130x130 sq 1358957101377 135895703852655.market7

Market Street Diner & Carl’s Cakes

Sun Prairie , WI
CONTACT US
CONTACT US

LOCATION

110 Market Street
Sun Prairie, WI 53590 US (map)

PHONE

608-825-3377

WEBSITE

View website
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.

ABOUT US

Market Street Diner offers an extensive catering menu with selections for everything from an intimate sit down dinner for 20 to your dream buffet for 300 of your closest friends and... Read more
Market Street Diner offers an extensive catering menu with selections for everything from an intimate sit down dinner for 20 to your dream buffet for 300 of your closest friends and family. Market Street Diner also offers a private dining room which can seat up to 30 people.

Carl's Cakes was founded by Carl Loeffel in 1985. In February 2009, Carl and his team relocated and became part of Market Street Diner and Bakery. Same great cakes, same talented staff, just a new, bigger location to provide even more cakes. Carl and his staff bring over 30 years of baking experience to the table when helping you plan your special cake, no matter your style of budget. Our exceptional cakes and buttercreams have made Carl's Cakes the most recommended cakes in the Madison area. Read less
Catering

PHOTOS

130x130 sq 1358957006710 538833297185fb8501a8z
130x130 sq 1358957012677 538833183965f1e5fa07b
130x130 sq 1358957019400 538833459123418ecc7fb
130x130 sq 1358957026618 538894118433a083d79db
130x130 sq 1358957033184 6071612910e82fe46ec8b
130x130 sq 1358957038526 55.market7
130x130 sq 1358957043760 55.market3
130x130 sq 1358957048503 55.market8

INFO FOR CATERING

What catering services do you provide?
Buffet, Cocktail Reception, Family Style, Hors d'oeuvres, Plated, Stations
What types of cuisine do you cater?
American
What dietary needs can you accommodate?
No Pork, Vegan, Vegetarian
What bar services do you provide?
House Beer, House Wine

REVIEWS

4.7
out of 5.0
4.6/5.0
4.6/5.0
4.6/5.0
4.8/5.0
4.6/5.0
Sort by
Default vendor profile pic
Mikaela
Wedding:
10/8/2016
5.0/5.0
What can we say – when we were shopping around for prices, Carl’s Cakes was both higher rated and lower cost than the other options! Carl is a great guy, really easy to work with, and definitely a master of his profession. The cake flavors themselves are very delicious. We picked chocolate raspberry and apricot hazelnut, and got a lot of compliments from our guests on both flavors. The cake was just beautiful, and we were really pleased with our overall experience with Carl’s Cakes!
What can we say – when we were shopping around for prices, Carl’s Cakes was both higher rated and lower cost than the Read more...
What can we say – when we were shopping around for prices, Carl’s Cakes was both higher rated and lower cost than the other options! Carl is a great guy, really easy to work with, and definitely a master of his profession. The cake flavors themselves are very delicious. We picked chocolate raspberry and apricot hazelnut, and got a lot of compliments from our guests on both flavors. The cake was just beautiful, and we were really pleased with our overall experience with Carl’s Cakes! Read less
Services Used: Catering
Default vendor profile pic
Leah
Wedding:
7/10/2016
5.0/5.0
My wedding cake was absolutely beautiful! We had a 4 tiered cake a simple white frosting. It was decorated with a blue ribbon that I had embellished with sparkles. Our cake topper was an elegant music symbol to match the ribbon and it was all put together perfectly! I wish I had a picture to share - we got so many compliments! And it was also delicious! In fact, we only had 1 extra slice at the end of the evening and our cake was plenty big enough for our number of guests! Our cake was also delivered about 35 miles outside of the Madison area and Carl was so fun to work with. I highly recommend Carl's Cakes!
My wedding cake was absolutely beautiful! We had a 4 tiered cake a simple white frosting. It was decorated with a blue Read more...
My wedding cake was absolutely beautiful! We had a 4 tiered cake a simple white frosting. It was decorated with a blue ribbon that I had embellished with sparkles. Our cake topper was an elegant music symbol to match the ribbon and it was all put together perfectly! I wish I had a picture to share - we got so many compliments! And it was also delicious! In fact, we only had 1 extra slice at the end of the evening and our cake was plenty big enough for our number of guests! Our cake was also delivered about 35 miles outside of the Madison area and Carl was so fun to work with. I highly recommend Carl's Cakes! Read less
Services Used: Catering
Default vendor profile pic
Abigail
Wedding:
7/10/2016
5.0/5.0
Carl was super friendly and great to work with. The cake tasted amazing - we went with lemon and raspberry and a layer of chocolate and raspberry. Sooooo delicious and very moist. Everything went without a single hitch.
Carl was super friendly and great to work with. The cake tasted amazing - we went with lemon and raspberry and a layer of Read more...
Carl was super friendly and great to work with. The cake tasted amazing - we went with lemon and raspberry and a layer of chocolate and raspberry. Sooooo delicious and very moist. Everything went without a single hitch. Read less
Services Used: Catering
Default vendor profile pic
Private User
Wedding:
5/7/2016
5.0/5.0
Carl's Cakes are the BEST. We had a lot of delicious options and ended up going with the vanilla raspberry and chocolate raspberry. It is a delicious cake that leaves a very clean (non-filmy) feeling in your mouth. The cake was beautiful, delivery went off without a hitch, and Carl is an absolute pleasure to work with!
Carl's Cakes are the BEST. We had a lot of delicious options and ended up going with the vanilla raspberry and chocolate Read more...
Carl's Cakes are the BEST. We had a lot of delicious options and ended up going with the vanilla raspberry and chocolate raspberry. It is a delicious cake that leaves a very clean (non-filmy) feeling in your mouth. The cake was beautiful, delivery went off without a hitch, and Carl is an absolute pleasure to work with! Read less
Services Used: Catering
Default vendor profile pic
Princess
Wedding:
11/14/2015
3.8/5.0
We wanted a simple cake that complemented our cake topper. Carl designed a simple yet elegant 3-tier cake. We loved the flavor options. The cake was beautiful.
We wanted a simple cake that complemented our cake topper. Carl designed a simple yet elegant 3-tier cake. We loved the Read more...
We wanted a simple cake that complemented our cake topper. Carl designed a simple yet elegant 3-tier cake. We loved the flavor options. The cake was beautiful. Read less
Services Used: Catering
Default vendor profile pic
Megan
Wedding:
10/2/2015
5.0/5.0
Carl's cakes did our wedding cake and it was amazing! Not only did it taste great but looked great too :) Couldn't have been happier!
Carl's cakes did our wedding cake and it was amazing! Not only did it taste great but looked great too :) Couldn't have Read more...
Carl's cakes did our wedding cake and it was amazing! Not only did it taste great but looked great too :) Couldn't have been happier! Read less
Services Used: Catering
130x130 sq 1404402241 962ac3a98424fdd9 kaylee kimberly seaton
Kimberly
Wedding:
8/22/2015
5.0/5.0
Great tasting cake and upfront and clear about pricing. Cake turned out exactly how I wanted it. Responsive to email.
Great tasting cake and upfront and clear about pricing. Cake turned out exactly how I wanted it. Responsive to email.
Great tasting cake and upfront and clear about pricing. Cake turned out exactly how I wanted it. Responsive to email. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Jackson
Wedding:
5/16/2015
5.0/5.0
Save yourself the time and energy and just go with Carl's Cakes. They were half as much as the competition and twice the taste. It still sounds too good to be true and our wedding is already over and everyone was impressed with the cake. Even the original Carl cake maker delivered our cakes. Overly impressed with what we received. By far the best value out there for your cake needs.
Save yourself the time and energy and just go with Carl's Cakes. They were half as much as the competition and twice the Read more...
Save yourself the time and energy and just go with Carl's Cakes. They were half as much as the competition and twice the taste. It still sounds too good to be true and our wedding is already over and everyone was impressed with the cake. Even the original Carl cake maker delivered our cakes. Overly impressed with what we received. By far the best value out there for your cake needs. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Jean
Wedding:
11/1/2014
4.4/5.0
The cakes were delicious! I ordered three sheet cakes instead of a standard wedding cake so we could offer lots of options. The cake got rave reviews all around, especially the carrot!
The cakes were delicious! I ordered three sheet cakes instead of a standard wedding cake so we could offer lots of Read more...
The cakes were delicious! I ordered three sheet cakes instead of a standard wedding cake so we could offer lots of options. The cake got rave reviews all around, especially the carrot! Read less
Services Used: Catering
Default vendor profile pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
4.8/5.0
Loved that they came and grilled on sight and was able to take leftovers.
Loved that they came and grilled on sight and was able to take leftovers.
Loved that they came and grilled on sight and was able to take leftovers. Read less
Services Used: Catering

MAP

 
110 Market Street, Sun Prairie, WI 53590 See On Map
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for Market Street Diner & Carl’s Cakes
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww logo
220x220 1358957101377 135895703852655.market7