130x130 sq 1374604552755 mag1004deconstructedweddingcake423

Magnolia Bakery

New York , NY
CONTACT US
CONTACT US

LOCATION

New York, NY 10023 US (map)

PHONE

212-724-8101

WEBSITE

View website
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.

ABOUT US

From its inception, Magnolia Bakery has been cherished for its classic American baked goods, vintage decor, and warm, inviting atmosphere. We feel it is our duty to provide you with the... Read more
From its inception, Magnolia Bakery has been cherished for its classic American baked goods, vintage decor, and warm, inviting atmosphere. We feel it is our duty to provide you with the best desserts and cakes or cupcakes for your special day! We pride ourselves on our friendly, knowledgable staff that will guide you through your order, answering any and all questions you might have along the way. Please contact us for more information or to book a consult today! Read less
Wedding Cake

PHOTOS

130x130 sq 1374600402925 mag1004deconstructedweddingcake94
130x130 sq 1374600409854 51
130x130 sq 1374600454608 2sdf
130x130 sq 1374600459325 46
130x130 sq 1374600465525 americatiffanyrosettecake
130x130 sq 1374600470423 central park 7
130x130 sq 1374600475757 img2521
130x130 sq 1374600481117 img2860
130x130 sq 1374600486227 mag1004deconstructedweddingcake31
130x130 sq 1374600491267 mag1004deconstructedweddingcake86
130x130 sq 1374600498437 packaged cookies
130x130 sq 1374600505468 photo 4
130x130 sq 1374600512118 photo 5
130x130 sq 1374600518192 photo 24
130x130 sq 1374600524139 rosette cake 1
130x130 sq 1374600529812 tuws11 67

INFO FOR WEDDING CAKE

Besides cakes, what other types of desserts do you provide?
Cookies, Cupcakes, Dessert Buffet
What additional services do you provide?
Consultations, On-site Delivery, On-site Setup, Pickup, Tastings
What dietary needs can you accommodate?
Gluten Free
Do you provide customary cakes, such as Croquembouche?
No
Are you licensed by the state health department?
Yes

REVIEWS

4.6
out of 5.0
4.6/5.0
4.6/5.0
4.6/5.0
4.7/5.0
4.5/5.0
Sort by
Default vendor profile pic
Harmony
Wedding:
9/25/2014
4.2/5.0
This review is for the Chicago based Magnolia Bakery on State Street.
I chose to use Magnolia Bakery to make my "wedding cake" for a Thursday afternoon wedding. I say wedding cake, but in actuality is was a 6inch one tier small cake to cut for our families, but not to share with the wedding. Magnolia did a fantastic job on the cake. I placed my order 2 month before the wedding, and brought in a color sample for them to match the ombré too. They did a fantastic job matching the color and the chocolate cake was delicious! My only gripe would be that I had originally set a pick up time of 10:30a and I called a few days before asking to change the time to earlier 9am, as my photographer had changed times, and was told that with an order of cake they couldn't. This I did not understand since it was a simple small cake and I was giving plenty of notice. The email response in the beginning was slow, but once the order was placed if I had a question they responded quickly.
This review is for the Chicago based Magnolia Bakery on State Street.
I chose to use Magnolia Bakery to make my Read more...
This review is for the Chicago based Magnolia Bakery on State Street.
I chose to use Magnolia Bakery to make my "wedding cake" for a Thursday afternoon wedding. I say wedding cake, but in actuality is was a 6inch one tier small cake to cut for our families, but not to share with the wedding. Magnolia did a fantastic job on the cake. I placed my order 2 month before the wedding, and brought in a color sample for them to match the ombré too. They did a fantastic job matching the color and the chocolate cake was delicious! My only gripe would be that I had originally set a pick up time of 10:30a and I called a few days before asking to change the time to earlier 9am, as my photographer had changed times, and was told that with an order of cake they couldn't. This I did not understand since it was a simple small cake and I was giving plenty of notice. The email response in the beginning was slow, but once the order was placed if I had a question they responded quickly. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
4.6/5.0
We absolutely adored our wedding cake from magnolia bakery. At times, the communication was a bit slow but on the day everything was so prefect. Cake was delivered directly to venue and magnolia bakery communicated directly with our venue to arrange times etc. 100 % recommend using magnolia for your wedding cake.
We absolutely adored our wedding cake from magnolia bakery. At times, the communication was a bit slow but on the day Read more...
We absolutely adored our wedding cake from magnolia bakery. At times, the communication was a bit slow but on the day everything was so prefect. Cake was delivered directly to venue and magnolia bakery communicated directly with our venue to arrange times etc. 100 % recommend using magnolia for your wedding cake. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Neil
Wedding:
7/12/2014
5.0/5.0
Our wedding cake turned out amazing and was delicious! Everyone that had the cake could not get enough of it, red velvet is the way to go. The cake looked beautiful!
Our wedding cake turned out amazing and was delicious! Everyone that had the cake could not get enough of it, red velvet Read more...
Our wedding cake turned out amazing and was delicious! Everyone that had the cake could not get enough of it, red velvet is the way to go. The cake looked beautiful! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130 sq 1403983805747 ry400 3
Lindsay
Wedding:
5/31/2014
5.0/5.0
People are still talking about our wedding cake! So... wedding cakes are WAY more expensive than I ever imagined. That being said, if I'm going to pay that kind of money, I want it to not only look good, but taste amazing! That's what you get with Magnolia. We had a New York wedding, so it seemed the obvious choice, and we weren't disappointed! It was beautiful- just what we had asked for, and tasted awesome! As far as using Magnolia as a vendor, I'd HIGHLY recommend them!
People are still talking about our wedding cake! So... wedding cakes are WAY more expensive than I ever imagined. That Read more...
People are still talking about our wedding cake! So... wedding cakes are WAY more expensive than I ever imagined. That being said, if I'm going to pay that kind of money, I want it to not only look good, but taste amazing! That's what you get with Magnolia. We had a New York wedding, so it seemed the obvious choice, and we weren't disappointed! It was beautiful- just what we had asked for, and tasted awesome! As far as using Magnolia as a vendor, I'd HIGHLY recommend them! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
3.8/5.0
So I went with Magnolia bakery for some mini cupcakes for our wedding. I feel like everyone knows what they are getting into with Magnolia taste wise so if you love their cakes/cupcakes/banana pudding (!!) then it's probably worth it.

HOWEVER, this vendor was the only vendor that gave me problems on my wedding day. The delivery man called my phone the day of and my bridesmaid had to talk to him for like ten minutes. He claimed that he could not drop off my cupcakes because I wasn't there to sign for them... My bridesmaid calmly told him about ten times that obviously I was not there because I was getting ready for my wedding. It was absolutely ridiculous.

Having said that, the cupcakes looked and tasted great. Just wish my cupcakes weren't the most stressful part of my wedding day.
So I went with Magnolia bakery for some mini cupcakes for our wedding. I feel like everyone knows what they are getting Read more...
So I went with Magnolia bakery for some mini cupcakes for our wedding. I feel like everyone knows what they are getting into with Magnolia taste wise so if you love their cakes/cupcakes/banana pudding (!!) then it's probably worth it.

HOWEVER, this vendor was the only vendor that gave me problems on my wedding day. The delivery man called my phone the day of and my bridesmaid had to talk to him for like ten minutes. He claimed that he could not drop off my cupcakes because I wasn't there to sign for them... My bridesmaid calmly told him about ten times that obviously I was not there because I was getting ready for my wedding. It was absolutely ridiculous.

Having said that, the cupcakes looked and tasted great. Just wish my cupcakes weren't the most stressful part of my wedding day. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
3.3/5.0
I ordered a three-layer six-inch cake, vanilla on vanilla. The icing was a beautiful Tiffany blue, with a white ribbon tied around it. The icing was shaped like a flower, at the bakery they call it the "chrysanthemum" design. It was gorgeous, and delicious, and it was only $75. However, when I first contacted the bakery (we used the one on 69th & Columbus) I was directed to speak to a woman named Delaney. I specifically mentioned in my email which cake flavors I was interested in (none of them vanilla) and I made sure to mention that I am severely allergic to chocolate. We scheduled a tasting, however when my husband and I got there we were made to wait over half an hour. Once Delaney came over, she did not even remember right away that we had an appointment. Once she brought out cupcakes for us to taste, four out of six of them had chocolate. When I reminded her that I am allergic to chocolate, she removed three and left the red velvet (which, working in a bakery, she should know still contains chocolate). We were unable to try the lemon or pistachio flavors, which we were most interested in, because she said she did not have them in cupcakes, only cake slices. I didn't understand why a cake slice couldn't be brought over, but we didn't put up a fuss about it and decided to go with the vanilla cupcake with vanilla frosting. Honestly, it was the best vanilla I have ever had. We absolutely loved it. So while our tasting experience was not all that great, we truly loved our cake and are happy we chose Magnolia for it.
I ordered a three-layer six-inch cake, vanilla on vanilla. The icing was a beautiful Tiffany blue, with a white ribbon Read more...
I ordered a three-layer six-inch cake, vanilla on vanilla. The icing was a beautiful Tiffany blue, with a white ribbon tied around it. The icing was shaped like a flower, at the bakery they call it the "chrysanthemum" design. It was gorgeous, and delicious, and it was only $75. However, when I first contacted the bakery (we used the one on 69th & Columbus) I was directed to speak to a woman named Delaney. I specifically mentioned in my email which cake flavors I was interested in (none of them vanilla) and I made sure to mention that I am severely allergic to chocolate. We scheduled a tasting, however when my husband and I got there we were made to wait over half an hour. Once Delaney came over, she did not even remember right away that we had an appointment. Once she brought out cupcakes for us to taste, four out of six of them had chocolate. When I reminded her that I am allergic to chocolate, she removed three and left the red velvet (which, working in a bakery, she should know still contains chocolate). We were unable to try the lemon or pistachio flavors, which we were most interested in, because she said she did not have them in cupcakes, only cake slices. I didn't understand why a cake slice couldn't be brought over, but we didn't put up a fuss about it and decided to go with the vanilla cupcake with vanilla frosting. Honestly, it was the best vanilla I have ever had. We absolutely loved it. So while our tasting experience was not all that great, we truly loved our cake and are happy we chose Magnolia for it. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bb12
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
5.0/5.0
Fantastic. Went out of their way to make a color they don't normally make. All for a small cake they didn't really make much margin on.
Fantastic. Went out of their way to make a color they don't normally make. All for a small cake they didn't really make Read more...
Fantastic. Went out of their way to make a color they don't normally make. All for a small cake they didn't really make much margin on. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Nicoletta
Wedding:
7/20/2013
5.0/5.0
Excellent quality wedding cake - and very tasty! Had many compliments about the red velvet...also was inexpensive and worth every bite!
Excellent quality wedding cake - and very tasty! Had many compliments about the red velvet...also was inexpensive and Read more...
Excellent quality wedding cake - and very tasty! Had many compliments about the red velvet...also was inexpensive and worth every bite! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Private User
Wedding:
5/24/2013
5.0/5.0
From the get-go I knew I wanted to have Magnolia as my wedding cake vendor as it is my Husband and my favorite bakery in New York City. I worked with Katie out of the Columbus Circle location and she was such a sweetie pie. We met for a tasting (even though I knew what everything tasted like already because I practically go there weekly) and she was so receptive to my ideas and helped with inspiration. She kept my budget in mind and really worked with me to make everything beautiful. We paid a little extra to have them decorate everything and put monograms on the cupcakes but it was totally worth it.
From the get-go I knew I wanted to have Magnolia as my wedding cake vendor as it is my Husband and my favorite bakery in Read more...
From the get-go I knew I wanted to have Magnolia as my wedding cake vendor as it is my Husband and my favorite bakery in New York City. I worked with Katie out of the Columbus Circle location and she was such a sweetie pie. We met for a tasting (even though I knew what everything tasted like already because I practically go there weekly) and she was so receptive to my ideas and helped with inspiration. She kept my budget in mind and really worked with me to make everything beautiful. We paid a little extra to have them decorate everything and put monograms on the cupcakes but it was totally worth it. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Jackie
Wedding:
1/12/2013
5.0/5.0
We worked with Lara during the whole planning process with Magnolia Bakery. She helped us make a deconstructed wedding cake that looked beautiful and wow'd our guests. She was super responsive in all emails and helped make recommendations with her input. The cakes looked beautiful and even more importantly, tasted great!
We worked with Lara during the whole planning process with Magnolia Bakery. She helped us make a deconstructed wedding Read more...
We worked with Lara during the whole planning process with Magnolia Bakery. She helped us make a deconstructed wedding cake that looked beautiful and wow'd our guests. She was super responsive in all emails and helped make recommendations with her input. The cakes looked beautiful and even more importantly, tasted great! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake

MAP

 
New York, NY 10023 See On Map
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for Magnolia Bakery
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww logo
 
220x220 1374604552755 mag1004deconstructedweddingcake423