Nophoto 130

HOMESTYLE BAKERY

Peekskill

LOCATION

PEEKSKILL, US
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Wedding Cake

REVIEWS

4.6
out of 5.0
4.6/5.0
4.6/5.0
4.3/5.0
4.8/5.0
4.7/5.0
Sort by
Default vendor profile pic
Lauren
Wedding:
7/3/2015
4.7/5.0
We were referred to Homestyle through InnCredible caterers. Went for a tasting and had such a difficult time deciding between so many mouthwatering options! Ultimately went with the black and white cake (two layers of chocolate, one yellow) layered with vanilla custard and chocolate mousse. Even guests who are not big dessert eaters raved about the cake. And they were great about matching the picture I gave them with "spackled" frosting. Looked great, tasted even better!
We were referred to Homestyle through InnCredible caterers. Went for a tasting and had such a difficult time deciding Read more...
We were referred to Homestyle through InnCredible caterers. Went for a tasting and had such a difficult time deciding between so many mouthwatering options! Ultimately went with the black and white cake (two layers of chocolate, one yellow) layered with vanilla custard and chocolate mousse. Even guests who are not big dessert eaters raved about the cake. And they were great about matching the picture I gave them with "spackled" frosting. Looked great, tasted even better! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Sara
Wedding:
5/16/2015
4.8/5.0
Our wedding cake was absolutely delicious. We went with chocolate and vanilla cake with strawberry and cheesecake filling. Everyone raved about it. We also had an Italian sampler table that went over pretty well as well. My only complaint is I asked for no ribbon around the layers of my cake only the flowers with the topper I provided and the cake showed up with yellow ribbon around the layers and my wedding colors were pink and black. Other then that they were responsive in changing my cake design when asked to do so and the cake tasted amazing.
Our wedding cake was absolutely delicious. We went with chocolate and vanilla cake with strawberry and cheesecake filling. Read more...
Our wedding cake was absolutely delicious. We went with chocolate and vanilla cake with strawberry and cheesecake filling. Everyone raved about it. We also had an Italian sampler table that went over pretty well as well. My only complaint is I asked for no ribbon around the layers of my cake only the flowers with the topper I provided and the cake showed up with yellow ribbon around the layers and my wedding colors were pink and black. Other then that they were responsive in changing my cake design when asked to do so and the cake tasted amazing. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Catherine
Wedding:
4/24/2015
5.0/5.0
Homestyle bakery made our wedding cake in April and it was fantastic! My husband and I went in for a cake tasting about a month prior and decided on the 3 layer per tier with canolli and chocolate mousse! It was so decadent and beautiful. I sent specific ribbon that I wanted on our cake and it turned out perfect! Our guests raved about our cake and how so many of them wished they had a second piece!!

Can't wait for our anniversary cake from them!!
Homestyle bakery made our wedding cake in April and it was fantastic! My husband and I went in for a cake tasting about a Read more...
Homestyle bakery made our wedding cake in April and it was fantastic! My husband and I went in for a cake tasting about a month prior and decided on the 3 layer per tier with canolli and chocolate mousse! It was so decadent and beautiful. I sent specific ribbon that I wanted on our cake and it turned out perfect! Our guests raved about our cake and how so many of them wished they had a second piece!!

Can't wait for our anniversary cake from them!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Meghan
Wedding:
4/25/2014
4.4/5.0
To begin the cake was beautiful and tasty. They did exactly what we wanted and we were happy with the product. The tasting experience on the other hand left a lot to be desired. The desk that we sat at for our tasting was in the middle of a very disorganized room. The cake was left out on a side table..uncovered...and pieces were cut an placed on a foam plate for us to try. I only mention this because I seriously thought about finding another place (our venue sent us here) because of the appearance of this office. We stuck with them and were happy with the product. I do hope they change the way the do tasting though it was pretty concerning as a bride.
To begin the cake was beautiful and tasty. They did exactly what we wanted and we were happy with the product. The tasting Read more...
To begin the cake was beautiful and tasty. They did exactly what we wanted and we were happy with the product. The tasting experience on the other hand left a lot to be desired. The desk that we sat at for our tasting was in the middle of a very disorganized room. The cake was left out on a side table..uncovered...and pieces were cut an placed on a foam plate for us to try. I only mention this because I seriously thought about finding another place (our venue sent us here) because of the appearance of this office. We stuck with them and were happy with the product. I do hope they change the way the do tasting though it was pretty concerning as a bride. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Tina
Wedding:
7/5/2013
5.0/5.0
"That was the best cake I've ever had in my life, and I don't even like cake" - seemed to be the theme of my wedding....I have never in my life tasted a cake like this, and to think I almost nixed the idea of having a cake!! It was chocolate cake layered with chocolate mousse and cheesecake topped with vanilla cake and whipped cream frosting...
And it LOOKED spectacular too!
"That was the best cake I've ever had in my life, and I don't even like cake" - seemed to be the theme of my wedding....I Read more...
"That was the best cake I've ever had in my life, and I don't even like cake" - seemed to be the theme of my wedding....I have never in my life tasted a cake like this, and to think I almost nixed the idea of having a cake!! It was chocolate cake layered with chocolate mousse and cheesecake topped with vanilla cake and whipped cream frosting...
And it LOOKED spectacular too! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130 sq 1343695216634 fbavatar2570746
Aisling
Wedding:
6/22/2013
5.0/5.0
Our wedding cake was beautiful and delicious.
Our wedding cake was beautiful and delicious.
Our wedding cake was beautiful and delicious. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Debra
Wedding:
5/26/2013
5.0/5.0
Best cake ever! Our families continued to eat it for days after the reception.
Best cake ever! Our families continued to eat it for days after the reception.
Best cake ever! Our families continued to eat it for days after the reception. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
christina
Wedding:
5/5/2013
5.0/5.0
Wonderful cake!!! We had a 4 tier cake with magnolias cascasing down the side. It was 2 layers of vanilla cake and 1 layer of choclate with chocolate mousee and cannoli filling. AMAZING.. I will drive to Peekskill again for any cake orders i have in the future.
Wonderful cake!!! We had a 4 tier cake with magnolias cascasing down the side. It was 2 layers of vanilla cake and 1 layer Read more...
Wonderful cake!!! We had a 4 tier cake with magnolias cascasing down the side. It was 2 layers of vanilla cake and 1 layer of choclate with chocolate mousee and cannoli filling. AMAZING.. I will drive to Peekskill again for any cake orders i have in the future. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Michelle
Wedding:
4/26/2013
4.0/5.0
Our wedding cake was delicious and looked beautiful.
Our wedding cake was delicious and looked beautiful.
Our wedding cake was delicious and looked beautiful. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Justine
Wedding:
12/21/2012
2.9/5.0
Don't get me wrong - Homestyle Bakery makes the best tasting cakes and desserts. Literally - so yummy. However, we had difficulty getting a hold of them to set up a tasting. When I finally did get someone on the phone, the snotty girl I spoke to hung up on me when I asked for a cake tasting more than 3 months in advance. As a bride who was planning a destination wedding (we got married at Bear Mountain - I was planning from Cleveland) it was difficult for me to come into town to do this - why could we not arranging a tasting sooner? It made no sense to me. While we tried a few different bakeries in the area - we ultimately came back to them only beacsue they have an account with our venue and we wouldn't get enough $ back from them to purchase the type of cake we wanted.
Luckily, I came into town a month before the wedding and they made an appointment with us. We went in a bit hesitant, but ended up having a seamless experience. The tasting was great, and to top it off, I had this picture of a cake I had ripped out of a magazine when I was a child and showed it to the baker hoping she could give me something like it. She said "No problem" and ended up making the exact replica - it was perfect.
The desserts were so good we ended up ordering a smaller cake and cookies for the rehearsal dinner we had across the street from the bakery at the Peekskill Brewery. So while I am checking that I would "recommend this vendor to a friend" I would do so only if you are in the area and can deal with a little drama.
Don't get me wrong - Homestyle Bakery makes the best tasting cakes and desserts. Literally - so yummy. However, we had Read more...
Don't get me wrong - Homestyle Bakery makes the best tasting cakes and desserts. Literally - so yummy. However, we had difficulty getting a hold of them to set up a tasting. When I finally did get someone on the phone, the snotty girl I spoke to hung up on me when I asked for a cake tasting more than 3 months in advance. As a bride who was planning a destination wedding (we got married at Bear Mountain - I was planning from Cleveland) it was difficult for me to come into town to do this - why could we not arranging a tasting sooner? It made no sense to me. While we tried a few different bakeries in the area - we ultimately came back to them only beacsue they have an account with our venue and we wouldn't get enough $ back from them to purchase the type of cake we wanted.
Luckily, I came into town a month before the wedding and they made an appointment with us. We went in a bit hesitant, but ended up having a seamless experience. The tasting was great, and to top it off, I had this picture of a cake I had ripped out of a magazine when I was a child and showed it to the baker hoping she could give me something like it. She said "No problem" and ended up making the exact replica - it was perfect.
The desserts were so good we ended up ordering a smaller cake and cookies for the rehearsal dinner we had across the street from the bakery at the Peekskill Brewery. So while I am checking that I would "recommend this vendor to a friend" I would do so only if you are in the area and can deal with a little drama. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for HOMESTYLE BAKERY
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww logo
Nophoto 220