Nophoto-130

Once In A Blue Moon Bakery

Cary , NC

LOCATION

115-G W. Chatham Street
Cary, NC US 27511 (map)

PHONE

919-319-6554

WEBSITE

View website
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Wedding Cake

REVIEWS

4.8
out of 5.0
4.9/5.0
4.8/5.0
4.8/5.0
4.8/5.0
4.8/5.0
Sort by
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
4.4/5.0
This was absolutely the best wedding cake I've ever eaten AND our guests loved it!
This was absolutely the best wedding cake I've ever eaten AND our guests loved it!
This was absolutely the best wedding cake I've ever eaten AND our guests loved it! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
Our Wedding Cake and The Groom's Cake were perfect and very delicious!!! We were especially impressed with the decoration of the Groom's Cake with the Marine Corps Emblem. Seemed like a challenging request, but they nailed it! Everyone we talked to at the Bakery was extremely helpful and responsive. We had lots of compliments from our guests and the event staff on how scrumptious the cake was!! We would highly recommend Once In A Blue Moon!!
Our Wedding Cake and The Groom's Cake were perfect and very delicious!!! We were especially impressed with the decoration Read more...
Our Wedding Cake and The Groom's Cake were perfect and very delicious!!! We were especially impressed with the decoration of the Groom's Cake with the Marine Corps Emblem. Seemed like a challenging request, but they nailed it! Everyone we talked to at the Bakery was extremely helpful and responsive. We had lots of compliments from our guests and the event staff on how scrumptious the cake was!! We would highly recommend Once In A Blue Moon!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Katherine
Wedding:
8/15/2014
5.0/5.0
DELICIOUS!!! I could not believe how moist and fresh the cake tasted the day of the wedding. The whole consultation and ordering process was very easy and the cake turned out just like the picture I sent to them. My guest could not stop raving about the almond buttercream frosting. For the price Once In a Blue Moon can't be beat!!!!
DELICIOUS!!! I could not believe how moist and fresh the cake tasted the day of the wedding. The whole consultation and Read more...
DELICIOUS!!! I could not believe how moist and fresh the cake tasted the day of the wedding. The whole consultation and ordering process was very easy and the cake turned out just like the picture I sent to them. My guest could not stop raving about the almond buttercream frosting. For the price Once In a Blue Moon can't be beat!!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Beth
Wedding:
7/20/2014
5.0/5.0
My guests are still raving about my cake. Thanks Blue Moon!
My guests are still raving about my cake. Thanks Blue Moon!
My guests are still raving about my cake. Thanks Blue Moon! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
robin
Wedding:
7/19/2014
5.0/5.0
My new son called me on his wedding night to ask me to save him more wedding cake! Enough said.
My new son called me on his wedding night to ask me to save him more wedding cake! Enough said.
My new son called me on his wedding night to ask me to save him more wedding cake! Enough said. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Julie
Wedding:
7/19/2014
5.0/5.0
A great locally owned bakery! Everyone must try their Frangelico Cake. AMAZING!!!
A great locally owned bakery! Everyone must try their Frangelico Cake. AMAZING!!!
A great locally owned bakery! Everyone must try their Frangelico Cake. AMAZING!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Marisa
Wedding:
6/14/2014
5.0/5.0
BEST CAKE PLACE IN TOWN!!! If you are looking for a delicious wedding cake, look no further! Once in a Blue Moon was the perfect choice for John and I with just one bite. The staff is very friendly and passionate about creating the wedding cake of your dreams or you can look through a catalog of previous made cakes for ideas. Cake tasting was our favorite part of the "creating" process (aside from seeing the cake in its final product form). We had so much fun deciding the right combination (size and number of layers, smooth moose fillers, colors, and decorations). Price is on average point or better than other cake shops. John and I had decided we did not want to save the top cake to freeze to eat on our year anniversary. At Once in a Blue Moon, if you take back your receipt after your first year, they will give you a mini cake to celebrate your anniversary. WIN! WIN! :)
BEST CAKE PLACE IN TOWN!!! If you are looking for a delicious wedding cake, look no further! Once in a Blue Moon was the Read more...
BEST CAKE PLACE IN TOWN!!! If you are looking for a delicious wedding cake, look no further! Once in a Blue Moon was the perfect choice for John and I with just one bite. The staff is very friendly and passionate about creating the wedding cake of your dreams or you can look through a catalog of previous made cakes for ideas. Cake tasting was our favorite part of the "creating" process (aside from seeing the cake in its final product form). We had so much fun deciding the right combination (size and number of layers, smooth moose fillers, colors, and decorations). Price is on average point or better than other cake shops. John and I had decided we did not want to save the top cake to freeze to eat on our year anniversary. At Once in a Blue Moon, if you take back your receipt after your first year, they will give you a mini cake to celebrate your anniversary. WIN! WIN! :) Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Roseanne
Wedding:
6/14/2014
5.0/5.0
Cake was beautiful and delicious. Lilly was great to work with and offered good ideas for flavors and design,.
Cake was beautiful and delicious. Lilly was great to work with and offered good ideas for flavors and design,.
Cake was beautiful and delicious. Lilly was great to work with and offered good ideas for flavors and design,. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Chrystal
Wedding:
5/25/2014
5.0/5.0
Cake was wonderful, light and delicious.

Very prettty! Exactly like the photo I gave them.
Cake was wonderful, light and delicious.

Very prettty! Exactly like the photo I gave them.
Cake was wonderful, light and delicious.

Very prettty! Exactly like the photo I gave them. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Allie
Wedding:
5/25/2014
5.0/5.0
We had a wonderful experience with Once In A Blue Moon. They allowed us to taste on two separate occasions, and worked with me when I explained I wanted multiple, small, and simply decorated cakes rather than one large tiered cake. Our guests loved the cakes we chose (Red Velvet, Chocolate Encounter, Margarita and Peanut Butter Mousse especially) and raved about how delicious they were. I myself am lactose intolerant, which was accommodated by ordering a small 6" inch cake for my husband and myself (he is not lactose intolerant but said that vegan chocolate cake was one of the best he'd ever had). Not many bakeries in the area offered a great-tasting vegan option but we found it here. Their prices were way better than many of the other places I looked at. Especially if you consider yourself a low maintenance bride, this is your bakery - you will not be disappointed!
We had a wonderful experience with Once In A Blue Moon. They allowed us to taste on two separate occasions, and worked Read more...
We had a wonderful experience with Once In A Blue Moon. They allowed us to taste on two separate occasions, and worked with me when I explained I wanted multiple, small, and simply decorated cakes rather than one large tiered cake. Our guests loved the cakes we chose (Red Velvet, Chocolate Encounter, Margarita and Peanut Butter Mousse especially) and raved about how delicious they were. I myself am lactose intolerant, which was accommodated by ordering a small 6" inch cake for my husband and myself (he is not lactose intolerant but said that vegan chocolate cake was one of the best he'd ever had). Not many bakeries in the area offered a great-tasting vegan option but we found it here. Their prices were way better than many of the other places I looked at. Especially if you consider yourself a low maintenance bride, this is your bakery - you will not be disappointed! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Cathy
Wedding:
11/9/2013
5.0/5.0
We set out to start our cake tasting journey at Once in a Blue Moon Cafe. We strolled in on Saturday morning with an agenda to try some cake and set up an official cake tasting appointment. While sitting at a small table that morning sampling some of their cake-by-the-slice options, we had the pleasure of striking up a conversation with a woman that had stopped in to pick up a cake order. She began to tell us she was from NJ and had never had a cake as fantastic as the ones that she gets from Once in a Blue Moon and that she has to order something from them on a regular bases. We had to agree, we tried the Key Lime and Cappuccino Blast that morning and even after being sliced and refrigerated they were amazing. We set up the tasting appt but made no effort to seek out any other bakeries. We went with a non-traditional plan of doing several 10 in round cakes on different cake stands rather than doing a traditional wedding cake - our guest loved this as we had 4 different flavors of cakes to choose from. We did the Lemon Star, Orange Orbiter, Far Out Frangelico and Cosmic Coconut - but had them all iced on the outside with white butter-cream to make them look more uniform as we had them decorated with flowers. They also did the grooms cake for us which was decorated as the backdrop for MST3K, the did a great job off of the pic we sent them! The cakes were beyond amazing, beautiful and tasty - though we didn't get to taste the Frangelico one, it must have been amazing because it was the first to be devoured by guests. We can't wait to go back and get our favorite for all the anniversaries to come - the Lemon Star!!
We set out to start our cake tasting journey at Once in a Blue Moon Cafe. We strolled in on Saturday morning with an Read more...
We set out to start our cake tasting journey at Once in a Blue Moon Cafe. We strolled in on Saturday morning with an agenda to try some cake and set up an official cake tasting appointment. While sitting at a small table that morning sampling some of their cake-by-the-slice options, we had the pleasure of striking up a conversation with a woman that had stopped in to pick up a cake order. She began to tell us she was from NJ and had never had a cake as fantastic as the ones that she gets from Once in a Blue Moon and that she has to order something from them on a regular bases. We had to agree, we tried the Key Lime and Cappuccino Blast that morning and even after being sliced and refrigerated they were amazing. We set up the tasting appt but made no effort to seek out any other bakeries. We went with a non-traditional plan of doing several 10 in round cakes on different cake stands rather than doing a traditional wedding cake - our guest loved this as we had 4 different flavors of cakes to choose from. We did the Lemon Star, Orange Orbiter, Far Out Frangelico and Cosmic Coconut - but had them all iced on the outside with white butter-cream to make them look more uniform as we had them decorated with flowers. They also did the grooms cake for us which was decorated as the backdrop for MST3K, the did a great job off of the pic we sent them! The cakes were beyond amazing, beautiful and tasty - though we didn't get to taste the Frangelico one, it must have been amazing because it was the first to be devoured by guests. We can't wait to go back and get our favorite for all the anniversaries to come - the Lemon Star!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
A
Wedding:
10/6/2013
5.0/5.0
The cake was beautiful and delicious. The only part not eaten was the top layer that is frozen for one year anniversary. We have used Blue Moon for years for birthday cakes, and now a wedding cake, and they have never disappointed.

Andrea
The cake was beautiful and delicious. The only part not eaten was the top layer that is frozen for one year anniversary. Read more...
The cake was beautiful and delicious. The only part not eaten was the top layer that is frozen for one year anniversary. We have used Blue Moon for years for birthday cakes, and now a wedding cake, and they have never disappointed.

Andrea Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1358212637058-img9771
Joyous726
Wedding:
7/27/2013
5.0/5.0
For my wedding, I didn't want wedding cake. I just wanted cake. Awesome tasting, good looking cake. I did not care for a lot of the cake I tried at various places, including my venue, but Once in a Blue Moon came recommended by a friend.

The tasting was great and the price SUPER reasonable. I opted for two 8" cakes and one 10" cake for display and then 2 sheet cakes in the back (so total 5), each in a different flavor with differing decorations, but all very simple... all 3 layers (we saved a small amount of money by having 3 instead of 4 layers, because... who cares!) and all were fresh and exceedingly delicious. The cake table looked great and we had many compliments on how good the cake was.
For my wedding, I didn't want wedding cake. I just wanted cake. Awesome tasting, good looking cake. I did not care for a Read more...
For my wedding, I didn't want wedding cake. I just wanted cake. Awesome tasting, good looking cake. I did not care for a lot of the cake I tried at various places, including my venue, but Once in a Blue Moon came recommended by a friend.

The tasting was great and the price SUPER reasonable. I opted for two 8" cakes and one 10" cake for display and then 2 sheet cakes in the back (so total 5), each in a different flavor with differing decorations, but all very simple... all 3 layers (we saved a small amount of money by having 3 instead of 4 layers, because... who cares!) and all were fresh and exceedingly delicious. The cake table looked great and we had many compliments on how good the cake was. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Viki
Wedding:
7/20/2013
5.0/5.0
Our wedding cake was both pretty and delicious! They decorated the cake just like we had asked them to do. The cake was so moist and fresh tasting!
Our wedding cake was both pretty and delicious! They decorated the cake just like we had asked them to do. The cake was so Read more...
Our wedding cake was both pretty and delicious! They decorated the cake just like we had asked them to do. The cake was so moist and fresh tasting! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Karen
Wedding:
5/4/2013
5.0/5.0
My wedding cake was literally the best wedding cake I've ever tasted in my life. And wedding cake is kind of my thing. The staff was great, and they even let us do two tastings. While all of the flavor combos were delicious, we settled on white cake with chocolate mousse and cream cheese frosting. To die for. Thank goodness we ended up with the entire bottom layer left over, because I want to eat that cake every day for the rest of my life. We wanted a very simple cake, and Once In a Blue Moon came through in that aspect as well. It turned out just how we wanted.
My wedding cake was literally the best wedding cake I've ever tasted in my life. And wedding cake is kind of my thing. The Read more...
My wedding cake was literally the best wedding cake I've ever tasted in my life. And wedding cake is kind of my thing. The staff was great, and they even let us do two tastings. While all of the flavor combos were delicious, we settled on white cake with chocolate mousse and cream cheese frosting. To die for. Thank goodness we ended up with the entire bottom layer left over, because I want to eat that cake every day for the rest of my life. We wanted a very simple cake, and Once In a Blue Moon came through in that aspect as well. It turned out just how we wanted. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
4/6/2013
5.0/5.0
Great bakery!! They provided me with a beautiful wedding cake! Left over cake was frozen and still tastes great as we thaw pieces out to eat! Highly recommend!!
Great bakery!! They provided me with a beautiful wedding cake! Left over cake was frozen and still tastes great as we thaw Read more...
Great bakery!! They provided me with a beautiful wedding cake! Left over cake was frozen and still tastes great as we thaw pieces out to eat! Highly recommend!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
3/9/2013
5.0/5.0
The most moist, delicious cake I've ever had at a wedding! We worked with the baker and the owner to ensure that my daughter's wedding cake would be exactly as she wanted, and we were not disappointed. This vendor is top notch. You need not worry about the delivery of the cake or whether it will be as requested. They have hundreds of pictures of cakes they have baked and decorated in case you need ideas. And, their cake tasting was one of the most fun things my daughter and I did as we planned the wedding. Hightly recommend Blue Moon!
The most moist, delicious cake I've ever had at a wedding! We worked with the baker and the owner to ensure that my Read more...
The most moist, delicious cake I've ever had at a wedding! We worked with the baker and the owner to ensure that my daughter's wedding cake would be exactly as she wanted, and we were not disappointed. This vendor is top notch. You need not worry about the delivery of the cake or whether it will be as requested. They have hundreds of pictures of cakes they have baked and decorated in case you need ideas. And, their cake tasting was one of the most fun things my daughter and I did as we planned the wedding. Hightly recommend Blue Moon! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
10/27/2012
5.0/5.0
YUM YUM!! and their cake looked good too! We were trying to stick to a specific budget and most cake places in the area were way out of our price range or had specific minimums that we had to meet to even order a cake. Nancy at Blue Moon was willing to work with us to figure out the best cake for our budget. I gave Blue Moon an inspiration picture of my cake and they couldn’t have made it more like the picture I gave them! Added bonus-they will make you a small 6” cake for your year anniversary so that you don’t need to eat old frozen cake to celebrate. I will definitely be ordering from them when I need cakes in the future.
YUM YUM!! and their cake looked good too! We were trying to stick to a specific budget and most cake places in the area Read more...
YUM YUM!! and their cake looked good too! We were trying to stick to a specific budget and most cake places in the area were way out of our price range or had specific minimums that we had to meet to even order a cake. Nancy at Blue Moon was willing to work with us to figure out the best cake for our budget. I gave Blue Moon an inspiration picture of my cake and they couldn’t have made it more like the picture I gave them! Added bonus-they will make you a small 6” cake for your year anniversary so that you don’t need to eat old frozen cake to celebrate. I will definitely be ordering from them when I need cakes in the future. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1330430127969-img17221
Marie
Wedding:
9/29/2012
5.0/5.0
We worked with Nancy at Once in a Blue Moon. She was fantastic to work with for the tasting/selection. She gave suggestions for small design details I hadn't considered. Their cakes are delicious and beautiful! The finished product was exactly as I envisioned and it tasted as good as it looked. I highly recommend this bakery for any special event cakes.
We worked with Nancy at Once in a Blue Moon. She was fantastic to work with for the tasting/selection. She gave Read more...
We worked with Nancy at Once in a Blue Moon. She was fantastic to work with for the tasting/selection. She gave suggestions for small design details I hadn't considered. Their cakes are delicious and beautiful! The finished product was exactly as I envisioned and it tasted as good as it looked. I highly recommend this bakery for any special event cakes. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Bevsblu1
Wedding:
11/19/2011
5.0/5.0
The cake was just what we wanted. It was beautiful. It tasted GREAT!! Delicious! Very reasonable prices, easy to work with. Nice cake tasting experiednce.
The cake was just what we wanted. It was beautiful. It tasted GREAT!! Delicious! Very reasonable prices, easy to work Read more...
The cake was just what we wanted. It was beautiful. It tasted GREAT!! Delicious! Very reasonable prices, easy to work with. Nice cake tasting experiednce. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Beth Mann Childress
Wedding:
11/12/2011
3.8/5.0
The taste of the cake was fantastic. People are still talking about it. I only wish I could have had a little more help planning the design. I felt my cake was very plain but of course that is what I chose do to the lack of ideas. Overall though the taste was worth it.
The taste of the cake was fantastic. People are still talking about it. I only wish I could have had a little more help Read more...
The taste of the cake was fantastic. People are still talking about it. I only wish I could have had a little more help planning the design. I felt my cake was very plain but of course that is what I chose do to the lack of ideas. Overall though the taste was worth it. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bg5
rockie18
Wedding:
10/22/2011
5.0/5.0
Coming from NJ to NC for our wedding was a huge feat. We went down in April for our consultation and taste testing. The cake was phenomenal! Our wedding was on October 22, 2011 and our cake was everything we hoped it would be. The staff at the bakery put us at ease about everything going smoothly on our wedding day. Our guests could not rave enough about how delicious this cake was! Yellow cake with lemon mousse filling and almond buttercream for one layer, chocolate cake (my fav!) with chocolate mousse filling and almond buttercream for the second layer and a yellow cake with almond buttercream for the top. Thank you Nancy and all the staff at Blue Moon for making our wedding cake the best cake we have ever had!
Coming from NJ to NC for our wedding was a huge feat. We went down in April for our consultation and taste testing. The Read more...
Coming from NJ to NC for our wedding was a huge feat. We went down in April for our consultation and taste testing. The cake was phenomenal! Our wedding was on October 22, 2011 and our cake was everything we hoped it would be. The staff at the bakery put us at ease about everything going smoothly on our wedding day. Our guests could not rave enough about how delicious this cake was! Yellow cake with lemon mousse filling and almond buttercream for one layer, chocolate cake (my fav!) with chocolate mousse filling and almond buttercream for the second layer and a yellow cake with almond buttercream for the top. Thank you Nancy and all the staff at Blue Moon for making our wedding cake the best cake we have ever had! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Christine
Wedding:
9/24/2011
4.7/5.0
My cake was both beautiful and delicious. The service was prompt. They worked with me to make sure I got exactly what I wanted even though I was buying a small cake. And the fact that they bake each couple a free 6 inch replica cake on their 1 year anniversary makes them even better!
My cake was both beautiful and delicious. The service was prompt. They worked with me to make sure I got exactly what I Read more...
My cake was both beautiful and delicious. The service was prompt. They worked with me to make sure I got exactly what I wanted even though I was buying a small cake. And the fact that they bake each couple a free 6 inch replica cake on their 1 year anniversary makes them even better! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Loretta
Wedding:
6/12/2011
4.8/5.0
Great cake! It is hard for me to give a review for value because I am not a cake person, but if you are and you want a fabulous cake this is the place for you.
Great cake! It is hard for me to give a review for value because I am not a cake person, but if you are and you want a Read more...
Great cake! It is hard for me to give a review for value because I am not a cake person, but if you are and you want a fabulous cake this is the place for you. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Clara
Wedding:
4/16/2011
4.8/5.0
We had a fantastic experience with Blue Moon. I had one of their cakes at an office party and remembered how great it was. I wasn't sure that they did wedding cakes, but called anyway. They were so helpful in selecting a cake especially because I was dealing with a picky groom! We settled on a great cake with a great combination of flavors. It was also really beautiful. Great value!
We had a fantastic experience with Blue Moon. I had one of their cakes at an office party and remembered how great it was. Read more...
We had a fantastic experience with Blue Moon. I had one of their cakes at an office party and remembered how great it was. I wasn't sure that they did wedding cakes, but called anyway. They were so helpful in selecting a cake especially because I was dealing with a picky groom! We settled on a great cake with a great combination of flavors. It was also really beautiful. Great value! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
MASON
Wedding:
2/4/2011
4.4/5.0
Really enjoyed our cakes. Our venue package included our cake, so we did a dessert bar with some of our favorite cakes. We have to include the orange dreamsicle cake from Blue Moon. It was a huge hit!
Really enjoyed our cakes. Our venue package included our cake, so we did a dessert bar with some of our favorite cakes. We Read more...
Really enjoyed our cakes. Our venue package included our cake, so we did a dessert bar with some of our favorite cakes. We have to include the orange dreamsicle cake from Blue Moon. It was a huge hit! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
elaineaus
Wedding:
12/18/2010
5.0/5.0
The cakes from Blue Moon Bakery taste great. We went for a consultation in August, and they spent a lot of time with us, letting us try out all of the flavors. They made a wonderful, and bigger than we expected, groom's cake that coordinated very nicely with our wedding cake. It arrived on time, and it was delicious!
The cakes from Blue Moon Bakery taste great. We went for a consultation in August, and they spent a lot of time with us, Read more...
The cakes from Blue Moon Bakery taste great. We went for a consultation in August, and they spent a lot of time with us, letting us try out all of the flavors. They made a wonderful, and bigger than we expected, groom's cake that coordinated very nicely with our wedding cake. It arrived on time, and it was delicious! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Trish
Wedding:
11/7/2010
5.0/5.0
Once in A Blue Moon Bakery made our lovely wedding cake. It was everything we hoped for! We loved this bakery and loved our Raspberry Rocket cake!
Once in A Blue Moon Bakery made our lovely wedding cake. It was everything we hoped for! We loved this bakery and loved Read more...
Once in A Blue Moon Bakery made our lovely wedding cake. It was everything we hoped for! We loved this bakery and loved our Raspberry Rocket cake! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jon
Wedding:
7/24/2010
5.0/5.0
Our wedding cake was both exceptionally delicious and beautiful! Once in a Blue Moon was very helpful all throughout our wedding planning, including changing the design of our cake a few times with no problem. We would highly recommend Once in a Blue Moon to any couples wanting a wedding cake that looks as good as it tastes!
Our wedding cake was both exceptionally delicious and beautiful! Once in a Blue Moon was very helpful all throughout our Read more...
Our wedding cake was both exceptionally delicious and beautiful! Once in a Blue Moon was very helpful all throughout our wedding planning, including changing the design of our cake a few times with no problem. We would highly recommend Once in a Blue Moon to any couples wanting a wedding cake that looks as good as it tastes! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
JAStucke
Wedding:
4/10/2010
4.5/5.0
If you want a simple vegan cake-- go here!

For our wedding, we ordered 5 smaller cakes. Three were their specialty cakes, 1 was a simple vanilla cake, and the other was a chocolate vegan cake with vegan vanilla icing. Everyone said the vegan cake was the best!

They were also able to use our own cake plate pedistals for the wedding. Unfortunately, they were not able to build directly onto the plate, like we thought. But they covered the cardboard with white wax paper, and no one would have noticed.

They also delivered for a small delivery fee-- less stress for us!
If you want a simple vegan cake-- go here!

For our wedding, we ordered 5 smaller cakes. Three were their Read more...
If you want a simple vegan cake-- go here!

For our wedding, we ordered 5 smaller cakes. Three were their specialty cakes, 1 was a simple vanilla cake, and the other was a chocolate vegan cake with vegan vanilla icing. Everyone said the vegan cake was the best!

They were also able to use our own cake plate pedistals for the wedding. Unfortunately, they were not able to build directly onto the plate, like we thought. But they covered the cardboard with white wax paper, and no one would have noticed.

They also delivered for a small delivery fee-- less stress for us! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
wmjones429
Wedding:
5/23/2009
4.9/5.0
Our cake was not only amazing but we also got so many compliments on how it was the best cake anyone has ever tasted! Blue Moon sits down with you and allows you to taste all sorts of combinations of icings, fillings, and cakes (which is the best part in my opinion!!). They are extremely easy to work with and flexible if you change your mind with filling cominations, etc.
Our cake was not only amazing but we also got so many compliments on how it was the best cake anyone has ever tasted! Blue Read more...
Our cake was not only amazing but we also got so many compliments on how it was the best cake anyone has ever tasted! Blue Moon sits down with you and allows you to taste all sorts of combinations of icings, fillings, and cakes (which is the best part in my opinion!!). They are extremely easy to work with and flexible if you change your mind with filling cominations, etc. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Terri
Wedding:
9/20/2008
4.4/5.0
Once in a Blue Moon Bakery provided us with a wedding cake and groom's cheesecakes for our reception. We've purchased their cakes before so knew the quality of their product. When we initially met with them, we pretty much knew what we wanted and took a magazine photograph of our ideal...a tiered cake covered in chocolate truffles. The taste test they provided was beneficial in determining the cake and filling flavors. We were to make the truffles for the cake, so did a trial run of truffles for them to determine the best size and way to adhere them. There was a fair amount of coordination involved and we had some difficulty in follow-up on their part, but we were persistent and worked thru it. The final cake was close to the photograph and very decadent and delicious. We topped it with a brushed silver last initial monogram accented with Swarovski crystals...which caught the candle light and gave it a perfect sparkle.

The cheesecakes were very good, served with a bowl of cherries on the side. Considering they were for the wedding, I would have liked them dressed up a little - they were very plain looking, so our caterer piped some cream around the edges. The center cake had a fun topper on it reflecting the groom's love of the Pittsburgh Steelers. My suggestion would be, if you're considering cheesecakes, think about presentation and ask the baker to give them a little flair.
Once in a Blue Moon Bakery provided us with a wedding cake and groom's cheesecakes for our reception. We've purchased Read more...
Once in a Blue Moon Bakery provided us with a wedding cake and groom's cheesecakes for our reception. We've purchased their cakes before so knew the quality of their product. When we initially met with them, we pretty much knew what we wanted and took a magazine photograph of our ideal...a tiered cake covered in chocolate truffles. The taste test they provided was beneficial in determining the cake and filling flavors. We were to make the truffles for the cake, so did a trial run of truffles for them to determine the best size and way to adhere them. There was a fair amount of coordination involved and we had some difficulty in follow-up on their part, but we were persistent and worked thru it. The final cake was close to the photograph and very decadent and delicious. We topped it with a brushed silver last initial monogram accented with Swarovski crystals...which caught the candle light and gave it a perfect sparkle.

The cheesecakes were very good, served with a bowl of cherries on the side. Considering they were for the wedding, I would have liked them dressed up a little - they were very plain looking, so our caterer piped some cream around the edges. The center cake had a fun topper on it reflecting the groom's love of the Pittsburgh Steelers. My suggestion would be, if you're considering cheesecakes, think about presentation and ask the baker to give them a little flair. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Elizabeth
Wedding:
8/8/2008
4.6/5.0
BEAUTIFUL cake that was delicious--also, as a treat, so you don't have to eat a nasty frozen cake in a year, they give you a small cake (whatever kind you want!) for your one-year anniversary. Not bad for prices. Charge a LOT for delivery but maybe everyone does...overall a beautiful cake :)
BEAUTIFUL cake that was delicious--also, as a treat, so you don't have to eat a nasty frozen cake in a year, they give you Read more...
BEAUTIFUL cake that was delicious--also, as a treat, so you don't have to eat a nasty frozen cake in a year, they give you a small cake (whatever kind you want!) for your one-year anniversary. Not bad for prices. Charge a LOT for delivery but maybe everyone does...overall a beautiful cake :) Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
hmw1229
Wedding:
12/29/2007
3.9/5.0
The cake tasted amazing however we did have an issue with the actual color and design of it. It was supposed to be ivory colored icing with white detail but it was white all over. I was very upset when I saw the mistake and it actually ruined some of my pictures.
The cake tasted amazing however we did have an issue with the actual color and design of it. It was supposed to be ivory Read more...
The cake tasted amazing however we did have an issue with the actual color and design of it. It was supposed to be ivory colored icing with white detail but it was white all over. I was very upset when I saw the mistake and it actually ruined some of my pictures. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jill
Wedding:
10/20/2007
5.0/5.0
Awesome place to go. They made a cake like the photo I had from a magazine. Baker was a great guy to work with. I would highly recommend this wedding cake bakery to everyone. The cake was delicious and everyone loved it. The best part is we did not have to save our top piece because the bakery gives you a free top cake on your 1 year anniversary! The pricing is fair and good for those on a budget.
Awesome place to go. They made a cake like the photo I had from a magazine. Baker was a great guy to work with. I would Read more...
Awesome place to go. They made a cake like the photo I had from a magazine. Baker was a great guy to work with. I would highly recommend this wedding cake bakery to everyone. The cake was delicious and everyone loved it. The best part is we did not have to save our top piece because the bakery gives you a free top cake on your 1 year anniversary! The pricing is fair and good for those on a budget. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Dawn
Wedding:
6/30/2007
5.0/5.0
Gorgeous cake! It tasted wonderful too. We got the hazelnut mouse and almond buttercream frosting. Yummy! I'm just bummed that I got more ON my face than in my mouth. :-) They even give you a cake on your first anniversary so you don't have to freeze any.
Gorgeous cake! It tasted wonderful too. We got the hazelnut mouse and almond buttercream frosting. Yummy! I'm just bummed Read more...
Gorgeous cake! It tasted wonderful too. We got the hazelnut mouse and almond buttercream frosting. Yummy! I'm just bummed that I got more ON my face than in my mouth. :-) They even give you a cake on your first anniversary so you don't have to freeze any. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Nancy
Wedding:
12/30/2006
4.8/5.0
Would recommend Blue Moon to anyone who wants a wonderful wedding cake. My husband and I were very open minded and just wanted them to pretty much do whatever they wanted just so it had our colors in it and it turned out beautiful. I've never had so many wonderful comments about where we got our cake because it was so good. All our guests just loved it.
Would recommend Blue Moon to anyone who wants a wonderful wedding cake. My husband and I were very open minded and just Read more...
Would recommend Blue Moon to anyone who wants a wonderful wedding cake. My husband and I were very open minded and just wanted them to pretty much do whatever they wanted just so it had our colors in it and it turned out beautiful. I've never had so many wonderful comments about where we got our cake because it was so good. All our guests just loved it. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Julie
Wedding:
5/28/2006
4.4/5.0
Best tasting cakes around. Great value for your budget!
Best tasting cakes around. Great value for your budget!
Best tasting cakes around. Great value for your budget! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Victoria
Wedding:
8/13/2005
5.0/5.0
The cake was amazing!!!!!!!!!! It was beautiful and tasted wonderful. I highly recommend this bakery. Go with the Strawberry Mouse filling!!!!!
The cake was amazing!!!!!!!!!! It was beautiful and tasted wonderful. I highly recommend this bakery. Go with the Read more...
The cake was amazing!!!!!!!!!! It was beautiful and tasted wonderful. I highly recommend this bakery. Go with the Strawberry Mouse filling!!!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Janie
Wedding:
7/9/2005
4.2/5.0
Very nice and helpful; even set up fresh flowers on the cake at the reception. Also, you get a free mini wedding cake on your 1-year anniversary, rather than eating gross frozen leftover cake.
Very nice and helpful; even set up fresh flowers on the cake at the reception. Also, you get a free mini wedding cake on Read more...
Very nice and helpful; even set up fresh flowers on the cake at the reception. Also, you get a free mini wedding cake on your 1-year anniversary, rather than eating gross frozen leftover cake. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
5.0/5.0
Cake was SOOOOOOOOOOOO tasty and great i couldn't have asked for anything better. It tasted amazing and they are great people who work there they do such good work. Tasting tray they give you has lots of options and they give you great suggestions.
Cake was SOOOOOOOOOOOO tasty and great i couldn't have asked for anything better. It tasted amazing and they are great Read more...
Cake was SOOOOOOOOOOOO tasty and great i couldn't have asked for anything better. It tasted amazing and they are great people who work there they do such good work. Tasting tray they give you has lots of options and they give you great suggestions. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lisa
Wedding:
1/13/0707
5.0/5.0
I planned a very low budget wedding, but I wanted my cake to be fabulous. Once in a Blue Moon Bakery made my cakes for me, and they allowed me to change the coloring and frosting on their specialty cakes to fit my wedding colors. Our guests raved about how delicious the cake was!
I planned a very low budget wedding, but I wanted my cake to be fabulous. Once in a Blue Moon Bakery made my cakes for me, Read more...
I planned a very low budget wedding, but I wanted my cake to be fabulous. Once in a Blue Moon Bakery made my cakes for me, and they allowed me to change the coloring and frosting on their specialty cakes to fit my wedding colors. Our guests raved about how delicious the cake was! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for Once In A Blue Moon Bakery
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww_logo
 
Nophoto-220