Nophoto 130

Island Sweet Stuff

St Thomas , VI

LOCATION

St Thomas, VI 00803 US
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Wedding Cake

REVIEWS

4.8
out of 5.0
4.7/5.0
4.8/5.0
4.8/5.0
4.7/5.0
4.8/5.0
Sort by
Default vendor profile pic
Carrie
Wedding:
11/8/2014
5.0/5.0
I have to say that wedding cakes are usually not that impressive but the cake at my wedding last weekend was by far the best cake I've ever had. Cynthia at Island Sweet Stuff did an amazing job and was super easy to work with. The cake was both beautiful to look at and so delicious. Many people went out of their way to tell me how good our cake was and that it was the best wedding cake they've ever had. We had 2 flavors: vanilla butter cream and red velvet and both of them were super moist and not overly sweet, everything was just right. I would highly recommend Island Sweet Stuff over any other bakery on the island. Thank you, Cynthia for creating the perfect wedding cake for us!
I have to say that wedding cakes are usually not that impressive but the cake at my wedding last weekend was by far the Read more...
I have to say that wedding cakes are usually not that impressive but the cake at my wedding last weekend was by far the best cake I've ever had. Cynthia at Island Sweet Stuff did an amazing job and was super easy to work with. The cake was both beautiful to look at and so delicious. Many people went out of their way to tell me how good our cake was and that it was the best wedding cake they've ever had. We had 2 flavors: vanilla butter cream and red velvet and both of them were super moist and not overly sweet, everything was just right. I would highly recommend Island Sweet Stuff over any other bakery on the island. Thank you, Cynthia for creating the perfect wedding cake for us! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Cece
Wedding:
10/17/2014
5.0/5.0
The cakes from Island Sweet Stuff are beautiful AND delicious. Cynthia provides great customer service and gives you plenty of options to choose from. Our guests loved the cupcakes that we ordered.
The cakes from Island Sweet Stuff are beautiful AND delicious. Cynthia provides great customer service and gives you Read more...
The cakes from Island Sweet Stuff are beautiful AND delicious. Cynthia provides great customer service and gives you plenty of options to choose from. Our guests loved the cupcakes that we ordered. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Ashley
Wedding:
10/4/2014
5.0/5.0
Cynthia at Island Sweet Stuff was so wonderful to work with for our wedding cake!

I initially sent my husband (then fiance) and my father-in-law down to St. Thomas to make final wedding arrangements. I sent them with a list and pictures of exactly what I wanted for the cake. They were so pleased with the service and help they received while they were down there, and the same service continued through email correspondence with me.

The cake was exactly what I envisioned and they were so accommodating about pick-up. She made the suggestion to use italian buttercream, as opposed to cream cheese, for our red velvet cake due to the warm climate and she was so right! Everyone raved that it was the best red velvet cake they had ever eaten, plus the cake withstood the entire night in an open air restaurant.

We loved our wedding cake and would definitely recommend Island Sweet Stuff!
Cynthia at Island Sweet Stuff was so wonderful to work with for our wedding cake!

I initially sent my husband Read more...
Cynthia at Island Sweet Stuff was so wonderful to work with for our wedding cake!

I initially sent my husband (then fiance) and my father-in-law down to St. Thomas to make final wedding arrangements. I sent them with a list and pictures of exactly what I wanted for the cake. They were so pleased with the service and help they received while they were down there, and the same service continued through email correspondence with me.

The cake was exactly what I envisioned and they were so accommodating about pick-up. She made the suggestion to use italian buttercream, as opposed to cream cheese, for our red velvet cake due to the warm climate and she was so right! Everyone raved that it was the best red velvet cake they had ever eaten, plus the cake withstood the entire night in an open air restaurant.

We loved our wedding cake and would definitely recommend Island Sweet Stuff! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Brandi
Wedding:
8/29/2014
2.0/5.0
What an embarrassment... I paid JUST under $10/cupcake for customized cupcakes to represent mine and my groom's fav college football teams... Wish I could post a pic!!! A 4 yr old could have done a better job! I was beyond embarrassed!!!! The pics on the website are beyond deceiving!
What an embarrassment... I paid JUST under $10/cupcake for customized cupcakes to represent mine and my groom's fav Read more...
What an embarrassment... I paid JUST under $10/cupcake for customized cupcakes to represent mine and my groom's fav college football teams... Wish I could post a pic!!! A 4 yr old could have done a better job! I was beyond embarrassed!!!! The pics on the website are beyond deceiving! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Elsa
Wedding:
6/28/2014
4.8/5.0
We selected Island Sweet Stuff based on a recommendation from our wedding coordinator. We were truly blown away by how great the cake tasted. Our guests said that this is the best wedding cake they ever had. I do not typically eat wedding cake but this one was truly amazing. So amazing that the next day we ate the the top tier which we had planned to freeze until our one year anniversary. Cynthia has so many flavors to choose from. We went with a vanilla chiffon cake, passion fruit filling and a vanilla icing, It was decorated with a blue ribbon (to match our wedding colors) and a monogram cake topper. It was absolutely beautiful and moist. I truly wish that I could have a piece of that cake while I am seating here writing this review. We will definitely order from Island Sweet Stuff again. Thank you Cynthia.
We selected Island Sweet Stuff based on a recommendation from our wedding coordinator. We were truly blown away by how Read more...
We selected Island Sweet Stuff based on a recommendation from our wedding coordinator. We were truly blown away by how great the cake tasted. Our guests said that this is the best wedding cake they ever had. I do not typically eat wedding cake but this one was truly amazing. So amazing that the next day we ate the the top tier which we had planned to freeze until our one year anniversary. Cynthia has so many flavors to choose from. We went with a vanilla chiffon cake, passion fruit filling and a vanilla icing, It was decorated with a blue ribbon (to match our wedding colors) and a monogram cake topper. It was absolutely beautiful and moist. I truly wish that I could have a piece of that cake while I am seating here writing this review. We will definitely order from Island Sweet Stuff again. Thank you Cynthia. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Stephanie
Wedding:
4/21/2014
5.0/5.0
So, so yummy! We selected Island Sweet stuff based on a recommendation from our wedding planner. The cake was the best we have ever tastes, no exaggeration. Cynthia has so many flavours that the combinations are pretty much endless. When it came down to that, we weren't really sure what we wanted - a lot of the flavours were much more exotic than what we were used to. We bounced ideas off of her, and she was very honest about what would work and what wouldn't. We had a two-tier cake - we ended up going with a tier of dark chocolate cake and a tier of red velvet cake, with coconut cream filling and an almond buttercream frosting. OMG, we still talk about it to this day, and so do our guests. The cake was so moist and flavourful. We are definitely getting something there when we return to St. Thomas!
So, so yummy! We selected Island Sweet stuff based on a recommendation from our wedding planner. The cake was the best we Read more...
So, so yummy! We selected Island Sweet stuff based on a recommendation from our wedding planner. The cake was the best we have ever tastes, no exaggeration. Cynthia has so many flavours that the combinations are pretty much endless. When it came down to that, we weren't really sure what we wanted - a lot of the flavours were much more exotic than what we were used to. We bounced ideas off of her, and she was very honest about what would work and what wouldn't. We had a two-tier cake - we ended up going with a tier of dark chocolate cake and a tier of red velvet cake, with coconut cream filling and an almond buttercream frosting. OMG, we still talk about it to this day, and so do our guests. The cake was so moist and flavourful. We are definitely getting something there when we return to St. Thomas! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Private User
Wedding:
4/9/2014
5.0/5.0
I was truly blown away for my wedding cake. Typically wedding cakes taste mediocre, but the cake Cynthia created was amazing!!! I have to say, one of the best cakes I've ever tasted. I had a traditional St. Thomian Vienna cake which is a vanilla cake with layers of guava, mango and pineapple jam and covered with buttercream frosting. I grew up on Vienna cakes and this one took it to another level. The cake was also beautifully decorated with fresh tropical flowers. Usually the couple saves the top layer for their one year anniversary, but my husband and I finished it within a week of the wedding...lol..My only disappointment is that I wish I had more! Thank you so much Cynthia!!!
I was truly blown away for my wedding cake. Typically wedding cakes taste mediocre, but the cake Cynthia created was Read more...
I was truly blown away for my wedding cake. Typically wedding cakes taste mediocre, but the cake Cynthia created was amazing!!! I have to say, one of the best cakes I've ever tasted. I had a traditional St. Thomian Vienna cake which is a vanilla cake with layers of guava, mango and pineapple jam and covered with buttercream frosting. I grew up on Vienna cakes and this one took it to another level. The cake was also beautifully decorated with fresh tropical flowers. Usually the couple saves the top layer for their one year anniversary, but my husband and I finished it within a week of the wedding...lol..My only disappointment is that I wish I had more! Thank you so much Cynthia!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Jennifer
Wedding:
2/9/2014
1.1/5.0
We ordered a specific cake, which we anticipated would be gorgeous and delicious, based on the previous reviews as well as the PRICE. Not only did we NOT receive the cake as ordered, or stated on the invoice, we received a cake which tasted horrendous. I was embarrassed to serve it to the guests we had present. Our wedding was extremely private, and small. We had a 6 inch cake on the bottom and a 4 inch on the top. Had the cake been made as ordered and per the invoice, as well as actually tasted like cake, we wouldn’t have minded paying $105.00.
However 105.00 for a cake which taste like cisco frosted cornbread was a disappointment.
We ordered a specific cake, which we anticipated would be gorgeous and delicious, based on the previous reviews as well as Read more...
We ordered a specific cake, which we anticipated would be gorgeous and delicious, based on the previous reviews as well as the PRICE. Not only did we NOT receive the cake as ordered, or stated on the invoice, we received a cake which tasted horrendous. I was embarrassed to serve it to the guests we had present. Our wedding was extremely private, and small. We had a 6 inch cake on the bottom and a 4 inch on the top. Had the cake been made as ordered and per the invoice, as well as actually tasted like cake, we wouldn’t have minded paying $105.00.
However 105.00 for a cake which taste like cisco frosted cornbread was a disappointment. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Ebonie
Wedding:
1/25/2014
5.0/5.0
Cynthia made my dream cake, if there is such a thing , it was exactly what I wanted. The cake gave the reception an extra touch, we didnt even want to cut it. It was extremely delicious and we would definitely use her again!!
Cynthia made my dream cake, if there is such a thing , it was exactly what I wanted. The cake gave the reception an extra Read more...
Cynthia made my dream cake, if there is such a thing , it was exactly what I wanted. The cake gave the reception an extra touch, we didnt even want to cut it. It was extremely delicious and we would definitely use her again!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Christy
Wedding:
1/14/2014
5.0/5.0
Cynthia was amazing! I was expecting two cakes when I told her my husband hates cake but she layered a nice cheesecake with chocolate cake. It was delicious and the turquoise with coral was so pretty!!
Cynthia was amazing! I was expecting two cakes when I told her my husband hates cake but she layered a nice cheesecake Read more...
Cynthia was amazing! I was expecting two cakes when I told her my husband hates cake but she layered a nice cheesecake with chocolate cake. It was delicious and the turquoise with coral was so pretty!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for Island Sweet Stuff
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww logo
 
Nophoto 220