130x130_sq_1251213242268-1.5radiant

I Do Now I Don't (www.idonowidont.com)

New York , NY
CONTACT US
CONTACT US

LOCATION

400 East 56th Street
New York, NY US 10022 (map)

PHONE

800-991-3706

WEBSITE

View website
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.

ABOUT US

I Do Now I Don't featured on Good Morning America, abcnews.go.com/GMA/story

I Do Now I Don’t is unlike any online auction site you’ve ever seen. It all starts with a simple... Read more
I Do Now I Don't featured on Good Morning America, abcnews.go.com/GMA/story

I Do Now I Don’t is unlike any online auction site you’ve ever seen. It all starts with a simple premise - put buyers and sellers together where both end up with a great price for their jewelry and other collectables. The site offers an outlet for people ready to unload their leftover “assets” from a failed relationship or a diamond ring they have not worn in years. Items for sale at any time range from diamonds, engagement rings, vintage and antique engagement rings, wedding rings to wedding dresses and collectible watches. Many items come with great stories like Aunt Rosa’s ring that transforms a generic gem into unique shopping experience. Buyers, in turn, get a great discount and the opportunity to own higher quality jewelry than they thought they could afford. During an economic recession, consumers are looking for ways to be smarter about everything they buy.

Key to I Do Now I Don’t is providing buyers and sellers with security, simplicity and superior service. A trained gemologist to assure its authenticity inspects each diamond sold on the site. The buyer’s money is released to the seller only when the diamond certification process is complete. In a world where so much is uncertain, I Do Now I Dont’s process allows everyone to buy and sell jewelry in 100% safe, secure and trusting environment.

Follow us on Twitter: twitter.com/idonowidont Read less
Jewelry

INFO FOR JEWELRY

What kind of jewelry do you offer?
Antique Accessories, Antique Engagement Rings, Antique Wedding Bands, Custom Engagement Rings, Custom Wedding Bands, Designer Accessories, Designer Engagement Rings, Designer Wedding Bands

REVIEWS

3.5
out of 5.0
3.3/5.0
3.6/5.0
3.4/5.0
3.8/5.0
3.3/5.0
Sort by
Bg22
Jenn
Wedding:
5/14/2016
5.0/5.0
My boyfriend just purchased my (soon-to-be!) engagement ring from IDoNowIDont.com. We were very nervous, not only because of buying online, but also because we were buying a ring "second-hand". We found a ring we both loved (I actually gasped when I saw it!), and contacted the seller. After a few emails back and forth, we settled on a price. He edited the listing to reflect our offer, and we purchased. The seller sent the ring to IDNID; they have a GIA trained specialist evaluate the ring to make sure it matches the listing and the certificate paperwork. (While they are evaluating it, our money was held in escrow). Once it was confirmed that the ring matched, they released the money to the seller, and sent the ring to us. I actually called IDNID, because I was checking the tracking number and it looked like it was going to be delivered on a Saturday (and I had it delivered to my work!) and I was all panicked that no one would be here to sign for it. A representative called me back almost immediately, was very pleasant, and assured me that they only deliver on weekdays. Their customer service is great.

I have not seen it in person, but my boyfriend says it looks amazing! It will have to be resized (the ring is a 7, but I am a 5.5), but that is not a big deal for the amazing deal we got.

Oh, also! I found a coupon online (I used code "EBBOX13") for a free insurance appraisal, so we got that too! The ring appraised for nearly DOUBLE what we ended up paying!! We have already recommended IDNID to several friends.

We got a ring MUCH nicer (& bigger!) than we would have been able to afford at a traditional store. I cannot wait to see it on! =)
My boyfriend just purchased my (soon-to-be!) engagement ring from IDoNowIDont.com. We were very nervous, not only because Read more...
My boyfriend just purchased my (soon-to-be!) engagement ring from IDoNowIDont.com. We were very nervous, not only because of buying online, but also because we were buying a ring "second-hand". We found a ring we both loved (I actually gasped when I saw it!), and contacted the seller. After a few emails back and forth, we settled on a price. He edited the listing to reflect our offer, and we purchased. The seller sent the ring to IDNID; they have a GIA trained specialist evaluate the ring to make sure it matches the listing and the certificate paperwork. (While they are evaluating it, our money was held in escrow). Once it was confirmed that the ring matched, they released the money to the seller, and sent the ring to us. I actually called IDNID, because I was checking the tracking number and it looked like it was going to be delivered on a Saturday (and I had it delivered to my work!) and I was all panicked that no one would be here to sign for it. A representative called me back almost immediately, was very pleasant, and assured me that they only deliver on weekdays. Their customer service is great.

I have not seen it in person, but my boyfriend says it looks amazing! It will have to be resized (the ring is a 7, but I am a 5.5), but that is not a big deal for the amazing deal we got.

Oh, also! I found a coupon online (I used code "EBBOX13") for a free insurance appraisal, so we got that too! The ring appraised for nearly DOUBLE what we ended up paying!! We have already recommended IDNID to several friends.

We got a ring MUCH nicer (& bigger!) than we would have been able to afford at a traditional store. I cannot wait to see it on! =) Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
1.3/5.0
I tried to sell my bridal ring set to I Do Now I Don't, recently.

The set is currently available on Helzberg Diamonds for $4000. Obviously, mine is a used version, but still has all its stones and setting and could be cleaned up for under $100.

I think this place is probably either a joke or scam in terms of selling. They offered me $300 and told me that the set would potentially sell on their site used for $650.

Furthermore, they got confused over my ring and did not follow through on their emails that said they would get an offer to me by a certain day. This happened multiple times, drawing out the process of even getting a quote from them.

Finally, the grammar and punctuation in their emails was atrocious and unprofessional. Ex: "Will have the offer today the email was confusing as you have it signed as [redacted] and the ring came in as [redacted]"

I will say they responded to my emails with a few hours each time.

So either the moral of the story is these guys are idiots/scammers or diamonds are the stupidest investment on the planet.

I went to a pawn shop and got a quote that was 180% of the price they offered, so ???

At the least, their website is false advertising.
I tried to sell my bridal ring set to I Do Now I Don't, recently.

The set is currently available on Helzberg Read more...
I tried to sell my bridal ring set to I Do Now I Don't, recently.

The set is currently available on Helzberg Diamonds for $4000. Obviously, mine is a used version, but still has all its stones and setting and could be cleaned up for under $100.

I think this place is probably either a joke or scam in terms of selling. They offered me $300 and told me that the set would potentially sell on their site used for $650.

Furthermore, they got confused over my ring and did not follow through on their emails that said they would get an offer to me by a certain day. This happened multiple times, drawing out the process of even getting a quote from them.

Finally, the grammar and punctuation in their emails was atrocious and unprofessional. Ex: "Will have the offer today the email was confusing as you have it signed as [redacted] and the ring came in as [redacted]"

I will say they responded to my emails with a few hours each time.

So either the moral of the story is these guys are idiots/scammers or diamonds are the stupidest investment on the planet.

I went to a pawn shop and got a quote that was 180% of the price they offered, so ???

At the least, their website is false advertising. Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
2.8/5.0
myoldring.com http://www.myoldring.com or shop.myoldring.com
myoldring.com http://www.myoldring.com or shop.myoldring.com
myoldring.com http://www.myoldring.com or shop.myoldring.com Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
0.8/5.0
I was a member of idonowidont.com for about 6 months hoping of what I going to find my engagement ring I make a few offers and those people sale those ring way more expensive of BLUE NILE,RITANI,ETC, anyway some of them answer me back very few, and they don't take any offers,when I star searching for price out there and find out those people asking too much for it I decide to close my account, and I bought my diamond in retail website very good color,clarity and good price.
I was a member of idonowidont.com for about 6 months hoping of what I going to find my engagement ring I make a few offers Read more...
I was a member of idonowidont.com for about 6 months hoping of what I going to find my engagement ring I make a few offers and those people sale those ring way more expensive of BLUE NILE,RITANI,ETC, anyway some of them answer me back very few, and they don't take any offers,when I star searching for price out there and find out those people asking too much for it I decide to close my account, and I bought my diamond in retail website very good color,clarity and good price. Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jessica
Wedding:
7/19/2014
5.0/5.0
My fiance and I had only been ring shopping once or twice before a friend told us about your website. She assured us that it was a legitimate business. After browsing the website together, I found exactly what I was looking for. I told him that even if he didn't get "that" one, that I'd like mine to look very similar. A few months later he proposed with "THE" ring from idonowidont.com and paid a fraction of the cost had he gone to either of the jewelers we had previously visited. The payment transaction and shipping process was fool proof and he had the ring a few days after initially speaking with the seller. I am in love with the ring and knowing that he had such a great experience with the purchase maikes it that much better.



You guys are onto something!
My fiance and I had only been ring shopping once or twice before a friend told us about your website. She assured us that Read more...
My fiance and I had only been ring shopping once or twice before a friend told us about your website. She assured us that it was a legitimate business. After browsing the website together, I found exactly what I was looking for. I told him that even if he didn't get "that" one, that I'd like mine to look very similar. A few months later he proposed with "THE" ring from idonowidont.com and paid a fraction of the cost had he gone to either of the jewelers we had previously visited. The payment transaction and shipping process was fool proof and he had the ring a few days after initially speaking with the seller. I am in love with the ring and knowing that he had such a great experience with the purchase maikes it that much better.



You guys are onto something! Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Heather
Wedding:
9/9/2013
0.9/5.0
I wish I would have read these post before I tried to sell my ring on idonowidont.com. The customer service leaves so much to be desired. While I understand its relatively new there's no excuse for the poor customer service! Is the guy just running this out of his basement? No one answers the phone when you call and emails are very vague and not helpful what so ever.
I posted, agreed upon and sold my ring...that's where the trouble started. I did my part and shipped the ring to them insured (which costs a fortune) they received it the Friday before Labor Day but failed to notify me it was delivered as promised by the website (I see now that this is an ongoing problem) when I inquired about this I was told that their "offices were closed on Friday" when I asked how UPS shows it delivered the answer I got was this "we have a third party sign for all deliveries". A third party? They knew it had delivered but still failed to notify me as the website promises. Ironically, i recieved an email shortly thereafter stating it had in fact delivered. It did only take 48 hours to verify the stone therefore I received an email stating it was shipped out and a check was cut. That was last Wednesday. Four us mail days later and still no check although the buyer has had the ring since Friday. In my opinion this site needs some completion one that will protect the seller as well as the buyer. There is no reason other than greed that they could not electronically transfer funds in this day and age. They have made over $1200.00 off of my ring with little to no customer service. I would not use this website or recommend them
I wish I would have read these post before I tried to sell my ring on idonowidont.com. The customer service leaves so much Read more...
I wish I would have read these post before I tried to sell my ring on idonowidont.com. The customer service leaves so much to be desired. While I understand its relatively new there's no excuse for the poor customer service! Is the guy just running this out of his basement? No one answers the phone when you call and emails are very vague and not helpful what so ever.
I posted, agreed upon and sold my ring...that's where the trouble started. I did my part and shipped the ring to them insured (which costs a fortune) they received it the Friday before Labor Day but failed to notify me it was delivered as promised by the website (I see now that this is an ongoing problem) when I inquired about this I was told that their "offices were closed on Friday" when I asked how UPS shows it delivered the answer I got was this "we have a third party sign for all deliveries". A third party? They knew it had delivered but still failed to notify me as the website promises. Ironically, i recieved an email shortly thereafter stating it had in fact delivered. It did only take 48 hours to verify the stone therefore I received an email stating it was shipped out and a check was cut. That was last Wednesday. Four us mail days later and still no check although the buyer has had the ring since Friday. In my opinion this site needs some completion one that will protect the seller as well as the buyer. There is no reason other than greed that they could not electronically transfer funds in this day and age. They have made over $1200.00 off of my ring with little to no customer service. I would not use this website or recommend them Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Tanya
Wedding:
8/3/2013
4.9/5.0
Every person needs to shop on this website. I am not kidding. The prices are negotiable, and there are a variety of styles and qualities of jewels at a fraction of the price you would pay in a big name chain store.
Every person needs to shop on this website. I am not kidding. The prices are negotiable, and there are a variety of styles Read more...
Every person needs to shop on this website. I am not kidding. The prices are negotiable, and there are a variety of styles and qualities of jewels at a fraction of the price you would pay in a big name chain store. Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Mary
Wedding:
8/1/2013
4.9/5.0
Just sold my ring and could not be happier. I was extremely nervous sending in a $25,000 item and they worked with me to feel comfortable.
Just sold my ring and could not be happier. I was extremely nervous sending in a $25,000 item and they worked with me to Read more...
Just sold my ring and could not be happier. I was extremely nervous sending in a $25,000 item and they worked with me to feel comfortable. Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jennifer
Wedding:
5/8/2013
5.0/5.0
This is my second purchase from the website and I bought a gorgeous diamond eternity band that I saved thousands on. They were extremely helpful as all my local jewelers said they could or would not be able to re size it so I send it back to the website where they sized it for me and it came out perfect. I recommend the site to all my friends.
This is my second purchase from the website and I bought a gorgeous diamond eternity band that I saved thousands on. They Read more...
This is my second purchase from the website and I bought a gorgeous diamond eternity band that I saved thousands on. They were extremely helpful as all my local jewelers said they could or would not be able to re size it so I send it back to the website where they sized it for me and it came out perfect. I recommend the site to all my friends. Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default-vendor-profile-pic
make7457
Wedding:
6/28/2012
1.5/5.0
They are full of it. No customer service and grading as third party works for them just to sell a ring on site.
They are full of it. No customer service and grading as third party works for them just to sell a ring on site.
They are full of it. No customer service and grading as third party works for them just to sell a ring on site. Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jessica
Wedding:
5/5/2010
5.0/5.0
Just sold my Cartier ring set and couldn't be happier. I was nervous selling such an expensive set and it sold for $17,000 on the website within 2 weeks. Sent my ring in and received the check within a week. Was very nerve racking sending in such an expensive item but they made me feel extremely comfortable. No I am trying to sell all my other jewelry from my ex.
Just sold my Cartier ring set and couldn't be happier. I was nervous selling such an expensive set and it sold for $17,000 Read more...
Just sold my Cartier ring set and couldn't be happier. I was nervous selling such an expensive set and it sold for $17,000 on the website within 2 weeks. Sent my ring in and received the check within a week. Was very nerve racking sending in such an expensive item but they made me feel extremely comfortable. No I am trying to sell all my other jewelry from my ex. Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Dan
Wedding:
2/14/2008
1.2/5.0
I found IDoNowIDont.com as someone trying to sell my wedding band and engagement ring set.

As a seller, I wanted to trust the premise of the site so badly, because it appeared more professional and specialized compared to alternatives like craigslist and ebay, but I'm having a really hard time with them now.

I got an offer, came to agreement, and made the sale. But now that I've sent them my rings, I can't help but feel as though I just handed them to some stranger on the street for free.

It's totally ambiguous how they connect the rings being mailed-in with the actual post and person sending it.
And to make it worse, my FedEx tracking has shown "delivered" for THREE days and I have yet to receive the email confirmation that they promise to send once they get your ring.

I've emailed and called their customer care and have yet to speak with a live person. They are leaving me in the dark with my very personal and expensive belongings and I don't appreciate it/ definitely don't feel comfortable anymore.

As a seller, even if all goes well, I wouldn't use this site again...
I found IDoNowIDont.com as someone trying to sell my wedding band and engagement ring set.

As a seller, I wanted Read more...
I found IDoNowIDont.com as someone trying to sell my wedding band and engagement ring set.

As a seller, I wanted to trust the premise of the site so badly, because it appeared more professional and specialized compared to alternatives like craigslist and ebay, but I'm having a really hard time with them now.

I got an offer, came to agreement, and made the sale. But now that I've sent them my rings, I can't help but feel as though I just handed them to some stranger on the street for free.

It's totally ambiguous how they connect the rings being mailed-in with the actual post and person sending it.
And to make it worse, my FedEx tracking has shown "delivered" for THREE days and I have yet to receive the email confirmation that they promise to send once they get your ring.

I've emailed and called their customer care and have yet to speak with a live person. They are leaving me in the dark with my very personal and expensive belongings and I don't appreciate it/ definitely don't feel comfortable anymore.

As a seller, even if all goes well, I wouldn't use this site again... Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
0.8/5.0
They do inside trading. Good diamonds they keep it to themselves and say its rejected by the gemologist but when a bad quality diamond you end up buying they will surely send it to you. I don't trust these guys for a second. Bought a diamond and lost thousands.
They do inside trading. Good diamonds they keep it to themselves and say its rejected by the gemologist but when a bad Read more...
They do inside trading. Good diamonds they keep it to themselves and say its rejected by the gemologist but when a bad quality diamond you end up buying they will surely send it to you. I don't trust these guys for a second. Bought a diamond and lost thousands. Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
I Do Now I Don't (www.idonowidont.com) responded with the following comments:

Would love to speak with you about your transaction. I am the owner of the site. Im sorry you had such a bad experience. Please feel free to call or direct message me to discuss. My apologies.
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
1.7/5.0
Poor customer service and slow response time at best.
Took them WAY longer to authenticate and ship than was stated.
I had to follow up repeatedly. i.e. 1st response - will ship on Monday. 2nd response on Monday - SHOULD go out the next day. 3rd response was that it shipped - had to ASK for a tracking # as one wasn't provided. Tracking # stayed at label created status. 4th response contacted them again to verify tracking # and was told UPS missed the pick up.
Great value, but please do not purchase from them if you need something in a timely fashion. We may not be able to get the ring sized by Tiffany before the wedding. This would have been possible if they had made an effort.
Poor customer service and slow response time at best.
Took them WAY longer to authenticate and ship than was Read more...
Poor customer service and slow response time at best.
Took them WAY longer to authenticate and ship than was stated.
I had to follow up repeatedly. i.e. 1st response - will ship on Monday. 2nd response on Monday - SHOULD go out the next day. 3rd response was that it shipped - had to ASK for a tracking # as one wasn't provided. Tracking # stayed at label created status. 4th response contacted them again to verify tracking # and was told UPS missed the pick up.
Great value, but please do not purchase from them if you need something in a timely fashion. We may not be able to get the ring sized by Tiffany before the wedding. This would have been possible if they had made an effort. Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
5.0/5.0
My boyfriend and I were talking about getting engaged, but were not financially ready to make a purchase as large as we would of liked to. After hearing about your website, I looked at it and found the ring of my dreams. I purchased it at a price much lower than what we could of bought the same ring for at any jeweler and the seller received more money than he would of made by selling it to any jeweler. We both made out great! We are thrilled about the being able to purchase the ring I have always wanted! Thank you I Do Now I Dont!
My boyfriend and I were talking about getting engaged, but were not financially ready to make a purchase as large as we Read more...
My boyfriend and I were talking about getting engaged, but were not financially ready to make a purchase as large as we would of liked to. After hearing about your website, I looked at it and found the ring of my dreams. I purchased it at a price much lower than what we could of bought the same ring for at any jeweler and the seller received more money than he would of made by selling it to any jeweler. We both made out great! We are thrilled about the being able to purchase the ring I have always wanted! Thank you I Do Now I Dont! Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
5.0/5.0
I bought a Tiffany Ring that I always wanted and could not afford until now as it was 50% off retail. They helped me get the ring of my dreams. My co worker recommended me and I would recommend all my friends as well.
I bought a Tiffany Ring that I always wanted and could not afford until now as it was 50% off retail. They helped me get Read more...
I bought a Tiffany Ring that I always wanted and could not afford until now as it was 50% off retail. They helped me get the ring of my dreams. My co worker recommended me and I would recommend all my friends as well. Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
5.0/5.0
Been searching for a Tacori ring for Months and could not afford the one I really wanted. Found the exact one on the website at almost half the cost. Best deal and website ever. I would recommend anyone to them.
Been searching for a Tacori ring for Months and could not afford the one I really wanted. Found the exact one on the Read more...
Been searching for a Tacori ring for Months and could not afford the one I really wanted. Found the exact one on the website at almost half the cost. Best deal and website ever. I would recommend anyone to them. Read less
Services Used: Jewelry
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
5.0/5.0
Just sold my ring with the company. I couldn't happier. I was very nervous sending in a $30,000 ring and they held my had the entire time and made me feel comfortable. I got more money then anywhere else. Would recommend them to anyone who wants to sell diamond jewelry.
Just sold my ring with the company. I couldn't happier. I was very nervous sending in a $30,000 ring and they held my had Read more...
Just sold my ring with the company. I couldn't happier. I was very nervous sending in a $30,000 ring and they held my had the entire time and made me feel comfortable. I got more money then anywhere else. Would recommend them to anyone who wants to sell diamond jewelry. Read less
Services Used: Jewelry

MAP

 
400 East 56th Street, New York, NY 10022 See On Map
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for I Do Now I Don't (www.idonowidont.com)
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww_logo
 
220x220_1251213242268-1.5radiant