in the getaway limo. :) Value for the price was fantastic and several of our guests commented on how good they were. Definitely recommend!
We had cupcakes for our guests (3 different kinds!) and a small cake for us to cut. Everything was amazing- presentation Read more...
We had cupcakes for our guests (3 different kinds!) and a small cake for us to cut. Everything was amazing- presentation was beautiful and taste was outstanding. I didn't have time to eat any at the reception, unfortunately, but the owner of the vineyard where we had the wedding packed up a bunch of cupcakes for us and had them waiting in the getaway limo. :) Value for the price was fantastic and several of our guests commented on how good they were. Definitely recommend! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Private User
Wedding:
5/18/2013
4.9/5.0
When we had our tasting with Frosted Pumpkin, we immediately knew that was the cake to be served at our wedding. It was delicious!! I had a 4 tier cake and each layer was a different flavor with different fillings and each layer turned out perfectly! The cake tasted the same, if not better, the day of the wedding as it did a year earlier at our tasting! Our design for the cake was simple and Jeff delivered on that as well! I would definitely recommend Jeff and Frosted Pumpkin for any wedding or other event!
When we had our tasting with Frosted Pumpkin, we immediately knew that was the cake to be served at our wedding. It was Read more...
When we had our tasting with Frosted Pumpkin, we immediately knew that was the cake to be served at our wedding. It was delicious!! I had a 4 tier cake and each layer was a different flavor with different fillings and each layer turned out perfectly! The cake tasted the same, if not better, the day of the wedding as it did a year earlier at our tasting! Our design for the cake was simple and Jeff delivered on that as well! I would definitely recommend Jeff and Frosted Pumpkin for any wedding or other event! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Maggie
Wedding:
5/4/2013
4.9/5.0
We got married 6 months ago and people are STILL raving about our wedding cake and Groom's cake from Frosted Pumpkin. At the taste testing all of the flavors were so good and we could not decide so we simply picked 5 different flavors for a tiered (multi layered) cake! Guests kept coming back to taste all the different flavors. Frosted Pumpkin also helped custom design our dream Wedding cake and the surprise Groom's cake for my husband. The only little mistake was a misspelling on the Groom's cake which was unfortunately noticed by all of my husband's business-lawyer friends in attendance to the wedding (oops!) at least it made for a good laugh :)
We highly recommend the Frosted Pumpkin for all of your wedding needs!
We got married 6 months ago and people are STILL raving about our wedding cake and Groom's cake from Frosted Pumpkin. At Read more...
We got married 6 months ago and people are STILL raving about our wedding cake and Groom's cake from Frosted Pumpkin. At the taste testing all of the flavors were so good and we could not decide so we simply picked 5 different flavors for a tiered (multi layered) cake! Guests kept coming back to taste all the different flavors. Frosted Pumpkin also helped custom design our dream Wedding cake and the surprise Groom's cake for my husband. The only little mistake was a misspelling on the Groom's cake which was unfortunately noticed by all of my husband's business-lawyer friends in attendance to the wedding (oops!) at least it made for a good laugh :)
We highly recommend the Frosted Pumpkin for all of your wedding needs! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Mars2685
Wedding:
3/24/2012
4.9/5.0
The most amazing wedding cake! Looked gorgeous and tasted amazing! Jeff was so nice and great to work with. He made sure that my vision came true and I could not have been happier with the way the cakes turned out.
The most amazing wedding cake! Looked gorgeous and tasted amazing! Jeff was so nice and great to work with. He made sure Read more...
The most amazing wedding cake! Looked gorgeous and tasted amazing! Jeff was so nice and great to work with. He made sure that my vision came true and I could not have been happier with the way the cakes turned out. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kbride
Wedding:
8/23/2008
4.9/5.0
This cake is UNREAL! I had guests calling me after the wedding to see if we had any leftovers! I am not even a cake person....and I had to go back for more! Also- very professional in the consultation- very nice people to work with.
This cake is UNREAL! I had guests calling me after the wedding to see if we had any leftovers! I am not even a cake Read more...
This cake is UNREAL! I had guests calling me after the wedding to see if we had any leftovers! I am not even a cake person....and I had to go back for more! Also- very professional in the consultation- very nice people to work with. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kate
Wedding:
4/29/2006
4.9/5.0
I went with Frosted Pumpkin at the last moment. I was having trouble with my cake at the Four Seasons (they didn't want to do colored frosting), so the week before the wedding, I hired them. They snuck me in since they had a good relationship with the Four Seasons. I have to say the cake design wasn't how I totally pictured it, but it was last minute. To do my dream cake, we would have needed to go with fondant, but everyone else was against it. I am happy with it, just wasn't how I pictured it. But the taste (that's the important thing right!) was amazing. We went with chocolate cake with chocolate ganache and mousse fillings. Wow! I only got a tiny taste, but the guests raved about it. I can't wait to eat our top layer on our anniversary.
I went with Frosted Pumpkin at the last moment. I was having trouble with my cake at the Four Seasons (they didn't want to Read more...
I went with Frosted Pumpkin at the last moment. I was having trouble with my cake at the Four Seasons (they didn't want to do colored frosting), so the week before the wedding, I hired them. They snuck me in since they had a good relationship with the Four Seasons. I have to say the cake design wasn't how I totally pictured it, but it was last minute. To do my dream cake, we would have needed to go with fondant, but everyone else was against it. I am happy with it, just wasn't how I pictured it. But the taste (that's the important thing right!) was amazing. We went with chocolate cake with chocolate ganache and mousse fillings. Wow! I only got a tiny taste, but the guests raved about it. I can't wait to eat our top layer on our anniversary. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kristin
Wedding:
6/1/2013
4.8/5.0
We had three cake tastings, and Frosted Pumpkin was by far the best tasting cake we tried. Moist, delicious, to die for fillings and frostings! I had found a picture of a cake I really liked on Pinterest, and Frosted Pumpkin was able to make that design for me. The groom got a James Bond cake. My fiance emailed Frosted Pumpkin and image that he wanted the top to look like and Frosted Pumpkin was able to print it on edible paper and place it on the grooms cake. Frosted Pumpkin is by no means the cheapest one out there, but for this quality of cake, it was well worth the money. My husband and I were only able to taste a little bit of it at the reception because we were so busy, but the little we did taste was AMAZING! If you are a chocolate fan, you will love Frosted Pumpkin's chocolate!
We had three cake tastings, and Frosted Pumpkin was by far the best tasting cake we tried. Moist, delicious, to die for Read more...
We had three cake tastings, and Frosted Pumpkin was by far the best tasting cake we tried. Moist, delicious, to die for fillings and frostings! I had found a picture of a cake I really liked on Pinterest, and Frosted Pumpkin was able to make that design for me. The groom got a James Bond cake. My fiance emailed Frosted Pumpkin and image that he wanted the top to look like and Frosted Pumpkin was able to print it on edible paper and place it on the grooms cake. Frosted Pumpkin is by no means the cheapest one out there, but for this quality of cake, it was well worth the money. My husband and I were only able to taste a little bit of it at the reception because we were so busy, but the little we did taste was AMAZING! If you are a chocolate fan, you will love Frosted Pumpkin's chocolate! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Caroline
Wedding:
1/19/2013
4.8/5.0
YUMMY! Jeff was great to work with, and very flexible to find options to meet our vision and our budget. The resulting cake was exactly as I had imagined it -- beautiful and absolutely delicious! We got tons of compliments.
YUMMY! Jeff was great to work with, and very flexible to find options to meet our vision and our budget. The resulting Read more...
YUMMY! Jeff was great to work with, and very flexible to find options to meet our vision and our budget. The resulting cake was exactly as I had imagined it -- beautiful and absolutely delicious! We got tons of compliments. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Samantha
Wedding:
10/13/2012
4.8/5.0
Frosted Pumpkin made our cake and cupcakes (four different flavors) and everyone loved it! The cupcakes and cake were delicious and beautifully decorated. They were perfect for our wedding! It was great working with Jeff, and we would definitely recommend Frosted Pumpkin to anyone!
Frosted Pumpkin made our cake and cupcakes (four different flavors) and everyone loved it! The cupcakes and cake were Read more...
Frosted Pumpkin made our cake and cupcakes (four different flavors) and everyone loved it! The cupcakes and cake were delicious and beautifully decorated. They were perfect for our wedding! It was great working with Jeff, and we would definitely recommend Frosted Pumpkin to anyone! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bg1
Kila
Wedding:
9/19/2010
4.8/5.0
This was the BEST cake ever! Jeff was awesome!
This was the BEST cake ever! Jeff was awesome!
This was the BEST cake ever! Jeff was awesome! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Keeley
Wedding:
9/11/2010
4.7/5.0
I’m not sure about the rest of you, but for me, whenever I’m at a wedding, I’m always UNDERwhelmed by the wedding cake. It might LOOK beautiful, but the cake is just so-so. Forgettable. Well, my husband and I did not want that kind of a reaction at our wedding. We’re not your typical “cake lovers” and we aren’t really “typical” either, so we really wanted a cake that would not only LOOK different but also TASTE amazing!

We found just what we were looking for with the Frosted Pumpkin. When we first met Jeff he welcomed us into his home, where he bakes and decorates all of his cakes with his wife, Karyn. My husband Brad and I really wanted to have a Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Fudge icing (how unconventional of a wedding cake is that?!?) and Jeff was great with suggested what he as a professional would recommend to us – size, shape, etc. And his cake tasted delicious of course. But what really got us, was his unique suggestion of tying in my whole wedding theme into the cake. I had a brooch bouquet and I wanted to incorporate brooches in other areas as well… so why not have a cascade of brooches down the cake he said?? It was perfect! Why didn’t I think of that?? And so we knew he was the one for us.

I was worried as all brides should be on the day of because of course we hadn’t seen the cake yet. But when I saw it for the first time, it was just as I had imagined it. And words cannot describe the taste!  We even had people asking us who made it? And can they make cakes for other occasions too??

I highly recommend the Frosted Pumpkin – for an amazing wedding cake – not matter how traditional or unconventional you wish!
I’m not sure about the rest of you, but for me, whenever I’m at a wedding, I’m always UNDERwhelmed by the wedding cake. It Read more...
I’m not sure about the rest of you, but for me, whenever I’m at a wedding, I’m always UNDERwhelmed by the wedding cake. It might LOOK beautiful, but the cake is just so-so. Forgettable. Well, my husband and I did not want that kind of a reaction at our wedding. We’re not your typical “cake lovers” and we aren’t really “typical” either, so we really wanted a cake that would not only LOOK different but also TASTE amazing!

We found just what we were looking for with the Frosted Pumpkin. When we first met Jeff he welcomed us into his home, where he bakes and decorates all of his cakes with his wife, Karyn. My husband Brad and I really wanted to have a Chocolate Cake with Chocolate Fudge icing (how unconventional of a wedding cake is that?!?) and Jeff was great with suggested what he as a professional would recommend to us – size, shape, etc. And his cake tasted delicious of course. But what really got us, was his unique suggestion of tying in my whole wedding theme into the cake. I had a brooch bouquet and I wanted to incorporate brooches in other areas as well… so why not have a cascade of brooches down the cake he said?? It was perfect! Why didn’t I think of that?? And so we knew he was the one for us.

I was worried as all brides should be on the day of because of course we hadn’t seen the cake yet. But when I saw it for the first time, it was just as I had imagined it. And words cannot describe the taste!  We even had people asking us who made it? And can they make cakes for other occasions too??

I highly recommend the Frosted Pumpkin – for an amazing wedding cake – not matter how traditional or unconventional you wish! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Mrs.
Wedding:
2/26/2010
4.7/5.0
Our cake was beautiful and tasted great, just thought it was super expensive for what we got.
Our cake was beautiful and tasted great, just thought it was super expensive for what we got.
Our cake was beautiful and tasted great, just thought it was super expensive for what we got. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
zta695
Wedding:
10/20/2007
4.7/5.0
We got out wedding cake and groom's cake from here. They did a great job. When we went to meet with him her had albums full of pictures to look at. We did a tasting at the same time. I didn't have a picture to show him just and idea and he drew out the designs for me to look at.

Our cake was sooooo good. We got tons on compliments on the cake! Best tasting wedding cakes hands down!
We got out wedding cake and groom's cake from here. They did a great job. When we went to meet with him her had albums Read more...
We got out wedding cake and groom's cake from here. They did a great job. When we went to meet with him her had albums full of pictures to look at. We did a tasting at the same time. I didn't have a picture to show him just and idea and he drew out the designs for me to look at.

Our cake was sooooo good. We got tons on compliments on the cake! Best tasting wedding cakes hands down! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Melanie
Wedding:
4/19/2014
4.6/5.0
Jeff was so friendly and welcoming when we met with him for a tasting! Even on the weeks leading up to our appointment, he was always very professional and prompt on his email replies. We came to him with a few ideas on what we had in mind as far as the look of the cake, and he made a few suggestions that we never really would have thought of on our own. We tried a few different flavors at our tasting and I actually ended up mixing a couple of slices ... different cakes with other fillings on a different slice.. I made a quiet comment to my husband that what I mixed was awesome and Jeff said "we can do that combination if you want!". That was great to hear! While we met with him in Alpharetta, he also has a Decatur location if that is more convenient to you. I'm really glad we decided to go with Frosted Pumpkin. He has worked w/ our caterer (Bold American) tons and tons of times and knows our venue (King Plow) really well which made us feel confident that he would get the job done without any hiccups. We ended up having our cake with two different flavors... people raved on the wedding night that it was delicious and actually after we got home from our week long honeymoon, we were having more cake for dessert!
Jeff was so friendly and welcoming when we met with him for a tasting! Even on the weeks leading up to our appointment, he Read more...
Jeff was so friendly and welcoming when we met with him for a tasting! Even on the weeks leading up to our appointment, he was always very professional and prompt on his email replies. We came to him with a few ideas on what we had in mind as far as the look of the cake, and he made a few suggestions that we never really would have thought of on our own. We tried a few different flavors at our tasting and I actually ended up mixing a couple of slices ... different cakes with other fillings on a different slice.. I made a quiet comment to my husband that what I mixed was awesome and Jeff said "we can do that combination if you want!". That was great to hear! While we met with him in Alpharetta, he also has a Decatur location if that is more convenient to you. I'm really glad we decided to go with Frosted Pumpkin. He has worked w/ our caterer (Bold American) tons and tons of times and knows our venue (King Plow) really well which made us feel confident that he would get the job done without any hiccups. We ended up having our cake with two different flavors... people raved on the wedding night that it was delicious and actually after we got home from our week long honeymoon, we were having more cake for dessert! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Private User
Wedding:
12/31/2013
4.6/5.0
Great working with Jeff! He also did my sisters wedding and we are happy that we got him to do mine as well. Cake was beautiful! He was very flexible as to when we met for the tasting which was helpful since we live in NC but wedding was in Atlanta, Ga.
Great working with Jeff! He also did my sisters wedding and we are happy that we got him to do mine as well. Cake was Read more...
Great working with Jeff! He also did my sisters wedding and we are happy that we got him to do mine as well. Cake was beautiful! He was very flexible as to when we met for the tasting which was helpful since we live in NC but wedding was in Atlanta, Ga. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1308793443856-dscn1372
Gretchen
Wedding:
2/4/2012
4.6/5.0
Jeff at Frosted Pumpkin is fantastic! The cakes are delicious as well as beautiful and he can make ANYTHING you want! I'd definitely recommend him for ANY event!
Jeff at Frosted Pumpkin is fantastic! The cakes are delicious as well as beautiful and he can make ANYTHING you want! I'd Read more...
Jeff at Frosted Pumpkin is fantastic! The cakes are delicious as well as beautiful and he can make ANYTHING you want! I'd definitely recommend him for ANY event! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Michele
Wedding:
8/31/2008
4.6/5.0
The cake was delicious. The customer service after the fact can be improved.
The cake was delicious. The customer service after the fact can be improved.
The cake was delicious. The customer service after the fact can be improved. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Nancy
Wedding:
10/13/2013
4.4/5.0
Too expensive. HOWEVER! The cake was beautiful and so so yummy! I can't wait to have to top in a year!
Too expensive. HOWEVER! The cake was beautiful and so so yummy! I can't wait to have to top in a year!
Too expensive. HOWEVER! The cake was beautiful and so so yummy! I can't wait to have to top in a year! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Beth
Wedding:
11/28/2009
4.4/5.0
Frosted Pumpkin made me the wedding cake of my dreams. I got a classic vanilla triple layer cake and it was not only an amazing looking cake, but an amazing tasting cake. It captured all five senses well and treated my purse well too.
Frosted Pumpkin made me the wedding cake of my dreams. I got a classic vanilla triple layer cake and it was not only an Read more...
Frosted Pumpkin made me the wedding cake of my dreams. I got a classic vanilla triple layer cake and it was not only an amazing looking cake, but an amazing tasting cake. It captured all five senses well and treated my purse well too. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Johnna
Wedding:
5/28/2011
4.3/5.0
We had a bit of a difficult time getting the tasting booked (and a double booking that was frustrating)... I also didn't feel like they were as quick to respond as other vendors (phone calls, e-mails,etc). However, Jeff apologized and made it right. I can honestly say I have never been to a wedding and heard complements on the cake but EVERYONE was talking about how great it was. The cake is outstanding and I think worth the money! I can't wait for our one year anniversary to eat the top :-)
We had a bit of a difficult time getting the tasting booked (and a double booking that was frustrating)... I also didn't Read more...
We had a bit of a difficult time getting the tasting booked (and a double booking that was frustrating)... I also didn't feel like they were as quick to respond as other vendors (phone calls, e-mails,etc). However, Jeff apologized and made it right. I can honestly say I have never been to a wedding and heard complements on the cake but EVERYONE was talking about how great it was. The cake is outstanding and I think worth the money! I can't wait for our one year anniversary to eat the top :-) Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1272980871442-meandbradinsanibelisland
Stephanie
Wedding:
7/4/2010
4.0/5.0
Frosted Pumpkin did a beautiful job on my cake. The only thing that I was not happy about was a miscommunication between me and the decorator. The cake was to have hot pink sugar ribbon and black scroll work. The cake at the wedding had light pink sugar ribbon and white scroll work. Nevertheless, the flavors were amazing and exactly what I picked out. It was delicious and the top layer has already been eaten. When I made mention of the how the cake was different after the wedding, Jeff at Frosted Pumpkin apologized and offered to do a free cake for me for a birthday, baby shower, etc. in the future. This was very generous and more than made for the error.

I would definitely work with them again and appreciated how they handled everything. It was a delicious and beautiful cake.
Frosted Pumpkin did a beautiful job on my cake. The only thing that I was not happy about was a miscommunication between Read more...
Frosted Pumpkin did a beautiful job on my cake. The only thing that I was not happy about was a miscommunication between me and the decorator. The cake was to have hot pink sugar ribbon and black scroll work. The cake at the wedding had light pink sugar ribbon and white scroll work. Nevertheless, the flavors were amazing and exactly what I picked out. It was delicious and the top layer has already been eaten. When I made mention of the how the cake was different after the wedding, Jeff at Frosted Pumpkin apologized and offered to do a free cake for me for a birthday, baby shower, etc. in the future. This was very generous and more than made for the error.

I would definitely work with them again and appreciated how they handled everything. It was a delicious and beautiful cake. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Private User
Wedding:
5/5/2013
3.6/5.0
My cake was lovely, but not exactly what I had ordered. We were originally going to do a cake from Publix, but we stressed about the delivery and design. I had ordered a square cake and it came out round. It wasn't the biggest deal (I didn't even notice until my mom pointed out), but when we sent an email to the owner, he basically said that we had never ordered it square. Guests enjoyed the cake, however.
My cake was lovely, but not exactly what I had ordered. We were originally going to do a cake from Publix, but we stressed Read more...
My cake was lovely, but not exactly what I had ordered. We were originally going to do a cake from Publix, but we stressed about the delivery and design. I had ordered a square cake and it came out round. It wasn't the biggest deal (I didn't even notice until my mom pointed out), but when we sent an email to the owner, he basically said that we had never ordered it square. Guests enjoyed the cake, however. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Juliecl1
Wedding:
9/5/2010
3.5/5.0
VERY expensive. Why is cake so expensive and he did 10 cakes in one weekend. WOW he makes a fortune! LUCKY! never got to taste the actual cake. But got a lot of compliments on it. So i guess it was worth the cost! We had 3 different flavors of cake.
VERY expensive. Why is cake so expensive and he did 10 cakes in one weekend. WOW he makes a fortune! LUCKY! never got to Read more...
VERY expensive. Why is cake so expensive and he did 10 cakes in one weekend. WOW he makes a fortune! LUCKY! never got to taste the actual cake. But got a lot of compliments on it. So i guess it was worth the cost! We had 3 different flavors of cake. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
3.4/5.0
The cake was pretty and tasted fine. However, I made some changes two weeks before the wedding to the design and stand that I wanted to use. Jeff made some suggestions, and then I confirmed our final decision. It took a few reminder emails for him to confirm, but he did eventually. Unfortunately, the day of the wedding we walked in and none of the changes had been made. The cake was still pretty and tasted good (I especially recommend the chocolate cake with the fudge frosting, which we had for the groom's cake. The red velvet and vanilla were just okay.), but it was the wrong stand and design. I was disappointed with the flexibility, responsiveness, and professionalism, since they clearly forgot to note the changes. I shouldn't have had to feel that little jolt of disappointment at the reception.
The cake was pretty and tasted fine. However, I made some changes two weeks before the wedding to the design and stand Read more...
The cake was pretty and tasted fine. However, I made some changes two weeks before the wedding to the design and stand that I wanted to use. Jeff made some suggestions, and then I confirmed our final decision. It took a few reminder emails for him to confirm, but he did eventually. Unfortunately, the day of the wedding we walked in and none of the changes had been made. The cake was still pretty and tasted good (I especially recommend the chocolate cake with the fudge frosting, which we had for the groom's cake. The red velvet and vanilla were just okay.), but it was the wrong stand and design. I was disappointed with the flexibility, responsiveness, and professionalism, since they clearly forgot to note the changes. I shouldn't have had to feel that little jolt of disappointment at the reception. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bg19
Andrew
Wedding:
4/30/2011
1.0/5.0
Don't use Frosted Pumpkin if you want a stress free experience. It took so much to get a phone call returned. Then they forgot items stated in the contract which made it painful to get a cake stand back to them. The cake was a bit lopsided too, but it did taste great.
Don't use Frosted Pumpkin if you want a stress free experience. It took so much to get a phone call returned. Then they Read more...
Don't use Frosted Pumpkin if you want a stress free experience. It took so much to get a phone call returned. Then they forgot items stated in the contract which made it painful to get a cake stand back to them. The cake was a bit lopsided too, but it did taste great. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake

MAP

 
221 Silver Birch CT, Alpharetta, GA 30004 See On Map
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for Frosted Pumpkin
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww_logo
 
220x220_1395168000290-dscn0511bw