You will no longer have access to your Project Wedding account on or after March 30, 2017. Save any photos or information you'd like to keep and join WeddingWire for your all of your wedding planning needs today. Learn more »
130x130 sq 1352234296047 icingonthetoplogo

Icing On The Top

Tulsa , OK
CONTACT US
CONTACT US

LOCATION

1243 S. Harvard Ave.
Tulsa, OK 74112 US (map)

PHONE

918-828-0399
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.

ABOUT US

At Icing On The Top, our cake is our art! We strive to create a custom designed cake as unique as your personality and would love the opportunity to make your special day extra SWEET!
At Icing On The Top, our cake is our art! We strive to create a custom designed cake as unique as your personality and would love the opportunity to make your special day extra SWEET! Read less
Wedding Cake

PHOTOS

130x130 sq 1352235102814 roselacecake
130x130 sq 1352235075383 blingandswag
130x130 sq 1352235087310 graffiticake
130x130 sq 1352235068646 bearbryanthat
130x130 sq 1352235071079 bigbow

INFO FOR WEDDING CAKE

What types of desserts do you provide?
Cakes, Cookies, Cupcakes, Groom's Cake
What services do you provide?
Consultations, Custom Cake Design, Delivery, Setup, Tastings - Private
What cake items do you provide?
Cake Stands
Are you licensed by the state health department?
Yes

REVIEWS

4.8
out of 5.0
4.8/5.0
4.8/5.0
4.9/5.0
4.7/5.0
4.8/5.0
Sort by
Default vendor profile pic
Andrea
Wedding:
9/24/2016
4.6/5.0
Icing on the Top was great to work with—very professional and accommodating. Not being local, we planned our tasting many months in advance when we were planning to be in Tulsa to visit family. On the day of our tasting, we received a call from Nicole, who was 9 months pregnant and had started to go into labor! She asked if we could reschedule our tasting, and since we were leaving the next day to go home to Boston, we said we couldn't. Amazingly, Nicole offered to do the tasting as planned, even though she was having contractions throughout! We insisted it wasn't necessary, but she promised it would be okay, so we went. After an event like that, we figured they deserved our business!

The cake we had at the tasting wasn't the most delicious of cakes we tried, but we knew they would be able to make the cakes look amazing. After going back and forth on the bride's cake design, we asked Nicole to recreate an image we found on pinterest of a dark teal cake with gold leaf. Unfortunately, when we saw the cake on our wedding day, we were somewhat disappointed, as the cake turned out bright turquoise instead of deep teal. We were also pretty unhappy with the way the groom's cake (Han Solo in carbonite) looked—pretty much just a glorified sheet cake. In retrospect, we probably should have been more specific about what we were after, and also, the bakery didn't actually have any examples of the kind of designs we were after, so I should have known we were taking a risk. The cakes also tasted pretty dry and bland, but like I said, we knew that we were picking Icing on the Top based on their design skill and not the taste of their cake.

All in all, Icing on the Top was great to work with, and I would recommend them based on their cake decorating talent, flexibility, and professionalism. Just make sure that if you have something very specific in mind to be extremely clear in communicating what you want. And if you prioritize deliciousness, I would go with another vendor.
Icing on the Top was great to work with—very professional and accommodating. Not being local, we planned our tasting many Read more...
Icing on the Top was great to work with—very professional and accommodating. Not being local, we planned our tasting many months in advance when we were planning to be in Tulsa to visit family. On the day of our tasting, we received a call from Nicole, who was 9 months pregnant and had started to go into labor! She asked if we could reschedule our tasting, and since we were leaving the next day to go home to Boston, we said we couldn't. Amazingly, Nicole offered to do the tasting as planned, even though she was having contractions throughout! We insisted it wasn't necessary, but she promised it would be okay, so we went. After an event like that, we figured they deserved our business!

The cake we had at the tasting wasn't the most delicious of cakes we tried, but we knew they would be able to make the cakes look amazing. After going back and forth on the bride's cake design, we asked Nicole to recreate an image we found on pinterest of a dark teal cake with gold leaf. Unfortunately, when we saw the cake on our wedding day, we were somewhat disappointed, as the cake turned out bright turquoise instead of deep teal. We were also pretty unhappy with the way the groom's cake (Han Solo in carbonite) looked—pretty much just a glorified sheet cake. In retrospect, we probably should have been more specific about what we were after, and also, the bakery didn't actually have any examples of the kind of designs we were after, so I should have known we were taking a risk. The cakes also tasted pretty dry and bland, but like I said, we knew that we were picking Icing on the Top based on their design skill and not the taste of their cake.

All in all, Icing on the Top was great to work with, and I would recommend them based on their cake decorating talent, flexibility, and professionalism. Just make sure that if you have something very specific in mind to be extremely clear in communicating what you want. And if you prioritize deliciousness, I would go with another vendor. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
They are amazing ladies and their cakes are to die for can't wait to have my cake.
P.s. I also ordered my fiancés birthday cake from them so yummy too
They are amazing ladies and their cakes are to die for can't wait to have my cake.
P.s. I also ordered my fiancés Read more...
They are amazing ladies and their cakes are to die for can't wait to have my cake.
P.s. I also ordered my fiancés birthday cake from them so yummy too Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Tracey
Wedding:
7/2/2016
5.0/5.0
Erin was great! She made sure to keep in constant communication with us and made the cake tasting an awesome experience! I wasn't sure what to expect but I know Icing On The Top went above and beyond. I would definitely recommend this service to others.
Erin was great! She made sure to keep in constant communication with us and made the cake tasting an awesome experience! I Read more...
Erin was great! She made sure to keep in constant communication with us and made the cake tasting an awesome experience! I wasn't sure what to expect but I know Icing On The Top went above and beyond. I would definitely recommend this service to others. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Tiffany
Wedding:
6/4/2016
4.9/5.0
My cake was GORGEOUS! I gave them a picture and told them how I wanted it customized and they pulled through better than imagined. I'm a little weird and I don't like almond extract in my icing, so they were so sweet and did vanilla instead! I've never seen a more beautiful cake truly. I kept the sugar flowers and put them in Christmas ornaments because they were so stunning. Might I also suggest the lemon cake with raspberry filling, it's delicious!
My cake was GORGEOUS! I gave them a picture and told them how I wanted it customized and they pulled through better than Read more...
My cake was GORGEOUS! I gave them a picture and told them how I wanted it customized and they pulled through better than imagined. I'm a little weird and I don't like almond extract in my icing, so they were so sweet and did vanilla instead! I've never seen a more beautiful cake truly. I kept the sugar flowers and put them in Christmas ornaments because they were so stunning. Might I also suggest the lemon cake with raspberry filling, it's delicious! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Nicole
Wedding:
4/29/2016
5.0/5.0
They gave us an absolutely beautiful cake and it tasted amazing!!!
They gave us an absolutely beautiful cake and it tasted amazing!!!
They gave us an absolutely beautiful cake and it tasted amazing!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Sarah
Wedding:
4/23/2016
5.0/5.0
Icing on the Top provided our wedding cake and groom's cake for our recent wedding. Their cakes are so delicious! We went to our initial cake tasting, and it was so hard to just pick a flavor! They have the most unique cake flavors and filling flavors. Not to mention, when you walk in their shop, their design experience is very clear. The things they are capable of is just amazing. The girls at Icing on the Top make sure that your cakes are exactly how you want them. We are so happy we chose Icing on the Top!
Icing on the Top provided our wedding cake and groom's cake for our recent wedding. Their cakes are so delicious! We went Read more...
Icing on the Top provided our wedding cake and groom's cake for our recent wedding. Their cakes are so delicious! We went to our initial cake tasting, and it was so hard to just pick a flavor! They have the most unique cake flavors and filling flavors. Not to mention, when you walk in their shop, their design experience is very clear. The things they are capable of is just amazing. The girls at Icing on the Top make sure that your cakes are exactly how you want them. We are so happy we chose Icing on the Top! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
5.0/5.0
Icing on the top helped us create the perfect wedding cake to fit our wedding theme and colors. It was beautiful and the cake was absolutely delicious. Very moist and just the right consistency, We received tons of complements from our guests. Couldn't wait the full year to eat our cake top so we dug into at after our honeymoon and it still tasted awesome after being frozen! There were so many flavor options and combinations it was hard to choose since they all tasted wonderful!
Icing on the top helped us create the perfect wedding cake to fit our wedding theme and colors. It was beautiful and the Read more...
Icing on the top helped us create the perfect wedding cake to fit our wedding theme and colors. It was beautiful and the cake was absolutely delicious. Very moist and just the right consistency, We received tons of complements from our guests. Couldn't wait the full year to eat our cake top so we dug into at after our honeymoon and it still tasted awesome after being frozen! There were so many flavor options and combinations it was hard to choose since they all tasted wonderful! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Megan
Wedding:
3/1/2016
4.9/5.0
I tried several bakeries when selecting my cake. Icing on top was at the top of of the list the minute i walked into their store. They were very professional with the tasting and helpful with cake ideas. They have so many more options than the other places I was looking at and their cakes will leave you speechless. I would highly recommend them.
I tried several bakeries when selecting my cake. Icing on top was at the top of of the list the minute i walked into their Read more...
I tried several bakeries when selecting my cake. Icing on top was at the top of of the list the minute i walked into their store. They were very professional with the tasting and helpful with cake ideas. They have so many more options than the other places I was looking at and their cakes will leave you speechless. I would highly recommend them. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Laura
Wedding:
9/19/2015
5.0/5.0
"This is the best cake I have ever had in my life". That quote pretty much sums it up. Icing on the top did exactly what i requested, they were on time, affordable and the cake was so so good. Thank you icing on the top!!!
"This is the best cake I have ever had in my life". That quote pretty much sums it up. Icing on the top did exactly what i Read more...
"This is the best cake I have ever had in my life". That quote pretty much sums it up. Icing on the top did exactly what i requested, they were on time, affordable and the cake was so so good. Thank you icing on the top!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
5.0/5.0
We used Icing on the Top for a bridal cake AND a grooms cake. Both were a hit! Erin worked so hard to make sure my cake was exactly what I wanted - modeled after my dress, without the groom knowing it. She even helped me design a grooms cake for him as a surprise. My dad helped me build a cake stand that was larger than the dimensions Erin had planned for. She immediately let me know she would make sure everything fit and looked perfect.
In the end, my family raved about how yummy both cakes were; even a guest who "doesn't like cake" had 2 slices.
We used Icing on the Top for a bridal cake AND a grooms cake. Both were a hit! Erin worked so hard to make sure my cake Read more...
We used Icing on the Top for a bridal cake AND a grooms cake. Both were a hit! Erin worked so hard to make sure my cake was exactly what I wanted - modeled after my dress, without the groom knowing it. She even helped me design a grooms cake for him as a surprise. My dad helped me build a cake stand that was larger than the dimensions Erin had planned for. She immediately let me know she would make sure everything fit and looked perfect.
In the end, my family raved about how yummy both cakes were; even a guest who "doesn't like cake" had 2 slices. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake

MAP

 
1243 S. Harvard Ave., Tulsa, OK 74112 See On Map
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for Icing On The Top
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww logo
220x220 1352234296047 icingonthetoplogo