130x130_sq_1392584766862-2013-11-2214-51-4
(8)

Nicole's Catering

Westerville , OH

LOCATION

558 West Schrock Rd
Westerville, OH US 43081 (map)
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Catering

REVIEWS

5.0
out of 5.0
4.9/5.0
4.9/5.0
5.0/5.0
5.0/5.0
5.0/5.0
Sort by
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Morgan
Wedding:
5/24/2014
5.0/5.0
I was planning my wedding from out of state, so having a caterer that was flexible and full service was a much needed relief of planning stress! Nicole and Dale were perfect! They took care of everything and then some! The food was great and they were very accomodating to allergies and vegetarian/vegan guests that were at our wedding.

They even came up with some great touches that made our wedding unique and even more perfect. My now husband and I are sort of beer snobs and I wanted us to have our own 6-pack of our favorite beer behind the bar. Dale went above and beyond and suggested we have our own cooler at our table just for us and our beer! It was perfect and my husband loved it!

I could not say anything negative about my experience working with Nicole's, they were great and their services are at such a value you cannot pass them up!!
I was planning my wedding from out of state, so having a caterer that was flexible and full service was a much needed Read more...
I was planning my wedding from out of state, so having a caterer that was flexible and full service was a much needed relief of planning stress! Nicole and Dale were perfect! They took care of everything and then some! The food was great and they were very accomodating to allergies and vegetarian/vegan guests that were at our wedding.

They even came up with some great touches that made our wedding unique and even more perfect. My now husband and I are sort of beer snobs and I wanted us to have our own 6-pack of our favorite beer behind the bar. Dale went above and beyond and suggested we have our own cooler at our table just for us and our beer! It was perfect and my husband loved it!

I could not say anything negative about my experience working with Nicole's, they were great and their services are at such a value you cannot pass them up!! Read less
Services Used: Catering
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
4.9/5.0
Nicole and Dale are absolutely amazing people. They are so nice and helpful. We hosted my bridal shower at their actual shop and it was great.

In regards to the wedding FOOD-- great! The Steak Merlot was amazing, and the herb chicken was pretty good, but it was hard to rival with the steak. ALL of her side dishes are amazing, and if it was up to me, we would have been eating an assortment of pasta salad, green beans and potatoes in all fashions...but that is not acceptable unfortunately. The servers were so nice, and I didn't hear any complaints about speed of lines etc.

Nicole is great about budgets. 1.She will work with you and not try to sell you something out of your league. 2. If she sees a way she could charge you less, she will. 3.She offers specials some months. Nicole handles your rentals. This was so nice because it was one less vendor. 5.her prices, are just reasonable!

During all the planning process it was fairly easy to get a hold of someone, but as it came closer to the wedding (and wedding season in general) it seemed as though there was some lack of communication between all three of us. However, everything was sorted out quickly and turned out great! I would suggest to create a list of questions as it nears the wedding to make it easier for both sides.

Finally they were so flexible with payments, and changes. They did not give me a hassle on anything.

Suggestions: If you are having signature drinks, or vegetarian meals(buffet) inform your guests with signs/verbal communication. Many people did not know I had a punch, but I also made it last minute and did not have a sign for our signature drink. I had a buffet and Nicole made separate veg meals for the number I indicated, thus they were not put out. Those guests were not aware that they just had to ask the staff for them, but everyone ate, and it was delicious!!
Nicole and Dale are absolutely amazing people. They are so nice and helpful. We hosted my bridal shower at their actual Read more...
Nicole and Dale are absolutely amazing people. They are so nice and helpful. We hosted my bridal shower at their actual shop and it was great.

In regards to the wedding FOOD-- great! The Steak Merlot was amazing, and the herb chicken was pretty good, but it was hard to rival with the steak. ALL of her side dishes are amazing, and if it was up to me, we would have been eating an assortment of pasta salad, green beans and potatoes in all fashions...but that is not acceptable unfortunately. The servers were so nice, and I didn't hear any complaints about speed of lines etc.

Nicole is great about budgets. 1.She will work with you and not try to sell you something out of your league. 2. If she sees a way she could charge you less, she will. 3.She offers specials some months. Nicole handles your rentals. This was so nice because it was one less vendor. 5.her prices, are just reasonable!

During all the planning process it was fairly easy to get a hold of someone, but as it came closer to the wedding (and wedding season in general) it seemed as though there was some lack of communication between all three of us. However, everything was sorted out quickly and turned out great! I would suggest to create a list of questions as it nears the wedding to make it easier for both sides.

Finally they were so flexible with payments, and changes. They did not give me a hassle on anything.

Suggestions: If you are having signature drinks, or vegetarian meals(buffet) inform your guests with signs/verbal communication. Many people did not know I had a punch, but I also made it last minute and did not have a sign for our signature drink. I had a buffet and Nicole made separate veg meals for the number I indicated, thus they were not put out. Those guests were not aware that they just had to ask the staff for them, but everyone ate, and it was delicious!! Read less
Services Used: Catering
130x130_sq_1375028625823-engagment-4
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
I would highly recommend this caterer to anyone. Nicole is very professional. She actually did both our rehearsal dinner and our reception. Her pricing is completely reasonable, actually better than most in the area and her food is amazing! My husband has an allergy and they were very accommodating and made something special for him to eat.
I would highly recommend this caterer to anyone. Nicole is very professional. She actually did both our rehearsal dinner Read more...
I would highly recommend this caterer to anyone. Nicole is very professional. She actually did both our rehearsal dinner and our reception. Her pricing is completely reasonable, actually better than most in the area and her food is amazing! My husband has an allergy and they were very accommodating and made something special for him to eat. Read less
Services Used: Catering
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lisa
Wedding:
12/28/2013
5.0/5.0
Nicole's was SO wonderful for our daughters wedding. She was on a caterers list provided by the city and we called her about 4th or 5th. She KILLED the others in terms of price and what she provided. Her packages included all the extras that the other caterers did not offer or had them as add ons that nickeled and dimed their prices so high. It was all part of what Nicole offered for one price.
Ok, probably one of the best parts of having Nicole and her wonderful team cater is that the food tasted so amazing!!!!! Before the wedding, she had my daughter and I come and taste some selections from their menu which was a nice touch.
The food was so good! It was presented well and the service was excellent!. So many people commented, including the photographer who said he's eaten plenty of rubber chicken at other peoples weddings. Not so with Nicole!
I am so glad that we found her! They were helpful in so many ways and in making our daughters wedding a complete success! Everything really turned out well and Nicole and her team were a HUGE part of it!
Nicole's was SO wonderful for our daughters wedding. She was on a caterers list provided by the city and we called her Read more...
Nicole's was SO wonderful for our daughters wedding. She was on a caterers list provided by the city and we called her about 4th or 5th. She KILLED the others in terms of price and what she provided. Her packages included all the extras that the other caterers did not offer or had them as add ons that nickeled and dimed their prices so high. It was all part of what Nicole offered for one price.
Ok, probably one of the best parts of having Nicole and her wonderful team cater is that the food tasted so amazing!!!!! Before the wedding, she had my daughter and I come and taste some selections from their menu which was a nice touch.
The food was so good! It was presented well and the service was excellent!. So many people commented, including the photographer who said he's eaten plenty of rubber chicken at other peoples weddings. Not so with Nicole!
I am so glad that we found her! They were helpful in so many ways and in making our daughters wedding a complete success! Everything really turned out well and Nicole and her team were a HUGE part of it! Read less
Services Used: Catering
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
5.0/5.0
Had Nicole's Catering for a 4th of July/Birthday party at our house with 80+ people. She managed our bar and food and we loved everything! The bartender was great and never stopped pouring and the food was delicious and had a great display!!
Had Nicole's Catering for a 4th of July/Birthday party at our house with 80+ people. She managed our bar and food and we Read more...
Had Nicole's Catering for a 4th of July/Birthday party at our house with 80+ people. She managed our bar and food and we loved everything! The bartender was great and never stopped pouring and the food was delicious and had a great display!! Read less
Services Used: Catering
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
4.9/5.0
Nicole's Catering was an awesome choice. My husband and I decided to have a vegetarian reception (I'm vegetarian, but he's not). Lots of our friends and family were bummed when they found out that we weren't having meat; after the wedding, though, so many people complimented us on the food (I even got a "I'd be a vegetarian too, if I could have food like that all the time!"). Nicole was VERY flexible - even making a recipe at our request.

She didn't initially impress me as much as a few of the other caterers we met with, but the food at the initial tasting was really great. As time went on, I was really glad that I chose Nicole's - Nicole and her staff were really incredible: very kind, patient, and professional.

The only thing that disappointed me was that I wanted more of the leftovers; we only got one peice of cake between us, and most of the leftover hot food (there was about 3 lbs. of cheese, olive tapinade, pretzels, etc.) There was also a lot of leftover cake (my favorite!), so I was bummed to hear that it was trashed. I don't fault Nicole's for this - I probably wasn't clear (but fair warning: ask for ALL the leftovers, if you want them!). All in all, I think this is an EXTREMELY minor miscommunication, and I would highly recommend Nicole's Catering!
Nicole's Catering was an awesome choice. My husband and I decided to have a vegetarian reception (I'm vegetarian, but he's Read more...
Nicole's Catering was an awesome choice. My husband and I decided to have a vegetarian reception (I'm vegetarian, but he's not). Lots of our friends and family were bummed when they found out that we weren't having meat; after the wedding, though, so many people complimented us on the food (I even got a "I'd be a vegetarian too, if I could have food like that all the time!"). Nicole was VERY flexible - even making a recipe at our request.

She didn't initially impress me as much as a few of the other caterers we met with, but the food at the initial tasting was really great. As time went on, I was really glad that I chose Nicole's - Nicole and her staff were really incredible: very kind, patient, and professional.

The only thing that disappointed me was that I wanted more of the leftovers; we only got one peice of cake between us, and most of the leftover hot food (there was about 3 lbs. of cheese, olive tapinade, pretzels, etc.) There was also a lot of leftover cake (my favorite!), so I was bummed to hear that it was trashed. I don't fault Nicole's for this - I probably wasn't clear (but fair warning: ask for ALL the leftovers, if you want them!). All in all, I think this is an EXTREMELY minor miscommunication, and I would highly recommend Nicole's Catering! Read less
Services Used: Catering
Default-vendor-profile-pic
cpitts555
Wedding:
10/9/2010
5.0/5.0
Nicole was great to work with! She helped us find the best package for our needs and budget. Nicole and her staff are very professional and very easy to work with. The food was great too! We had many compliments from our guests about the food. Thanks Nicole!
Nicole was great to work with! She helped us find the best package for our needs and budget. Nicole and her staff are very Read more...
Nicole was great to work with! She helped us find the best package for our needs and budget. Nicole and her staff are very professional and very easy to work with. The food was great too! We had many compliments from our guests about the food. Thanks Nicole! Read less
Services Used: Catering
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
5.0/5.0
Nicole is so friendly and so helpful! She knows what she is doing and our event was delicious and a success because of her. She also is happy to help with many thing outside of catering...if you have a question just ask her. Nicole is a wonderful person and her business reflects that.
Nicole is so friendly and so helpful! She knows what she is doing and our event was delicious and a success because of Read more...
Nicole is so friendly and so helpful! She knows what she is doing and our event was delicious and a success because of her. She also is happy to help with many thing outside of catering...if you have a question just ask her. Nicole is a wonderful person and her business reflects that. Read less
Services Used: Catering
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for Nicole's Catering
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww_logo
 
220x220_1392584766862-2013-11-2214-51-4