You will no longer have access to your Project Wedding account on or after March 30, 2017. Save any photos or information you'd like to keep and join WeddingWire for your all of your wedding planning needs today. Learn more »
130x130 sq 1478370116 258cff089aa47227 image

Petonitos Pastry Shop

East Haven , CT
CONTACT US
CONTACT US

LOCATION

190 Main St
East Haven, CT 06512 US (map)

PHONE

203-469-1817

WEBSITE

View website
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.

ABOUT US

Dear Friends,

Welcome to the storefront for one of the few traditional Italian Pastry Shops left in the greater New Haven Area. We have a full line of cakes, cookies, and... Read more
Dear Friends,

Welcome to the storefront for one of the few traditional Italian Pastry Shops left in the greater New Haven Area. We have a full line of cakes, cookies, and pastries. Everything edible that we sell is made right here in our East Haven bakery.

Our specialty is wedding cakes. We estimate that we have made over 25,000 est. custom wedding cakes since 1954. Call and make an appointment for your "wedding cake consultation". We can help you find that perfect cake for your special day.

Please come in and visit. We are looking forward to serving you.

Sincerely,

Mark Petonito, Owner Petonito's Pastry Shop

Call for an appointment at 203-876-8747 or visit us online at www.petonitospastryshop.com or come in and visit! Read less
Wedding Cake

PHOTOS

130x130 sq 1415120455220 petinitos 2
130x130 sq 1415120458521 petonitos 1
130x130 sq 1415120461526 petonitos 3
130x130 sq 1478370257087 image
130x130 sq 1478370259232 image
130x130 sq 1478370301474 image
130x130 sq 1478370455883 image
130x130 sq 1478370469421 image
130x130 sq 1415120464515 petonitos 4
130x130 sq 1478370485835 image
130x130 sq 1478370548299 image
130x130 sq 1478370575440 image
130x130 sq 1478370841105 image
130x130 sq 1478370840778 image
130x130 sq 1478370871125 image
130x130 sq 1478370884404 image
130x130 sq 1478370909964 image
130x130 sq 1478370930836 image

INFO FOR WEDDING CAKE

What types of desserts do you provide?
Cakes, Cookies, Cupcakes, Dessert Buffet, Groom's Cake, Pastries
What services do you provide?
Consultations, Custom Cake Design, Delivery, Setup, Tastings - Private
What cake items do you provide?
Cake Stands
What special ingredients do you use?
Fresh Fruit, Local
Are you licensed by the state health department?
Yes

REVIEWS

4.9
out of 5.0
4.9/5.0
4.9/5.0
4.9/5.0
4.9/5.0
4.9/5.0
Sort by
Default vendor profile pic
Elena
Wedding:
11/6/2016
5.0/5.0
From the minute we met Mark we knew Petonito's was our decision. We loved how traditional he was & how it is a family owned business. It truly felt like he cared about every person that came in his pastry shop. He let us taste several cakes and fillings. Let me tell you, it was hard to choose! Mark and Adrianna made the process so easy & ensured us everything would look beautiful. LET ME TELL YOU, they were right! Not only was the cake gorgeous, we got endless compliments on how delicious our cake was (White cake with strawberry mouse filling for those wondering). We were able to rent out their cake stand, and it was definitely one of our best decisions. The cake was prettier than I could have ever dreamed. One of my best vendor choices! Thank you Petonito's for your beautiful and delicious work. I would highly recommend.
From the minute we met Mark we knew Petonito's was our decision. We loved how traditional he was & how it is a family Read more...
From the minute we met Mark we knew Petonito's was our decision. We loved how traditional he was & how it is a family owned business. It truly felt like he cared about every person that came in his pastry shop. He let us taste several cakes and fillings. Let me tell you, it was hard to choose! Mark and Adrianna made the process so easy & ensured us everything would look beautiful. LET ME TELL YOU, they were right! Not only was the cake gorgeous, we got endless compliments on how delicious our cake was (White cake with strawberry mouse filling for those wondering). We were able to rent out their cake stand, and it was definitely one of our best decisions. The cake was prettier than I could have ever dreamed. One of my best vendor choices! Thank you Petonito's for your beautiful and delicious work. I would highly recommend. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130 sq 1443464669097 pfmcmlb2etristsjjvdfzmkzf7cdnoqlyk53gyjnpb4
Patricia
Wedding:
9/4/2016
5.0/5.0
We loved our cake! it was exactly what we asked for and was so great we might not be able to freeze the top!
We loved our cake! it was exactly what we asked for and was so great we might not be able to freeze the top!
We loved our cake! it was exactly what we asked for and was so great we might not be able to freeze the top! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Danielle&Rob
Wedding:
6/4/2016
5.0/5.0
We had the pleasure of working with Mark, and the whole experience was absolutely perfect! He was open to customizing our cake, even though it was included with our reception venue. It was absolutely stunning, and tasted even more delicious!
We had the pleasure of working with Mark, and the whole experience was absolutely perfect! He was open to customizing our Read more...
We had the pleasure of working with Mark, and the whole experience was absolutely perfect! He was open to customizing our cake, even though it was included with our reception venue. It was absolutely stunning, and tasted even more delicious! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Linda
Wedding:
5/29/2016
5.0/5.0
Cake was beautiful and tasted delicious! I had real flowers added to the cake, cascading down and it was just as I imagined it. The only thing I wanted to change was to only have dots for design ( no swirls). I called 3 days before my wedding to change it but it turned out my cake had already been made and decorated. So just know exactly what you want or call at least a week in advance to make any changes.
Cake was beautiful and tasted delicious! I had real flowers added to the cake, cascading down and it was just as I Read more...
Cake was beautiful and tasted delicious! I had real flowers added to the cake, cascading down and it was just as I imagined it. The only thing I wanted to change was to only have dots for design ( no swirls). I called 3 days before my wedding to change it but it turned out my cake had already been made and decorated. So just know exactly what you want or call at least a week in advance to make any changes. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Private User
Wedding:
11/8/2015
5.0/5.0
Our cake was PERFECT. Draped roses and a cake design... Exactly what we wanted ... beautiful. It tasted AMAZING.
Our cake was PERFECT. Draped roses and a cake design... Exactly what we wanted ... beautiful. It tasted AMAZING.
Our cake was PERFECT. Draped roses and a cake design... Exactly what we wanted ... beautiful. It tasted AMAZING. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
5.0/5.0
Petonito's made mine and my husband's wedding cake. It looked gorgeous and tasted amazing! Before going for our initial tasting, we went to a different cake company and had a very poor experience with them. After leaving this company, we decided to take a chance and show up at Petonito's unannounced expecting to be told we would need to make an appointment. To our surprise, they sat down with us right away and gave us a cake tasting! Everything was delicious and we booked with them right away. The entire staff was so friendly and the cake came out perfect!
Petonito's made mine and my husband's wedding cake. It looked gorgeous and tasted amazing! Before going for our initial Read more...
Petonito's made mine and my husband's wedding cake. It looked gorgeous and tasted amazing! Before going for our initial tasting, we went to a different cake company and had a very poor experience with them. After leaving this company, we decided to take a chance and show up at Petonito's unannounced expecting to be told we would need to make an appointment. To our surprise, they sat down with us right away and gave us a cake tasting! Everything was delicious and we booked with them right away. The entire staff was so friendly and the cake came out perfect! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
5.0/5.0
We got our fill of amazing cakes during the tasting and the wedding cake was beautiful, elegant, and absolutely perfect
We got our fill of amazing cakes during the tasting and the wedding cake was beautiful, elegant, and absolutely perfect
We got our fill of amazing cakes during the tasting and the wedding cake was beautiful, elegant, and absolutely perfect Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
5.0/5.0
Petonito's was absolutely fabulous! Mark was so nice and welcoming when we went to meet him for the first time. I gave them a picture of my cake and they replicated it perfectly. I was so pleased and excited with the final product when I saw it on my wedding day. Not only was the cake beautiful, but it tasted amazing as well! Everyone was raving about how good the cake was. Thank you Petonito's for the fabulous job!!
Petonito's was absolutely fabulous! Mark was so nice and welcoming when we went to meet him for the first time. I gave Read more...
Petonito's was absolutely fabulous! Mark was so nice and welcoming when we went to meet him for the first time. I gave them a picture of my cake and they replicated it perfectly. I was so pleased and excited with the final product when I saw it on my wedding day. Not only was the cake beautiful, but it tasted amazing as well! Everyone was raving about how good the cake was. Thank you Petonito's for the fabulous job!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
5.0/5.0
Petonito's made our wedding cake and I cannot tell you how beautiful and delicious it was! We met with Mark the owner on two occasions and he was so friendly and easy to work with! We sampled many cake flavors and fillings, they were all delicious! I also fell in love with a five tier wedding cake that I saw in a bridal magazine I brought a picture of it to Mark and he replicated it beautifully ! My cake looked like it was literally out of a bridal magazine, just perfect! When I walked into my reception and saw it I got emotional I was not expecting such an amazing cake but Mark pulled it off beautifully! I would highly recommend Petonito's!!
Petonito's made our wedding cake and I cannot tell you how beautiful and delicious it was! We met with Mark the owner on Read more...
Petonito's made our wedding cake and I cannot tell you how beautiful and delicious it was! We met with Mark the owner on two occasions and he was so friendly and easy to work with! We sampled many cake flavors and fillings, they were all delicious! I also fell in love with a five tier wedding cake that I saw in a bridal magazine I brought a picture of it to Mark and he replicated it beautifully ! My cake looked like it was literally out of a bridal magazine, just perfect! When I walked into my reception and saw it I got emotional I was not expecting such an amazing cake but Mark pulled it off beautifully! I would highly recommend Petonito's!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Debra
Wedding:
9/20/2014
5.0/5.0
Not only did the cake taste great but it was absolutely gorgeous. We were actually afraid to cut into it because it was a work of art.
Not only did the cake taste great but it was absolutely gorgeous. We were actually afraid to cut into it because it was a Read more...
Not only did the cake taste great but it was absolutely gorgeous. We were actually afraid to cut into it because it was a work of art. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake

MAP

 
190 Main St, East Haven, CT 06512 See On Map
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for Petonitos Pastry Shop
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww logo
220x220 1478370116 258cff089aa47227 image