130x130_sq_1278952373824-0502copy

Olde Mill Inn

Basking Ridge , NJ
CONTACT US
CONTACT US

LOCATION

225 U.S. 202
Basking Ridge, NJ US 07920 (map)

PHONE

908-696-2315

WEBSITE

View website
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.

ABOUT US

The Olde Mill Inn is the only venue of its kind, offering an Historic setting in an 18th century Grain House for an intimate size wedding or a Grand Ballroom for a more elaborate affair.... Read more
The Olde Mill Inn is the only venue of its kind, offering an Historic setting in an 18th century Grain House for an intimate size wedding or a Grand Ballroom for a more elaborate affair. Only the Olde Mill Inn can offer you an elegant Inn and historic restaurant with full catering facilities nestled on a 10 acre estate providing the picture perfect setting and ambiance for the wedding of your dreams.


The Grand Washington Ballroom at the Olde Mill Inn with stonewall terrace, English gardens and gazebo comfortably accommodates your wedding up to 240 guests with a beautiful hardwood dancefloor. A wall of French doors open to the beautiful English garden setting perfect for an outdoor ceremony or your cocktail hour.


The Hunt Room at the Grain House is the picture perfect setting for an Intimate Size Wedding accommodating up to 120 guests. An elegantly styled split level room with fireplace all adorned by its Historic 18th century charm offering a unique setting for your wedding with meandering stream, gazebo, and a spacious seasonal tented patio with quaint country gardens for cocktail hour or an outdoor ceremony. Read less

PHOTOS

130x130_sq_1268340024051-brideflowergirlbyomisign
130x130_sq_1268340053130-lightimpressionsphotography0329
130x130_sq_1303400487194-formalsoldmill0026
130x130_sq_1268340685458-1000649
130x130_sq_1303400866850-152041129
130x130_sq_1357364756061-web0042
130x130_sq_1357364875138-22fallbrideinwindowattheoldemillinnbaskingridge
130x130_sq_1360865747530-brideonthestairsatourhotel
130x130_sq_1357363238091-0213
130x130_sq_1357526246453-0475
130x130_sq_1360865632330-img9822credittoeloquentstudios2
130x130_sq_1357527035138-web9663
130x130_sq_1357363365742-autumnweddingjohnarcara
130x130_sq_1357363416742-img05
130x130_sq_1357363672017-webimg7554
130x130_sq_1357364801593-web0504
130x130_sq_1357526987235-webcourtyardrobkneller
130x130_sq_1357364196170-webrobknellerportraitdesign
130x130_sq_1357526943570-web0445
130x130_sq_1357363964025-weblightimpressionsphotography0234
130x130_sq_1357526896642-web00585
130x130_sq_1360865881347-brideflowergirlbyomisign
130x130_sq_1360866015653-elitephotographers056
130x130_sq_1357368636016-huntroom
130x130_sq_1357369003692-slide3
130x130_sq_1357368571950-ej66
130x130_sq_1357368464810-tentweddingkrisrupp
130x130_sq_1357368618272-huntroom2
130x130_sq_1357368898790-grainhousegazeboceremony
130x130_sq_1357368840694-grainhousegazebo
130x130_sq_1357368416123-sharonsweddingartne0235
130x130_sq_1357368316873-omiweddingsgallerystephentaylor.com2
130x130_sq_1357368364773-sharonsweddingartne0473
130x130_sq_1357369435177-webej125
130x130_sq_1357368815177-grainhousedeck
130x130_sq_1357368951574-huntroom
130x130_sq_1360863680589-ej150
130x130_sq_1357369323912-webej131
130x130_sq_1357527536794-huntroomst2
130x130_sq_1357527462422-brideandgroomwithchipmunk
130x130_sq_1357837974279-test
130x130_sq_1360863770644-ej157

INFO FOR WEDDING VENUE

When was your venue built?
1930
When was your venue last renovated?
2013
Describe your venue:
Historic Site, Hotel, Inn / Bed & Breakfast
Describe the style of your venue
Classic / Traditional, Garden / Romantic, Rustic
What wedding services does your venue provide?
Bridal Shower, Ceremony, Engagement Party, Reception
What is the maximum capacity of your venue?
240
How many event spaces or rooms does your venue offer?
2
Does your venue offer an indoor space?
Yes
Does your venue offer a covered outdoor space?
Yes
Does your venue offer an uncovered outdoor space?
Yes
Does your venue have on-site accommodations?
Yes
Number of guest rooms
102
Number of suites
2
What is the minimum rental fee for your venue?
0
Bar Service
Offered in-house
Is bar service included in the minimum rental fee?
No
Beverage Service
Offered in-house
Is beverage service included in the minimum rental fee?
No
Catering
Offered in-house, Outside vendors welcome
Is catering included in the minimum rental fee?
No
What is the average catering price per person at your venue?
120
Event Coordination
Offered in-house
Is event coordination included in the minimum rental fee?
Yes
Event Rentals
Offered in-house
Are event rentals included in the minimum rental fee?
No
Lighting and Sound
Offered in-house
Are lighting and sound included in the minimum rental fee?
No
Linens
Offered in-house
Are linens included in the minimum rental fee?
Yes
Seating
Offered in-house
Is seating included in the minimum rental fee?
Yes
Shuttle / Transportation
Offered in-house, Outside vendors welcome
Is transportation included in the minimum rental fee?
No
Wedding Cake
Offered in-house
Is wedding cake included in the minimum rental fee?
No

INFO FOR REHEARSAL DINNER

When was your venue built?
1930
When was your venue last renovated?
2013
Describe your venue:
Historic Site, Hotel, Inn / Bed & Breakfast
Describe the style of your venue
Classic / Traditional, Garden / Romantic, Rustic
What wedding services does your venue provide?
Bridal Shower, Ceremony, Engagement Party, Reception
How many event spaces or rooms does your venue offer?
2
Does your venue offer an indoor space?
Yes
Does your venue offer a covered outdoor space?
Yes
Does your venue offer an uncovered outdoor space?
Yes
Does your venue have on-site accommodations?
Yes
Number of guest rooms
102
Number of suites
2
What is the minimum rental fee for your venue?
0
Bar Service
Offered in-house
Is bar service included in the minimum rental fee?
No
Beverage Service
Offered in-house
Is beverage service included in the minimum rental fee?
No
Catering
Offered in-house, Outside vendors welcome
Is catering included in the minimum rental fee?
No
What is the average catering price per person at your venue?
120
Event Coordination
Offered in-house
Is event coordination included in the minimum rental fee?
Yes
Event Rentals
Offered in-house
Are event rentals included in the minimum rental fee?
No
Lighting and Sound
Offered in-house
Are lighting and sound included in the minimum rental fee?
No
Linens
Offered in-house
Are linens included in the minimum rental fee?
Yes
Seating
Offered in-house
Is seating included in the minimum rental fee?
Yes
Shuttle / Transportation
Offered in-house, Outside vendors welcome
Is transportation included in the minimum rental fee?
No
Wedding Cake
Offered in-house
Is wedding cake included in the minimum rental fee?
No

REVIEWS

4.8
out of 5.0
4.8/5.0
4.7/5.0
4.8/5.0
4.8/5.0
4.8/5.0
Sort by
Default-vendor-profile-pic
stephanie
Wedding:
8/24/2014
5.0/5.0
We got married this past August 24th at The Grain House at the Olde Mill Inn, it was exactly what we were looking for. From the moment we walked in to book their services to the end of our wedding, it was seamless. This place is absolutely gorgeous! We did the ceremony, cocktail hour, and reception there. Our guest raved about the food, the wait staff, and the venue. Everything was breathtaking. I can't thank Amanda Virga, Lindsay Stewart and their amazing staff enough for all their help, they did a phenomenal job. Amanda our maitre'd pretty much took my vision and brought it to life, she was amazing! We wanted a romantic, vintage wedding and this was the perfect setting for it. We were extremely happy with our decision to have our wedding at the OMI. We can't wait to come celebrate our one year anniversary! Thanks again for making my dream come true!

Stephanie & Geovanni
We got married this past August 24th at The Grain House at the Olde Mill Inn, it was exactly what we were looking for. Read more...
We got married this past August 24th at The Grain House at the Olde Mill Inn, it was exactly what we were looking for. From the moment we walked in to book their services to the end of our wedding, it was seamless. This place is absolutely gorgeous! We did the ceremony, cocktail hour, and reception there. Our guest raved about the food, the wait staff, and the venue. Everything was breathtaking. I can't thank Amanda Virga, Lindsay Stewart and their amazing staff enough for all their help, they did a phenomenal job. Amanda our maitre'd pretty much took my vision and brought it to life, she was amazing! We wanted a romantic, vintage wedding and this was the perfect setting for it. We were extremely happy with our decision to have our wedding at the OMI. We can't wait to come celebrate our one year anniversary! Thanks again for making my dream come true!

Stephanie & Geovanni Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
Thank you so much to the staff and especially John Leitz for making our day so perfect. The food, the presentation, the hotel rooms were exactly what we were looking for when we looked for a venue for this wedding. Everyone enjoyed it all, from the beautiful ballroom to the spacious cocktail hour, to the outdoor area as well. Your staff even seemed to deliver perfect weather! Thanks so much.
Thank you so much to the staff and especially John Leitz for making our day so perfect. The food, the presentation, the Read more...
Thank you so much to the staff and especially John Leitz for making our day so perfect. The food, the presentation, the hotel rooms were exactly what we were looking for when we looked for a venue for this wedding. Everyone enjoyed it all, from the beautiful ballroom to the spacious cocktail hour, to the outdoor area as well. Your staff even seemed to deliver perfect weather! Thanks so much. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Renee
Wedding:
8/1/2014
5.0/5.0
My wedding was truly special thanks to the Olde Mill Inn. The venue, particularly the Grain House, was absolutely breathtaking on my wedding day. My guests (and even those who weren't invited) marveled at the space. The Olde Mill Inn's Grain House was perfect for my relatively small, romantic wedding. The service was impeccable. Amanda Virga was extremely helpful and flexible. I can't thank her and the team at the Olde Mill enough!
My wedding was truly special thanks to the Olde Mill Inn. The venue, particularly the Grain House, was absolutely Read more...
My wedding was truly special thanks to the Olde Mill Inn. The venue, particularly the Grain House, was absolutely breathtaking on my wedding day. My guests (and even those who weren't invited) marveled at the space. The Olde Mill Inn's Grain House was perfect for my relatively small, romantic wedding. The service was impeccable. Amanda Virga was extremely helpful and flexible. I can't thank her and the team at the Olde Mill enough! Read less
Services Used: Rehearsal Dinner, Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Hi Renee & Ricardo,
It was an absolute pleasure to work with you in planning for your wedding!! On behalf of Amanda & the banquet team, thank you for taking the time to write this lovely review. We cannot thank you enough for hosting your wedding at the Olde Mill Inn & Grain House! Send us some photos & please visit soon.
All the best,
Lindsay Stewart
& the Olde Mill Inn Management
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jennifer
Wedding:
6/28/2014
5.0/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn sets the standards for a 5+ star business, venue, presentation, and quality!
Our experience visiting, booking, staying, eating, and celebrating our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn was exceptional! We called up shortly after we got engaged and Marien told us to come in that day to look at the venue because she knew we lived out of state. She was amazing to work with, professional, attentive to detail, and prompt to respond to questions. Amanda, our Maitre D, took over the final details for our big day. She was also very professional, attentive to detail, quick to respond and exceeded our expectations in setting up details like our candy bar favor table, and taking on the task of putting flowers on our wedding cake for decor! The food was also AMAZING! There was never a lack of good food or drinks for the guests. All of our guests complimented on how good the food was from cocktail hour all the way to the reception. It's evident the food is quality and fresh! Not only is the venue elegant with a cozy feel but everyone to include the front desk staff is friendly and very helpful. It's also a great venue to have your pictures taken at. We had 23 rooms booked for guests and every room was clean and updated! All of my guests said it was "one of the best weddings they've been too!" Thank you to the Olde Mill Inn and their amazing staff for making our day PERFECT! We will be back to celebrate our one year anniversary!
The Olde Mill Inn sets the standards for a 5+ star business, venue, presentation, and quality!
Our experience Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn sets the standards for a 5+ star business, venue, presentation, and quality!
Our experience visiting, booking, staying, eating, and celebrating our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn was exceptional! We called up shortly after we got engaged and Marien told us to come in that day to look at the venue because she knew we lived out of state. She was amazing to work with, professional, attentive to detail, and prompt to respond to questions. Amanda, our Maitre D, took over the final details for our big day. She was also very professional, attentive to detail, quick to respond and exceeded our expectations in setting up details like our candy bar favor table, and taking on the task of putting flowers on our wedding cake for decor! The food was also AMAZING! There was never a lack of good food or drinks for the guests. All of our guests complimented on how good the food was from cocktail hour all the way to the reception. It's evident the food is quality and fresh! Not only is the venue elegant with a cozy feel but everyone to include the front desk staff is friendly and very helpful. It's also a great venue to have your pictures taken at. We had 23 rooms booked for guests and every room was clean and updated! All of my guests said it was "one of the best weddings they've been too!" Thank you to the Olde Mill Inn and their amazing staff for making our day PERFECT! We will be back to celebrate our one year anniversary! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jenna
Wedding:
5/30/2014
5.0/5.0
I booked the Olde Mill Inn in January of 2013 for our wedding on May 30, 2014. It was the first place we saw, and I cancelled all appointments with other venues and booked them immediately. They don't give themselves enough credit for all that they do. Pictures do not do them justice. They worked with me every step of the way, working with me when I could not meet the minimum guarantee, remembering every single detail and meeting every expectation and beyond. Our room was beautiful, the ballroom was mind blowing, and the ceremony was elegant beyond belief. I worked with John, who was there for every second on my wedding day, and he worked so hard to make sure it was all perfect. I could not have asked for a better day.
I booked the Olde Mill Inn in January of 2013 for our wedding on May 30, 2014. It was the first place we saw, and I Read more...
I booked the Olde Mill Inn in January of 2013 for our wedding on May 30, 2014. It was the first place we saw, and I cancelled all appointments with other venues and booked them immediately. They don't give themselves enough credit for all that they do. Pictures do not do them justice. They worked with me every step of the way, working with me when I could not meet the minimum guarantee, remembering every single detail and meeting every expectation and beyond. Our room was beautiful, the ballroom was mind blowing, and the ceremony was elegant beyond belief. I worked with John, who was there for every second on my wedding day, and he worked so hard to make sure it was all perfect. I could not have asked for a better day. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Congratulations Jenna & Paul!
On behalf of the ownership, thank you so much for taking the time to write this wonderful review! It was an absolute pleasure to host this special day and to be a part of celebrating with family & friends.
We hope that you visit soon and don't forget to send us some photos :)
All the best,
Lindsay Stewart
Director of Social Sales & Olde Mill Inn Management
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Ula
Wedding:
5/17/2014
5.0/5.0
We had our wedding reception at the Olde Mill in on May 17, 2014. Amanda Virga was our Maître' D and she did an amazing job!!! Amanda was very attentive, professional and responsive. We never had a problem getting in contact with her. She was a pleasure to deal with.

The weather on the day of our wedding was beautiful and we got to extend our cocktail hour to the courtyard. It was amazing! The courtyard looked beautiful and we even had a bar set up out there. Our reception was in the ballroom which very comfortably fit 180 people. The food was ABSOLUTELY delicious and plentiful! We chose the red sangria as our signature drink- it was soooooo good. I highly recommend it!

The Olde Mill Inn is a beautiful venue and we are so happy we decided to have out reception here.

Thank you for making our wedding day so special Amanda!
We had our wedding reception at the Olde Mill in on May 17, 2014. Amanda Virga was our Maître' D and she did an amazing Read more...
We had our wedding reception at the Olde Mill in on May 17, 2014. Amanda Virga was our Maître' D and she did an amazing job!!! Amanda was very attentive, professional and responsive. We never had a problem getting in contact with her. She was a pleasure to deal with.

The weather on the day of our wedding was beautiful and we got to extend our cocktail hour to the courtyard. It was amazing! The courtyard looked beautiful and we even had a bar set up out there. Our reception was in the ballroom which very comfortably fit 180 people. The food was ABSOLUTELY delicious and plentiful! We chose the red sangria as our signature drink- it was soooooo good. I highly recommend it!

The Olde Mill Inn is a beautiful venue and we are so happy we decided to have out reception here.

Thank you for making our wedding day so special Amanda! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Congratulations Ula & Cory!
On behalf of Amanda and the Olde Mill Inn Management, Thank you for hosting your wedding at the Olde Mill Inn & for taking the time to write this wonderful review about your experience! We truly appreciate it and enjoyed working with you as well.
Wishing you all the best!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
T&J2014
Wedding:
5/4/2014
5.0/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn was a dream come true for us! We had to plan our wedding in 3 months and working with this venue was the easiest part of the process. We had an outdoor ceremony, then cocktail hour and reception! The food (oh the food, thinking about it makes me hungry). Mashed Potato Bar - um...yes please! Several of our guests also stayed at the Inn. Everything flowed seamlessly thanks to the amazing staff at the Olde Mill. Everyone (sales team, Maitre d, front desk/reception staff, banquet staff, really everyone!) was simply a pleasure to work with. They were extremely accommodating and flexible. They helped us out beyond the call of duty. Recommendations made for florists and an officiant were all a hit. If the staff recommends vendors to you, it’s because they’ve had such a good experience with these vendors, trust them. John (a true gem of a man who was our maitre d) recommended an Officiant - Celia Milton to us and we are still getting calls about our quaint ceremony. The venue has its own charm and we didn’t overdo the decorations so the true beauty of this place can shine. Yes, our guests and family members made our wedding memorable, but I truly believe that choosing this space made everything come together beautifully for us. Thank You Olde Mill Inn!
The Olde Mill Inn was a dream come true for us! We had to plan our wedding in 3 months and working with this venue was the Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn was a dream come true for us! We had to plan our wedding in 3 months and working with this venue was the easiest part of the process. We had an outdoor ceremony, then cocktail hour and reception! The food (oh the food, thinking about it makes me hungry). Mashed Potato Bar - um...yes please! Several of our guests also stayed at the Inn. Everything flowed seamlessly thanks to the amazing staff at the Olde Mill. Everyone (sales team, Maitre d, front desk/reception staff, banquet staff, really everyone!) was simply a pleasure to work with. They were extremely accommodating and flexible. They helped us out beyond the call of duty. Recommendations made for florists and an officiant were all a hit. If the staff recommends vendors to you, it’s because they’ve had such a good experience with these vendors, trust them. John (a true gem of a man who was our maitre d) recommended an Officiant - Celia Milton to us and we are still getting calls about our quaint ceremony. The venue has its own charm and we didn’t overdo the decorations so the true beauty of this place can shine. Yes, our guests and family members made our wedding memorable, but I truly believe that choosing this space made everything come together beautifully for us. Thank You Olde Mill Inn! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you for your lovely review! It was a true pleasure to work with you in planning for your special day and we are honored that you selected the Olde Mill Inn for this celebration!
All the best!
Lindsay Stewart, Director of Social Sales
& Olde Mill Inn Management
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Johnny and Ashley
Wedding:
4/26/2014
5.0/5.0
We loved the entire night. Amanada Virga helped with the planning and was the best we could have asked for. We live in Oklahoma and had to plan most over the phone and email, she helped with everything and kept in contact with us for every detail. I would recommend the Olde Mill Inn and grain house to anyone planning a wedding in New Jersey!
We loved the entire night. Amanada Virga helped with the planning and was the best we could have asked for. We live in Read more...
We loved the entire night. Amanada Virga helped with the planning and was the best we could have asked for. We live in Oklahoma and had to plan most over the phone and email, she helped with everything and kept in contact with us for every detail. I would recommend the Olde Mill Inn and grain house to anyone planning a wedding in New Jersey! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake, Wedding Planning, Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you for your review! The Olde Mill Inn & Grain House assists many brides that live in other states and we always strive to make the planning experience just as it would be face-to-face. On behalf of our Maitre D' Amanda, thank you for your kind words. We enjoyed celebrating your wedding day with you and your guests!
Wishing you all the best - please visit us next time you are in NJ!
Olde Mill Inn Management & Staff
130x130_sq_1377969956509-nye
kmhowley42614
Wedding:
4/26/2014
5.0/5.0
Our experience at the olde mill inn was remarkable! We had a wonderful matire D named John Lietz! He took care of everything for us!! Before cocktail hour he brought down food to our bridal suite to make sure my husband had his favorite station right there! Throughout the night he took such excellent care of my groom and I and also my mom. There was never anything to little or silly that he would say no to, all night he checked to see if we needed anything at all!!

Thank you john!! We really appreciate it!!!
Our experience at the olde mill inn was remarkable! We had a wonderful matire D named John Lietz! He took care of Read more...
Our experience at the olde mill inn was remarkable! We had a wonderful matire D named John Lietz! He took care of everything for us!! Before cocktail hour he brought down food to our bridal suite to make sure my husband had his favorite station right there! Throughout the night he took such excellent care of my groom and I and also my mom. There was never anything to little or silly that he would say no to, all night he checked to see if we needed anything at all!!

Thank you john!! We really appreciate it!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you so much for taking the time to write such a nice review about your experience! It was a pleasure to work with you and host your guests on this special day! Thank you for choosing to celebrate at the Olde Mill Inn!
We wish you all the best,
Olde Mill Inn Management & Staff
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lauren
Wedding:
4/19/2014
5.0/5.0
I just had my wedding at the Olde Mill Inn on 4.19.14 and it was absolutely perfect! The process began with Lindsey Smillie with whom we booked our wedding date a year ago. For the year that followed she was my adviser and lifeline to all things wedding related. Her responses were fast and beyond helpful. I couldn't have planned this without her! Then there's the venue itself. My husband and I chose OMI because of it's classic and quaint appeal but also because many of our guests would need to stay the night and OMI provide the perfect venue for this. We had our rehearsal dinner the night before at the Grain House (which was perfect as well!) So, many of our guests stayed from Friday through Sunday. It was so convenient and the rooms and service were impeccable. Maureen at the front desk was also so pleasant and never seemed bothered by how many times I called for an updated room roster. We chose John Lietz as our maitre'D because of reviews we'd read and it turns out the rave reviews were absolutely correct! John was amazing. He was on top of everything and kept me calm, fed and hydrated throughout the entire weekend. We couldn't have asked for a better team! Our ceremony was outdoors in the inn's courtyard and our ceremony was in the Washington Ballroom. Both spaces were SO beautiful! And the food for cocktail hour and our reception was DELICIOUS! By the end of the night everyone commented on how beautiful the place was and how great the service and food were. We could not have asked for a more perfect weekend!
I just had my wedding at the Olde Mill Inn on 4.19.14 and it was absolutely perfect! The process began with Lindsey Read more...
I just had my wedding at the Olde Mill Inn on 4.19.14 and it was absolutely perfect! The process began with Lindsey Smillie with whom we booked our wedding date a year ago. For the year that followed she was my adviser and lifeline to all things wedding related. Her responses were fast and beyond helpful. I couldn't have planned this without her! Then there's the venue itself. My husband and I chose OMI because of it's classic and quaint appeal but also because many of our guests would need to stay the night and OMI provide the perfect venue for this. We had our rehearsal dinner the night before at the Grain House (which was perfect as well!) So, many of our guests stayed from Friday through Sunday. It was so convenient and the rooms and service were impeccable. Maureen at the front desk was also so pleasant and never seemed bothered by how many times I called for an updated room roster. We chose John Lietz as our maitre'D because of reviews we'd read and it turns out the rave reviews were absolutely correct! John was amazing. He was on top of everything and kept me calm, fed and hydrated throughout the entire weekend. We couldn't have asked for a better team! Our ceremony was outdoors in the inn's courtyard and our ceremony was in the Washington Ballroom. Both spaces were SO beautiful! And the food for cocktail hour and our reception was DELICIOUS! By the end of the night everyone commented on how beautiful the place was and how great the service and food were. We could not have asked for a more perfect weekend! Read less
Services Used: Catering, Wedding Planning, Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Hi Lauren!!
We are so appreciative of this wonderful review!! Thank you so much! I know that Lindsey & John really enjoyed working with you as well and it was a pleasure to host you and your guests throughout the entire weekend!! We wish you and Matt all the best in your marriage! We hope to see more of you in the near future :) Please visit soon!
Thank you & Congratulations again,
Lindsay Stewart, Director of Social Sales
and Olde Mill Inn Management
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
This Inn is the perfect wedding venue.
The staff is warm, friendly ,attentive, and engaging, without being intrusive.
Lindsay and John went over and above to make this day memorable and each and every staff member we encountered was pleasant and helpful.
The grounds keeper did a wonderful job preparing for the early spring outdoor ceremony
by replacing flowers and shrubs after this long winter and the patio looked beautiful.
The rooms are comfortable, roomy and clean.
Our guests all commented on how relaxed the weekend was because we were all together on the same property from the Fri night Grain House dinner through the breakfast Sunday morning.

The location is an easy drive from the airport ,NJ and NY highways which was also a plus for our guests.

The Olde Mill Inn is a true NJ gem!!
This Inn is the perfect wedding venue.
The staff is warm, friendly ,attentive, and engaging, without being intrusive. Read more...
This Inn is the perfect wedding venue.
The staff is warm, friendly ,attentive, and engaging, without being intrusive.
Lindsay and John went over and above to make this day memorable and each and every staff member we encountered was pleasant and helpful.
The grounds keeper did a wonderful job preparing for the early spring outdoor ceremony
by replacing flowers and shrubs after this long winter and the patio looked beautiful.
The rooms are comfortable, roomy and clean.
Our guests all commented on how relaxed the weekend was because we were all together on the same property from the Fri night Grain House dinner through the breakfast Sunday morning.

The location is an easy drive from the airport ,NJ and NY highways which was also a plus for our guests.

The Olde Mill Inn is a true NJ gem!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

On behalf of the Lindsay, John, Grounds Keeper & Staff, we thank you for your review and we are so pleased to hear that you enjoyed your wedding weekend!!
It was our pleasure to host you and your guests! Thank you for choosing to celebrate at the Olde Mill Inn for your special day!
Congratulations again,
Olde Mill Inn Management
Default-vendor-profile-pic
M
Wedding:
4/18/2014
5.0/5.0
If I could give a higher rating, I would. We just had our wedding last week and I am STILL floating on cloud nine. Everyone at the Olde Mill Inn made our event a real treat, especially Lindsey in the sales department and Amanda in banquets. Whatever you want your day to look and feel like, the Inn will work with you to make that dream a reality. Everyone at our wedding was so impressed not just with the location but with the incredible service we received over our two days at the Inn. Thank you for truly making our wedding day amazing!
If I could give a higher rating, I would. We just had our wedding last week and I am STILL floating on cloud nine. Read more...
If I could give a higher rating, I would. We just had our wedding last week and I am STILL floating on cloud nine. Everyone at the Olde Mill Inn made our event a real treat, especially Lindsey in the sales department and Amanda in banquets. Whatever you want your day to look and feel like, the Inn will work with you to make that dream a reality. Everyone at our wedding was so impressed not just with the location but with the incredible service we received over our two days at the Inn. Thank you for truly making our wedding day amazing! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you thank you for this wonderful review and again for selecting the Olde Mill Inn & Grain House as the location for your wedding! Congratulations & best wishes!
We would love to see photos if you can send us a link or a few in an email!
Thank you,
Lindsay Stewart, Director of Social Sales & Olde Mill Inn Management
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Justine
Wedding:
4/4/2014
5.0/5.0
From the initial email to the end, everyone was extremely professional and worked with us to create the wedding we had imagined!!! We had our ceremony & reception there. Amanda Virga, worked with me on everything. The day of the wedding it rained and I was stressing...a lot!! I spoke with Amanda before arriving at the venue because I was so unsure if we should have had the ceremony outside. Thanks to Amanda reminding us of how large the tent was we elected to continue in having the ceremony outside. It was the BEST decision we made because everything looked absolutely beautiful!!! She also helped keeping my stress level down for the day because anything I said was worrying me, she took care of it!! The entire staff was so professional and my guests enjoyed the interactions with them as well. The food, I can't say enough about it!! My husband and I have since gone back for lunch and have formed a small group of friends (who were guests) to go once a month for dinner!!! This is a must see venue and if the date you desire is already booked, I would suggest changing your date just to have your wedding here!!!
From the initial email to the end, everyone was extremely professional and worked with us to create the wedding we had Read more...
From the initial email to the end, everyone was extremely professional and worked with us to create the wedding we had imagined!!! We had our ceremony & reception there. Amanda Virga, worked with me on everything. The day of the wedding it rained and I was stressing...a lot!! I spoke with Amanda before arriving at the venue because I was so unsure if we should have had the ceremony outside. Thanks to Amanda reminding us of how large the tent was we elected to continue in having the ceremony outside. It was the BEST decision we made because everything looked absolutely beautiful!!! She also helped keeping my stress level down for the day because anything I said was worrying me, she took care of it!! The entire staff was so professional and my guests enjoyed the interactions with them as well. The food, I can't say enough about it!! My husband and I have since gone back for lunch and have formed a small group of friends (who were guests) to go once a month for dinner!!! This is a must see venue and if the date you desire is already booked, I would suggest changing your date just to have your wedding here!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Justine,
Thank you for your wonderful testimonial! On behalf of Amanda & our staff, it means so much that you would take the time to express how pleased you were with your wedding at the Olde Mill Inn & Grain House! We wish you all the best and look forward to having you visit soon!
Thank you & Congratulations again,
Lindsay Stewart, Director of Social Sales
& Olde Mill Inn Management
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jessica
Wedding:
3/22/2014
5.0/5.0
We knew from the moment we visited The Olde Mill Inn that it was the perfect place for our wedding. A big thanks to Lindsey Smillie, our booking agent, who showed us the grounds and answered all of our questions. John Lietz, our Maître D, was so helpful! He was willing to do anything to make our day perfect. John and his staff went above and beyond to make sure every detail of our wedding ran smoothly. John made sure our guests had everything and anything they needed; which meant the world to us. I can't say enough how much we loved everything The Olde Mill Inn did for us! Thank you Olde Mill Inn for all your hard work and efforts. Our guests are still talking about the delicious food and amazing time they had at this " Top-Notch" Wedding. We are truly grateful.
Jessica and Mark Tynan
March 22, 2014
We knew from the moment we visited The Olde Mill Inn that it was the perfect place for our wedding. A big thanks to Read more...
We knew from the moment we visited The Olde Mill Inn that it was the perfect place for our wedding. A big thanks to Lindsey Smillie, our booking agent, who showed us the grounds and answered all of our questions. John Lietz, our Maître D, was so helpful! He was willing to do anything to make our day perfect. John and his staff went above and beyond to make sure every detail of our wedding ran smoothly. John made sure our guests had everything and anything they needed; which meant the world to us. I can't say enough how much we loved everything The Olde Mill Inn did for us! Thank you Olde Mill Inn for all your hard work and efforts. Our guests are still talking about the delicious food and amazing time they had at this " Top-Notch" Wedding. We are truly grateful.
Jessica and Mark Tynan
March 22, 2014 Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

On behalf of Lindsey & John, thank you thank you for your review! We are so pleased to hear that you enjoyed the food & service that was provided on our wedding day at the Olde Mill Inn! It was our pleasure to host you and your guests!
We would love if you sent us a photo! :) Also, please come visit us soon!

Congratulations & All the best!!

Olde Mill Inn Management and Staff
130x130_sq_1377655012388-engagement-picture-looking-back
Mary
Wedding:
2/15/2014
5.0/5.0
We had our rehearsal dinner, ceremony and reception at the Olde Mill Inn and everything was wonderful! From signing our contract to the day of the wedding, everyone we spoke to at the inn was helpful, kind, and responsive. All of our guests raved about the accommodations, the food, and the service. People warned me about the stress a bride can feel on her wedding day, making sure people are in the right places and dealing with unexpected issues - but I didn't have any worries. Amanda was right there checking in with me and making sure everything was going smoothly. Many, many thanks to Lindsay S. and Amanda for all of their help! I highly recommend the Olde Mill Inn!
We had our rehearsal dinner, ceremony and reception at the Olde Mill Inn and everything was wonderful! From signing our Read more...
We had our rehearsal dinner, ceremony and reception at the Olde Mill Inn and everything was wonderful! From signing our contract to the day of the wedding, everyone we spoke to at the inn was helpful, kind, and responsive. All of our guests raved about the accommodations, the food, and the service. People warned me about the stress a bride can feel on her wedding day, making sure people are in the right places and dealing with unexpected issues - but I didn't have any worries. Amanda was right there checking in with me and making sure everything was going smoothly. Many, many thanks to Lindsay S. and Amanda for all of their help! I highly recommend the Olde Mill Inn! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you Mary, it was our pleasure to host you & your guests on your wedding weekend!! We had a wonderful time working with you and celebrating your special day!
We would love to have you send/share photos with us!

All the best,
Director of Social Sales Lindsay Stewart
Olde Mill Inn Staff & Management
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Janet
Wedding:
2/8/2014
5.0/5.0
My husband and I were married at The Olde Mill Inn-Grain House on February 8, 2014. As soon as we viewed the venue we fell in love. The layout and décor of the Grain House was exactly what we wanted.
We first met with Lindsay and she was very knowledgeable and was always able to answer all of our questions mainly through email. She gave us a thorough tour of the venue and a detailed estimate of how much the wedding would cost. We ended up booking this venue a couple days later because we knew it was the one.
Our maître d was Amanda and she took care of all the details of our wedding. She always followed up with us and cared about how our wedding planning was coming along. When we first met with her in person, she was very welcoming and was excited to help us plan our wedding. We went over every detail with her and she always answered our emails very quickly. The day of our wedding went smoothly because Amanda took care of the timeline and made sure our guests knew where to go at specific times. She always asked how we were doing that night to make sure it was the best day of our lives. The service staff was excellent and very friendly with our guests. The food was spectacular and we couldn’t believe how much food was at the cocktail hour! I recommend the sangria, which was our signature drink, all of the guests said it was delicious.
The Olde Mill Inn-Grain House was the best choice we could have made for our wedding venue. All of our guests said that it was the best wedding that they have ever been to. My mother in law is still raving about what a great time she had and said it could not have been any better!
My husband and I were married at The Olde Mill Inn-Grain House on February 8, 2014. As soon as we viewed the venue we fell Read more...
My husband and I were married at The Olde Mill Inn-Grain House on February 8, 2014. As soon as we viewed the venue we fell in love. The layout and décor of the Grain House was exactly what we wanted.
We first met with Lindsay and she was very knowledgeable and was always able to answer all of our questions mainly through email. She gave us a thorough tour of the venue and a detailed estimate of how much the wedding would cost. We ended up booking this venue a couple days later because we knew it was the one.
Our maître d was Amanda and she took care of all the details of our wedding. She always followed up with us and cared about how our wedding planning was coming along. When we first met with her in person, she was very welcoming and was excited to help us plan our wedding. We went over every detail with her and she always answered our emails very quickly. The day of our wedding went smoothly because Amanda took care of the timeline and made sure our guests knew where to go at specific times. She always asked how we were doing that night to make sure it was the best day of our lives. The service staff was excellent and very friendly with our guests. The food was spectacular and we couldn’t believe how much food was at the cocktail hour! I recommend the sangria, which was our signature drink, all of the guests said it was delicious.
The Olde Mill Inn-Grain House was the best choice we could have made for our wedding venue. All of our guests said that it was the best wedding that they have ever been to. My mother in law is still raving about what a great time she had and said it could not have been any better! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Janet & David,
Thank you for your review! We appreciate you taking the time to express how pleased you were with our service for your Grain House Wedding!!! You were a pleasure to work with and we enjoyed hosting this memorable day in your lives!! We wish you all the best and look forward to seeing you again in the future!
Take care,
Lindsay Stewart, Director of Social Sales
Amanda & Olde Mill Inn Staff
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
We could not have asked for a more perfect wedding reception! We were looking for a cozy, winter feel at our venue and the Olde Mill Inn was just that! We planned our wedding in just about 6 months and found all the staff to be extremely helpful and courteous! Throughout the planning process, both Lindsay Stewart and John Lietz were easy to work with and quick to respond to all of our needs. The week of the wedding we had a few last minute requests, including adding a day after breakfast, and they handled it with no problem. On our wedding day, John made sure every detail ran smoothly. Every single guest remarked at what a wonderful time they had and how beautiful the venue was. The cocktail hour was a huge hit...especially the mashed potato bar and the mini French onion soup bowls! Dinner was delicious as was breakfast the next day. It was great to have the reception at a venue with a bar for an afterparty and rooms for our guests to stay. Our suite was beautiful and big enough for friends to hang out in before the ceremony. We loved the fireplace and the champagne and chocolate-covered strawberries delivered to our room afterward. We didn't have a thing to worry about with set-up or collecting our items after the reception...John had it all taken care of! I would highly recommend Olde Mill Inn if you are looking for a wonderful wedding experience! Thanks so much John and Lindsay and all exceptional staff at the Olde Mill Inn!
We could not have asked for a more perfect wedding reception! We were looking for a cozy, winter feel at our venue and the Read more...
We could not have asked for a more perfect wedding reception! We were looking for a cozy, winter feel at our venue and the Olde Mill Inn was just that! We planned our wedding in just about 6 months and found all the staff to be extremely helpful and courteous! Throughout the planning process, both Lindsay Stewart and John Lietz were easy to work with and quick to respond to all of our needs. The week of the wedding we had a few last minute requests, including adding a day after breakfast, and they handled it with no problem. On our wedding day, John made sure every detail ran smoothly. Every single guest remarked at what a wonderful time they had and how beautiful the venue was. The cocktail hour was a huge hit...especially the mashed potato bar and the mini French onion soup bowls! Dinner was delicious as was breakfast the next day. It was great to have the reception at a venue with a bar for an afterparty and rooms for our guests to stay. Our suite was beautiful and big enough for friends to hang out in before the ceremony. We loved the fireplace and the champagne and chocolate-covered strawberries delivered to our room afterward. We didn't have a thing to worry about with set-up or collecting our items after the reception...John had it all taken care of! I would highly recommend Olde Mill Inn if you are looking for a wonderful wedding experience! Thanks so much John and Lindsay and all exceptional staff at the Olde Mill Inn! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you so much for taking the time to write all of your kind words & feedback! We loved being a part of this special day for you and your family! Wishing you all the best! Please visit soon and send photos :)
Take care,
Director of Social Sales Lindsay Stewart
Olde Mill Inn Management & Staff
Default-vendor-profile-pic
C
Wedding:
2/1/2014
5.0/5.0
Absolutely perfect. My original contact, Lindsay, always responded quickly to my emails, which usually included a ridiculous number of questions, and was always very helpful. John, our Maitre D, was awesome and set everything up exactly the way we wanted. When our photography session ran ridiculously long he brought us up food from cocktail hour, which was desperately needed. Everything was great, the food was fantastic, and the grounds are lovely. There are a few things I would change about my wedding if I could do it again, but the reception venue is not one of them.
Absolutely perfect. My original contact, Lindsay, always responded quickly to my emails, which usually included a Read more...
Absolutely perfect. My original contact, Lindsay, always responded quickly to my emails, which usually included a ridiculous number of questions, and was always very helpful. John, our Maitre D, was awesome and set everything up exactly the way we wanted. When our photography session ran ridiculously long he brought us up food from cocktail hour, which was desperately needed. Everything was great, the food was fantastic, and the grounds are lovely. There are a few things I would change about my wedding if I could do it again, but the reception venue is not one of them. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
This review has been a long time coming! My wedding was in December, right after Christmas, and it couldn't have been more perfect. While a winter wedding is less traditional, the gorgeous decorations at the Olde Mill Inn made for an absolutely beautiful backdrop to the reception. I was living in Los Angeles at the time, but Marien assured me that she would take care of me through the entire process of selecting everything for the wedding. I always knew I wanted to get married at the Olde Mill Inn, so picking the venue was easy for me. We were fortunate enough to get in on a winter special and we were able to select some add-ons without too much of a price increase. As an event planner myself, I tried to stay as organized as possible, but even if I hadn't been, Marien was always helpful to walk me through the different choices I had to make.

Since the week of our wedding was Christmas, Marien was great in communicating with us the week before to let us know when we could drop off the items for the wedding, like the chair sashes and overlays that we purchased ourselves, along with our table cards, name cards, and candy bar items. Marien set everything up for us, and it looked incredible!

Our cocktail reception food was so good, our guests raved about the mashed potato bar. The dinner was maybe the best food I have ever tasted. That filet mignon was unbelievable! Everyone loved the stuffed chicken and salmon, too. Since we lived across the country, we didn't have time to set up a tasting for the cake, but we got it through Palermo's (which comes with the wedding package) and seriously, it was the most gorgeous cake I have EVER seen. I was blown away. At the end of the night, we didn't want to end, so the staff and bartenders stayed longer and we were up until 2 am. Marien is the best, the Olde Mill Inn is the best, my guests still rave that it's the best wedding they've ever been to, and keep asking to do it over again! We love the Olde Mill Inn!!
This review has been a long time coming! My wedding was in December, right after Christmas, and it couldn't have been more Read more...
This review has been a long time coming! My wedding was in December, right after Christmas, and it couldn't have been more perfect. While a winter wedding is less traditional, the gorgeous decorations at the Olde Mill Inn made for an absolutely beautiful backdrop to the reception. I was living in Los Angeles at the time, but Marien assured me that she would take care of me through the entire process of selecting everything for the wedding. I always knew I wanted to get married at the Olde Mill Inn, so picking the venue was easy for me. We were fortunate enough to get in on a winter special and we were able to select some add-ons without too much of a price increase. As an event planner myself, I tried to stay as organized as possible, but even if I hadn't been, Marien was always helpful to walk me through the different choices I had to make.

Since the week of our wedding was Christmas, Marien was great in communicating with us the week before to let us know when we could drop off the items for the wedding, like the chair sashes and overlays that we purchased ourselves, along with our table cards, name cards, and candy bar items. Marien set everything up for us, and it looked incredible!

Our cocktail reception food was so good, our guests raved about the mashed potato bar. The dinner was maybe the best food I have ever tasted. That filet mignon was unbelievable! Everyone loved the stuffed chicken and salmon, too. Since we lived across the country, we didn't have time to set up a tasting for the cake, but we got it through Palermo's (which comes with the wedding package) and seriously, it was the most gorgeous cake I have EVER seen. I was blown away. At the end of the night, we didn't want to end, so the staff and bartenders stayed longer and we were up until 2 am. Marien is the best, the Olde Mill Inn is the best, my guests still rave that it's the best wedding they've ever been to, and keep asking to do it over again! We love the Olde Mill Inn!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

On behalf of Marien, thank you for your fabulous review & for taking the time! We appreciate all of the wonderful comments! Marien had actually taken a video of your candy bar/dessert display set up and the video has gone a long way to show other clients the possibilities!! We wish we can do it all over again too!
Wishing you all the best - please visit when you are back in NJ!

Lindsay Stewart, Director of Social Sales & Olde Mill Inn Management
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Sara
Wedding:
12/21/2013
5.0/5.0
We were completely happy with our whole experience with the Olde Mill Inn. From the accomodations, food and staff, everything was exceptional. All we wanted was a wedding where everyone had nothing but fun, even if things went wrong, and that's exactly what we got. Except nothing went wrong! John, our matre' d, made the evening fantastic...we worried and wanted for nothing. He truly ran the show. From the day we booked the Inn, we had a simply easy and pleasuable experience. Everyone who attended complimented all parts of the day - we heard no negatives. We would highly recommend this venue to anyone looking for a beautiful, stress free day.
We were completely happy with our whole experience with the Olde Mill Inn. From the accomodations, food and staff, Read more...
We were completely happy with our whole experience with the Olde Mill Inn. From the accomodations, food and staff, everything was exceptional. All we wanted was a wedding where everyone had nothing but fun, even if things went wrong, and that's exactly what we got. Except nothing went wrong! John, our matre' d, made the evening fantastic...we worried and wanted for nothing. He truly ran the show. From the day we booked the Inn, we had a simply easy and pleasuable experience. Everyone who attended complimented all parts of the day - we heard no negatives. We would highly recommend this venue to anyone looking for a beautiful, stress free day. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you Sara & Jason for your review! We were delighted to work with you and enjoyed hosting your special day! We hope to see you soon!
All the best,
Director of Social Sales Lindsay Stewart
Olde Mill Inn Management & Staff
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jennifer
Wedding:
11/30/2013
5.0/5.0
We absolutely loved everything about our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn. We were able to do it all here! Wedding Ceremony, Reception, Lodging...all with their impeccable style and attention to detail that the OMI is known for. The place just has such a unique ambiance, it's really special. Our friends and family keep talking about the food, the beautiful ceremony/reception room, and even the hotel beds! Our Maitre D (Amanda Virga) guided us through the whole process step by step and was a behind the scenes superstar for us all night long.

For anyone considering a wedding during the "off season"...we did it ALL inside, and it was absolutely lovely. We wouldn't have changed a thing about our night.
We absolutely loved everything about our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn. We were able to do it all here! Wedding Ceremony, Read more...
We absolutely loved everything about our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn. We were able to do it all here! Wedding Ceremony, Reception, Lodging...all with their impeccable style and attention to detail that the OMI is known for. The place just has such a unique ambiance, it's really special. Our friends and family keep talking about the food, the beautiful ceremony/reception room, and even the hotel beds! Our Maitre D (Amanda Virga) guided us through the whole process step by step and was a behind the scenes superstar for us all night long.

For anyone considering a wedding during the "off season"...we did it ALL inside, and it was absolutely lovely. We wouldn't have changed a thing about our night. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Jennifer & Joe,
We appreciate you taking the time to write a review on your wedding experience!! Thank you for choosing the Grain House as your wedding venue! It was a pleasure to work with you! Send us some photos when you have a chance.
Wish you the best,
Director of Social Sales Lindsay Stewart & Olde Mill Inn Management
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Diana
Wedding:
11/29/2013
5.0/5.0
My husband and I chose to have our 11.29.13 wedding at the Olde Mill Inn because of its cozy and rustic feel. Best choice we could have made!! We booked with Lindsey Smillie- she was so sweet and we were so impressed with the level of professionalism. She was open and flexible to working with us on planning a perfect wedding day within what we could afford. She was immediately responsive throughout the planning months whenever I emailed her and provided great advice & suggestions. We encountered much of the same with our Maitre 'd John. He was warm & friendly, responsive when I contacted him, very helpful when we met with him to plan our menu, and very organized when I went the week of the wedding to drop off all of our stuff. The day of the wedding, was the best day of our lives! And OMI had alot to do with that. Not only was the venue breathtaking, but everyone raved about the food and the service. John was always there when I needed him with a drink or a plate of food without being overbearing. Also, at the end of the night, there was nothing better than everyone just being able to walk up to their rooms. I also liked that fact that I got to wake up the next morning and spend breakfast again with my friends and family. It felt like a weekend getaway! We highly recommend the OMI!! They made our wedding day so special- we didn't want it to be over!!!
My husband and I chose to have our 11.29.13 wedding at the Olde Mill Inn because of its cozy and rustic feel. Best choice Read more...
My husband and I chose to have our 11.29.13 wedding at the Olde Mill Inn because of its cozy and rustic feel. Best choice we could have made!! We booked with Lindsey Smillie- she was so sweet and we were so impressed with the level of professionalism. She was open and flexible to working with us on planning a perfect wedding day within what we could afford. She was immediately responsive throughout the planning months whenever I emailed her and provided great advice & suggestions. We encountered much of the same with our Maitre 'd John. He was warm & friendly, responsive when I contacted him, very helpful when we met with him to plan our menu, and very organized when I went the week of the wedding to drop off all of our stuff. The day of the wedding, was the best day of our lives! And OMI had alot to do with that. Not only was the venue breathtaking, but everyone raved about the food and the service. John was always there when I needed him with a drink or a plate of food without being overbearing. Also, at the end of the night, there was nothing better than everyone just being able to walk up to their rooms. I also liked that fact that I got to wake up the next morning and spend breakfast again with my friends and family. It felt like a weekend getaway! We highly recommend the OMI!! They made our wedding day so special- we didn't want it to be over!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Hi Diana & Mike,
Thank you for your kind words in your review and for hosting your wedding at the Olde Mill Inn! We have seen your wedding photos & they are phenomenal!
We wish you the best & hope to see you soon!
Take care,
Lindsay Stewart, Director of Social Sales
and Olde Mill Inn Management
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kevin
Wedding:
11/23/2013
5.0/5.0
My wife and I had a tremendous experience when getting married at Olde Mill Inn. From the moment with first met Lindsey Smillie, our Sales Manager, the Olde Mill Inn staff helped make this day perfect. There was a seamless transition from working with Lindsey to John Lietz, our maître d. Lindsey remained available for questions, but John was everything we could have asked for on our big day.

We were married inside the Grand Ballroom - the transition for the reception was quick and painless for all guests. My wife and I were told numerous times on how great the food was, not to mention how much food there was. One thing that I thought was above and beyond - John took great care of my mother and mother in law. John made sure that they had their plates of food and that any allergy concerns were met with an alternative selection.

My wife and I saw 20+ venues prior to booking with Olde Mill Inn. There was no clear second choice beforehand and, after experiencing how the OMI community comes together for a couple getting married, our belief was reaffirmed that Olde Mill Inn was clearly the right choice.
My wife and I had a tremendous experience when getting married at Olde Mill Inn. From the moment with first met Lindsey Read more...
My wife and I had a tremendous experience when getting married at Olde Mill Inn. From the moment with first met Lindsey Smillie, our Sales Manager, the Olde Mill Inn staff helped make this day perfect. There was a seamless transition from working with Lindsey to John Lietz, our maître d. Lindsey remained available for questions, but John was everything we could have asked for on our big day.

We were married inside the Grand Ballroom - the transition for the reception was quick and painless for all guests. My wife and I were told numerous times on how great the food was, not to mention how much food there was. One thing that I thought was above and beyond - John took great care of my mother and mother in law. John made sure that they had their plates of food and that any allergy concerns were met with an alternative selection.

My wife and I saw 20+ venues prior to booking with Olde Mill Inn. There was no clear second choice beforehand and, after experiencing how the OMI community comes together for a couple getting married, our belief was reaffirmed that Olde Mill Inn was clearly the right choice. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

What a wonderful review, thank you so much for taking the time to write about the Olde Mill Inn, Lindsey & John! We cannot thank you enough for hosting your wedding at the Olde Mill Inn & we wish you all the best!

Lindsay Stewart, Director of Social Sales
and Olde Mill Inn Management
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Stephanie
Wedding:
11/16/2013
5.0/5.0
Olde Mill Inn was amazing. Lindsey, when we booked the venue a year ago was so great and helpful and once we toured the property we knew we wanted our wedding there. They made everything so easy. Our maitre'd John was so amazing. He made sure I had nothing to worry about the day of our wedding. He made everything flow so smoothly I never had to worry about a thing. Always had food and a drink ready for me. The FOOD WAS SOOO DELICIOUS. Everyone loved the mashed potato bar at cocktail hour. Everyone kept telling us how stuffed they were after the wedding and how delicious all the options we had were. So many choices and so accommodating to our food preferences. The hotel itself is beautiful and loved all our guests stayed right with us and got breakfast with us the next day. Would definitely recommend this place to any bride/groom looking for a amazing venue with amazing staff and food! It was the greatest night of our lives and so glad we chose the Olde Mill Inn.
Olde Mill Inn was amazing. Lindsey, when we booked the venue a year ago was so great and helpful and once we toured the Read more...
Olde Mill Inn was amazing. Lindsey, when we booked the venue a year ago was so great and helpful and once we toured the property we knew we wanted our wedding there. They made everything so easy. Our maitre'd John was so amazing. He made sure I had nothing to worry about the day of our wedding. He made everything flow so smoothly I never had to worry about a thing. Always had food and a drink ready for me. The FOOD WAS SOOO DELICIOUS. Everyone loved the mashed potato bar at cocktail hour. Everyone kept telling us how stuffed they were after the wedding and how delicious all the options we had were. So many choices and so accommodating to our food preferences. The hotel itself is beautiful and loved all our guests stayed right with us and got breakfast with us the next day. Would definitely recommend this place to any bride/groom looking for a amazing venue with amazing staff and food! It was the greatest night of our lives and so glad we chose the Olde Mill Inn. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Hi Stephanie & Matt,
On behalf of Lindsey & John, we thank you for your review and are so pleased to hear that your wedding was all that you dreamed of! We had a wonderful time hosting you, your family & friends on this special occassion!
Wishing you all the best,

Lindsay Stewart, Director of Social Sales
&
Olde Mill Inn Management
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Patrick
Wedding:
11/15/2013
5.0/5.0
Had a great time at the wedding. Guests kept raving about how much fun they had and how great the food was. John helped us out so much and gave us much more than we hoped for.
Had a great time at the wedding. Guests kept raving about how much fun they had and how great the food was. John helped us Read more...
Had a great time at the wedding. Guests kept raving about how much fun they had and how great the food was. John helped us out so much and gave us much more than we hoped for. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank your for your review Patrick! It was a real pleasure to host your wedding day at the Olde Mill Inn!

All the best,
Lindsay Stewart
Director of Social Sales
130x130_sq_1384183175443-profile-cove
Sara Moran
Wedding:
11/2/2013
5.0/5.0
I booked my reception at the Olde Mill Inn through Lindsey Smilie who is an absolute sweetheart! She was very professional and answered all my questions about booking the venue with ease. For my wedding my maitre'd was John Lietz who was also incredible. If you are booking your wedding here try to get John as your maitre'd! He made sure that everything was perfect ( I could not find one thing that was wrong or out of place at the venue-it was exactly how I wanted it!). He made sure I always had a drink in my hand and food on my plate! My guests also commented how nice he was, and he was very attentive to my family as well including my father and my uncle who said John always asked if they needed anything. The venue itself is very beautiful and charming. I loved the warmth of the ballroom and the hotel in general. My husband and I stayed overnight in the Dayton Suite and we had champagne waiting for us in our room after out "after party" in the Grain House. We appreciated the option of having the party continue in the Grain House which stayed open until 1 AM. The waitstaff were also incredible and very accommodating. My only complaint is that the front desk double charged some of my guests for their room. Other than that, our wedding was amazing thanks to such friendly, professional, and attentive staff like John and Lindsey! Thanks again Olde Mill Inn!!
I booked my reception at the Olde Mill Inn through Lindsey Smilie who is an absolute sweetheart! She was very professional Read more...
I booked my reception at the Olde Mill Inn through Lindsey Smilie who is an absolute sweetheart! She was very professional and answered all my questions about booking the venue with ease. For my wedding my maitre'd was John Lietz who was also incredible. If you are booking your wedding here try to get John as your maitre'd! He made sure that everything was perfect ( I could not find one thing that was wrong or out of place at the venue-it was exactly how I wanted it!). He made sure I always had a drink in my hand and food on my plate! My guests also commented how nice he was, and he was very attentive to my family as well including my father and my uncle who said John always asked if they needed anything. The venue itself is very beautiful and charming. I loved the warmth of the ballroom and the hotel in general. My husband and I stayed overnight in the Dayton Suite and we had champagne waiting for us in our room after out "after party" in the Grain House. We appreciated the option of having the party continue in the Grain House which stayed open until 1 AM. The waitstaff were also incredible and very accommodating. My only complaint is that the front desk double charged some of my guests for their room. Other than that, our wedding was amazing thanks to such friendly, professional, and attentive staff like John and Lindsey! Thanks again Olde Mill Inn!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Hi Sara & Jason,
On behalf of Lindsey & John, thank you!! We LOVED working with you and making sure that your day was absolutely perfect!
We wish you all the best in your marraige! Please visit :)
Take care,
Lindsay Stewart, Director of Social Sales
and Olde Mill Inn Management
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Samantha
Wedding:
11/1/2013
5.0/5.0
Everyone here was great to work with. I booked my Nov 2013 wedding in August with Catherine, they respected my budget and we're happy to do what they could to help. My maitre'd Amanda was great. We met a few weeks before the wedding to go over everything and the day/night of she was amazing. She made sure we had everything we needed and took care of everything behind the scenes. Not only is the Olde Mill Inn beautiful the staff is great, I would recommend this venue to anyone planning a wedding.
Everyone here was great to work with. I booked my Nov 2013 wedding in August with Catherine, they respected my budget and Read more...
Everyone here was great to work with. I booked my Nov 2013 wedding in August with Catherine, they respected my budget and we're happy to do what they could to help. My maitre'd Amanda was great. We met a few weeks before the wedding to go over everything and the day/night of she was amazing. She made sure we had everything we needed and took care of everything behind the scenes. Not only is the Olde Mill Inn beautiful the staff is great, I would recommend this venue to anyone planning a wedding. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn was an absolute pleasure to work with. We booked our contract with Lindsey and she was amazing. From the very beginning she was extremely responsive, accommodating (we were not living in NJ which made the planning trickier!), and professional. Once we got closer to our event we started working with John (our Maitre d') and he was fantastic. He clearly has done a few weddings in his day as he had excellent recommendations for the flow of the evening, the set-up of the room, etc. He took all of the stress out of the day of schedule and our reception perfectly - we didn't worry about a thing.

I would highly recommend the Olde Mill Inn to anyone looking to get married in NJ - we had a fantastic experience and could not be happier with the way our special day turned out.
The Olde Mill Inn was an absolute pleasure to work with. We booked our contract with Lindsey and she was amazing. From the Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn was an absolute pleasure to work with. We booked our contract with Lindsey and she was amazing. From the very beginning she was extremely responsive, accommodating (we were not living in NJ which made the planning trickier!), and professional. Once we got closer to our event we started working with John (our Maitre d') and he was fantastic. He clearly has done a few weddings in his day as he had excellent recommendations for the flow of the evening, the set-up of the room, etc. He took all of the stress out of the day of schedule and our reception perfectly - we didn't worry about a thing.

I would highly recommend the Olde Mill Inn to anyone looking to get married in NJ - we had a fantastic experience and could not be happier with the way our special day turned out. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
We knew from the moment we visited the Olde Mill Inn that it was the perfect place for our wedding. And everywhere we went we heard great things about the OMI. And now, we can't stop hearing friends and family tell us how marvelous everything was. Lindsay Stewart was incredible. She was there for us from our first visit through our wedding day. She was wonderful and willing to do anything to make our day perfect. Lindsay and her staff were also willing to go above and beyond to do anything for our guests, which meant so much to us. Every idea I had...Lindsay always had a better one. I can't say enough how much we loved everything at the Olde Mill Inn from the rehearsal dinner at the Grain House to the outdoor ceremony to the food to the service...it was all top notch.
We knew from the moment we visited the Olde Mill Inn that it was the perfect place for our wedding. And everywhere we went Read more...
We knew from the moment we visited the Olde Mill Inn that it was the perfect place for our wedding. And everywhere we went we heard great things about the OMI. And now, we can't stop hearing friends and family tell us how marvelous everything was. Lindsay Stewart was incredible. She was there for us from our first visit through our wedding day. She was wonderful and willing to do anything to make our day perfect. Lindsay and her staff were also willing to go above and beyond to do anything for our guests, which meant so much to us. Every idea I had...Lindsay always had a better one. I can't say enough how much we loved everything at the Olde Mill Inn from the rehearsal dinner at the Grain House to the outdoor ceremony to the food to the service...it was all top notch. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you for your review!! It means so much that you took the time to write these kind words! It was an absolute pleasure to work with you and your family! We wish you all the best.
Please visit us the next time you are in town.

Kind Regards,
Lindsay Stewart
& Olde Mill Inn Management
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lauren
Wedding:
10/13/2013
5.0/5.0
Our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn was the stuff fairy tales are written about! From the first time we went to meet with Cathi to visit, we were overwhelmed by the beauty of the venue and the helpfulness of everyone we met! Our day was absolutely perfect and I cant say enough about the professionalism of the staff here and their willingness to make sure that a bride feels like a princess on her day! We had our rehearsal dinner at the Grain House and our ceremony and reception at The Olde Mill Inn! We received compliment after compliment on how beautiful the grounds were, how delicious the food was, how friendly the staff was, and the list goes on and on! The Olde Mill Inn went above and beyond and we are forever thankful!! Cathi answered questions day and night leading up to the wedding and John Lietz went above and beyond on the day of our wedding to make sure everything was where it needed to be. An A+++ from this bride!!!
Our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn was the stuff fairy tales are written about! From the first time we went to meet with Read more...
Our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn was the stuff fairy tales are written about! From the first time we went to meet with Cathi to visit, we were overwhelmed by the beauty of the venue and the helpfulness of everyone we met! Our day was absolutely perfect and I cant say enough about the professionalism of the staff here and their willingness to make sure that a bride feels like a princess on her day! We had our rehearsal dinner at the Grain House and our ceremony and reception at The Olde Mill Inn! We received compliment after compliment on how beautiful the grounds were, how delicious the food was, how friendly the staff was, and the list goes on and on! The Olde Mill Inn went above and beyond and we are forever thankful!! Cathi answered questions day and night leading up to the wedding and John Lietz went above and beyond on the day of our wedding to make sure everything was where it needed to be. An A+++ from this bride!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kelly
Wedding:
10/13/2013
5.0/5.0
The Olde Mill in is exceptional for so many reason. The event space is beautiful, the staff is attentive, kind and professional, the food was great and ultimately our wedding was perfect in every way! Lindsay and Amanda are amazing at what they do and makde us feel comfortable and confident the entire time from when we booked the space in August of 2012 until our wedding in October of 2013. The Grain House and Hunt Room are perfect for our smaller, vintage wedding feel. I had hand-made several aspects of the wedding and they helped unpack a ton of boxes and set up everything for us! after the wedding the gathered everything we left behind and had it all at the room waiting for us! the Wedding suite was so beautiful it made everything come together perfectly, plus the hotel manager comped us a free night in the suite!! It is also so convenient that out of town guest did not need to worry about transportation between ceremony and reception and we did not have to rent a bus or car service for after the reception! We can't wait to go back to the grain house for our anniversary dinner and relive the wonderful day and night we got married at this amazing venue!
The Olde Mill in is exceptional for so many reason. The event space is beautiful, the staff is attentive, kind and Read more...
The Olde Mill in is exceptional for so many reason. The event space is beautiful, the staff is attentive, kind and professional, the food was great and ultimately our wedding was perfect in every way! Lindsay and Amanda are amazing at what they do and makde us feel comfortable and confident the entire time from when we booked the space in August of 2012 until our wedding in October of 2013. The Grain House and Hunt Room are perfect for our smaller, vintage wedding feel. I had hand-made several aspects of the wedding and they helped unpack a ton of boxes and set up everything for us! after the wedding the gathered everything we left behind and had it all at the room waiting for us! the Wedding suite was so beautiful it made everything come together perfectly, plus the hotel manager comped us a free night in the suite!! It is also so convenient that out of town guest did not need to worry about transportation between ceremony and reception and we did not have to rent a bus or car service for after the reception! We can't wait to go back to the grain house for our anniversary dinner and relive the wonderful day and night we got married at this amazing venue! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Christie
Wedding:
10/6/2013
5.0/5.0
What I appreciate the most about this venue, was there flexibility we had traditions that went against their house rules but they worked with us and we came to a reasonable compromise. The restaurant is a beautiful venue to have an intimate affair.
What I appreciate the most about this venue, was there flexibility we had traditions that went against their house rules Read more...
What I appreciate the most about this venue, was there flexibility we had traditions that went against their house rules but they worked with us and we came to a reasonable compromise. The restaurant is a beautiful venue to have an intimate affair. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kristin
Wedding:
8/24/2013
5.0/5.0
My husband and I were very impressed with the Olde Mill Inn. They did a great job with the flow of the wedding as well as working with our budget. We had the rehearsal dinner, ceremony and reception at the Grain House/Olde Mill Inn and all the festivities went very smoothly. We worked with Lindsay Stewart, who was very easy to work with and was always available when needed.
My husband and I were very impressed with the Olde Mill Inn. They did a great job with the flow of the wedding as well as Read more...
My husband and I were very impressed with the Olde Mill Inn. They did a great job with the flow of the wedding as well as working with our budget. We had the rehearsal dinner, ceremony and reception at the Grain House/Olde Mill Inn and all the festivities went very smoothly. We worked with Lindsay Stewart, who was very easy to work with and was always available when needed. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Dear Kristen,

Thank you for your kind testimonial! We are thrilled to read of your pleasure and wonderful memory on your wedding day!! Please, when you have time, share photos with us. We'd be thrilled to display a photo of you and yours!

Kind regards,
Catherine Notaro-Schweitzer
Director of Sales & Catering
908-696-2311
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jennifer
Wedding:
7/22/2006
5.0/5.0
Amazing!!! The food was excellent, the service was superb, and our guests still comment how beautiful everything was!! We couldn't have picked a better place!! Guests enjoyed their stay at the inn also!!
Amazing!!! The food was excellent, the service was superb, and our guests still comment how beautiful everything was!! We Read more...
Amazing!!! The food was excellent, the service was superb, and our guests still comment how beautiful everything was!! We couldn't have picked a better place!! Guests enjoyed their stay at the inn also!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Verzi
Wedding:
8/9/2013
5.0/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn was the perfect venue for our wedding ceremony and reception. From the start, Lindsey S. guided me through the entire process with professionalism and amazing hospitality. She was so good to me that I decided to have my bridal shower at The Grain House, which was spectacular. John L. was our maitre'd and he was the absolute best. He made sure everything ran smooth from start to finish and went above and beyond. Everything was perfect, the ceremony, food, service and accommodations. I would recommend The Olde Mill Inn to anyone. Thank you to John and Lindsey and the entire Olde Mill Inn staff.
The Olde Mill Inn was the perfect venue for our wedding ceremony and reception. From the start, Lindsey S. guided me Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn was the perfect venue for our wedding ceremony and reception. From the start, Lindsey S. guided me through the entire process with professionalism and amazing hospitality. She was so good to me that I decided to have my bridal shower at The Grain House, which was spectacular. John L. was our maitre'd and he was the absolute best. He made sure everything ran smooth from start to finish and went above and beyond. Everything was perfect, the ceremony, food, service and accommodations. I would recommend The Olde Mill Inn to anyone. Thank you to John and Lindsey and the entire Olde Mill Inn staff. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you for your kind testimonial. We were thrilled to have hosted your special wedding day! Please, please share some photos with us.

Wishing you the very best!!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
amanda
Wedding:
7/27/2013
5.0/5.0
I wish there were more stars...
When I was searching for wedding venues, I went to five different ones in one day. Starting with a place who bragged about making a bride cry because she waited too long to put her deposit down, then to a place who asked me if I had the kind of "daddy" who would give me more money for the wedding if I cried and batted my eye lashes and ended with the Olde Mill Inn. My mom and I walked into the venue without an appointment and down walked Marien, an extremely upbeat lady who told us if we had our wedding here, it would be a party!! We were hooked. Marien was our matre d extraordinaire! She answered every annoying email and phone call from me this year very quickly and was EXTREMELLY organized throughout the process. The food was amazing and several guests asked if the cocktail hour was the dinner. The steaks were cooked the way guests ordered and the vendors Marien suggested were wonderful. Our guest also loved having our rehearsal dinner and post nuptial breakfast on the property. Everything was contained to one spot so the party didn't stop all weekend. As an extremely picky bride, I have absolutely no complaints. Make the right choice and book the Olde Mill!!!
I wish there were more stars...
When I was searching for wedding venues, I went to five different ones in one day. Read more...
I wish there were more stars...
When I was searching for wedding venues, I went to five different ones in one day. Starting with a place who bragged about making a bride cry because she waited too long to put her deposit down, then to a place who asked me if I had the kind of "daddy" who would give me more money for the wedding if I cried and batted my eye lashes and ended with the Olde Mill Inn. My mom and I walked into the venue without an appointment and down walked Marien, an extremely upbeat lady who told us if we had our wedding here, it would be a party!! We were hooked. Marien was our matre d extraordinaire! She answered every annoying email and phone call from me this year very quickly and was EXTREMELLY organized throughout the process. The food was amazing and several guests asked if the cocktail hour was the dinner. The steaks were cooked the way guests ordered and the vendors Marien suggested were wonderful. Our guest also loved having our rehearsal dinner and post nuptial breakfast on the property. Everything was contained to one spot so the party didn't stop all weekend. As an extremely picky bride, I have absolutely no complaints. Make the right choice and book the Olde Mill!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Awww, your testimonial is so appeciated...we are delighted to have been chosen as your host venue....thank you for taking the time and post your sentiments....please, share photos with us....on behalf of Marien and the staff, THANK YOU!!

Kind regards,
Catherine Notaro-Schweitzer
Director of Sales & Catering
908-696-2311
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Mary Anne
Wedding:
7/20/2013
5.0/5.0
I can't say enough wonderful things about the Olde Mill Inn. The staff was so pleasant to work with by the end of the wedding planning process, I felt like they were family. John, who ran the event for the day, was extremely attentive and detail oriented, which made the day run so smoothly. The food was delicious, I received so many compliments from my guests. Not to mention, the gorgeous grounds. Overall, a top choice to hold your wedding or special event!
I can't say enough wonderful things about the Olde Mill Inn. The staff was so pleasant to work with by the end of the Read more...
I can't say enough wonderful things about the Olde Mill Inn. The staff was so pleasant to work with by the end of the wedding planning process, I felt like they were family. John, who ran the event for the day, was extremely attentive and detail oriented, which made the day run so smoothly. The food was delicious, I received so many compliments from my guests. Not to mention, the gorgeous grounds. Overall, a top choice to hold your wedding or special event! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you for your kind testimonial to our staff, Lindsey and John, Mary Anne! It was an honor and pleasure to host your shower and wedding celebration!

We hope to see you in the near future and please, share photos with us!

Take care and many blessings,
Catherine Notaro-Schweitzer
Director of Sales & Catering
908-696-2314
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lauren
Wedding:
7/19/2013
5.0/5.0
When looking at wedding venues, we took a trip up to OMI, and it was the 2nd venue we had looked at it. As soon as we walked up to the venue we fell in love with how nice the venue looked from the outside. After going in and seeing the inside we loved it even more. We met with Lindsay Stewart, and she was very helpful, and helped answer all of our questions. Throughout the process she was great, and very responsive. We never felt pressured at all working with Lindsay.

As for the actual wedding we worked with John Lietz, who was amazing. We met with him prior to the wedding, and he was very detailed, and patient with all of the questions we had. He helped us plan the day, and choose our menu. He was also really responsive when it came to answering questions we had. Throughout the night he did a great job of making sure we were eating, and drinking.

We are still receiving compliments on how amazing the wedding was, and how it was the best wedding our guests have been to. From the ceremony, the cocktail hour, the reception, the food, the wait staff. It was all amazing!

We would highly recommend the Olde Mill Inn to anyone looking for a venue for their wedding day!
When looking at wedding venues, we took a trip up to OMI, and it was the 2nd venue we had looked at it. As soon as we Read more...
When looking at wedding venues, we took a trip up to OMI, and it was the 2nd venue we had looked at it. As soon as we walked up to the venue we fell in love with how nice the venue looked from the outside. After going in and seeing the inside we loved it even more. We met with Lindsay Stewart, and she was very helpful, and helped answer all of our questions. Throughout the process she was great, and very responsive. We never felt pressured at all working with Lindsay.

As for the actual wedding we worked with John Lietz, who was amazing. We met with him prior to the wedding, and he was very detailed, and patient with all of the questions we had. He helped us plan the day, and choose our menu. He was also really responsive when it came to answering questions we had. Throughout the night he did a great job of making sure we were eating, and drinking.

We are still receiving compliments on how amazing the wedding was, and how it was the best wedding our guests have been to. From the ceremony, the cocktail hour, the reception, the food, the wait staff. It was all amazing!

We would highly recommend the Olde Mill Inn to anyone looking for a venue for their wedding day! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you Lauren for your lovely testimonial...we were delighted to have been chosen to host your special wedding day!

Lindsay delivers the highest level of hospitality, service and truly takes all of our events to heart!

Please stop by and make sure you share photos...we'd be delighted to frame one and display at the Olde Mill Inn!

Kind regards and blessings,
Catherine Notaro-Schweitzer
Director of Sales and Catering
908-696-2315
Default-vendor-profile-pic
francine
Wedding:
6/23/2013
5.0/5.0
There are truly not enough nice words to say about the Olde Mill Inn! Just married on 6/23/13 and my husband and I cannot be more pleased with everything. All the staff were extremely helpful any time help was needed. I even had guests comment on their experience with booking a room for the night! The venue was perfect for us. It was truly a cozy, relaxed wedding. All our friends and family loved the overall "feel" of the place, with the split floors, floral designs, grounds around the outside, it was perfect! Of course I also have to mention having Marien the extraordinary, amazing, phenomenal woman that she is as our maitre d. This woman was heavensent! She made it all happen smoothly. My husband and I can't thank her enough for all her help! One of the biggest compliments a friend made was when she asked me if we hired a wedding planner!! That was allll Marien! I highly recommend having any function at the Olde Mill Inn!
There are truly not enough nice words to say about the Olde Mill Inn! Just married on 6/23/13 and my husband and I cannot Read more...
There are truly not enough nice words to say about the Olde Mill Inn! Just married on 6/23/13 and my husband and I cannot be more pleased with everything. All the staff were extremely helpful any time help was needed. I even had guests comment on their experience with booking a room for the night! The venue was perfect for us. It was truly a cozy, relaxed wedding. All our friends and family loved the overall "feel" of the place, with the split floors, floral designs, grounds around the outside, it was perfect! Of course I also have to mention having Marien the extraordinary, amazing, phenomenal woman that she is as our maitre d. This woman was heavensent! She made it all happen smoothly. My husband and I can't thank her enough for all her help! One of the biggest compliments a friend made was when she asked me if we hired a wedding planner!! That was allll Marien! I highly recommend having any function at the Olde Mill Inn! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you for taking the time and post your beautiful testimonial...on behalf of Marien and the staff of the Olde Mill Inn and Grain House, thank you, thank you, and, thank you!

Please be sure to stop in or, email photos..

Kind regards,
Catherine Notaro-Schweitzer
Director of Sales & Catering
90-8-696-2311
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Alexandra
Wedding:
6/15/2013
5.0/5.0
Thank You to the Grain House and staff for the superb customer service. We had a wonderful time as did our guests. Our guests raved about the food and surroundings. I would recommend this place to all.
Thank You to the Grain House and staff for the superb customer service. We had a wonderful time as did our guests. Our Read more...
Thank You to the Grain House and staff for the superb customer service. We had a wonderful time as did our guests. Our guests raved about the food and surroundings. I would recommend this place to all. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Hi and thank you for the kind post...we are honored to have hosted your special day...by all means, share photos...we love to scatter photos throughout our hotel and restaurant....

Best wishes,
Catherine Notaro-Schweitzer
Director of Sales and Catering
908-696-2311
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kathryn
Wedding:
5/26/2013
5.0/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn was an amazing place for our wedding. We couldn't have asked for a more wonderful day. All our needs were attended to, the food was delicious and the staff was more than accommodating. Our maitre'd John was incredible--he was like the energizer bunny and made sure everything flowed smoothly. He was patient with us and listened to all our questions and concerns from the beginning. He did an amazing job and took care of all the details so my husband and I got to actually enjoy our wedding! We have nothing but wonderful things to say and got tons of compliments from our guests who had a great time. People couldn't believe our amazing cocktail hour and all the food that was provided. The hotel room was beautiful and we were floored when we walked in with two fresh meals cooked just for us (since we were busy dancing during dinner) and pastries and desserts. We felt so well taken care of. Our personal attendant was fantastic--I never had to ask her for anything the entire night and she made sure we had drinks and food and anything we needed. The personal attention was just incredible. The Grain House is an awesome venue for a wedding and we just loved every minute of it. We wish we could have a wedding there every weekend! Thank you Olde Mill Inn for a fantastic experience!
The Olde Mill Inn was an amazing place for our wedding. We couldn't have asked for a more wonderful day. All our needs Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn was an amazing place for our wedding. We couldn't have asked for a more wonderful day. All our needs were attended to, the food was delicious and the staff was more than accommodating. Our maitre'd John was incredible--he was like the energizer bunny and made sure everything flowed smoothly. He was patient with us and listened to all our questions and concerns from the beginning. He did an amazing job and took care of all the details so my husband and I got to actually enjoy our wedding! We have nothing but wonderful things to say and got tons of compliments from our guests who had a great time. People couldn't believe our amazing cocktail hour and all the food that was provided. The hotel room was beautiful and we were floored when we walked in with two fresh meals cooked just for us (since we were busy dancing during dinner) and pastries and desserts. We felt so well taken care of. Our personal attendant was fantastic--I never had to ask her for anything the entire night and she made sure we had drinks and food and anything we needed. The personal attention was just incredible. The Grain House is an awesome venue for a wedding and we just loved every minute of it. We wish we could have a wedding there every weekend! Thank you Olde Mill Inn for a fantastic experience! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

On behalf of John Lietz and the staff of the Olde Mill Inn and Grain House, thank you for taking the time and post this lovely testimonial...we are grateful to have had the opportunity in being your choice of venue...please be sure to share some photos...we love to scatter photos throughout our hotel levels...once again, thank you!

Kind regards,
Catherine Notaro-Schweitzer
Director of Sales & Catering
908-696-2311
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Emily
Wedding:
3/23/2013
5.0/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn was a magical place to have our wedding! The ambiance, food and professional staff were impeccable. We also loved that the Inn was attached which made it convienient for all of our out of town guests and let us continue to mingle both later that night and in the morning. John was a wonderful Maitre D and helped make the day run completely smooth. We highly recommend the Olde Mill Inn.
The Olde Mill Inn was a magical place to have our wedding! The ambiance, food and professional staff were impeccable. We Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn was a magical place to have our wedding! The ambiance, food and professional staff were impeccable. We also loved that the Inn was attached which made it convienient for all of our out of town guests and let us continue to mingle both later that night and in the morning. John was a wonderful Maitre D and helped make the day run completely smooth. We highly recommend the Olde Mill Inn. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you on behalf of Marien and the staff at the Olde Mill Inn and Grain House for the lovely testimonial you have posted....we deeply appreciate the time and are delighted to have been chosen as your host venue...please, share phtos with us....once again, thank you!

Catherine Notaro-Schweitzer
Director of Sales & Catering
908-696-2311
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Emma
Wedding:
3/9/2013
5.0/5.0
Having my wedding reception at the Olde Mill Inn was an easy decision. The lobby, library, and courtyard are the perfect backdrops for pictures and video. The ballroom is so beautiful it barely needs to be decorated! The stunning grounds, cozy atmosphere, and friendly staff make guests feel welcome upon arrival. John Leitz, our Maitre D’, could not have been more accommodating. During the planning process he made himself constantly available and made final preparations easy! During the reception everything was taken care of so my husband and I were able to relax and enjoy the party! John was constantly checking to make sure our every need was met. He even personally got me a plate of food that I missed during cocktail hour. My husband said the service made him feel like a celebrity! The food was delicious and the bartenders were not stingy with the alcohol! Our guests raved about the clean and luxurious hotel rooms. I cannot say enough about the staff at the Olde Mill Inn; housekeeping, waiters, bartenders, and especially John Leitz made our wedding day everything we dreamed of.
Having my wedding reception at the Olde Mill Inn was an easy decision. The lobby, library, and courtyard are the perfect Read more...
Having my wedding reception at the Olde Mill Inn was an easy decision. The lobby, library, and courtyard are the perfect backdrops for pictures and video. The ballroom is so beautiful it barely needs to be decorated! The stunning grounds, cozy atmosphere, and friendly staff make guests feel welcome upon arrival. John Leitz, our Maitre D’, could not have been more accommodating. During the planning process he made himself constantly available and made final preparations easy! During the reception everything was taken care of so my husband and I were able to relax and enjoy the party! John was constantly checking to make sure our every need was met. He even personally got me a plate of food that I missed during cocktail hour. My husband said the service made him feel like a celebrity! The food was delicious and the bartenders were not stingy with the alcohol! Our guests raved about the clean and luxurious hotel rooms. I cannot say enough about the staff at the Olde Mill Inn; housekeeping, waiters, bartenders, and especially John Leitz made our wedding day everything we dreamed of. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you for taking the time and post your lovely sentiments...it was our honor to have hosted your special wedding celebration...On behalf of John and the entire staff, thank you!!

Please be sure to share photos....

Kind regards,
Catherine Notaro-Schweitzer
Director of Sales & Catering
908-696-2311
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Alicia
Wedding:
1/5/2013
5.0/5.0
I recently had a Saturday night wedding with 175 people at the Olde Mill Inn. I cannot say enough good things about how my wedding turned out. I never pictured an indoor, winter wedding but once we saw the venue we couldn't imagine doing it any other way. It was decorated beautifully for the holidays and had such a warm, cozy ambiance for all the guests. We had Marien as both our wedding coordinator AND our Maitre D the night of. She is absolutely wonderful. Sometimes when I was feeling stressed, Marien was the person that would make me feel the most calm. She went over every detail with us multiple times so that I never felt unclear of what was going on. She never got frustrated with my millions of emails and questions. During the wedding, she checked in with us a lot to make sure we were getting everything we wanted out of the experience even up until we went back to our room where she brought us all the things we hadn't gotten to try during the wedding. I even had guests comment on how great she was. I have had a lot of guests already tell me it was one of the best weddings they had been to, how great the food was (it was! yum!), how much they loved there rooms, and overall how beautiful the venue was. I would highly recommend the Olde Mill Inn to anyone looking to get married in the area!
I recently had a Saturday night wedding with 175 people at the Olde Mill Inn. I cannot say enough good things about how my Read more...
I recently had a Saturday night wedding with 175 people at the Olde Mill Inn. I cannot say enough good things about how my wedding turned out. I never pictured an indoor, winter wedding but once we saw the venue we couldn't imagine doing it any other way. It was decorated beautifully for the holidays and had such a warm, cozy ambiance for all the guests. We had Marien as both our wedding coordinator AND our Maitre D the night of. She is absolutely wonderful. Sometimes when I was feeling stressed, Marien was the person that would make me feel the most calm. She went over every detail with us multiple times so that I never felt unclear of what was going on. She never got frustrated with my millions of emails and questions. During the wedding, she checked in with us a lot to make sure we were getting everything we wanted out of the experience even up until we went back to our room where she brought us all the things we hadn't gotten to try during the wedding. I even had guests comment on how great she was. I have had a lot of guests already tell me it was one of the best weddings they had been to, how great the food was (it was! yum!), how much they loved there rooms, and overall how beautiful the venue was. I would highly recommend the Olde Mill Inn to anyone looking to get married in the area! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

On behalf of Marien, the owners, associates and our General Manager Alicia, thank you for the lovely testimonial letter. We were and shall remain honored to have hosted your beautiful wedding celebration.
Please stop by and share photos with us....perhaps you'd consider gifting us with a photo that we could display in our hotel?
Best Wishes,
Catherine Notaro-Schweitzer
Director of Sales & Catering
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Alexa
Wedding:
12/31/2012
5.0/5.0
My husband and I just had our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn on NYE in the Washington Ballroom. We had 200 people and there was PLENTY of room. There was even a flat screen TV for the ball drop! Everything was amazing and exceeded our expectations! The service was fantastic and every person we encountered went out of their way to help us. We started the wedding planning with Lindsey Smilie who answered every single question we had, and usually it was within hours of us writing to her! When it was time for our tasting, we had awesome service and we were walked through each and every part of the night in terms of food. Once it got closer, our Maitre D Marien, contacted us for our final walk through. Marien is AMAZING!!! If you can request her, do it, she will take care of everything. We went through every single detail and when we didn't know the answer to a question, Marien was there with an answer. She took care of everything the night of the wedding and even our guests noticed! They commented on how smoothly everything went and how Marien was on top of every detail! At the end of the night, Marien came to our room with Champange, strawberries, and lots of food from the wedding in case we didn't get to taste it. All of our friends said that this was one of their favorite weddings! We would 100% recommend The Olde Mill Inn to anyone considering having their wedding there!
My husband and I just had our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn on NYE in the Washington Ballroom. We had 200 people and there Read more...
My husband and I just had our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn on NYE in the Washington Ballroom. We had 200 people and there was PLENTY of room. There was even a flat screen TV for the ball drop! Everything was amazing and exceeded our expectations! The service was fantastic and every person we encountered went out of their way to help us. We started the wedding planning with Lindsey Smilie who answered every single question we had, and usually it was within hours of us writing to her! When it was time for our tasting, we had awesome service and we were walked through each and every part of the night in terms of food. Once it got closer, our Maitre D Marien, contacted us for our final walk through. Marien is AMAZING!!! If you can request her, do it, she will take care of everything. We went through every single detail and when we didn't know the answer to a question, Marien was there with an answer. She took care of everything the night of the wedding and even our guests noticed! They commented on how smoothly everything went and how Marien was on top of every detail! At the end of the night, Marien came to our room with Champange, strawberries, and lots of food from the wedding in case we didn't get to taste it. All of our friends said that this was one of their favorite weddings! We would 100% recommend The Olde Mill Inn to anyone considering having their wedding there! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Congratulations and Happy New Year Alexa and Andrew,

Thank you for taking the time and write the Wedding Wire review board...your testimonial is lovely!

We were honored to host your wedding this past New Year's Eve...I will be sure to make Lindsey and Marien aware of your wonderful review.

Once again, thank you and I wish you the very best.....come visit soon and share your photos!!

Catherine Notaro Schweitzer
Director of Sales & Catering
Default-vendor-profile-pic
kyla
Wedding:
12/30/2012
5.0/5.0
I knew the moment i saw the Olde Mill inn and walked inside that this would be a beautiful place to get married. My husband and i totaly fell in love with the venue and all the staff! Once booking our wedding they were so accomodating! Everything from the beginning went perfect. I really cant say enough about the olde mill inn! We got married Dec 30, 2012 so the holiday decoration was goregous and we were lucky enough to have snow on the ground for outside photos! We had our ceremony inside and it was so romantic and intimate! The food is to die for, they give you so much during the cocktail hour- especially our favorite the mashed potato bar! All of our family and friends continure to rave about it! If you are looking for a venue that will exceed your expectations and have a better wedding then you picture in you head, this is the place for you! Thank you so much olde mill inn staff! and a special thanks to John Lietz our Matire d & Lindsey Smilie our sales manager! It was perfect and we couldnt have asked for more! Best day of our lives!
I knew the moment i saw the Olde Mill inn and walked inside that this would be a beautiful place to get married. My Read more...
I knew the moment i saw the Olde Mill inn and walked inside that this would be a beautiful place to get married. My husband and i totaly fell in love with the venue and all the staff! Once booking our wedding they were so accomodating! Everything from the beginning went perfect. I really cant say enough about the olde mill inn! We got married Dec 30, 2012 so the holiday decoration was goregous and we were lucky enough to have snow on the ground for outside photos! We had our ceremony inside and it was so romantic and intimate! The food is to die for, they give you so much during the cocktail hour- especially our favorite the mashed potato bar! All of our family and friends continure to rave about it! If you are looking for a venue that will exceed your expectations and have a better wedding then you picture in you head, this is the place for you! Thank you so much olde mill inn staff! and a special thanks to John Lietz our Matire d & Lindsey Smilie our sales manager! It was perfect and we couldnt have asked for more! Best day of our lives! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you for taking the time and write such a lovely testimonial...we were honored to have hosted your wedding celebration. We would be thrilled to see you in the near future....by all means, please stop in and share your photos with us.

On behalf of the entire staff, thank you and we wish you the very best!

Kind regards,
Catherine Notaro-Schweitzer
Director of Sales and Catering
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jonathan
Wedding:
12/29/2012
5.0/5.0
We loved the Old Mill Inn! Marien Barker was our coordinator and did an amazing job. The staff of the OMI could not have been nicer. The food was amazing and the service excellent. The hotel was such a beautiful setting for the reception and for the guests who stayed over. Our wedding day was more than we could have dreamed! Thank you Olde Mill Inn for helping make the day so memorable and special.
We loved the Old Mill Inn! Marien Barker was our coordinator and did an amazing job. The staff of the OMI could not have Read more...
We loved the Old Mill Inn! Marien Barker was our coordinator and did an amazing job. The staff of the OMI could not have been nicer. The food was amazing and the service excellent. The hotel was such a beautiful setting for the reception and for the guests who stayed over. Our wedding day was more than we could have dreamed! Thank you Olde Mill Inn for helping make the day so memorable and special. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you for your lovely testimonial....we were honored to have hosted your wedding celebration and hope to see you in the near future. By all means, stop in and share your wedding photos with us.

As soon as Marien arrives to work today, I will have her read your blog...thank you ever so much!

Wishing you the very best,
Catherine Notaro-Schweitzer
Director of Sales and Catering
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Maura
Wedding:
11/23/2012
5.0/5.0
The picturesque and cozy Olde Mill Inn exceeded our expectations in every way! Everyone was extremely helpful & accommodating making our guests feel comfortable & welcomed! Our maître de Marien was amazing! Marien was extremely knowledgeable, confident and experienced which made us at ease! Our guests are still talking about how great the food was at the OMI and what a beautiful venue! We can't wait to attend another wedding there!
The picturesque and cozy Olde Mill Inn exceeded our expectations in every way! Everyone was extremely helpful & Read more...
The picturesque and cozy Olde Mill Inn exceeded our expectations in every way! Everyone was extremely helpful & accommodating making our guests feel comfortable & welcomed! Our maître de Marien was amazing! Marien was extremely knowledgeable, confident and experienced which made us at ease! Our guests are still talking about how great the food was at the OMI and what a beautiful venue! We can't wait to attend another wedding there! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Dear Maura,
Thank you for taking the time to write and share your exceeded expectations and delivery of our staff, food service, overnight accommodations and your Maitre d' Marien's experience putting all at ease while celebrating your wedding festivities....I will be sure to pass on your lovely testimonial to all!

We would be so appreciative if you shared photos with us...thank you and the very best for a wonderful union!!

Kind regards,
Catherine Notaro-Schweitzer
Director of Sales & Catering
908-696-2311
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Marilyn
Wedding:
10/14/2012
5.0/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn in Basking Ridge, NJ was the perfect setting for our wedding and ceremony! The accommodations are on-location as well as a beautiful wedding reception venue and ceremony courtyard. There is a lovely "after party" site, The Grain House, in walking distance of the hotel across the parking lot. Our guests were in awe of the attention to every detail, outstanding food, and service. How often can one say that an event EXCEEDS expectations; ours clearly did! You will be delighted with your experience!
The Olde Mill Inn in Basking Ridge, NJ was the perfect setting for our wedding and ceremony! The accommodations are Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn in Basking Ridge, NJ was the perfect setting for our wedding and ceremony! The accommodations are on-location as well as a beautiful wedding reception venue and ceremony courtyard. There is a lovely "after party" site, The Grain House, in walking distance of the hotel across the parking lot. Our guests were in awe of the attention to every detail, outstanding food, and service. How often can one say that an event EXCEEDS expectations; ours clearly did! You will be delighted with your experience! Read less
Services Used: Catering, Wedding Planning, Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jo-Ann
Wedding:
10/13/2012
5.0/5.0
We had our entire wedding at the Olde Mill Inn from the ceremony to the reception. Our sales person was Marien Barker and she was absolutely amazing. She sat us down and we went through every piece of information from start to finish and she didn't let us walk away until we understood everything that was happening. We booked the venue in early 2012 and the wedding wasn't until 10-13-12. During that time, she quickly answered any emails I sent, returned any phone calls I made and would generally reach out to me if she didn't hear from us in a while. She was very attentive. I was thrilled when I found out she would be our Maitre D. We even planned our rehearsal dinner at the Olde Mill Inn because she was so easy to work with. Everything from the rehearsal dinner all the way to the reception went perfectly. There were no major problems and most of the issues, Marien handled right away. We even had special forks for our cake cutting which we both forget to tell the servers about. Once that was done, they took the forks thinking they were ordinary banquet forks. I contacted Marien 2 days later to tell her that we didn't get the back. She had the whole staff looking and they actually found them and returned them wrapped in tissue paper with a pink ribbon! I couldn't believe it. Besides that, our friends and family have told us it was the best wedding they have ever been too. They are still talking about the food (which was so amazing!) I would tell anyone to have their wedding there if they could. The Olde Mill has 2 rooms. The main ballroom for large wedding and the Grain House for small weddings. Both have outdoor ceremony sites and they even have back up plans in place for rain.
We had our entire wedding at the Olde Mill Inn from the ceremony to the reception. Our sales person was Marien Barker and Read more...
We had our entire wedding at the Olde Mill Inn from the ceremony to the reception. Our sales person was Marien Barker and she was absolutely amazing. She sat us down and we went through every piece of information from start to finish and she didn't let us walk away until we understood everything that was happening. We booked the venue in early 2012 and the wedding wasn't until 10-13-12. During that time, she quickly answered any emails I sent, returned any phone calls I made and would generally reach out to me if she didn't hear from us in a while. She was very attentive. I was thrilled when I found out she would be our Maitre D. We even planned our rehearsal dinner at the Olde Mill Inn because she was so easy to work with. Everything from the rehearsal dinner all the way to the reception went perfectly. There were no major problems and most of the issues, Marien handled right away. We even had special forks for our cake cutting which we both forget to tell the servers about. Once that was done, they took the forks thinking they were ordinary banquet forks. I contacted Marien 2 days later to tell her that we didn't get the back. She had the whole staff looking and they actually found them and returned them wrapped in tissue paper with a pink ribbon! I couldn't believe it. Besides that, our friends and family have told us it was the best wedding they have ever been too. They are still talking about the food (which was so amazing!) I would tell anyone to have their wedding there if they could. The Olde Mill has 2 rooms. The main ballroom for large wedding and the Grain House for small weddings. Both have outdoor ceremony sites and they even have back up plans in place for rain. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Rae
Wedding:
10/12/2012
5.0/5.0
OMI was amazing it couldn't have been a better wedding Lindsay Stewart is amazing and took such great care of us! Food is delicious and the service is just beyond comparison. Thank you for making our big day the best day ever!!!! <3
OMI was amazing it couldn't have been a better wedding Lindsay Stewart is amazing and took such great care of us! Food is Read more...
OMI was amazing it couldn't have been a better wedding Lindsay Stewart is amazing and took such great care of us! Food is delicious and the service is just beyond comparison. Thank you for making our big day the best day ever!!!! <3 Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you for taking the time and email such a lovely testimonial on behalf of the Olde Mill Inn's staff to include Lindsay....most appreciated and, we wish you a lifetime of health, happiness, and love!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Stephanie
Wedding:
9/29/2012
5.0/5.0
John is THE maitre d to have. Even my mother, who was stressed about him executing every detail of the wedding and setting up all of her decorations and things JUST how she wanted them, had to admit it came out just as she'd hoped - and even better. As the bride, John was incredibly accommodating - him and his staff made sure I had whatever I wanted to eat, whatever I needed to drink, and even helped me with my bustle before going into the cocktail hour. I didn't even have to go to the bar for a drink the entire night. The ceremony was outside in the courtyard and was gorgeous - especially with the Christmas lights in the tree lit up. Him and his staff made sure everything was brought up to our room after the wedding, including leftover cake and desserts. He even made sure to bring my mum's dinner up to her room when he saw that she was so nervous she couldn't eat during the reception. Plus, we had a little "incident" with a guest of a guest, which OMI handled very delicately to the point that very few other guests even knew what had happened. They were complete professionals and I would whole-heartedly recommend them.
John is THE maitre d to have. Even my mother, who was stressed about him executing every detail of the wedding and setting Read more...
John is THE maitre d to have. Even my mother, who was stressed about him executing every detail of the wedding and setting up all of her decorations and things JUST how she wanted them, had to admit it came out just as she'd hoped - and even better. As the bride, John was incredibly accommodating - him and his staff made sure I had whatever I wanted to eat, whatever I needed to drink, and even helped me with my bustle before going into the cocktail hour. I didn't even have to go to the bar for a drink the entire night. The ceremony was outside in the courtyard and was gorgeous - especially with the Christmas lights in the tree lit up. Him and his staff made sure everything was brought up to our room after the wedding, including leftover cake and desserts. He even made sure to bring my mum's dinner up to her room when he saw that she was so nervous she couldn't eat during the reception. Plus, we had a little "incident" with a guest of a guest, which OMI handled very delicately to the point that very few other guests even knew what had happened. They were complete professionals and I would whole-heartedly recommend them. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
130x130_sq_1349917087569-kissingattheendofaisle
Mrs.
Wedding:
9/21/2012
5.0/5.0
I can not say enough good things about my entire experience with the Olde Mill. From my first interactions with Lindsey to finally getting to work with our Maitre D John I had such a welcome feeling. The staff was extremely helpful and courteous in every aspect of the wedding planning process. Our wedding was beautiful and we couldn't have done it all without the help of everyone at The Olde Mill.
I can not say enough good things about my entire experience with the Olde Mill. From my first interactions with Lindsey to Read more...
I can not say enough good things about my entire experience with the Olde Mill. From my first interactions with Lindsey to finally getting to work with our Maitre D John I had such a welcome feeling. The staff was extremely helpful and courteous in every aspect of the wedding planning process. Our wedding was beautiful and we couldn't have done it all without the help of everyone at The Olde Mill. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

The honor of hosting your beautiful wedding celebration was and will continue to be all ours! We wish you the very best!!!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Eva
Wedding:
9/15/2012
5.0/5.0
5 stars is not enough! this place really truly went above and beyond to make our day perfect from start to finish! Our Maitre D’ Marien Barker was a doll ! She helped me every step of the way even doing things beyond her role !The entire staff at the Olde Mill Inn was amazing! We had both our rehearsal dinner & wedding there & the service as well as the food were impeccable. They put out a spread meant for royalty, the highest quality & so much of it & might I say very reasonably priced! We highly recommend The Olde Mill Inn & will be using them for future family functions! All our guests can't stop raving how amazing everything was & how it was the best wedding & venue they have been to . Some even spoke of booking the venue themselves! When you hear that from everyone guest makes you happy & 5 stars is not enough!
5 stars is not enough! this place really truly went above and beyond to make our day perfect from start to finish! Our Read more...
5 stars is not enough! this place really truly went above and beyond to make our day perfect from start to finish! Our Maitre D’ Marien Barker was a doll ! She helped me every step of the way even doing things beyond her role !The entire staff at the Olde Mill Inn was amazing! We had both our rehearsal dinner & wedding there & the service as well as the food were impeccable. They put out a spread meant for royalty, the highest quality & so much of it & might I say very reasonably priced! We highly recommend The Olde Mill Inn & will be using them for future family functions! All our guests can't stop raving how amazing everything was & how it was the best wedding & venue they have been to . Some even spoke of booking the venue themselves! When you hear that from everyone guest makes you happy & 5 stars is not enough! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Dear Eva,
Thank you for taking the time and write to wedding wire on behalf of your special wedding celebration hosted by the staff at The Olde Mill Inn!
We are honored that you chose our facility and hope that you will visit in the very near future and share photos with Marien....we love to display photos of our wedding family....wishing you and yours the happiest, healthiest, and loving marriage!!!!
Kind regards,
Catherine Notaro-Schweitzer
Director of Sales & Catering
908-696-2311
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Megan
Wedding:
8/25/2012
5.0/5.0
We recently had our ceremony & reception at the OMI. The venue is beautiful, all of our guests were able to stay at the hotel, and we couldn't have asked for better service. Our maitre'd, Marien, was phenomenal - she took care of every single detail, making sure we had nothing to worry about, and kept us happy throughout the entire event.
We recently had our ceremony & reception at the OMI. The venue is beautiful, all of our guests were able to stay at the Read more...
We recently had our ceremony & reception at the OMI. The venue is beautiful, all of our guests were able to stay at the hotel, and we couldn't have asked for better service. Our maitre'd, Marien, was phenomenal - she took care of every single detail, making sure we had nothing to worry about, and kept us happy throughout the entire event. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Dear Megan,
Thank you for honoring our staff at The Olde Mill Inn and choosing the staff as your hosts! The pleasure was and shall always remain, all ours.
We hope you visit in the near future and share your photos as you may have noticed, we love displaying photos of our brides and grooms that celebrated their union at our facility! May your union be filled with love, happiness and health!!!
Kind regards,
Catherine Notaro-Schweitzer
Director of Sales and Catering
908-696-2311
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
8/25/2012
5.0/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn Grain House was the perfect location for our wedding! From the initial inquiry to the day of, everything was perfect. Lindsey and Victoria were fantastic wedding planners and I knew the wedding would be perfect. The food was absolutely delicious and the bartenders are even better! The adjoining hotel was amazing for our guests as well. I highly recommend this wedding venue!
The Olde Mill Inn Grain House was the perfect location for our wedding! From the initial inquiry to the day of, everything Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn Grain House was the perfect location for our wedding! From the initial inquiry to the day of, everything was perfect. Lindsey and Victoria were fantastic wedding planners and I knew the wedding would be perfect. The food was absolutely delicious and the bartenders are even better! The adjoining hotel was amazing for our guests as well. I highly recommend this wedding venue! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you for taking the time and email the Wedding Wire on behalf of the service you received from the staff at The Olde Mill Inn while celebrating your wedding.....most kind of you! Please know, we were honored and hope that you visit soon and share photos.....I would have addressed you by your proper name however, a name was not provided....thank you once again......
Kind regards,
Catherine Notaro-Schweitzer
Director of Sales & Catering
908-696-2311
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kate
Wedding:
8/18/2012
5.0/5.0
I had my wedding at the Olde Mill Inn this summer, and it was absolutely perfect! Everyone who works at the OMI are wonderful people and true professionals. They could not have been more accommodating, and went above and beyond to make sure all of our guests had a wonderful experience there. Working with John as our Maitre D was such a huge reason why everything went so smoothly on our actual wedding day. Leading up to it he was extremely responsive and helpful. He could not have done more to make sure every last detail was taken care of - and let's just say I had A LOT of little details :) The night of our wedding he took care of my husband and I, and made sure we didn't have to worry about a thing. The food was great, the ballroom looked beautiful, and we were lucky enough to have gorgeous weather so we could enjoy the outdoor courtyard. I would highly recommend the OMI and could not have been happier that we chose it as our venue.
I had my wedding at the Olde Mill Inn this summer, and it was absolutely perfect! Everyone who works at the OMI are Read more...
I had my wedding at the Olde Mill Inn this summer, and it was absolutely perfect! Everyone who works at the OMI are wonderful people and true professionals. They could not have been more accommodating, and went above and beyond to make sure all of our guests had a wonderful experience there. Working with John as our Maitre D was such a huge reason why everything went so smoothly on our actual wedding day. Leading up to it he was extremely responsive and helpful. He could not have done more to make sure every last detail was taken care of - and let's just say I had A LOT of little details :) The night of our wedding he took care of my husband and I, and made sure we didn't have to worry about a thing. The food was great, the ballroom looked beautiful, and we were lucky enough to have gorgeous weather so we could enjoy the outdoor courtyard. I would highly recommend the OMI and could not have been happier that we chose it as our venue. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jennifer
Wedding:
7/7/2012
5.0/5.0
The whole place is beautiful and the food is fantastic. Our Maitre'D was extrememly attentive and we did not want for anything that night. I want everyone I know to get married there!!!
The whole place is beautiful and the food is fantastic. Our Maitre'D was extrememly attentive and we did not want for Read more...
The whole place is beautiful and the food is fantastic. Our Maitre'D was extrememly attentive and we did not want for anything that night. I want everyone I know to get married there!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Dear Jennifer,
thank you for your kind email to wedding wire....most appreciated!
We hope to see you in the near future and please bring wedding photos...we love to display them throughout our Inn!
Very Best,
Catherine Notaro-Schweitzer
Director of Sales & Catering
908-696-2311
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kelly
Wedding:
6/30/2012
5.0/5.0
Our wedding was absolute perfection! The staff, food, quality of service and flexibility made it an even more special day. All of our guests said it was the best wedding they've been to. We could not have been happier with the amazing service we received.
Our wedding was absolute perfection! The staff, food, quality of service and flexibility made it an even more special day. Read more...
Our wedding was absolute perfection! The staff, food, quality of service and flexibility made it an even more special day. All of our guests said it was the best wedding they've been to. We could not have been happier with the amazing service we received. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
valerie
Wedding:
6/23/2012
5.0/5.0
From my first encounter with Allan the Front Desk Manager and his efficient and willing staff through the meetings with our planner Lindsey Smillie and our Maitre'D Vitoria Vicari everything was handled with professionalism, courtesy, patience, kindness and a genuine desire to make our wedding day and the planning for it work seamlessly. The venue itself was beautiful, the Inn rooms lovely (especially apprecaited the "green" commitment of the hotel). The Inn runs like a Swiss watch and all staff were pleasant, greeting us with open smiles. Lindsey and Victoria guided us through the myriad of decisions needed to be made and helped us select outside vendors for flowers, music, photography and a warm and wonderful officiant Rev. John Graf. Somerset Hills Florist, Sweet Music and Stephen Taylor Photography did a superb job enhancing our wedding day beautifully. Victoria watched over us through our rehearsal and early on in our wedding day through to its late afternoon conclusion. She was a quiet presence making sure everything went smoothly. The serving staff were wonderful.
From my first encounter with Allan the Front Desk Manager and his efficient and willing staff through the meetings with Read more...
From my first encounter with Allan the Front Desk Manager and his efficient and willing staff through the meetings with our planner Lindsey Smillie and our Maitre'D Vitoria Vicari everything was handled with professionalism, courtesy, patience, kindness and a genuine desire to make our wedding day and the planning for it work seamlessly. The venue itself was beautiful, the Inn rooms lovely (especially apprecaited the "green" commitment of the hotel). The Inn runs like a Swiss watch and all staff were pleasant, greeting us with open smiles. Lindsey and Victoria guided us through the myriad of decisions needed to be made and helped us select outside vendors for flowers, music, photography and a warm and wonderful officiant Rev. John Graf. Somerset Hills Florist, Sweet Music and Stephen Taylor Photography did a superb job enhancing our wedding day beautifully. Victoria watched over us through our rehearsal and early on in our wedding day through to its late afternoon conclusion. She was a quiet presence making sure everything went smoothly. The serving staff were wonderful. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
dyingfortruth
Wedding:
6/15/2012
5.0/5.0
Absolutely top notch! The wedding was so beautiful and they couldn't do enough for you throughout the day! Marien is absolutely amazing and really knows what she's doing! Wonderful to work with! The day went smoothly, everything was in it's place and we didn't have to worry about a thing! The food was fantastic! The rooms were comfortable and reasonably priced for my guests! The grounds are gorgeous and wonderful for taking pictures!

I would recommend it to ANYONE!
Absolutely top notch! The wedding was so beautiful and they couldn't do enough for you throughout the day! Marien is Read more...
Absolutely top notch! The wedding was so beautiful and they couldn't do enough for you throughout the day! Marien is absolutely amazing and really knows what she's doing! Wonderful to work with! The day went smoothly, everything was in it's place and we didn't have to worry about a thing! The food was fantastic! The rooms were comfortable and reasonably priced for my guests! The grounds are gorgeous and wonderful for taking pictures!

I would recommend it to ANYONE! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
5.0/5.0
I couldn't imagine having my wedding anywhere else. The setting was beautiful, the staff provided great service and the quality/quantity of the food was amazing. I would highly recommend Olde Mill to anyone.
I couldn't imagine having my wedding anywhere else. The setting was beautiful, the staff provided great service and the Read more...
I couldn't imagine having my wedding anywhere else. The setting was beautiful, the staff provided great service and the quality/quantity of the food was amazing. I would highly recommend Olde Mill to anyone. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake, Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
svd20715
Wedding:
5/27/2012
5.0/5.0
Wow! We just had our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn on 5/27/12 and we could not of dreamed of a better experience. Everything went smoothly, thanks to the incredible staff and our Maitre D,' John.

The hotel was beautiful and the rooms were so cute and comfortable. All of our guests came from out of town and the hotel was the perfect spot to accommodate everyone. Our suite was so big and lush! We were able to invite just about everyone up to party with us before and after the wedding! The hotel staff was superb and daily breakfast was nice and provided a place for everyone to meet in the mornings. The surrounding area, including Morristown, provided a variety of activities for our guests from shopping, dining, and visiting historical areas. Just perfect for all age groups and quiet enough to enjoy some down time at the hotel.

Ceremony - We had our ceremony outside near the gazebo by the Grain House restaurant across the parking lot from the hotel. It was exactly what we wanted, no one had to travel from ceremony site to reception to hotel, they were all right there! John and his staff did a wonderful scheduling everything and making sure it was all set up. In fact, both my husband I commented afterward that the "behind-the-scenes" work must have been quite a lot, but that everything was done perfectly without our overseeing anything at all on the day of.

Cocktail Hour - Perfectly done under the tent...my guests are still raving about the mashed potato bar! In fact, ALL of the food was some of the best we've ever had. Not just at a wedding, but ever! The guests were floored by the quantity and quality of the food served - we were so pleased.

Reception - At the Grain House's Hunt Room. This reception area is so glamorous...it is so well-decorated and feels so classy. The room itself is intimate but not stuffy or crowded. The dance floor and bar area accommodated our guests (about 60) and photo booth perfectly. My one complaint about this area was the lack of bathrooms - there is one large bathroom that allows for only one person at a time. Not a huge deal, but I did notice a few guests having to wait to use it. Adding just one additional bathroom would greatly improve this issue.

PROS:

John, our Maitre D' and his staff were so helpful and professional. They never rushed us or made us feel like we were bothering them with requests. All of them were friendly and seemed to really enjoy being there. We had John running around all night and he never seemed annoyed or stressed out!

The food and quality was excellent.

The little extras, such as providing menus, direction, and table cards were a big help. They also provided the delicious wedding cake through Palermo's. We also loved the tasting at the Grain House to try out the delicious food!

Seamless execution of our ideas and requests. John timed everything perfectly with our DJ, photobooth, and photographer. They even allowed us to have an after-party with a cash bar back at the hotel! Both my husband and I felt in good hands with John and the staff, which is crucial when you are alreadyu worried about everything else!

CONS:
Just one - the lack of additional bathrooms in the banquet room. Not a huge deal, but still a drawback.

Overall, we would HIGHLY recommend this venue to anyone looking for a beautiful wedding site. Stellar location, service, and food!
Wow! We just had our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn on 5/27/12 and we could not of dreamed of a better experience. Read more...
Wow! We just had our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn on 5/27/12 and we could not of dreamed of a better experience. Everything went smoothly, thanks to the incredible staff and our Maitre D,' John.

The hotel was beautiful and the rooms were so cute and comfortable. All of our guests came from out of town and the hotel was the perfect spot to accommodate everyone. Our suite was so big and lush! We were able to invite just about everyone up to party with us before and after the wedding! The hotel staff was superb and daily breakfast was nice and provided a place for everyone to meet in the mornings. The surrounding area, including Morristown, provided a variety of activities for our guests from shopping, dining, and visiting historical areas. Just perfect for all age groups and quiet enough to enjoy some down time at the hotel.

Ceremony - We had our ceremony outside near the gazebo by the Grain House restaurant across the parking lot from the hotel. It was exactly what we wanted, no one had to travel from ceremony site to reception to hotel, they were all right there! John and his staff did a wonderful scheduling everything and making sure it was all set up. In fact, both my husband I commented afterward that the "behind-the-scenes" work must have been quite a lot, but that everything was done perfectly without our overseeing anything at all on the day of.

Cocktail Hour - Perfectly done under the tent...my guests are still raving about the mashed potato bar! In fact, ALL of the food was some of the best we've ever had. Not just at a wedding, but ever! The guests were floored by the quantity and quality of the food served - we were so pleased.

Reception - At the Grain House's Hunt Room. This reception area is so glamorous...it is so well-decorated and feels so classy. The room itself is intimate but not stuffy or crowded. The dance floor and bar area accommodated our guests (about 60) and photo booth perfectly. My one complaint about this area was the lack of bathrooms - there is one large bathroom that allows for only one person at a time. Not a huge deal, but I did notice a few guests having to wait to use it. Adding just one additional bathroom would greatly improve this issue.

PROS:

John, our Maitre D' and his staff were so helpful and professional. They never rushed us or made us feel like we were bothering them with requests. All of them were friendly and seemed to really enjoy being there. We had John running around all night and he never seemed annoyed or stressed out!

The food and quality was excellent.

The little extras, such as providing menus, direction, and table cards were a big help. They also provided the delicious wedding cake through Palermo's. We also loved the tasting at the Grain House to try out the delicious food!

Seamless execution of our ideas and requests. John timed everything perfectly with our DJ, photobooth, and photographer. They even allowed us to have an after-party with a cash bar back at the hotel! Both my husband and I felt in good hands with John and the staff, which is crucial when you are alreadyu worried about everything else!

CONS:
Just one - the lack of additional bathrooms in the banquet room. Not a huge deal, but still a drawback.

Overall, we would HIGHLY recommend this venue to anyone looking for a beautiful wedding site. Stellar location, service, and food! Read less
Services Used: Catering, Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
ckpascale
Wedding:
5/12/2012
5.0/5.0
Everything about my wedding at the Olde Mill Inn was perfect. The entire staff was absolutely wonderful. Marien, our maitre d' , was so nice and made us feel like we were the most important people in the world. She even found me in the middle of the room while I was talking to guests to give me a cappuccino since she knew I wasn't sitting down any time soon! The waitstaff was very friendly and attentive. Everyone raved about the food. Luckily we had gorgeous weather and the courtyard was open. The pictures outside at night were amazing. I HIGHLY recommend having your wedding at the OMI :)
Everything about my wedding at the Olde Mill Inn was perfect. The entire staff was absolutely wonderful. Marien, our Read more...
Everything about my wedding at the Olde Mill Inn was perfect. The entire staff was absolutely wonderful. Marien, our maitre d' , was so nice and made us feel like we were the most important people in the world. She even found me in the middle of the room while I was talking to guests to give me a cappuccino since she knew I wasn't sitting down any time soon! The waitstaff was very friendly and attentive. Everyone raved about the food. Luckily we had gorgeous weather and the courtyard was open. The pictures outside at night were amazing. I HIGHLY recommend having your wedding at the OMI :) Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Mary Jane
Wedding:
4/14/2012
5.0/5.0
We had our reception at the Olde Mill Inn a few weeks ago and thought everything was beyond our expectation the service, food and organization were all wonderful. Marien Barker the event manager there was amazing to work with. She made sure everything was done to perfectly and that there was absolutely nothing that we had to worry about not only at the reception but also all the planning leading up to it. Compared to other venues we looked at in the area they definitely provide high quality service at a reasonable cost.
We had our reception at the Olde Mill Inn a few weeks ago and thought everything was beyond our expectation the service, Read more...
We had our reception at the Olde Mill Inn a few weeks ago and thought everything was beyond our expectation the service, food and organization were all wonderful. Marien Barker the event manager there was amazing to work with. She made sure everything was done to perfectly and that there was absolutely nothing that we had to worry about not only at the reception but also all the planning leading up to it. Compared to other venues we looked at in the area they definitely provide high quality service at a reasonable cost. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jessica
Wedding:
3/3/2012
5.0/5.0
We had our wedding in the ballroom at the Olde Mill Inn and could not have been happier with our choice. The venue itself is beautiful and provided many different locations for photos. The food was delicious and its presentation creative, above and beyond traditional wedding fare. The staff accommodated all of our requests and were responsive when issues arose (it's inevitable!). Many of our guests stayed overnight, and I loved that we were able to continue the party that night at the Grain House and then the next morning at brunch. Our guests are still raving about what a great time they had!
We had our wedding in the ballroom at the Olde Mill Inn and could not have been happier with our choice. The venue itself Read more...
We had our wedding in the ballroom at the Olde Mill Inn and could not have been happier with our choice. The venue itself is beautiful and provided many different locations for photos. The food was delicious and its presentation creative, above and beyond traditional wedding fare. The staff accommodated all of our requests and were responsive when issues arose (it's inevitable!). Many of our guests stayed overnight, and I loved that we were able to continue the party that night at the Grain House and then the next morning at brunch. Our guests are still raving about what a great time they had! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you Jessica....we were honored to host your wedding celebration and hope to see photos:)
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lisa
Wedding:
10/8/2011
5.0/5.0
Everything was Perfect! posted 10/20/2011
We celebrated our wedding at the Grain House on 10/8/2011. I am from that area in NJ and always knew the Olde Mill/Grain House as being a lovely venue. We were not disappointed. Our ceremony/cocktail reception were run smoothly and our guests raved about the venue, ambiance and food. Tomas Ordonez, our wedding manager, was top notch and kept us at ease throughout the planning process and on the big day. The mimosas at 11am didn't hurt either. : ) I train people in customer service and have very high expectations. I was not disappointed. If you want a lovely venue which is run by true professionals we highly recommend the Olde Mill Inn/Grain House Restaurant. Ask for Tomas!
Everything was Perfect! posted 10/20/2011
We celebrated our wedding at the Grain House on 10/8/2011. I am from that Read more...
Everything was Perfect! posted 10/20/2011
We celebrated our wedding at the Grain House on 10/8/2011. I am from that area in NJ and always knew the Olde Mill/Grain House as being a lovely venue. We were not disappointed. Our ceremony/cocktail reception were run smoothly and our guests raved about the venue, ambiance and food. Tomas Ordonez, our wedding manager, was top notch and kept us at ease throughout the planning process and on the big day. The mimosas at 11am didn't hurt either. : ) I train people in customer service and have very high expectations. I was not disappointed. If you want a lovely venue which is run by true professionals we highly recommend the Olde Mill Inn/Grain House Restaurant. Ask for Tomas! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
MattMaggiacomo
Wedding:
9/24/2011
5.0/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn is fantastic. We were married there on September 24 and went through roughly one year of planning with two primary contacts at the venue (Marien and Tomas). Both individuals were wonderful to work with, and our guests raved about the friendliness of the staff and the quality of the food. The setting itself was perfect. One of the venue's greatest qualities is that it's very classy without being over the top. An added bonus: the rooms at the hotel are extremely comfortable and rival most five-star hotels. Seriously, we had no complaints.
The Olde Mill Inn is fantastic. We were married there on September 24 and went through roughly one year of planning with Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn is fantastic. We were married there on September 24 and went through roughly one year of planning with two primary contacts at the venue (Marien and Tomas). Both individuals were wonderful to work with, and our guests raved about the friendliness of the staff and the quality of the food. The setting itself was perfect. One of the venue's greatest qualities is that it's very classy without being over the top. An added bonus: the rooms at the hotel are extremely comfortable and rival most five-star hotels. Seriously, we had no complaints. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Erin
Wedding:
9/2/2011
5.0/5.0
Our wedding at the Olde Mill was fabolous! Our Maitre D Marien was awesome! She understood what was important to us and made sure everything ran smooth. I hear nothing but great things from our guests especially that the food was amazing. would definitely recommend this venue to future brides. The rooms are very accomodating and the service from all of the staff is wonderful! You are bound to enjoy the Olde Mill and the staff!
Our wedding at the Olde Mill was fabolous! Our Maitre D Marien was awesome! She understood what was important to us and Read more...
Our wedding at the Olde Mill was fabolous! Our Maitre D Marien was awesome! She understood what was important to us and made sure everything ran smooth. I hear nothing but great things from our guests especially that the food was amazing. would definitely recommend this venue to future brides. The rooms are very accomodating and the service from all of the staff is wonderful! You are bound to enjoy the Olde Mill and the staff! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Megan
Wedding:
8/19/2011
5.0/5.0
We were married at the Olde Mill Inn on August 19, 2011. We had an amazing day, and the Olde Mill Inn was a perfect backdrop for our wedding. The hotel is beautiful, the food was delicious, and the service second to none. Tomas our maitre d was wonderful and went out of his way to make sure that everything was perfect for us. Our guests are still talking about the amazing food, convenient rooms, and overall great party. I am so happy we decided to have our reception at the Olde Mill Inn.
We were married at the Olde Mill Inn on August 19, 2011. We had an amazing day, and the Olde Mill Inn was a perfect Read more...
We were married at the Olde Mill Inn on August 19, 2011. We had an amazing day, and the Olde Mill Inn was a perfect backdrop for our wedding. The hotel is beautiful, the food was delicious, and the service second to none. Tomas our maitre d was wonderful and went out of his way to make sure that everything was perfect for us. Our guests are still talking about the amazing food, convenient rooms, and overall great party. I am so happy we decided to have our reception at the Olde Mill Inn. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
MJM
Wedding:
7/16/2011
5.0/5.0
The only place to have your wedding!!! They have it all and they do it all with such style and grace. The entire staff was a delight to work with and they granted all are requests. The wedding was beyond anything we imagined and the reception was out of this world. I can not thank them enough for the dream wedding always wished for.
The only place to have your wedding!!! They have it all and they do it all with such style and grace. The entire staff was Read more...
The only place to have your wedding!!! They have it all and they do it all with such style and grace. The entire staff was a delight to work with and they granted all are requests. The wedding was beyond anything we imagined and the reception was out of this world. I can not thank them enough for the dream wedding always wished for. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Julie
Wedding:
7/16/2011
5.0/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn made our wedding reception an amazing event. All our relatives and friends keep complimenting us on our wedding and how wonderful everything was. We definitely did a thorough search of venues since we toured and met with over 20 venues before we decided on the OMI. The majority of our 200 guests were coming from out of town so having the hotel there was a huge perk. It was so nice to not have to worry about shuttling guests and everyone was able to enjoy themselves more knowing they just had to walk upstairs to their rooms when it was over. Plus, The Grain House next door is very accommodating for guests to go hangout after the wedding if you want the party to continue. We had Tomas as our Maitre'D and I was so pleased. He was very attentive and went out of his way to make sure everything was perfect. He even found blue Maraschino cherries so they would look cool in our Blue Hawaiian cocktails. We were able to relax the day of our wedding because we had gone over every detail with him and we totally trusted that he had things taken care of. He also made sure that me and my husband got to taste all our h'orderves at the cocktail hour by bringing out a tray for just us during our photos. Our friends loooved the mashed potato bar, wok station and hibachi station. The OMI does several wedding shows throughout the year for potential brides so I highly recommend going. They are free and you get to sample many of the different stations and popular h'orderves. We actually were way more impressed with the food the day of our wedding then we were at the shows. We know we could not have found a better location for our event!
The Olde Mill Inn made our wedding reception an amazing event. All our relatives and friends keep complimenting us on our Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn made our wedding reception an amazing event. All our relatives and friends keep complimenting us on our wedding and how wonderful everything was. We definitely did a thorough search of venues since we toured and met with over 20 venues before we decided on the OMI. The majority of our 200 guests were coming from out of town so having the hotel there was a huge perk. It was so nice to not have to worry about shuttling guests and everyone was able to enjoy themselves more knowing they just had to walk upstairs to their rooms when it was over. Plus, The Grain House next door is very accommodating for guests to go hangout after the wedding if you want the party to continue. We had Tomas as our Maitre'D and I was so pleased. He was very attentive and went out of his way to make sure everything was perfect. He even found blue Maraschino cherries so they would look cool in our Blue Hawaiian cocktails. We were able to relax the day of our wedding because we had gone over every detail with him and we totally trusted that he had things taken care of. He also made sure that me and my husband got to taste all our h'orderves at the cocktail hour by bringing out a tray for just us during our photos. Our friends loooved the mashed potato bar, wok station and hibachi station. The OMI does several wedding shows throughout the year for potential brides so I highly recommend going. They are free and you get to sample many of the different stations and popular h'orderves. We actually were way more impressed with the food the day of our wedding then we were at the shows. We know we could not have found a better location for our event! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Diane
Wedding:
7/1/2011
5.0/5.0
The service at the Olde Mill Inn was incredible. My husband and I were so happy we decided on this location for wedding. The staff we wonderful and the food was out of this world.
The service at the Olde Mill Inn was incredible. My husband and I were so happy we decided on this location for wedding. Read more...
The service at the Olde Mill Inn was incredible. My husband and I were so happy we decided on this location for wedding. The staff we wonderful and the food was out of this world. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Susie
Wedding:
6/25/2011
5.0/5.0
We had our reception at the Hunt room. The food and service were both fabalous. The chef and our maitre D, Tomas both sat down with us to go over the menu in detail. Tomas took detailed notes as to all the things we wanted to make sure our night was perfect- and it was! The cocktail hour food as well as the main courses were all delicious. They also took care to make sure the whole evening flowed smoothly from the moment we arrived through our very last dance and a final glass of wine with friends. Many people reached out to us and told us that they had a wonderful time.
We had our reception at the Hunt room. The food and service were both fabalous. The chef and our maitre D, Tomas both sat Read more...
We had our reception at the Hunt room. The food and service were both fabalous. The chef and our maitre D, Tomas both sat down with us to go over the menu in detail. Tomas took detailed notes as to all the things we wanted to make sure our night was perfect- and it was! The cocktail hour food as well as the main courses were all delicious. They also took care to make sure the whole evening flowed smoothly from the moment we arrived through our very last dance and a final glass of wine with friends. Many people reached out to us and told us that they had a wonderful time. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Bg5
Lauren
Wedding:
5/15/2011
5.0/5.0
I LOVED having my wedding at the Olde Mill Inn. I have heard nothing but rave reviews from all my guests since the wedding!

My husband found the venue and though I was initially looking for modern style decor, I definitely had to open my mind to this place. Marien showed us around, and immediately treated us like family. She is so bubbly and welcoming, and one of the reasons we fell in love with Olde Mill, to be honest! She worked with us throughout the process until we were assigned a Maitre D – John - who was equally as fantastic. They were both so easily accessible through email and phone, or even if we walked in to ask a question. I had so many details at our wedding, and he was receptive to each one. We felt like we were the only couple he was working with. And forget it - the day of, he was heaven sent! He took care of everything flawlessly and we didn't need to worry.

The place itself has a quaint 1800s Inn feel, and was really lovely to have people stay over there the night before - it felt like I was staying with all my family at a bed-and-breakfast, or someone's large home. The staff was very professional, and the food was out of this world.

The courtyard they use for the ceremony is absolutely gorgeous, and is what sold me initially. Unfortunately it did rain on our day, and they set up the ceremony in half the ballroom. I was VERY concerned that it wouldn't look as nice, but it looked PHENOMENAL. They did a great job and in a short timeframe. So I would definitely say this place has a solid rain plan.

If I had to give a critique, it would be that if you do get rained out, and you hired a photojournalistic photog like I did, there are less opportunities for pictures. I was banking on strolling the grounds outside for pictures (which are lovely), but I was restricted to a few places inside the Inn.

For the amount and quality of food and the quality of service, I would say the prices were more than reasonable. We had 150 people on a Sunday afternoon, and for food, reception, ceremony, and cake, we paid about $20k. If you've priced out other places in NJ, you know that is comparable, or even a bargain!

I would highly recommend you take a look at Olde Mill. They really helped us have the wedding we were picturing.
I LOVED having my wedding at the Olde Mill Inn. I have heard nothing but rave reviews from all my guests since the Read more...
I LOVED having my wedding at the Olde Mill Inn. I have heard nothing but rave reviews from all my guests since the wedding!

My husband found the venue and though I was initially looking for modern style decor, I definitely had to open my mind to this place. Marien showed us around, and immediately treated us like family. She is so bubbly and welcoming, and one of the reasons we fell in love with Olde Mill, to be honest! She worked with us throughout the process until we were assigned a Maitre D – John - who was equally as fantastic. They were both so easily accessible through email and phone, or even if we walked in to ask a question. I had so many details at our wedding, and he was receptive to each one. We felt like we were the only couple he was working with. And forget it - the day of, he was heaven sent! He took care of everything flawlessly and we didn't need to worry.

The place itself has a quaint 1800s Inn feel, and was really lovely to have people stay over there the night before - it felt like I was staying with all my family at a bed-and-breakfast, or someone's large home. The staff was very professional, and the food was out of this world.

The courtyard they use for the ceremony is absolutely gorgeous, and is what sold me initially. Unfortunately it did rain on our day, and they set up the ceremony in half the ballroom. I was VERY concerned that it wouldn't look as nice, but it looked PHENOMENAL. They did a great job and in a short timeframe. So I would definitely say this place has a solid rain plan.

If I had to give a critique, it would be that if you do get rained out, and you hired a photojournalistic photog like I did, there are less opportunities for pictures. I was banking on strolling the grounds outside for pictures (which are lovely), but I was restricted to a few places inside the Inn.

For the amount and quality of food and the quality of service, I would say the prices were more than reasonable. We had 150 people on a Sunday afternoon, and for food, reception, ceremony, and cake, we paid about $20k. If you've priced out other places in NJ, you know that is comparable, or even a bargain!

I would highly recommend you take a look at Olde Mill. They really helped us have the wedding we were picturing. Read less
Services Used: Catering, Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
ckeene416
Wedding:
4/16/2011
5.0/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn was the PERFECT venue. Everyone is still raving about our venue, a month later. Some of the feedback from our guests "they kept the table nice and clean, took empty glasses away, and kept refilling ours, we never even had to get up to go to the bar", "the food was wonderful, better than any wedding we've ever been to", "this place is beautiful". I have NOTHING negative to say about the Olde Mill Inn. Marien booked us and John was our maitre'd. They were both there whenever you needed them throughout the entire planning process. The night of our wedding my parents had one of the suites booked, and the other one had never been booked, so they upgraded my husbands mother at no charge (they really upgraded us, but we gave it to her so she could entertain afterwards). The whole experience was wonderful! We booked the venue because it was so gorgeous, but it rained like hell the day of our wedding, but it didn't even matter. We were just so happy, and the inside is just as gorgeous!
The Olde Mill Inn was the PERFECT venue. Everyone is still raving about our venue, a month later. Some of the feedback Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn was the PERFECT venue. Everyone is still raving about our venue, a month later. Some of the feedback from our guests "they kept the table nice and clean, took empty glasses away, and kept refilling ours, we never even had to get up to go to the bar", "the food was wonderful, better than any wedding we've ever been to", "this place is beautiful". I have NOTHING negative to say about the Olde Mill Inn. Marien booked us and John was our maitre'd. They were both there whenever you needed them throughout the entire planning process. The night of our wedding my parents had one of the suites booked, and the other one had never been booked, so they upgraded my husbands mother at no charge (they really upgraded us, but we gave it to her so she could entertain afterwards). The whole experience was wonderful! We booked the venue because it was so gorgeous, but it rained like hell the day of our wedding, but it didn't even matter. We were just so happy, and the inside is just as gorgeous! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Robin
Wedding:
11/21/2010
5.0/5.0
After visiting the Grain House at the Old Mill Inn, I knew this is where I wanted to have my dream wedding. Meeting with Lindsey S. confirmed this is the right place for me and my fiancé to tie the knot and share this wonderful day with family and friends. Lindsey guided us through out the entire planning phase and the was assigned a wonderful Maître d', Amanda. Amanda was always cheerful and professional and always willing to offer her advise when asked. She was there bright and early the day of my wedding and made sure everything went smoothly. I could not have asked for better service and attention by the entire staff on the OMI. Thanks again for making my special day really special
After visiting the Grain House at the Old Mill Inn, I knew this is where I wanted to have my dream wedding. Meeting with Read more...
After visiting the Grain House at the Old Mill Inn, I knew this is where I wanted to have my dream wedding. Meeting with Lindsey S. confirmed this is the right place for me and my fiancé to tie the knot and share this wonderful day with family and friends. Lindsey guided us through out the entire planning phase and the was assigned a wonderful Maître d', Amanda. Amanda was always cheerful and professional and always willing to offer her advise when asked. She was there bright and early the day of my wedding and made sure everything went smoothly. I could not have asked for better service and attention by the entire staff on the OMI. Thanks again for making my special day really special Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake, Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Congratulations Robin!! Thank you for your fabulous review and for sharing your memorable day with us at the Olde Mill Inn & Grain House! Please visit soon & send us photos :)

Best Wishes!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
NJFallWed
Wedding:
11/7/2010
5.0/5.0
WOW is all I can say. The Olde Mill Inn exceeded my expectations!! From the first time we went there to see it to the day of the wedding, they were incredible to work with and everyone was so nice when we called with any questions. We were in the Washington Ballroom, and we were concerned the size of our wedding would be a little small for the room. We were told not to worry about it, and they were right. They made the room look absolutely beautiful down to every detail! We really wanted to do the ceremony outside, but we decided it was too cold for our guests, but we did do the pictures outside and the courtyard was just lovely. Our cake was delicious and beautiful too (ordered through the Olde Mill Inn using the bakery they work with). It was exactly what we wanted. And the food was delicious!! I wish I had eaten more of it, but we got so many rave reviews! Also, we got a lot of compliments on how good the service there was - how guests never had to ask for a refill of drinks or anything and that the waiters were very attentive. Our maitre'd (Marien) made sure the night ran smoothly and was always there if we needed anything. This was the perfect venue for us, and they really made our night incredibly special!
WOW is all I can say. The Olde Mill Inn exceeded my expectations!! From the first time we went there to see it to the day Read more...
WOW is all I can say. The Olde Mill Inn exceeded my expectations!! From the first time we went there to see it to the day of the wedding, they were incredible to work with and everyone was so nice when we called with any questions. We were in the Washington Ballroom, and we were concerned the size of our wedding would be a little small for the room. We were told not to worry about it, and they were right. They made the room look absolutely beautiful down to every detail! We really wanted to do the ceremony outside, but we decided it was too cold for our guests, but we did do the pictures outside and the courtyard was just lovely. Our cake was delicious and beautiful too (ordered through the Olde Mill Inn using the bakery they work with). It was exactly what we wanted. And the food was delicious!! I wish I had eaten more of it, but we got so many rave reviews! Also, we got a lot of compliments on how good the service there was - how guests never had to ask for a refill of drinks or anything and that the waiters were very attentive. Our maitre'd (Marien) made sure the night ran smoothly and was always there if we needed anything. This was the perfect venue for us, and they really made our night incredibly special! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Crystal
Wedding:
8/1/2010
5.0/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn was such a perfect setting for our ceremony and reception. Our maitre d', John, was so accommodating and helpful no matter how many questions or concerns we had. On the day of the wedding, it started raining about an hour and a half before our ceremony, which was supposed to take place outside. John let us wait to see if the rain would stop until the last moment before we had to start the ceremony. I appreciated that so much even though the rain didn't stop! They were able to transform the ballroom into a lovely ceremony room. And once it was set up for the reception it honestly didn't even feel like it was the same room the ceremony had just taken place in.

Our friends and family couldn't stop raving about the food. One said that they had never seen so many passed h'ordeuvres at wedding. Also we had never seen waiters take drink orders tableside at a wedding before. We thought it was just for us but then guests kept coming up to us excited that they were bringing them drinks as well!

The cake was just perfect. When we went in to make our food choices we were given a bunch of different cake design options but I had something specific in mind. They put me in touch with the baker and he was able to recreate it perfectly. I loved the cake...it was so yummy too!

Overall, The Olde Mill Inn did an exceptional job for us. Everything went off without a hitch and we were thrilled with our wedding.
The Olde Mill Inn was such a perfect setting for our ceremony and reception. Our maitre d', John, was so accommodating and Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn was such a perfect setting for our ceremony and reception. Our maitre d', John, was so accommodating and helpful no matter how many questions or concerns we had. On the day of the wedding, it started raining about an hour and a half before our ceremony, which was supposed to take place outside. John let us wait to see if the rain would stop until the last moment before we had to start the ceremony. I appreciated that so much even though the rain didn't stop! They were able to transform the ballroom into a lovely ceremony room. And once it was set up for the reception it honestly didn't even feel like it was the same room the ceremony had just taken place in.

Our friends and family couldn't stop raving about the food. One said that they had never seen so many passed h'ordeuvres at wedding. Also we had never seen waiters take drink orders tableside at a wedding before. We thought it was just for us but then guests kept coming up to us excited that they were bringing them drinks as well!

The cake was just perfect. When we went in to make our food choices we were given a bunch of different cake design options but I had something specific in mind. They put me in touch with the baker and he was able to recreate it perfectly. I loved the cake...it was so yummy too!

Overall, The Olde Mill Inn did an exceptional job for us. Everything went off without a hitch and we were thrilled with our wedding. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
jlewisprof1
Wedding:
7/24/2010
5.0/5.0
This was absolutely the best ! The staff, food, location, etc. were perfect. Our maitre de' (Lilndsay) was incredible. We were able to attend a tasting, practice our dance at the venue several times, call with questions about details. Everything was done professionally and carefully. My wedding day was the best day ever, and much of the credit goes to the superb care given to details by the staff at OMI. Nearly one month later, guests are still talking about the amazing food.
This was absolutely the best ! The staff, food, location, etc. were perfect. Our maitre de' (Lilndsay) was incredible. We Read more...
This was absolutely the best ! The staff, food, location, etc. were perfect. Our maitre de' (Lilndsay) was incredible. We were able to attend a tasting, practice our dance at the venue several times, call with questions about details. Everything was done professionally and carefully. My wedding day was the best day ever, and much of the credit goes to the superb care given to details by the staff at OMI. Nearly one month later, guests are still talking about the amazing food. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Katie
Wedding:
6/26/2010
5.0/5.0
Our ceremony and reception were at the Grain House, a quaint, historical building on the grounds of the hotel. Both were fantastic - our maitre'd Lindsay was wonderful. Guests raved about the food, service and attention to detail shown by the staff. Overall, my husband and I had a wonderful time and highly recommend Olde Mill and Lindsay.
Our ceremony and reception were at the Grain House, a quaint, historical building on the grounds of the hotel. Both were Read more...
Our ceremony and reception were at the Grain House, a quaint, historical building on the grounds of the hotel. Both were fantastic - our maitre'd Lindsay was wonderful. Guests raved about the food, service and attention to detail shown by the staff. Overall, my husband and I had a wonderful time and highly recommend Olde Mill and Lindsay. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you for reviewing our beautiful facility.....I am delighted to read your wonderful review......wishing you and yours the very best:)
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Leah
Wedding:
6/24/2010
5.0/5.0
We cannot say enough positive comments about the Olde Mill Inn and Grain House. From the moment we visited to see the site, the staff was attentive and accomodating. They were available by phone and email and answered all questions with ease. Our wedding day was perfect from start to finish! The staff was super and Lindsay Stewart was a pleasure to work with. She was easy to talk to, fun to share the day with and she made sure that everything was perfect, without us needing to ask or say anything. And she was even our "DJ" as she worked the ipod for the music! Our guests raved about everything...the food, service, beautiful setting, accomodations and the overall quality of the event. Lindsay Stewart and Lindsey Smilie were amazing to work with and even after the wedding, the emailed us to check in. Again, we HIGHLY recommend the OMI and Grain House for ANY event. We plan to go back every chance we get.
We cannot say enough positive comments about the Olde Mill Inn and Grain House. From the moment we visited to see the Read more...
We cannot say enough positive comments about the Olde Mill Inn and Grain House. From the moment we visited to see the site, the staff was attentive and accomodating. They were available by phone and email and answered all questions with ease. Our wedding day was perfect from start to finish! The staff was super and Lindsay Stewart was a pleasure to work with. She was easy to talk to, fun to share the day with and she made sure that everything was perfect, without us needing to ask or say anything. And she was even our "DJ" as she worked the ipod for the music! Our guests raved about everything...the food, service, beautiful setting, accomodations and the overall quality of the event. Lindsay Stewart and Lindsey Smilie were amazing to work with and even after the wedding, the emailed us to check in. Again, we HIGHLY recommend the OMI and Grain House for ANY event. We plan to go back every chance we get. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
dfkam
Wedding:
6/5/2010
5.0/5.0
They did a wonderful job with our ceremony and wedding. The food was outstanding and the guests raved about everything afterwards. They did everything possible to make it a wonderful day for us and we could not have been happier with their service and attention to detail.
They did a wonderful job with our ceremony and wedding. The food was outstanding and the guests raved about everything Read more...
They did a wonderful job with our ceremony and wedding. The food was outstanding and the guests raved about everything afterwards. They did everything possible to make it a wonderful day for us and we could not have been happier with their service and attention to detail. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
LexSinclair
Wedding:
5/8/2010
5.0/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn is a beautiful Inn and reception venue. The center courtyard is the perfect location for a ceremony and/or cocktail hour. Almost half our guests stayed at the hotel and loved the rooms. The best part of the Olde Mill Inn is the staff. We found Marien and the Olde Mill Inn extremely helpful. We did not hire a wedding consultant, but found Marien was there every step of the way to guide us. We couldn't have done it without her. Olde Mill Inn was extremely flexible and gave us the wedding of our dreams. We had such an easy and fun planning experience and it was all because of Marien and the Olde Mill Inn. The day of, the food was fabulous and the staff was great. Everyone was very attentive not only to us, but our guests as well. We still get rave reviews from friends and are excited to have other events there in the future. We would recommend the Olde Mill Inn to everyone. If you want the wedding of your dreams, you have to have it there!! Call now, ask for Marien!!!!
The Olde Mill Inn is a beautiful Inn and reception venue. The center courtyard is the perfect location for a ceremony Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn is a beautiful Inn and reception venue. The center courtyard is the perfect location for a ceremony and/or cocktail hour. Almost half our guests stayed at the hotel and loved the rooms. The best part of the Olde Mill Inn is the staff. We found Marien and the Olde Mill Inn extremely helpful. We did not hire a wedding consultant, but found Marien was there every step of the way to guide us. We couldn't have done it without her. Olde Mill Inn was extremely flexible and gave us the wedding of our dreams. We had such an easy and fun planning experience and it was all because of Marien and the Olde Mill Inn. The day of, the food was fabulous and the staff was great. Everyone was very attentive not only to us, but our guests as well. We still get rave reviews from friends and are excited to have other events there in the future. We would recommend the Olde Mill Inn to everyone. If you want the wedding of your dreams, you have to have it there!! Call now, ask for Marien!!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kelly
Wedding:
4/25/2010
5.0/5.0
We had our wedding in the Hunt Room, located in the Grain House Restaurant. I can't say enough how wonderful everything was, the brunch was amazing, everyone had a wonderful time.
We had our wedding in the Hunt Room, located in the Grain House Restaurant. I can't say enough how wonderful everything Read more...
We had our wedding in the Hunt Room, located in the Grain House Restaurant. I can't say enough how wonderful everything was, the brunch was amazing, everyone had a wonderful time. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Bg2
Tim
Wedding:
3/27/2010
5.0/5.0
Loved the Olde Mill. Food was excellent and the reception area beautiful. It's quaint, but not small. The service was fantastic and they catered to the bride and groom on our day. I couldn't beat the price for service and quality of the event. They were very accomodating and responsive to my requests. Great hotel too.
Loved the Olde Mill. Food was excellent and the reception area beautiful. It's quaint, but not small. The service was Read more...
Loved the Olde Mill. Food was excellent and the reception area beautiful. It's quaint, but not small. The service was fantastic and they catered to the bride and groom on our day. I couldn't beat the price for service and quality of the event. They were very accomodating and responsive to my requests. Great hotel too. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jason
Wedding:
11/22/2009
5.0/5.0
I have only high praise for you guys. Everything was tasteful and elegant; the entire venue was scrupulously clean, and the staff were extremely professional and attentive. We felt like we were "in good hands" throughout the planning process and the reception itself. The food was just perfect and we have received many compliments on it from our friends and family!
I have only high praise for you guys. Everything was tasteful and elegant; the entire venue was scrupulously clean, and Read more...
I have only high praise for you guys. Everything was tasteful and elegant; the entire venue was scrupulously clean, and the staff were extremely professional and attentive. We felt like we were "in good hands" throughout the planning process and the reception itself. The food was just perfect and we have received many compliments on it from our friends and family! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
lelicamarie
Wedding:
8/29/2009
5.0/5.0
From start to finish my husband and I found everything we needed and fell in love with everything the Olde Mill Inn had to offer. They were extremely accommodating, helpful and between Marian Barker our Maitre De to our Chef, Walter Leffler, any worry or doubt we might have had quickly melted away. Our day was flawlessly perfect. If we had the money we'd throw the same party every year at the Olde Mill Inn. We cannot thank them enough for providing the most memorable day for the start of our life together!
From start to finish my husband and I found everything we needed and fell in love with everything the Olde Mill Inn had to Read more...
From start to finish my husband and I found everything we needed and fell in love with everything the Olde Mill Inn had to offer. They were extremely accommodating, helpful and between Marian Barker our Maitre De to our Chef, Walter Leffler, any worry or doubt we might have had quickly melted away. Our day was flawlessly perfect. If we had the money we'd throw the same party every year at the Olde Mill Inn. We cannot thank them enough for providing the most memorable day for the start of our life together! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
donut321
Wedding:
7/24/2009
5.0/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn hosted a fantastic ceremony and reception for our July 24, 2009 wedding. From the moment we arrived for the rehearsal, OMI graciously took over gift bags for the guests, center piece additions for the reception, the card box, favors...EVERYTHING...and allowed the entire bridal party to simply relax. We had a rehearsal dinner at the Grain House - which was divinely set up for an intimate gathering (we had free reign over the entire downstairs, a private bar tender, and use of the garden/patio outside). The day of the wedding, the baker (Gourtmet Delights - the baker offered through OMI) had a question about the cake, and John (my maitre'd) asked enough questions to not upset anyone, but answered the baker clearly enough to have the most perfect cake. More than a year later, people are still raving about the food (which, by the way, you get to taste at an adorable food-tasting event), the rooms (go green!), the the provided brunch the next day. And - OMI thanks the bride and groom with a dinner gift certificate to come back to the Grain House for their one year anniversary!
The Olde Mill Inn hosted a fantastic ceremony and reception for our July 24, 2009 wedding. From the moment we arrived for Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn hosted a fantastic ceremony and reception for our July 24, 2009 wedding. From the moment we arrived for the rehearsal, OMI graciously took over gift bags for the guests, center piece additions for the reception, the card box, favors...EVERYTHING...and allowed the entire bridal party to simply relax. We had a rehearsal dinner at the Grain House - which was divinely set up for an intimate gathering (we had free reign over the entire downstairs, a private bar tender, and use of the garden/patio outside). The day of the wedding, the baker (Gourtmet Delights - the baker offered through OMI) had a question about the cake, and John (my maitre'd) asked enough questions to not upset anyone, but answered the baker clearly enough to have the most perfect cake. More than a year later, people are still raving about the food (which, by the way, you get to taste at an adorable food-tasting event), the rooms (go green!), the the provided brunch the next day. And - OMI thanks the bride and groom with a dinner gift certificate to come back to the Grain House for their one year anniversary! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
emmag
Wedding:
7/11/2009
5.0/5.0
I loved the venue! It was beautiful, the service was great and the food was delicious!
I loved the venue! It was beautiful, the service was great and the food was delicious!
I loved the venue! It was beautiful, the service was great and the food was delicious! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jennifer
Wedding:
4/4/2009
5.0/5.0
My wedding was perfect and beautiful!
The food was outrageous and our maitre'd Lindsay Stewart was exceptional.

People are still raving about the day- they go out of your way to make you happy...
and exceeded all of our expectations for our special day!
My wedding was perfect and beautiful!
The food was outrageous and our maitre'd Lindsay Stewart was exceptional.
Read more...
My wedding was perfect and beautiful!
The food was outrageous and our maitre'd Lindsay Stewart was exceptional.

People are still raving about the day- they go out of your way to make you happy...
and exceeded all of our expectations for our special day! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Courtney
Wedding:
10/24/2008
5.0/5.0
We had our ceremony and reception at the Grain House Restaurant, adjacent to the Olde Mill Inn. The Grain House is a quaint, historic building and hosts smaller wedding receptions. The ceremony site looked beautiful and the reception room was set up perfectly. We heard from many of our guests who said how delicious the food was. The cake was spectacular as well--looked gorgeous and tasted even better! Our maitre'd was very helpful and proved responsive and available when we had questions in the weeks leading up to our wedding. We booked the Bernard suite at the Olde Mill for our wedding night, and also used it as the location for me and the bridesmaids to get dressed--very spacious and comfortable. Overall, our experience with the Olde Mill Inn and Grain House Restaurant was wonderful!
We had our ceremony and reception at the Grain House Restaurant, adjacent to the Olde Mill Inn. The Grain House is a Read more...
We had our ceremony and reception at the Grain House Restaurant, adjacent to the Olde Mill Inn. The Grain House is a quaint, historic building and hosts smaller wedding receptions. The ceremony site looked beautiful and the reception room was set up perfectly. We heard from many of our guests who said how delicious the food was. The cake was spectacular as well--looked gorgeous and tasted even better! Our maitre'd was very helpful and proved responsive and available when we had questions in the weeks leading up to our wedding. We booked the Bernard suite at the Olde Mill for our wedding night, and also used it as the location for me and the bridesmaids to get dressed--very spacious and comfortable. Overall, our experience with the Olde Mill Inn and Grain House Restaurant was wonderful! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake, Catering, Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kyra
Wedding:
8/23/2013
5.0/5.0
I don't even know where to begin. I was married at The Olde Mill Inn on August 23, 2013, and it was the most amazing day of my life. The Olde Mill Inn made my every dream came true. We worked with Lindsay Stewart from day one, and she was even our maitre d' on the day of the wedding. Having Lindsay with us from the start to finish was the greatest thing. I was so happy to have a familiar face with me that day. Every little thing I ever needed, Lindsay took care of flawlessly, even to the point of calming me down on the day before the wedding when I was in tears over family drama. During the wedding and reception, every time I turned around and needed something, Lindsay always seemed to be right there. As for the venue, it was beautiful, and the food is still the talk of everyone. At one point, I even found my dad, hiding before the introductions with another plate of food from cocktail hour, and as he tried to eat as much as he could before we had to go, he said to me, each thing is better then the next!!! I am so happy that I decided to have my wedding at The Olde Mill Inn!! It was by far the best decision I made during the wedding process.
I don't even know where to begin. I was married at The Olde Mill Inn on August 23, 2013, and it was the most amazing day Read more...
I don't even know where to begin. I was married at The Olde Mill Inn on August 23, 2013, and it was the most amazing day of my life. The Olde Mill Inn made my every dream came true. We worked with Lindsay Stewart from day one, and she was even our maitre d' on the day of the wedding. Having Lindsay with us from the start to finish was the greatest thing. I was so happy to have a familiar face with me that day. Every little thing I ever needed, Lindsay took care of flawlessly, even to the point of calming me down on the day before the wedding when I was in tears over family drama. During the wedding and reception, every time I turned around and needed something, Lindsay always seemed to be right there. As for the venue, it was beautiful, and the food is still the talk of everyone. At one point, I even found my dad, hiding before the introductions with another plate of food from cocktail hour, and as he tried to eat as much as he could before we had to go, he said to me, each thing is better then the next!!! I am so happy that I decided to have my wedding at The Olde Mill Inn!! It was by far the best decision I made during the wedding process. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Hi Kyra & Michael,
Thank you for your review!! It was wonderful to work with you in planning for your wedding and we certainly had so much fun watching the day come together! Look forward to seeing you soon!
All the best,
Lindsay Stewart & Olde Mill Inn Staff
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Christine
Wedding:
7/4/2014
4.9/5.0
What a wonderful place to have our wedding - the service, the food and all around being treated amazing by AManda our Maitre D' ---- the hotel staff was sooo fabulous and the check in desk was nothing but smiles and helpful the entire time !!

I highly recommend this property! the area in New Jersey is soo gorgeous and the venue has a lil rustic flare that will WOW your guests.

Thank you - the Happy Bride & Groom
Christine & Matthew Bohn
What a wonderful place to have our wedding - the service, the food and all around being treated amazing by AManda our Read more...
What a wonderful place to have our wedding - the service, the food and all around being treated amazing by AManda our Maitre D' ---- the hotel staff was sooo fabulous and the check in desk was nothing but smiles and helpful the entire time !!

I highly recommend this property! the area in New Jersey is soo gorgeous and the venue has a lil rustic flare that will WOW your guests.

Thank you - the Happy Bride & Groom
Christine & Matthew Bohn Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Hi Christine & Matthew,
Thank you so much for your review and for choosing to host your wedding at the Grain House AND for celebrating July 4th with us!!!!! :)
Congratulations and best wishes for a lifetime of love & laughter!
Visit soon!
Olde Mill Inn Management
130x130_sq_1402211836964-wedding-day-highlights-0045
Christina
Wedding:
5/24/2014
4.9/5.0
Olde Mill Inn was our top choice after seeing 8 popular venues in one day. A couple friends had previously attended weddings there and said the food and service were great, and they were right. Lindsey Smillie, our sales associate, was extremely responsive from the beginning. I'm a Quality Control Manager by profession so you can imagine all the questions and specific requests I had. She was very quick to respond and reassuring for our wedding of 175ppl. We ended up booking our farewell brunch for 125 ppl in the Hunt Room for the Sunday after, and she was on top of everything. John Lietz, our Banquet Manager and Maître D, was amazing!!! Truly everything was perfect, if not beyond our expectations. We had a special roast pig brought in from outside for cocktail hour, and John was very accommodating. It was displayed beautifully and carved wonderfully. We opted for the Emerald Menu which includes the seafood bar, and several people said it was the best cocktail hour they had ever been to. The bartenders was also very quick. There was never really a line with waiters also getting drinks for guests. The accommodations on site were key for us with many out of town guests. The block rate is very reasonable and rooms nice and comfortable. The front desk attendants were also very pleasant. Brunch the next day was also really delicious. Honestly, so many raves about the food and service. The price was premium since we had a Saturday night wedding in peak season and the indoor cocktail area is a little cramped, but otherwise nothing but accolades for OMI. I had so many personal details, and John and his team took care of everything to a tee. They are truly professionals and will make every effort to make your wedding the best day ever. Lastly, I highly recommend the Bernard Suite for bride and groom. It is a huge space, beautiful, and really fun for having people over. Pictures online don't do it justice. Thank you Olde Mill Inn for memories of a lifetime!
Olde Mill Inn was our top choice after seeing 8 popular venues in one day. A couple friends had previously attended Read more...
Olde Mill Inn was our top choice after seeing 8 popular venues in one day. A couple friends had previously attended weddings there and said the food and service were great, and they were right. Lindsey Smillie, our sales associate, was extremely responsive from the beginning. I'm a Quality Control Manager by profession so you can imagine all the questions and specific requests I had. She was very quick to respond and reassuring for our wedding of 175ppl. We ended up booking our farewell brunch for 125 ppl in the Hunt Room for the Sunday after, and she was on top of everything. John Lietz, our Banquet Manager and Maître D, was amazing!!! Truly everything was perfect, if not beyond our expectations. We had a special roast pig brought in from outside for cocktail hour, and John was very accommodating. It was displayed beautifully and carved wonderfully. We opted for the Emerald Menu which includes the seafood bar, and several people said it was the best cocktail hour they had ever been to. The bartenders was also very quick. There was never really a line with waiters also getting drinks for guests. The accommodations on site were key for us with many out of town guests. The block rate is very reasonable and rooms nice and comfortable. The front desk attendants were also very pleasant. Brunch the next day was also really delicious. Honestly, so many raves about the food and service. The price was premium since we had a Saturday night wedding in peak season and the indoor cocktail area is a little cramped, but otherwise nothing but accolades for OMI. I had so many personal details, and John and his team took care of everything to a tee. They are truly professionals and will make every effort to make your wedding the best day ever. Lastly, I highly recommend the Bernard Suite for bride and groom. It is a huge space, beautiful, and really fun for having people over. Pictures online don't do it justice. Thank you Olde Mill Inn for memories of a lifetime! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Elizabeth
Wedding:
6/22/2013
4.9/5.0
The entire staff at the Olde Mill Inn was a true pleasure to work with. John, our maitre'd was tending to our needs before we knew we even had them on the wedding day and he would respond to my crazed bride emails at all hours of the night. Cathi, the Director of Sales, was always immediately responsive to all of my questions throughout the planning process. I could not have asked for a better team to help create my wedding. The rest of the staff, from the front desk to the waitstaff, was wonderful to work with as well. The Olde Mill Inn was always willing to accommodate my requests, especially as vegetarian bride! All of our guests continue to rave about the food and the experience. Guests have asked if we could do the wedding again because they had such a wonderful time. I would do it again in a heartbeat! And you can't beat the beautiful, rustic, classy feel of the decor. I would recommend the Olde Mill Inn to any bride!
The entire staff at the Olde Mill Inn was a true pleasure to work with. John, our maitre'd was tending to our needs before Read more...
The entire staff at the Olde Mill Inn was a true pleasure to work with. John, our maitre'd was tending to our needs before we knew we even had them on the wedding day and he would respond to my crazed bride emails at all hours of the night. Cathi, the Director of Sales, was always immediately responsive to all of my questions throughout the planning process. I could not have asked for a better team to help create my wedding. The rest of the staff, from the front desk to the waitstaff, was wonderful to work with as well. The Olde Mill Inn was always willing to accommodate my requests, especially as vegetarian bride! All of our guests continue to rave about the food and the experience. Guests have asked if we could do the wedding again because they had such a wonderful time. I would do it again in a heartbeat! And you can't beat the beautiful, rustic, classy feel of the decor. I would recommend the Olde Mill Inn to any bride! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Crystal
Wedding:
5/26/2012
4.9/5.0
This place was just right for us. It has a country like setting and they were very flexible with us with everything. My guests loved the place. The food was great. I wished they had left the chocolate fountain out a little longer..it was sooooo good. The food was excellent. I cant wait to eat there again. There was a little mix up with a piece of the ceremony but it turned out okay in the end.
This place was just right for us. It has a country like setting and they were very flexible with us with everything. My Read more...
This place was just right for us. It has a country like setting and they were very flexible with us with everything. My guests loved the place. The food was great. I wished they had left the chocolate fountain out a little longer..it was sooooo good. The food was excellent. I cant wait to eat there again. There was a little mix up with a piece of the ceremony but it turned out okay in the end. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
figmen91
Wedding:
3/25/2012
4.9/5.0
I honestly do not know where to begin. Lindsey and John were so amazing to work with. They made my day so special and stress free. They were so responsive throughout this whole process...always getting back to me right away. They really did such an amazing job!!! I am so grateful that I had them with me throughout this! John was my maitre'd on my wedding day...he made sure everything went smoothly and that we were happy the whole night! He went out of his way more than once to make things easier for us while we were planning the big day! John rocked!!!
I honestly do not know where to begin. Lindsey and John were so amazing to work with. They made my day so special and Read more...
I honestly do not know where to begin. Lindsey and John were so amazing to work with. They made my day so special and stress free. They were so responsive throughout this whole process...always getting back to me right away. They really did such an amazing job!!! I am so grateful that I had them with me throughout this! John was my maitre'd on my wedding day...he made sure everything went smoothly and that we were happy the whole night! He went out of his way more than once to make things easier for us while we were planning the big day! John rocked!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you so very much for your wonderful testimonial....I am so happy to read that Lindsey and John made your special day most memorable and we hope to see you in the near future.....thank you for entrusting us with your wedding celebration....Catherine Schweitzer, Director of Sales and Catering
Default-vendor-profile-pic
laurensmiles
Wedding:
9/24/2011
4.9/5.0
We had our ceremony and reception here, and it was absolutely everything we wanted and needed. They worked with us from the very beginning, making sure that we had everything set and that even the tiniest details would be just what we wanted. I made all of these little favors and decorations and they set them up perfectly so I didn't have to worry about anything but getting down the aisle and having the night of my life. They were even right there to hand me plates of food the night of the wedding when I was finding it impossible to make it to the cocktail hour stations through the congratulations from friends and family. Everything was included, which made it so much easier to plan, and the location itself is cozy and beautiful and clean and classy. It was perfect for us and our guests, who stayed on the property, and I am so glad we went with the Olde Mill Inn for the most important and wonderful day of our lives.
We had our ceremony and reception here, and it was absolutely everything we wanted and needed. They worked with us from Read more...
We had our ceremony and reception here, and it was absolutely everything we wanted and needed. They worked with us from the very beginning, making sure that we had everything set and that even the tiniest details would be just what we wanted. I made all of these little favors and decorations and they set them up perfectly so I didn't have to worry about anything but getting down the aisle and having the night of my life. They were even right there to hand me plates of food the night of the wedding when I was finding it impossible to make it to the cocktail hour stations through the congratulations from friends and family. Everything was included, which made it so much easier to plan, and the location itself is cozy and beautiful and clean and classy. It was perfect for us and our guests, who stayed on the property, and I am so glad we went with the Olde Mill Inn for the most important and wonderful day of our lives. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Fred
Wedding:
6/26/2010
4.9/5.0
The Grain House & Olde Mill Inn are a beautiful venue for a wedding and we couldn't've been happier. Having the Inn for your out-of-town guests is a big plus. All the staff was friendly, the food was great (many of our guests raved), and our maitre'd Lindsay was fantastic. She was helpful in advance with all the preparation, and did an unbelievable job the day-off keeping track of all the various things to put out, move, special requests, etc. She took care of things before you even knew to ask. Only as we were leaving did we realize she was busy preparing for another wedding right after ours... very impressive (who apparently posted on here as well :) ). We would absolutely recommend the Grain House and Olde Mill Inn.
The Grain House & Olde Mill Inn are a beautiful venue for a wedding and we couldn't've been happier. Having the Inn for Read more...
The Grain House & Olde Mill Inn are a beautiful venue for a wedding and we couldn't've been happier. Having the Inn for your out-of-town guests is a big plus. All the staff was friendly, the food was great (many of our guests raved), and our maitre'd Lindsay was fantastic. She was helpful in advance with all the preparation, and did an unbelievable job the day-off keeping track of all the various things to put out, move, special requests, etc. She took care of things before you even knew to ask. Only as we were leaving did we realize she was busy preparing for another wedding right after ours... very impressive (who apparently posted on here as well :) ). We would absolutely recommend the Grain House and Olde Mill Inn. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lynda
Wedding:
9/2/2007
4.9/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn was the perfect business partner to organize my wedding! Thoughtful and flexible with all details.
The Olde Mill Inn was the perfect business partner to organize my wedding! Thoughtful and flexible with all details.
The Olde Mill Inn was the perfect business partner to organize my wedding! Thoughtful and flexible with all details. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake, Catering
Default-vendor-profile-pic
tjzcbz
Wedding:
12/28/2001
4.9/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn at Basking Ridge was a beautiful place for my wedding reception. The staff was attentive to details and very responsive to my requests/needs.
The Olde Mill Inn at Basking Ridge was a beautiful place for my wedding reception. The staff was attentive to details and Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn at Basking Ridge was a beautiful place for my wedding reception. The staff was attentive to details and very responsive to my requests/needs. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake, Catering, Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
4.8/5.0
We couldn't have been happier with our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn Grainhouse. Everything fell into place perfectly. The staff was extremely helpful and set everything up the day of the wedding from the cookie table to the luminarees outside. Plus our maitre'd contacted all of our vendors ahead of time himself. They were extremely accomodating and helpful. We paid to extend our reception to 1:00am and even had a midnight snack! Prior to the end of the reception our maitre'd even took all the gifts, leftover cookies and things left in the bridal suite to our hotel room. Our wedding was stress free thanks to the Olde Mill Inn. Not to mention the food was amazing and there was SO MUCH of it! Our guests are still talking about cocktail hour. At least ten or fifteen people have said ours was the best wedding they had ever been to!
We couldn't have been happier with our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn Grainhouse. Everything fell into place perfectly. The Read more...
We couldn't have been happier with our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn Grainhouse. Everything fell into place perfectly. The staff was extremely helpful and set everything up the day of the wedding from the cookie table to the luminarees outside. Plus our maitre'd contacted all of our vendors ahead of time himself. They were extremely accomodating and helpful. We paid to extend our reception to 1:00am and even had a midnight snack! Prior to the end of the reception our maitre'd even took all the gifts, leftover cookies and things left in the bridal suite to our hotel room. Our wedding was stress free thanks to the Olde Mill Inn. Not to mention the food was amazing and there was SO MUCH of it! Our guests are still talking about cocktail hour. At least ten or fifteen people have said ours was the best wedding they had ever been to! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Carolyn
Wedding:
1/25/2014
4.8/5.0
Olde Mill Inn was the perfect venue for our ceremony and reception. We got so many compliments from our guests about the rooms, staff, food, and decor. The staff was very attentive to the needs of myself and the groom. They definitely know what they're doing here!
Olde Mill Inn was the perfect venue for our ceremony and reception. We got so many compliments from our guests about the Read more...
Olde Mill Inn was the perfect venue for our ceremony and reception. We got so many compliments from our guests about the rooms, staff, food, and decor. The staff was very attentive to the needs of myself and the groom. They definitely know what they're doing here! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jenna
Wedding:
1/18/2014
4.8/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn was the perfect venue for our wedding. We had our wedding in the Ballroom, and the Inn had just the charm and rustic elegance we were looking for. The accommodations were great and our guests were very comfortable, we loved that our guests had the option to spend the night and not have to worry about driving home. Our Maitre d', Amanda, took care of everything on our wedding day and catered to our needs. We didn't have to worry about a thing! Amanda was always there making sure things ran smoothly. All around the staff was excellent, from the front desk to the catering/bartending, to housekeeping, truly excellent! The food was excellent and plentiful and our guests raved about everything from the moment they arrived until the moment they left. I can't tell you how many times I have heard "this is the best wedding I've ever been to...", and it is true! Thank you Olde Mill Inn for a truly unforgettable event!
The Olde Mill Inn was the perfect venue for our wedding. We had our wedding in the Ballroom, and the Inn had just the Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn was the perfect venue for our wedding. We had our wedding in the Ballroom, and the Inn had just the charm and rustic elegance we were looking for. The accommodations were great and our guests were very comfortable, we loved that our guests had the option to spend the night and not have to worry about driving home. Our Maitre d', Amanda, took care of everything on our wedding day and catered to our needs. We didn't have to worry about a thing! Amanda was always there making sure things ran smoothly. All around the staff was excellent, from the front desk to the catering/bartending, to housekeeping, truly excellent! The food was excellent and plentiful and our guests raved about everything from the moment they arrived until the moment they left. I can't tell you how many times I have heard "this is the best wedding I've ever been to...", and it is true! Thank you Olde Mill Inn for a truly unforgettable event! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lauren
Wedding:
6/1/2013
4.8/5.0
Olde Mill Inn is a unique venue in that it offers so much more than your typical 5 hour wedding package. Many of our guests stayed overnight, allowing them to enjoy post-reception drinks at the Grain House afterwards, then partake in the complimentary continental bfast the next morning. It is a stunningly beautiful venue both inside and outside and the food was plentiful and fabulous! The entire staff is very professional, but at the same time very warm and personal. They truly helped our wedding celebration to be absolutely perfect! Great value as well!
Olde Mill Inn is a unique venue in that it offers so much more than your typical 5 hour wedding package. Many of our Read more...
Olde Mill Inn is a unique venue in that it offers so much more than your typical 5 hour wedding package. Many of our guests stayed overnight, allowing them to enjoy post-reception drinks at the Grain House afterwards, then partake in the complimentary continental bfast the next morning. It is a stunningly beautiful venue both inside and outside and the food was plentiful and fabulous! The entire staff is very professional, but at the same time very warm and personal. They truly helped our wedding celebration to be absolutely perfect! Great value as well! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Raquel
Wedding:
1/19/2013
4.8/5.0
Overall, I loved my experience with the Olde Mill Inn. I just got married in January and my wedding was truly lovely. We also did our rehearsal dinner, after party and next day breakfast at the Inn and all were a success. On the day of, everything was spot on perfect. I have gotten so many compliments on my wedding. One of which is the food. People told me that their meat was cooked to order perfectly and that their main courses suprisingly were as delicious as cocktail hour. Catherine & John put together an amazing event for me. During the planning process, Catherine was so responsive and did everything she could to make my life easier. On the day of, John was everywhere and went above and beyond. I did not have a bridal attendant for some reason (so if that is important to you, you should stress that issue) and to be honest, I think the attendant may not have been necessary... John got us everything we needed. I had a wonderful time at my wedding and all the related events and would definitely recommend this venue.
Overall, I loved my experience with the Olde Mill Inn. I just got married in January and my wedding was truly lovely. We Read more...
Overall, I loved my experience with the Olde Mill Inn. I just got married in January and my wedding was truly lovely. We also did our rehearsal dinner, after party and next day breakfast at the Inn and all were a success. On the day of, everything was spot on perfect. I have gotten so many compliments on my wedding. One of which is the food. People told me that their meat was cooked to order perfectly and that their main courses suprisingly were as delicious as cocktail hour. Catherine & John put together an amazing event for me. During the planning process, Catherine was so responsive and did everything she could to make my life easier. On the day of, John was everywhere and went above and beyond. I did not have a bridal attendant for some reason (so if that is important to you, you should stress that issue) and to be honest, I think the attendant may not have been necessary... John got us everything we needed. I had a wonderful time at my wedding and all the related events and would definitely recommend this venue. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Hi Raquel,
Thank you for taking the time to write such a lovely testimonial. We too were honored to have hosted your Rehearsal Dinner, Wedding Celebration and Post Nuptial Breakfast.
Please honor us one more time by sharing a photo....hoping to see you in the near future!
Best Wishes,
Catherine
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Nicole
Wedding:
2/25/2012
4.8/5.0
The winter package was a great value. I worked with Lindsey and she got back to me very quickly whenever I had a question or concern. The hotel is very clean and nice and all our guests enjoyed their experience there
The winter package was a great value. I worked with Lindsey and she got back to me very quickly whenever I had a question Read more...
The winter package was a great value. I worked with Lindsey and she got back to me very quickly whenever I had a question or concern. The hotel is very clean and nice and all our guests enjoyed their experience there Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
4.8/5.0
I had my wedding at the Grain House at the Olde Mill Inn. We were having an intimate wedding and I was looking for something different than the traditional wedding venues. I felt that this fit in what we were looking for. We had both our ceremony and reception at the site. It was a beautiful day so we were able to have our ceremony outside by the gazebo and cocktail hour outside under the tent. The food was excellent and we received many compliments on how attentive the servers were. We got the cake from the place the OMI uses and it was both beautiful and delicious. Lindsay was our Maitre D and did a great job - she went out of her way to make sure everything went smoothly. A lot of our guests stayed at the Inn the night of our wedding and Lindsay had reserved an area that we could all sit together for the breakfast in the morning, which was nice. The only thing that slightly bothered me was that there was a lot of events scheduled in the Grain House the same day of our wedding (I think there was a bridal shower, baby shower, graduation party that went on earlier in the day). When we were going around the grounds to take pictures before the ceremony, there were some kids running around from the graduation party and my florist had commented that the kids were playing with the flowers that she had already set up for the ceremony. Overall, I was very happy with the OMI and would recommend to others to have their wedding there.
I had my wedding at the Grain House at the Olde Mill Inn. We were having an intimate wedding and I was looking for Read more...
I had my wedding at the Grain House at the Olde Mill Inn. We were having an intimate wedding and I was looking for something different than the traditional wedding venues. I felt that this fit in what we were looking for. We had both our ceremony and reception at the site. It was a beautiful day so we were able to have our ceremony outside by the gazebo and cocktail hour outside under the tent. The food was excellent and we received many compliments on how attentive the servers were. We got the cake from the place the OMI uses and it was both beautiful and delicious. Lindsay was our Maitre D and did a great job - she went out of her way to make sure everything went smoothly. A lot of our guests stayed at the Inn the night of our wedding and Lindsay had reserved an area that we could all sit together for the breakfast in the morning, which was nice. The only thing that slightly bothered me was that there was a lot of events scheduled in the Grain House the same day of our wedding (I think there was a bridal shower, baby shower, graduation party that went on earlier in the day). When we were going around the grounds to take pictures before the ceremony, there were some kids running around from the graduation party and my florist had commented that the kids were playing with the flowers that she had already set up for the ceremony. Overall, I was very happy with the OMI and would recommend to others to have their wedding there. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Aud
Wedding:
4/19/2008
4.8/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn did a great job with our wedding reception and hospitality for our guests. John, our maitre'd, did a phenomenal job the day of wedding. He was constantly checking in on us to ask us if we needed anything and met any requests we made that day. The cocktail hour setup in the courtyard was lovely and our guests really enjoyed themselves. We've gotten wonderful compliments the food they were served. The reception hall was set up exactly as we had pictured it... they did not miss a detail! The reception schedule and meal service went very smoothly. If there were any problems that day, we had no idea!

The hotel itself is great also! The front desk employees were very kind to us. Handing out OOT bags for our guests was no problem at all for them. We also used the Bernards suite the morning of the wedding to get ready and it was fantastic. It's very nice and big and could accomodate moms, bridesmaids, friends, photographers, hair stylists, and makeup artists with no problem! I'd highly recommend reserving that if it's available. They also have a very nice continental breakfast set up every morning, which was great for the morning after the wedding.

I would highly recommend the Olde Mill Inn to other brides.
The Olde Mill Inn did a great job with our wedding reception and hospitality for our guests. John, our maitre'd, did a Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn did a great job with our wedding reception and hospitality for our guests. John, our maitre'd, did a phenomenal job the day of wedding. He was constantly checking in on us to ask us if we needed anything and met any requests we made that day. The cocktail hour setup in the courtyard was lovely and our guests really enjoyed themselves. We've gotten wonderful compliments the food they were served. The reception hall was set up exactly as we had pictured it... they did not miss a detail! The reception schedule and meal service went very smoothly. If there were any problems that day, we had no idea!

The hotel itself is great also! The front desk employees were very kind to us. Handing out OOT bags for our guests was no problem at all for them. We also used the Bernards suite the morning of the wedding to get ready and it was fantastic. It's very nice and big and could accomodate moms, bridesmaids, friends, photographers, hair stylists, and makeup artists with no problem! I'd highly recommend reserving that if it's available. They also have a very nice continental breakfast set up every morning, which was great for the morning after the wedding.

I would highly recommend the Olde Mill Inn to other brides. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jessica
Wedding:
8/18/2012
4.7/5.0
This venue is wonderful for weddings! Most everyone I told that I was having my wedding here said they had been to a wedding here and loved it. During my wedding, the guests raved about the food. I agreed. The staff helped us with the planning, and were so flexible with food requests and assisted us with setting up our party favors and basically took care of everything. The venue itself is gorgeous, and works for both intimate and large weddings. I cannot recommend the Olde Mill Inn and Grain House highly enough. - Jessica
This venue is wonderful for weddings! Most everyone I told that I was having my wedding here said they had been to a Read more...
This venue is wonderful for weddings! Most everyone I told that I was having my wedding here said they had been to a wedding here and loved it. During my wedding, the guests raved about the food. I agreed. The staff helped us with the planning, and were so flexible with food requests and assisted us with setting up our party favors and basically took care of everything. The venue itself is gorgeous, and works for both intimate and large weddings. I cannot recommend the Olde Mill Inn and Grain House highly enough. - Jessica Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Joanna33t
Wedding:
1/26/2008
4.7/5.0
Love this place! They are so good at what they do and they did such a great job. The ONLY minor things that didn't go that great were:
1) Dropping off all the decorations and centerpieces for the reception was a bit disorganized. Everything just got plopped into a storage room downstairs and I didn't really have a chance to show them how I wanted it set up specifically.
2) The captain was nice enough to let me view the reception room before opening it up to everyone to go in. But we hadn't been announced yet and we had to walk through the cocktail hour to see it. My guests were sort of confused with us walking around all of a sudden and just scooting past them.
All in all though - they did such a great job and everyone raved. And we loved that the rooms were on site!
Love this place! They are so good at what they do and they did such a great job. The ONLY minor things that didn't go that Read more...
Love this place! They are so good at what they do and they did such a great job. The ONLY minor things that didn't go that great were:
1) Dropping off all the decorations and centerpieces for the reception was a bit disorganized. Everything just got plopped into a storage room downstairs and I didn't really have a chance to show them how I wanted it set up specifically.
2) The captain was nice enough to let me view the reception room before opening it up to everyone to go in. But we hadn't been announced yet and we had to walk through the cocktail hour to see it. My guests were sort of confused with us walking around all of a sudden and just scooting past them.
All in all though - they did such a great job and everyone raved. And we loved that the rooms were on site! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake, Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
4.6/5.0
John and Cathi from OMI were fantastic! The food was AMAZING, the timing was right on schedule, my husband and I were waited on hand and foot all night by our own personal waitress, and I didn't have to worry about a single thing! Cathi answered all of my questions in an extremely timely manner throughout my whole planning process, which is GREATLY appreciated when planning a wedding. My only comment to them would be that it would have been nice to have been assigned my maitre'd prior to 2 months before the wedding. However, that's hindsight and everything else about OMI outshines soooo many other venues that I've seen and been to for other weddings - they can't even hold a candle to OMI's atmosphere, service, staff, food, space, etc.! I just wish we could do it all over again :-)
John and Cathi from OMI were fantastic! The food was AMAZING, the timing was right on schedule, my husband and I were Read more...
John and Cathi from OMI were fantastic! The food was AMAZING, the timing was right on schedule, my husband and I were waited on hand and foot all night by our own personal waitress, and I didn't have to worry about a single thing! Cathi answered all of my questions in an extremely timely manner throughout my whole planning process, which is GREATLY appreciated when planning a wedding. My only comment to them would be that it would have been nice to have been assigned my maitre'd prior to 2 months before the wedding. However, that's hindsight and everything else about OMI outshines soooo many other venues that I've seen and been to for other weddings - they can't even hold a candle to OMI's atmosphere, service, staff, food, space, etc.! I just wish we could do it all over again :-) Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you for your lovely review Katie....I received an email from your father today and that was the icing on the cake!! Hosting your wedding was all our pleasure and we wish you the very best.....love to have a photo??? Stop in and see us in the near future.....Kind regards, Cathi
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Samantha
Wedding:
11/10/2012
4.5/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn did an outstanding job at our wedding. During Hurricane Sandy they were constantly updating us each day until power was restored. We had the most amazing party and couldn't have done it without John our maitre d. Thanks again!
The Olde Mill Inn did an outstanding job at our wedding. During Hurricane Sandy they were constantly updating us each day Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn did an outstanding job at our wedding. During Hurricane Sandy they were constantly updating us each day until power was restored. We had the most amazing party and couldn't have done it without John our maitre d. Thanks again! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
mz
Wedding:
4/23/2011
4.5/5.0
What else can you say when your wedding is referred to as "Simply Remarkable". The food, ambiance and servcie were just exceptional. I fell in love with the Olde Mill Inn the minute I set eye on it and my wedding was even lovelier than I imagined. I HIGHLY recommend the Olde Mill Inn.
What else can you say when your wedding is referred to as "Simply Remarkable". The food, ambiance and servcie were just Read more...
What else can you say when your wedding is referred to as "Simply Remarkable". The food, ambiance and servcie were just exceptional. I fell in love with the Olde Mill Inn the minute I set eye on it and my wedding was even lovelier than I imagined. I HIGHLY recommend the Olde Mill Inn. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
130x130_sq_1213444507225-02
Tristia
Wedding:
5/24/2008
4.5/5.0
My experiences with the Olde Mill Inn were mixed in the beginning, but overall was extremely positive in the end. Our contact at the Olde Mill Inn had left the company and the communication I received from them in the beginning was hazy. There was no one in touch with me to schedule payments that were due as well as no one to talk to about tastings and other things until about 3 months before the wedding when we were eventually assigned a matre de. Our 1st matre de also left the company shortly after we were introduced (which we were not told, I got the front desk after calls not being returned and was told she quit), but she was working on the weekends and working in the city during the week. This made her very hard to reach. Fortunately, after contacting the banquet manager about the problem and being reassigned a matre de, things went extremely smoothly and all my calls went answered.

The day of the wedding was fantastic, our new Matre De, John Lietz, was phenomenal. Along with our DJ (Joe Zarzano at ESP Entertainment) we had not a thing to worry about the entire day. Depending on the time of day/what day you get married, you will pay between $100 - $150pp, which in NJ is relatively reasonable. If you are good at following up on your own stuff (just in case of any staffing mishaps, which I ran into a few times at the inn) I would recommend them as a ceremony site and reception hall.

Also, to note, in previous reviews where brides noted that the food was excellent, but that the rehearsal was rushed and the matre de came across pushy... is very accurate. If your a bride who wants to be completely catered to and waited on hand and foot, this is probably not the place for you. They do make sure you are comfortable and have what you need, but they pump out quite a few weddings in a weekend and don't seem to admire a lot of the specifics a pickier bride may want on her wedding day.
My experiences with the Olde Mill Inn were mixed in the beginning, but overall was extremely positive in the end. Our Read more...
My experiences with the Olde Mill Inn were mixed in the beginning, but overall was extremely positive in the end. Our contact at the Olde Mill Inn had left the company and the communication I received from them in the beginning was hazy. There was no one in touch with me to schedule payments that were due as well as no one to talk to about tastings and other things until about 3 months before the wedding when we were eventually assigned a matre de. Our 1st matre de also left the company shortly after we were introduced (which we were not told, I got the front desk after calls not being returned and was told she quit), but she was working on the weekends and working in the city during the week. This made her very hard to reach. Fortunately, after contacting the banquet manager about the problem and being reassigned a matre de, things went extremely smoothly and all my calls went answered.

The day of the wedding was fantastic, our new Matre De, John Lietz, was phenomenal. Along with our DJ (Joe Zarzano at ESP Entertainment) we had not a thing to worry about the entire day. Depending on the time of day/what day you get married, you will pay between $100 - $150pp, which in NJ is relatively reasonable. If you are good at following up on your own stuff (just in case of any staffing mishaps, which I ran into a few times at the inn) I would recommend them as a ceremony site and reception hall.

Also, to note, in previous reviews where brides noted that the food was excellent, but that the rehearsal was rushed and the matre de came across pushy... is very accurate. If your a bride who wants to be completely catered to and waited on hand and foot, this is probably not the place for you. They do make sure you are comfortable and have what you need, but they pump out quite a few weddings in a weekend and don't seem to admire a lot of the specifics a pickier bride may want on her wedding day. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
tishy13
Wedding:
9/12/1999
4.5/5.0
Our wedding was raved about for months (years) by our guests. We had only 65 people - a very intimate venue - in the most gorgeous and romantic room at the Olde Mill Inn. The gardens, the terrace, the food, the service - everything was perfect! We only wish we had more time!
Our wedding was raved about for months (years) by our guests. We had only 65 people - a very intimate venue - in the most Read more...
Our wedding was raved about for months (years) by our guests. We had only 65 people - a very intimate venue - in the most gorgeous and romantic room at the Olde Mill Inn. The gardens, the terrace, the food, the service - everything was perfect! We only wish we had more time! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
9/14/2012
4.4/5.0
Our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn was beautiful. The setting and atmosphere fit our style and needs. In most areas, the venue exceeded our expectations. The staff was attentive and the food was well presented and prepared.
Most of the shortcomings were realized in our experience with the maitre'd. During the event, the communication was lacking. Before the ceremony it felt disorganized and no one in the bridal party knew what was going on. The MD seemed to be MIA often, and I even went looking for her to know when the ceremony would begin. We were running late taking pictures and the location for pictures was next to the ceremony, guests started arriving and walking over.. We were not happy, I feel it is the venues job to control these things and I had not even seen our MD yet that day. Your wedding day can be very hectic and you really need someone to be directing the people involved in the actual ceremony. You need a MD that will take charge, you do not want to be worrying about anything on this day.
Our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn was beautiful. The setting and atmosphere fit our style and needs. In most areas, the Read more...
Our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn was beautiful. The setting and atmosphere fit our style and needs. In most areas, the venue exceeded our expectations. The staff was attentive and the food was well presented and prepared.
Most of the shortcomings were realized in our experience with the maitre'd. During the event, the communication was lacking. Before the ceremony it felt disorganized and no one in the bridal party knew what was going on. The MD seemed to be MIA often, and I even went looking for her to know when the ceremony would begin. We were running late taking pictures and the location for pictures was next to the ceremony, guests started arriving and walking over.. We were not happy, I feel it is the venues job to control these things and I had not even seen our MD yet that day. Your wedding day can be very hectic and you really need someone to be directing the people involved in the actual ceremony. You need a MD that will take charge, you do not want to be worrying about anything on this day. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
jmearch
Wedding:
9/8/2007
4.4/5.0
they assign a coordinator to you about a month before the wedding with whom you can constantly update and communicate. it's nice to have a point person to contact.
they assign a coordinator to you about a month before the wedding with whom you can constantly update and communicate. Read more...
they assign a coordinator to you about a month before the wedding with whom you can constantly update and communicate. it's nice to have a point person to contact. Read less
Services Used: Catering, Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Georgine
Wedding:
2/24/2012
4.2/5.0
Overall a very successful wedding but at first had some stresses about menu planning & pricing. Also if the bridal party is not getting ready there, make sure when you arrive you have a room to fix your hair, dresses, veil, etc. That part was a little confusing as we were trying to hide me from the crowd (our ceremony was there as well). Make sure the trees in the courtyard are lit. The brochure shows a beautiful pic of 2 tress with white lights, but the night of my wedding only one of them were working...very disappointing. These are my only complaints, but after I got that out, they did a beautiful job & service was great.
Overall a very successful wedding but at first had some stresses about menu planning & pricing. Also if the bridal party Read more...
Overall a very successful wedding but at first had some stresses about menu planning & pricing. Also if the bridal party is not getting ready there, make sure when you arrive you have a room to fix your hair, dresses, veil, etc. That part was a little confusing as we were trying to hide me from the crowd (our ceremony was there as well). Make sure the trees in the courtyard are lit. The brochure shows a beautiful pic of 2 tress with white lights, but the night of my wedding only one of them were working...very disappointing. These are my only complaints, but after I got that out, they did a beautiful job & service was great. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Edith
Wedding:
6/10/2006
4.2/5.0
They were very accomodating, and attentive to our needs. The food was excellent and they took the time to make our day special.
We also loved the fact that the accomodations were on the premises. We also received a gift certificate as a wedding gift to come back on our anniversary.
They were very accomodating, and attentive to our needs. The food was excellent and they took the time to make our day Read more...
They were very accomodating, and attentive to our needs. The food was excellent and they took the time to make our day special.
We also loved the fact that the accomodations were on the premises. We also received a gift certificate as a wedding gift to come back on our anniversary. Read less
Services Used: Catering
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Marjorie
Wedding:
5/31/2008
4.1/5.0
We loved our ceremony there. They were responsive and professional. Only problems: they tried to charge us a fee the day before to have names on our out of town bags (didn't tell us in advance but never charged us) and they had a glitch in the computer system so we weren't sure who was registered in the hotel for our wedding. To their credit they let us go over our guest list over the phone to figure it out one by one (but a pain in the butt). They really wanted us to be happy and tried to make it the perfect day.

The huge suites they have are expensive (we paid $300/night) but totally worth it if you can use the room (we threw a party for our closest 20 friends and it was an awesome after-party). We were rained out and had the ceremony inside but with flowers it wound up being gorgeous (I thought it looked blah beforehand). I loved having family stay at the inn and we all met at the free continental breakfast the next morning to say goodbyes, chat on the patio... it was wonderful b/c they could accomodate all the guests but it's small enough to feel homey and not stiff like a regular hotel.
We loved our ceremony there. They were responsive and professional. Only problems: they tried to charge us a fee the day Read more...
We loved our ceremony there. They were responsive and professional. Only problems: they tried to charge us a fee the day before to have names on our out of town bags (didn't tell us in advance but never charged us) and they had a glitch in the computer system so we weren't sure who was registered in the hotel for our wedding. To their credit they let us go over our guest list over the phone to figure it out one by one (but a pain in the butt). They really wanted us to be happy and tried to make it the perfect day.

The huge suites they have are expensive (we paid $300/night) but totally worth it if you can use the room (we threw a party for our closest 20 friends and it was an awesome after-party). We were rained out and had the ceremony inside but with flowers it wound up being gorgeous (I thought it looked blah beforehand). I loved having family stay at the inn and we all met at the free continental breakfast the next morning to say goodbyes, chat on the patio... it was wonderful b/c they could accomodate all the guests but it's small enough to feel homey and not stiff like a regular hotel. Read less
Services Used: Catering, Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Michelle
Wedding:
10/7/2012
4.0/5.0
WE love this place, its beautiful and the food is delicious! Trust me when I say that our guests really loved this venue and were amorous about the dishes they were served. I strongly recommend to any bride that chooses any venue, if you plan for an outdoors wedding you should also plan how everything would work if you have to move your plans indoors. If you are considering the movements of your guests and figure out where they will go during your wedding, this may change if your celebration is indoors instead of outside. Always create another setup/plan in case this situation arises. You will fall in love with this place from the moment you walk in.
WE love this place, its beautiful and the food is delicious! Trust me when I say that our guests really loved this venue Read more...
WE love this place, its beautiful and the food is delicious! Trust me when I say that our guests really loved this venue and were amorous about the dishes they were served. I strongly recommend to any bride that chooses any venue, if you plan for an outdoors wedding you should also plan how everything would work if you have to move your plans indoors. If you are considering the movements of your guests and figure out where they will go during your wedding, this may change if your celebration is indoors instead of outside. Always create another setup/plan in case this situation arises. You will fall in love with this place from the moment you walk in. Read less
Services Used: Catering, Transportation, Wedding Venue, Unique Services
Olde Mill Inn responded with the following comments:

Thank you Michelle....we wish you the very best and hope to see you soon with photos of your beautiful wedding celebration!
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Mrs. Bove2B
Wedding:
6/16/2009
4.0/5.0
The Olde Mill Inn was the PREFECT setting for our wedding but it was not without flaws getting to the day. I will say though, the quality of service they my guests, and we recieved was next to none. It was a perfect day and The Olde Mill Inn help to make it come true.
I was extremely frustrated with the service before the wedding thoug, we have phone call that when un returned, recieved our day of coordinator over a moonth late and had to go to 2 tastings because they messed up our selection (the food was amazing!!! they just weren't organized and we didn't end up letting us taste the food that would be served at our wedding) They did do their best to rectify any issues but it was not with causeing stress for a busy bride!
My big recommendation is to encourage your guest to stay over night and be sure to spring for the suite. We actually booked both! Once for us and one for an after party!
The Olde Mill Inn was the PREFECT setting for our wedding but it was not without flaws getting to the day. I will say Read more...
The Olde Mill Inn was the PREFECT setting for our wedding but it was not without flaws getting to the day. I will say though, the quality of service they my guests, and we recieved was next to none. It was a perfect day and The Olde Mill Inn help to make it come true.
I was extremely frustrated with the service before the wedding thoug, we have phone call that when un returned, recieved our day of coordinator over a moonth late and had to go to 2 tastings because they messed up our selection (the food was amazing!!! they just weren't organized and we didn't end up letting us taste the food that would be served at our wedding) They did do their best to rectify any issues but it was not with causeing stress for a busy bride!
My big recommendation is to encourage your guest to stay over night and be sure to spring for the suite. We actually booked both! Once for us and one for an after party! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
christy
Wedding:
6/30/2006
4.0/5.0
beautiful place- great food- but clarify the contract carefully- what we were told when we signed by the sales team and what was really the case was different- however they did accomedate us with the changes that we thought we were entitled to so they do get points for that..but this is not a place for you if you want to have a really late night wedding...
beautiful place- great food- but clarify the contract carefully- what we were told when we signed by the sales team and Read more...
beautiful place- great food- but clarify the contract carefully- what we were told when we signed by the sales team and what was really the case was different- however they did accomedate us with the changes that we thought we were entitled to so they do get points for that..but this is not a place for you if you want to have a really late night wedding... Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
sharon
Wedding:
3/3/2007
3.8/5.0
this venue was fantastic and worth every penny, i would recommend this place for a reception any day.
this venue was fantastic and worth every penny, i would recommend this place for a reception any day.
this venue was fantastic and worth every penny, i would recommend this place for a reception any day. Read less
Services Used: Catering
Default-vendor-profile-pic
handm2007
Wedding:
12/30/2007
3.7/5.0
My husband and I picked the Olde Mill Inn for our wedding simply because it is a gorgeous little retreat where our guests could not only attend the wedding, but could spend the night as well. Moreover, the stair cases in the hotel were perfect for wedding photography. So we booked it. Overall, I was pleased with the experience of the hotel because everything was beautiful, the food was excellent, and everything we wanted was provided through the contract. However, the service of the establishment may need some primping. The hotel assigns a maitre'd for your wedding, which gets in contact with you approximately 2 months before the wedding. He did that...but it took forever for him to return my message after I called him back. This pattern seemed to repeat itself throughout our communications, which became annoying after the second time. Our ceremony was also held at the hotel, where we also had rehearsal the night before. There was a wedding taking place that night as well, so our rehearsal was held in another room. No big deal. However, the time the maitre'd told us to have the rehearsal was a little funny because he had the other wedding starting one hour later. Needless to say, our rehearsal was not his priority that night and we were rushed through. I didn't really care about that, but again it seemed that the lack of communication was coming through. The night of the wedding went smoothly for the most part. The room was gorgeous, the food was great, and everyone raved about the party for days. But there were little things that, had I been a pickier bride, could have been dealbreakers. First, when we were sat after our first dance, some of the groomsmen were asking for extra chairs to sit at our table because there were not enough place settings at the groomsmen table. I asked the maitre'd about this, and he argued to me, in front of other people at my reception, that there were enough seats. I then counted them to him where he realized he was wrong. He quickly rendered the problem. Then, part of our decor was smacked into a partially fell on the cake (sidenote: my husband and his friend, who had been drinking, were the culprits and it was funny). However, my husband and I were the ones to fix it. None of the passing waiters came over to help or went to get help. The cake survived with minimal scarring. Later, towards the end of the reception, my mother pulled me to the side. She and my father wanted to ask me to reduce the maitre'd tip (ps, the hotels "requests" an optional amount of 5% of the total cost of the reception as a tip for the maitre'd, a number which, according to all the books, websites, and other people, is extremely high). When I asked why, she said she had multiple guests complaining about him during both the ceremony and the cocktail hour for being pushy and rude. That did it.

I am beyond thrilled that we had our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn simply because the ambiance was so perfect for the event we had in mind, and for the most part they delivered it. If you are thinking of booking them, you won't be disappointed but be prepared to be vocal.
My husband and I picked the Olde Mill Inn for our wedding simply because it is a gorgeous little retreat where our guests Read more...
My husband and I picked the Olde Mill Inn for our wedding simply because it is a gorgeous little retreat where our guests could not only attend the wedding, but could spend the night as well. Moreover, the stair cases in the hotel were perfect for wedding photography. So we booked it. Overall, I was pleased with the experience of the hotel because everything was beautiful, the food was excellent, and everything we wanted was provided through the contract. However, the service of the establishment may need some primping. The hotel assigns a maitre'd for your wedding, which gets in contact with you approximately 2 months before the wedding. He did that...but it took forever for him to return my message after I called him back. This pattern seemed to repeat itself throughout our communications, which became annoying after the second time. Our ceremony was also held at the hotel, where we also had rehearsal the night before. There was a wedding taking place that night as well, so our rehearsal was held in another room. No big deal. However, the time the maitre'd told us to have the rehearsal was a little funny because he had the other wedding starting one hour later. Needless to say, our rehearsal was not his priority that night and we were rushed through. I didn't really care about that, but again it seemed that the lack of communication was coming through. The night of the wedding went smoothly for the most part. The room was gorgeous, the food was great, and everyone raved about the party for days. But there were little things that, had I been a pickier bride, could have been dealbreakers. First, when we were sat after our first dance, some of the groomsmen were asking for extra chairs to sit at our table because there were not enough place settings at the groomsmen table. I asked the maitre'd about this, and he argued to me, in front of other people at my reception, that there were enough seats. I then counted them to him where he realized he was wrong. He quickly rendered the problem. Then, part of our decor was smacked into a partially fell on the cake (sidenote: my husband and his friend, who had been drinking, were the culprits and it was funny). However, my husband and I were the ones to fix it. None of the passing waiters came over to help or went to get help. The cake survived with minimal scarring. Later, towards the end of the reception, my mother pulled me to the side. She and my father wanted to ask me to reduce the maitre'd tip (ps, the hotels "requests" an optional amount of 5% of the total cost of the reception as a tip for the maitre'd, a number which, according to all the books, websites, and other people, is extremely high). When I asked why, she said she had multiple guests complaining about him during both the ceremony and the cocktail hour for being pushy and rude. That did it.

I am beyond thrilled that we had our wedding at the Olde Mill Inn simply because the ambiance was so perfect for the event we had in mind, and for the most part they delivered it. If you are thinking of booking them, you won't be disappointed but be prepared to be vocal. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
arobinson
Wedding:
8/6/2011
3.5/5.0
The Inn is beautiful and the prices are reasonable. The Maitre D, John did a fabulous job; he is worth his weight in gold! I found my sales person disappointing. Once I booked her customer service went out the window! I called with a concern and she told me I had to hold on b/c she deals with hundreds of brides and had no idea who I was. Even if that is true, why on earth would you say that to your client!!!! Also, it rained on the day of our wedding so the ceremony had to be moved inside and all throughout the ceremony you can hear the wait staff banging trays, talking, and laughing. I still enjoyed my day and liked the Inn. I would just make sure you get everything Sales promises you in writing in your contract.
The Inn is beautiful and the prices are reasonable. The Maitre D, John did a fabulous job; he is worth his weight in gold! Read more...
The Inn is beautiful and the prices are reasonable. The Maitre D, John did a fabulous job; he is worth his weight in gold! I found my sales person disappointing. Once I booked her customer service went out the window! I called with a concern and she told me I had to hold on b/c she deals with hundreds of brides and had no idea who I was. Even if that is true, why on earth would you say that to your client!!!! Also, it rained on the day of our wedding so the ceremony had to be moved inside and all throughout the ceremony you can hear the wait staff banging trays, talking, and laughing. I still enjoyed my day and liked the Inn. I would just make sure you get everything Sales promises you in writing in your contract. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Fawn
Wedding:
1/5/2007
3.5/5.0
We loved the venue but the matre de left something to be desired. She was sweet at first but after we gave her our money she didnt care about us. And on the day of she was very pushy and bossy.
We loved the venue but the matre de left something to be desired. She was sweet at first but after we gave her our money Read more...
We loved the venue but the matre de left something to be desired. She was sweet at first but after we gave her our money she didnt care about us. And on the day of she was very pushy and bossy. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake, Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jennifer
Wedding:
9/25/2010
2.4/5.0
They sell you this venue with a really great, dynamic woman. Unless you are planning on dropping 40K, you will not have her involved with your wedding past this point. My matre'd had a horrible attitude, was extremely rude and short when asked questions, and complained in the hallway about having to run our rehearsal dinner (as scheduled) for the entire wedding party to hear! Great food, beautiful venue though
They sell you this venue with a really great, dynamic woman. Unless you are planning on dropping 40K, you will not have Read more...
They sell you this venue with a really great, dynamic woman. Unless you are planning on dropping 40K, you will not have her involved with your wedding past this point. My matre'd had a horrible attitude, was extremely rude and short when asked questions, and complained in the hallway about having to run our rehearsal dinner (as scheduled) for the entire wedding party to hear! Great food, beautiful venue though Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake, Catering, Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
1.4/5.0
Not a happy bride! I want express my profound frustration and disappointment with the Olde Mill Inn because I NEVER want anyone to go through what I did.
My Maitre' D, John was an absolute mess! To start, I had my best man running around trying to figure out what to do with our overnight stuff. Because a bunch of us stayed the night before we had a lot of things with us, especially me as the bride. We were thrown out of the room at 11am. No one was willing to help us move our luggage and things. My guest had to put the ceremony runner down because he couldn't figure out how to. Then, I was promised a table of bottled water would be set up outside before the ceremony for the guest. Our ceremony was outside in the gazebo. There was no water! I was promised by the Maitre D that my sky Lanterns would be set up on a separate table next to the water. Not only were they not, they completely disappeared. (& they are NOT cheap). During my cocktail hour champagne was handed out, however there were not enough of glasses. I had several people ask for water, including a few pregnant women. They were not spoken to, they were YELLED at by the maitre d. He was refusing to give water. HELLO, water is free! Plus he failed to put the bottles out like I was told. When I heard him raise his voice I went to go speak with him and I was yelled at by my own Maitre D. I thought a Maitre D's job was to help the couple, not stress them out!
My reception was rushed. The staff cleared off all of the table 75 minutes before my time was up and when my guest asked for drinks, they were told no because they had another wedding coming in.
I had my extra flowers I paid for go missing as well as my sky lanterns. My sand ceremony heart was completely mixed up and ruined.
It was just a horrible experience! I would never wish any bride to go through what I did. My special day was destroyed. I had sent a long complaint letter to the General Manager and I basically got, Oh Sorry!
Not a happy bride! I want express my profound frustration and disappointment with the Olde Mill Inn because I NEVER want Read more...
Not a happy bride! I want express my profound frustration and disappointment with the Olde Mill Inn because I NEVER want anyone to go through what I did.
My Maitre' D, John was an absolute mess! To start, I had my best man running around trying to figure out what to do with our overnight stuff. Because a bunch of us stayed the night before we had a lot of things with us, especially me as the bride. We were thrown out of the room at 11am. No one was willing to help us move our luggage and things. My guest had to put the ceremony runner down because he couldn't figure out how to. Then, I was promised a table of bottled water would be set up outside before the ceremony for the guest. Our ceremony was outside in the gazebo. There was no water! I was promised by the Maitre D that my sky Lanterns would be set up on a separate table next to the water. Not only were they not, they completely disappeared. (& they are NOT cheap). During my cocktail hour champagne was handed out, however there were not enough of glasses. I had several people ask for water, including a few pregnant women. They were not spoken to, they were YELLED at by the maitre d. He was refusing to give water. HELLO, water is free! Plus he failed to put the bottles out like I was told. When I heard him raise his voice I went to go speak with him and I was yelled at by my own Maitre D. I thought a Maitre D's job was to help the couple, not stress them out!
My reception was rushed. The staff cleared off all of the table 75 minutes before my time was up and when my guest asked for drinks, they were told no because they had another wedding coming in.
I had my extra flowers I paid for go missing as well as my sky lanterns. My sand ceremony heart was completely mixed up and ruined.
It was just a horrible experience! I would never wish any bride to go through what I did. My special day was destroyed. I had sent a long complaint letter to the General Manager and I basically got, Oh Sorry! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Venue
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Sacco210
Wedding:
3/27/2009
1.4/5.0
I was very disappointed in the Olde Mill Inn for my wedding reception. I had higher expectations after reading reviews on this venue and them being voted The Knot "best of weddings" for several years. First the Maitre'd was nearly impossible to get a hold of and would not respond to messages in a timely manner. While going over our menu he did not take time out to listen to what we wanted and pushed us into other choices. Additionally, he did not follow directions on our wedding cake design we picked out. We weren't allowed to have any cake testing and when our wedding day came, the cake tasted disgusting. More then half our guests didn't eat it. Some items the Maitre'd was in charge of during the reception was conveniently "lost/stolen" (according to him) by the time we got all our stuff back at the end. The reception hall set up was poor and the only other complaint was during the cocktail hour - many of the passed appetizers were not present. Overall, I thought I could have had better service.
I was very disappointed in the Olde Mill Inn for my wedding reception. I had higher expectations after reading reviews on Read more...
I was very disappointed in the Olde Mill Inn for my wedding reception. I had higher expectations after reading reviews on this venue and them being voted The Knot "best of weddings" for several years. First the Maitre'd was nearly impossible to get a hold of and would not respond to messages in a timely manner. While going over our menu he did not take time out to listen to what we wanted and pushed us into other choices. Additionally, he did not follow directions on our wedding cake design we picked out. We weren't allowed to have any cake testing and when our wedding day came, the cake tasted disgusting. More then half our guests didn't eat it. Some items the Maitre'd was in charge of during the reception was conveniently "lost/stolen" (according to him) by the time we got all our stuff back at the end. The reception hall set up was poor and the only other complaint was during the cocktail hour - many of the passed appetizers were not present. Overall, I thought I could have had better service. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake, Catering, Wedding Venue

MAP

 
225 U.S. 202, Basking Ridge, NJ 07920 See On Map
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for Olde Mill Inn
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww_logo
 
220x220_1278952373824-0502copy