130x130 sq 1358957101377 135895703852655.market7

Market Street Diner & Carl’s Cakes

Sun Prairie , WI
CONTACT US
CONTACT US

LOCATION

110 Market Street
Sun Prairie, WI 53590 US (map)

PHONE

608-825-3377

WEBSITE

View website
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.

ABOUT US

Market Street Diner offers an extensive catering menu with selections for everything from an intimate sit down dinner for 20 to your dream buffet for 300 of your closest friends and... Read more
Market Street Diner offers an extensive catering menu with selections for everything from an intimate sit down dinner for 20 to your dream buffet for 300 of your closest friends and family. Market Street Diner also offers a private dining room which can seat up to 30 people.

Carl's Cakes was founded by Carl Loeffel in 1985. In February 2009, Carl and his team relocated and became part of Market Street Diner and Bakery. Same great cakes, same talented staff, just a new, bigger location to provide even more cakes. Carl and his staff bring over 30 years of baking experience to the table when helping you plan your special cake, no matter your style of budget. Our exceptional cakes and buttercreams have made Carl's Cakes the most recommended cakes in the Madison area. Read less
Catering

PHOTOS

130x130 sq 1358957006710 538833297185fb8501a8z
130x130 sq 1358957012677 538833183965f1e5fa07b
130x130 sq 1358957019400 538833459123418ecc7fb
130x130 sq 1358957026618 538894118433a083d79db
130x130 sq 1358957033184 6071612910e82fe46ec8b
130x130 sq 1358957038526 55.market7
130x130 sq 1358957043760 55.market3
130x130 sq 1358957048503 55.market8

INFO FOR CATERING

What catering services do you provide?
Buffet, Cocktail Reception, Family Style, Hors d'oeuvres - Displayed, Hors d'oeuvres - Passed, Plated, Stations
What bar services do you provide?
Limited Bar
What alcohol services do you provide?
House Beer, House Wine
What types of cuisine do you cater?
American (New), American (Traditional)
Do you accommodate dietary needs?
No Pork, Vegan, Vegetarian
What is your maximum catering capacity?
400

REVIEWS

4.6
out of 5.0
4.5/5.0
4.6/5.0
4.5/5.0
4.8/5.0
4.5/5.0
Sort by
Default vendor profile pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
Best cake ever! Carl was very professional and made a fantastic cake. Everyone loved it. I would absolutely recommend Carl's Cakes!
Best cake ever! Carl was very professional and made a fantastic cake. Everyone loved it. I would absolutely recommend Read more...
Best cake ever! Carl was very professional and made a fantastic cake. Everyone loved it. I would absolutely recommend Carl's Cakes! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
4.6/5.0
The cake itself was perfect and delicious but I gave Carl's cakes a 4/5 due to communication. I had a tasting and signed the contract for our cake about ten months before our wedding and once it got closer I started contacting them with ideas of what I wanted. The first person I talked to sent me to talk to someone else who then kept guiding me back to the first person. It made it feel disorganized. They also tried to charge me again even though I had put a deposit down when I signed the contract. I had to tell them when and how much I paid. Then they looked back at their records and the cake ended up being cheaper than they originally had said (which was fine by me).
The cake itself was perfect and delicious but I gave Carl's cakes a 4/5 due to communication. I had a tasting and signed Read more...
The cake itself was perfect and delicious but I gave Carl's cakes a 4/5 due to communication. I had a tasting and signed the contract for our cake about ten months before our wedding and once it got closer I started contacting them with ideas of what I wanted. The first person I talked to sent me to talk to someone else who then kept guiding me back to the first person. It made it feel disorganized. They also tried to charge me again even though I had put a deposit down when I signed the contract. I had to tell them when and how much I paid. Then they looked back at their records and the cake ended up being cheaper than they originally had said (which was fine by me). Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Jean
Wedding:
11/1/2014
4.4/5.0
The cakes were delicious! I ordered three sheet cakes instead of a standard wedding cake so we could offer lots of options. The cake got rave reviews all around, especially the carrot!
The cakes were delicious! I ordered three sheet cakes instead of a standard wedding cake so we could offer lots of Read more...
The cakes were delicious! I ordered three sheet cakes instead of a standard wedding cake so we could offer lots of options. The cake got rave reviews all around, especially the carrot! Read less
Services Used: Catering
130x130 sq 1373639031452 apple
CandyApple
Wedding:
8/9/2014
4.7/5.0
We wanted to have different options of cake for every table & Carl was able to provide that to us at a cost that was more reasonable then anywhere else local to our area. We had a small two tiered wedding cake & then single cakes & cheesecakes at each guests table. (We also had fruit pizza from a different vendor). Carl's cakes are much better than Craig's in Verona. And the cake tastes delicious! Competitive prices + great tasting cake = BONUS!!! We had a separate catering vendor, but discounts are given if food & cake are purchased for the same event from Market Street Diner. My only complaint is that the cakes had cracks down the sides of them which gave me the impression that they were either baked too soon or maybe sat out too long before being brought to our event. We had an air conditioned venue in Poynette. Regardless, I would choose this vendor again & again! Thank you!
We wanted to have different options of cake for every table & Carl was able to provide that to us at a cost that was more Read more...
We wanted to have different options of cake for every table & Carl was able to provide that to us at a cost that was more reasonable then anywhere else local to our area. We had a small two tiered wedding cake & then single cakes & cheesecakes at each guests table. (We also had fruit pizza from a different vendor). Carl's cakes are much better than Craig's in Verona. And the cake tastes delicious! Competitive prices + great tasting cake = BONUS!!! We had a separate catering vendor, but discounts are given if food & cake are purchased for the same event from Market Street Diner. My only complaint is that the cakes had cracks down the sides of them which gave me the impression that they were either baked too soon or maybe sat out too long before being brought to our event. We had an air conditioned venue in Poynette. Regardless, I would choose this vendor again & again! Thank you! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Private User
Wedding:
8/8/2014
4.5/5.0
Carl's Cakes are absolutely fabulous! We selected the yellow cake with raspberry filling and all of our guests loved it! We had a wedding beach theme and brought pictures to help the baker create our cake. The only downfall is that I had to provide the candy shells to put on the cake as the bakery wouldn't make them there even if I supplied all the candy and molds.
Carl's Cakes are absolutely fabulous! We selected the yellow cake with raspberry filling and all of our guests loved it! Read more...
Carl's Cakes are absolutely fabulous! We selected the yellow cake with raspberry filling and all of our guests loved it! We had a wedding beach theme and brought pictures to help the baker create our cake. The only downfall is that I had to provide the candy shells to put on the cake as the bakery wouldn't make them there even if I supplied all the candy and molds. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Kara
Wedding:
6/28/2014
4.8/5.0
We worked with Jamie on our catering needs for our wedding and she was awesome! Super helpful and very quick responses. The prices for the meals were very reasonable and the service was great at the wedding. Even though I didn't really eat at the wedding (too much excitement!) the few bites I had were delicious. The guests seemed to love it - we got lots of complements. I removed one star because our wedding cake didn't look like the photo we had sent them, but it was still nice (just verrrrrry plain).
We worked with Jamie on our catering needs for our wedding and she was awesome! Super helpful and very quick responses. Read more...
We worked with Jamie on our catering needs for our wedding and she was awesome! Super helpful and very quick responses. The prices for the meals were very reasonable and the service was great at the wedding. Even though I didn't really eat at the wedding (too much excitement!) the few bites I had were delicious. The guests seemed to love it - we got lots of complements. I removed one star because our wedding cake didn't look like the photo we had sent them, but it was still nice (just verrrrrry plain). Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake, Catering
Default vendor profile pic
james
Wedding:
9/28/2013
5.0/5.0
We were very happy with Carl. We went in with a small budget for our cake. We told him our budget and numbers and he made it work. We chose him after several tastings. We wanted just a white cake with buttercream frosting and his was the best around.
We were very happy with Carl. We went in with a small budget for our cake. We told him our budget and numbers and he made Read more...
We were very happy with Carl. We went in with a small budget for our cake. We told him our budget and numbers and he made it work. We chose him after several tastings. We wanted just a white cake with buttercream frosting and his was the best around. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Jennifer
Wedding:
9/27/2013
5.0/5.0
Best, most beautiful cake I could have asked for!
Best, most beautiful cake I could have asked for!
Best, most beautiful cake I could have asked for! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Jessica
Wedding:
8/17/2013
5.0/5.0
Carl's Cakes was the best. I had family telling me it was the best wedding cake that they have ever had. I would use them again for all of my events that take place from birthdays to baby showers. Yumm!
Carl's Cakes was the best. I had family telling me it was the best wedding cake that they have ever had. I would use them Read more...
Carl's Cakes was the best. I had family telling me it was the best wedding cake that they have ever had. I would use them again for all of my events that take place from birthdays to baby showers. Yumm! Read less
Services Used: Catering
Default vendor profile pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
4.0/5.0
We went with Carl because we had a coupon through our wedding venue that allowed us to get our wedding cake at 10% off and free delivery. We did do a cake tasting and his cake was delicious so we really just couldn't pass up the good deal. Overall we were very pleased with our cake, but it took some convincing on our part to get the cake we really wanted. We really wanted lime green accents on our cake and initially Carl said that would be feasible. Once we actually paid our deposit and went back to design our cake, he no longer wanted to do the green as it would likely bleed into the white. We held our ground and he eventually agreed to do it, but made it very clear that he wasn't going to be held responsible if it bled. Overall, the cake turned out beautiful (with no color bleeding at all) and I would say that Carl was overall easy to work with and helpful. I think he really does just want his cake to turn out the best it possibly can.
We went with Carl because we had a coupon through our wedding venue that allowed us to get our wedding cake at 10% off and Read more...
We went with Carl because we had a coupon through our wedding venue that allowed us to get our wedding cake at 10% off and free delivery. We did do a cake tasting and his cake was delicious so we really just couldn't pass up the good deal. Overall we were very pleased with our cake, but it took some convincing on our part to get the cake we really wanted. We really wanted lime green accents on our cake and initially Carl said that would be feasible. Once we actually paid our deposit and went back to design our cake, he no longer wanted to do the green as it would likely bleed into the white. We held our ground and he eventually agreed to do it, but made it very clear that he wasn't going to be held responsible if it bled. Overall, the cake turned out beautiful (with no color bleeding at all) and I would say that Carl was overall easy to work with and helpful. I think he really does just want his cake to turn out the best it possibly can. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake

MAP

 
110 Market Street, Sun Prairie, WI 53590 See On Map
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for Market Street Diner & Carl’s Cakes
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww logo
 
220x220 1358957101377 135895703852655.market7