130x130_sq_1399474388908-screen-shot-2014-05-07-at-10.46.46-a

Piece O' Cake

Shrewsbury , NJ
CONTACT US
CONTACT US

LOCATION

717 broad street
Shrewsbury, NJ US 07702 (map)

PHONE

732-741-3802

WEBSITE

View website
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.

ABOUT US

Piece O' Cake is a custom cake shop that has been in business since 1993. We provide cakes for all occasions. All cakes are done to order to maintain quality. All weddings are done by... Read more
Piece O' Cake is a custom cake shop that has been in business since 1993. We provide cakes for all occasions. All cakes are done to order to maintain quality. All weddings are done by appointment. We provide you with tastings that are packaged with your specifically chosen cakes and fillings to take home and sample in you own private setting. We only do a certain number of cakes a week and prefer at least 3 months notice for a wedding. Please check us out on Facebook..we love new fans! Read less
Wedding Cake

PHOTOS

130x130_sq_1243994572921-imgp1397
130x130_sq_1243994572953-imgp1438
130x130_sq_1243994573468-imgp1378
130x130_sq_1243994573515-imgp1372
130x130_sq_1243994573984-imgp1368
130x130_sq_1243994574078-imgp1351
130x130_sq_1243994574515-imgp1318
130x130_sq_1243994574656-imgp1154
130x130_sq_1243994574984-imgp1151
130x130_sq_1243994575265-imgp1149
130x130_sq_1243994575578-imgp0992
130x130_sq_1243994575937-imgp0979
130x130_sq_1243994576171-imgp0969
130x130_sq_1243994576546-imgp0922
130x130_sq_1243994576734-imgp0913
130x130_sq_1243994577312-imgp0505
130x130_sq_1243994577328-imgp0454
130x130_sq_1281527050013-476
130x130_sq_1281529298123-504
130x130_sq_1281529406404-488

INFO FOR WEDDING CAKE

Do you provide customary cakes, such as Croquembouche?
No
Are you licensed by the state health department?
Yes
Do you offer private tastings or open house tastings?
Our tastings are very private. You can either per-order what you would like to try or we can give you our most popular choices. They are packaged especially for you and taken home so you may enjoy them as privately as you would like.
What are your tasting hours?
Vary by appointment
Describe how you price, such as by slice or by tier, for your cakes?
By the slice
Does the price include the top tier of the cake?
Yes. We advise not to save the top tier. If you call us a week or so before your anniversary we will make you a complimentary cake with a "Happy 1st Anniversary" inscription on it for you to enjoy.
Do you offer custom cakes, or do you work with pre-designed styles?
We will work with either
On average, how far in advance of the event do you prepare the cake?
We would prefer the cakes be mostly finished 24 hours before delivery time so that it has plenty of time to set up.
How many cakes do you schedule for a typical weekend?
It really depends on the weekend
Will you work with the client's florist to garnish the cake?
We will arrainge delivery time to work with the schedule of the florist if the are using fresh flowers.
What (if any) cake accessories, such as a cake stand or cake cutter, do you rent out?
The only accessories that we rent would be a cupcake tower for cupcake wedding cakes.
Do you offer delivery? If yes, how much is your average delivery fee?
Most local deliveries are included in the price of the cake.

REVIEWS

4.7
out of 5.0
4.9/5.0
4.5/5.0
4.6/5.0
4.8/5.0
4.7/5.0
Sort by
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Devin
Wedding:
5/23/2014
5.0/5.0
The cake we got for our wedding was honestly the best cake I have ever had. They listened to everything we wanted...even when it came to having sprinkles put into the batter to make a "funfetti" cake. I was so thrilled with the way it came out...I definitely recommend them.
The cake we got for our wedding was honestly the best cake I have ever had. They listened to everything we wanted...even Read more...
The cake we got for our wedding was honestly the best cake I have ever had. They listened to everything we wanted...even when it came to having sprinkles put into the batter to make a "funfetti" cake. I was so thrilled with the way it came out...I definitely recommend them. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Victoria
Wedding:
5/3/2014
4.9/5.0
Piece O Cake designed my Grooms Cake, which was zombie themed after the "Walking Dead." I wasn't 100% sure what I wanted, so I sent them a couple pictures from pinterest and let them do the rest. All I can say about the cake was.....WOW. Everyone at the wedding was so impressed with the detailed work on the cake. Furthermore, the cake tasted great. They did an awesome job and cannot thank them enough. People couldn't stop talking about how they had never seen such an original and amazing cake.
Piece O Cake designed my Grooms Cake, which was zombie themed after the "Walking Dead." I wasn't 100% sure what I wanted, Read more...
Piece O Cake designed my Grooms Cake, which was zombie themed after the "Walking Dead." I wasn't 100% sure what I wanted, so I sent them a couple pictures from pinterest and let them do the rest. All I can say about the cake was.....WOW. Everyone at the wedding was so impressed with the detailed work on the cake. Furthermore, the cake tasted great. They did an awesome job and cannot thank them enough. People couldn't stop talking about how they had never seen such an original and amazing cake. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Terese
Wedding:
11/2/2013
4.6/5.0
Joely and staff were amazing to work with for our wedding cake! I sent some pictures of what I wanted the cake to look like and she and her team made it look better than I had imagined! Not only did our cake look beautiful, it tasted amazing!!
Joely and staff were amazing to work with for our wedding cake! I sent some pictures of what I wanted the cake to look Read more...
Joely and staff were amazing to work with for our wedding cake! I sent some pictures of what I wanted the cake to look like and she and her team made it look better than I had imagined! Not only did our cake look beautiful, it tasted amazing!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Danielle
Wedding:
10/19/2013
5.0/5.0
Joely and her team were awesome!! We went for our cake testing and she had a ton of amazing options. Everything was great. We opted for something a little different (Red Velvet cake). Everyone at the wedding raved about it. Said it was so good! And I loved how simple but beautiful the cake was. Thank you so much and I would definitely recommend!! So tasty!
Joely and her team were awesome!! We went for our cake testing and she had a ton of amazing options. Everything was great. Read more...
Joely and her team were awesome!! We went for our cake testing and she had a ton of amazing options. Everything was great. We opted for something a little different (Red Velvet cake). Everyone at the wedding raved about it. Said it was so good! And I loved how simple but beautiful the cake was. Thank you so much and I would definitely recommend!! So tasty! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Kristine
Wedding:
10/12/2013
5.0/5.0
We worked with Piece O Cake because they were part of our package at The Molly Pitcher Inn, but we are so glad we did. Joely worked really with us trying to figure out the design and also provided good input with what flavors worked best. The cake came out awesome and my mom said it was so good even if she didn't like cake in general! We requested the cake topper to be saved but when we found out the whole cake had to be served Piece O Cake agreed to make us a similar cake topper that we could save for later. They were great and I will definitely recommend them to other potential clients!
We worked with Piece O Cake because they were part of our package at The Molly Pitcher Inn, but we are so glad we did. Read more...
We worked with Piece O Cake because they were part of our package at The Molly Pitcher Inn, but we are so glad we did. Joely worked really with us trying to figure out the design and also provided good input with what flavors worked best. The cake came out awesome and my mom said it was so good even if she didn't like cake in general! We requested the cake topper to be saved but when we found out the whole cake had to be served Piece O Cake agreed to make us a similar cake topper that we could save for later. They were great and I will definitely recommend them to other potential clients! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jamie
Wedding:
9/15/2013
5.0/5.0
The girls at piece o'cake were helpful from the very beginning. They responded to emails promptly and were flexible with everything from cake ideas, flavor combos, and designs. Our cake was absolutely scrumptious and all guests agreed!
The girls at piece o'cake were helpful from the very beginning. They responded to emails promptly and were flexible with Read more...
The girls at piece o'cake were helpful from the very beginning. They responded to emails promptly and were flexible with everything from cake ideas, flavor combos, and designs. Our cake was absolutely scrumptious and all guests agreed! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Private User
Wedding:
9/1/2013
5.0/5.0
I have to say, going to your cake tasting with your fiance has got to be one of the MOST fun experiences. It's a laid back easy going fun way to share a good time together, and it's that much better when your Wedding Cake Baker bakes AMAZING cakes!!! We easily picked what we wanted, and the cake just showed up on our special day, I didn't even have to worry about following up, it was an effortless transaction. Our cake was simply gorgeous and it tasted DELICIOUS! We had SO MANY wonderful compliments about how good our cake was. As a matter of fact, it was so delicious, when we arrived home from our honeymoon, we decided we were eating our top layer that week, there was no way it was lasting in our freezer for a year! We can't wait to buy another "mini cake" for our anniversary next year and every year after that! Thank you Piece O Cake for such a fantastic cake!!!
I have to say, going to your cake tasting with your fiance has got to be one of the MOST fun experiences. It's a laid back Read more...
I have to say, going to your cake tasting with your fiance has got to be one of the MOST fun experiences. It's a laid back easy going fun way to share a good time together, and it's that much better when your Wedding Cake Baker bakes AMAZING cakes!!! We easily picked what we wanted, and the cake just showed up on our special day, I didn't even have to worry about following up, it was an effortless transaction. Our cake was simply gorgeous and it tasted DELICIOUS! We had SO MANY wonderful compliments about how good our cake was. As a matter of fact, it was so delicious, when we arrived home from our honeymoon, we decided we were eating our top layer that week, there was no way it was lasting in our freezer for a year! We can't wait to buy another "mini cake" for our anniversary next year and every year after that! Thank you Piece O Cake for such a fantastic cake!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
4.6/5.0
As a soon-to-be bride, I contacted Piece O' Cake on a moment's notice hoping that I would be able to get an appointment for a cake tasting. The place where we are having our reception told us that they require at least a week's notice, but my fiancée and I don't live in the area and we would only be in town for the weekend. So when I called to order a cake sampling, I expected to be turned down, but when I spoke to Deirdre, she was extremely helpful and understanding to our situation. She also guided me through the process of choosing our wedding cake. It was a surprisingly unexpected delight to speak to someone like Deidre who sounded like she was actually interested in us as people and not just customers! I will be using Piece O' Cake over and over again when we relocate after our wedding!
As a soon-to-be bride, I contacted Piece O' Cake on a moment's notice hoping that I would be able to get an appointment Read more...
As a soon-to-be bride, I contacted Piece O' Cake on a moment's notice hoping that I would be able to get an appointment for a cake tasting. The place where we are having our reception told us that they require at least a week's notice, but my fiancée and I don't live in the area and we would only be in town for the weekend. So when I called to order a cake sampling, I expected to be turned down, but when I spoke to Deirdre, she was extremely helpful and understanding to our situation. She also guided me through the process of choosing our wedding cake. It was a surprisingly unexpected delight to speak to someone like Deidre who sounded like she was actually interested in us as people and not just customers! I will be using Piece O' Cake over and over again when we relocate after our wedding! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Christina
Wedding:
8/24/2013
5.0/5.0
Our wedding cake from Piece O Cake was not only beautiful, it was delicious! We got so many compliments on it, great job!
Our wedding cake from Piece O Cake was not only beautiful, it was delicious! We got so many compliments on it, great job!
Our wedding cake from Piece O Cake was not only beautiful, it was delicious! We got so many compliments on it, great job! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Chelsea
Wedding:
8/16/2013
1.6/5.0
I think the cake was good. I only tasted it during our cake cutting ceremony at the venue. Every communication we had with the vendor was poor. They didn't remember we were coming in for our tasting, so had to put it together while we waited there. We didn't really enjoy what we tasted, though I remember it being a little better on our wedding day. I maybe got three responses to all of the emails I sent them over the course of the planning process. They seemed to not remember any of my inquiries. Everything I asked for was also an "up charge." I asked if I could make each layer of the cake a different flavor, and was flatly told no. I wasn't sure the cake was actually going to get to the venue, but it was there when I got there, so that was a plus. A very strange experience to say the least.
I think the cake was good. I only tasted it during our cake cutting ceremony at the venue. Every communication we had with Read more...
I think the cake was good. I only tasted it during our cake cutting ceremony at the venue. Every communication we had with the vendor was poor. They didn't remember we were coming in for our tasting, so had to put it together while we waited there. We didn't really enjoy what we tasted, though I remember it being a little better on our wedding day. I maybe got three responses to all of the emails I sent them over the course of the planning process. They seemed to not remember any of my inquiries. Everything I asked for was also an "up charge." I asked if I could make each layer of the cake a different flavor, and was flatly told no. I wasn't sure the cake was actually going to get to the venue, but it was there when I got there, so that was a plus. A very strange experience to say the least. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Daryl
Wedding:
8/10/2013
5.0/5.0
As someone in the event business, I have to say that I was absolutely speechless when I first saw my wedding cake from Joely at Piece O Cake. I wasn't sure of my vision at first, but after talking to Joely and telling her about my theme and color scheme of my wedding, she suggested the most perfect design for my cake. My guests kept commenting how it even matched my dress! Beyond the design, Piece O Cake has hands down the best tasting wedding cakes (and birthday cakes, as I have gotten many from them also) I have ever had. Red Velvet is my favorite cake, and this was perfectly moist - I want a piece right now! THANK YOU Joely, I can't recommend you enough!
As someone in the event business, I have to say that I was absolutely speechless when I first saw my wedding cake from Read more...
As someone in the event business, I have to say that I was absolutely speechless when I first saw my wedding cake from Joely at Piece O Cake. I wasn't sure of my vision at first, but after talking to Joely and telling her about my theme and color scheme of my wedding, she suggested the most perfect design for my cake. My guests kept commenting how it even matched my dress! Beyond the design, Piece O Cake has hands down the best tasting wedding cakes (and birthday cakes, as I have gotten many from them also) I have ever had. Red Velvet is my favorite cake, and this was perfectly moist - I want a piece right now! THANK YOU Joely, I can't recommend you enough! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Evelyn
Wedding:
7/12/2013
5.0/5.0
We loved our cake, it was exactly what I had wanted and it was delicious.
We loved our cake, it was exactly what I had wanted and it was delicious.
We loved our cake, it was exactly what I had wanted and it was delicious. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Nina
Wedding:
6/29/2013
5.0/5.0
We knew we had to do our wedding cake from Piece O' Cake. Joely was so sweet and helpful....we knew how much she cares about her product. The cake was so delicious and beautiful! Our guests said they never tasted such a great wedding cake. We cant wait for our complimentary anniversary cake as well. A MUST use!!
We knew we had to do our wedding cake from Piece O' Cake. Joely was so sweet and helpful....we knew how much she cares Read more...
We knew we had to do our wedding cake from Piece O' Cake. Joely was so sweet and helpful....we knew how much she cares about her product. The cake was so delicious and beautiful! Our guests said they never tasted such a great wedding cake. We cant wait for our complimentary anniversary cake as well. A MUST use!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
5.0/5.0
Piece O Cake is a vendor for Oyster Point, but regardless we would have chosen them. The cake is delicious!!! Wedding cake is always hit or miss - and people came up to us letting us know how tasty it was. We can't wait for our 1 year anniversary to get another bite :)
Piece O Cake is a vendor for Oyster Point, but regardless we would have chosen them. The cake is delicious!!! Wedding cake Read more...
Piece O Cake is a vendor for Oyster Point, but regardless we would have chosen them. The cake is delicious!!! Wedding cake is always hit or miss - and people came up to us letting us know how tasty it was. We can't wait for our 1 year anniversary to get another bite :) Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
1+ year ago
1.3/5.0
This was the second worst vendor I had to deal with for my wedding day. While this vendor provided a quality product, they made our day so much more difficult than it needed to be. Additionally, they were completely disrespectful to me and hung up on me twice on the phone for no reason. This place was provided to us by our venue, however, given the chance I would have picked someone else. They made us pick from their wholesale cakes on their website which were only buttercream and not fondant. Any tiny change that we wanted for decoration would be extra because they said it would be too much work. They only seem to care about their caring patrons and not ones contracted out to a vendor. They flat out said to me they would only be providing a plain frosted cake and anything else would cost extra.
This was the second worst vendor I had to deal with for my wedding day. While this vendor provided a quality product, they Read more...
This was the second worst vendor I had to deal with for my wedding day. While this vendor provided a quality product, they made our day so much more difficult than it needed to be. Additionally, they were completely disrespectful to me and hung up on me twice on the phone for no reason. This place was provided to us by our venue, however, given the chance I would have picked someone else. They made us pick from their wholesale cakes on their website which were only buttercream and not fondant. Any tiny change that we wanted for decoration would be extra because they said it would be too much work. They only seem to care about their caring patrons and not ones contracted out to a vendor. They flat out said to me they would only be providing a plain frosted cake and anything else would cost extra. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Cadence
Wedding:
10/11/2012
5.0/5.0
Delicious cake! They really made a fantastic cake, the cake was just gorgeous! Highly recommend!
Delicious cake! They really made a fantastic cake, the cake was just gorgeous! Highly recommend!
Delicious cake! They really made a fantastic cake, the cake was just gorgeous! Highly recommend! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
3.6/5.0
My wedding cake was included with my reception package. The cake was delicious and beautiful. It was exactly what I asked for.
My wedding cake was included with my reception package. The cake was delicious and beautiful. It was exactly what I asked Read more...
My wedding cake was included with my reception package. The cake was delicious and beautiful. It was exactly what I asked for. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Bg5
Margaux
Wedding:
9/21/2012
4.6/5.0
The cakes here are DELICIOUS.
As a testament to how delicious, my guests all actually ATE their cake as did the groom and I! In fact, the next day, I ate 2 more pieces (partly because I no longer had to worry about fitting in a dress but mostly because the cake is RIDICULOUSLY TASTY).

I will say that getting in contact with the team can be a little difficult--they are obviously very busy and a small team of bakers. However, week of wedding, I heard from them and talked through the design and decor I was looking for to confirm and didn't worry about a thing. And in the end, as long as they come through with a cake, I am not too worried about having multiple conversations! :)
They can do lots of fun designs, so definitely check them out!
The cakes here are DELICIOUS.
As a testament to how delicious, my guests all actually ATE their cake as did the groom Read more...
The cakes here are DELICIOUS.
As a testament to how delicious, my guests all actually ATE their cake as did the groom and I! In fact, the next day, I ate 2 more pieces (partly because I no longer had to worry about fitting in a dress but mostly because the cake is RIDICULOUSLY TASTY).

I will say that getting in contact with the team can be a little difficult--they are obviously very busy and a small team of bakers. However, week of wedding, I heard from them and talked through the design and decor I was looking for to confirm and didn't worry about a thing. And in the end, as long as they come through with a cake, I am not too worried about having multiple conversations! :)
They can do lots of fun designs, so definitely check them out! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jennifer
Wedding:
9/21/2012
3.8/5.0
Piece o'cake was recommeded to me by Nancy at the Avenue as I'm having my wedding there. My girlfriend that lives in Lincroft also suggested them before I made an appointment for a tasting. Upon my arrival there were 2 separate couples that came to pick up their anniverary cakes and before leaving the door both couples mentioned that their wedding guests are still raving about their cakes. Funny enough they both had the rasberry mouse so I just had to try. The best part, Joely the owner is the no fuss owner super down to earth and was very accomodating with a collaberated cake design of 3 different photos that I chose from her gallery to make my wedding. Can't wait to see the outcome, I too chose the rasberry mouse on chocolate cake on 2 of the 4 layers. The other 2 layers are yellow cake with peanut butter mouse that's pretty outrageous!
If you can get past the fact that this is not a bakery with lots of people to answer the phone or quick on emails or the straight to the point baker which I can appreciate and not rude at all, you'll end up with a great tasting cake, mine looked amazing and the great value in comparison to your $10 per person slice of cake. Good Luck!
Piece o'cake was recommeded to me by Nancy at the Avenue as I'm having my wedding there. My girlfriend that lives in Read more...
Piece o'cake was recommeded to me by Nancy at the Avenue as I'm having my wedding there. My girlfriend that lives in Lincroft also suggested them before I made an appointment for a tasting. Upon my arrival there were 2 separate couples that came to pick up their anniverary cakes and before leaving the door both couples mentioned that their wedding guests are still raving about their cakes. Funny enough they both had the rasberry mouse so I just had to try. The best part, Joely the owner is the no fuss owner super down to earth and was very accomodating with a collaberated cake design of 3 different photos that I chose from her gallery to make my wedding. Can't wait to see the outcome, I too chose the rasberry mouse on chocolate cake on 2 of the 4 layers. The other 2 layers are yellow cake with peanut butter mouse that's pretty outrageous!
If you can get past the fact that this is not a bakery with lots of people to answer the phone or quick on emails or the straight to the point baker which I can appreciate and not rude at all, you'll end up with a great tasting cake, mine looked amazing and the great value in comparison to your $10 per person slice of cake. Good Luck! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
5.0/5.0
Our wedding cake came out exactly as we had hoped it would! It was soooo delicious! I would highly recommend them!
Our wedding cake came out exactly as we had hoped it would! It was soooo delicious! I would highly recommend them!
Our wedding cake came out exactly as we had hoped it would! It was soooo delicious! I would highly recommend them! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1348064931660-wedding
Kimberly
Wedding:
8/24/2012
4.8/5.0
Cake tasted amazing and looked beautiful!
Cake tasted amazing and looked beautiful!
Cake tasted amazing and looked beautiful! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Marilyn
Wedding:
8/18/2012
5.0/5.0
My father had a Coach bag cake made for my stepmother’s birthday, and recommended that I went to Piece O’ Cake for our wedding. We chose a cake from their website and requested a few changes to be made in color over the phone. When the cake was delivered, it was more beautiful than we could have imagined. Not only did the cake look beautiful, but it was also delicious, and we received so many compliments. Piece O’ Cake does a phenomenal job and truly takes pride in their work and I absolutely recommend them for any occasion!
My father had a Coach bag cake made for my stepmother’s birthday, and recommended that I went to Piece O’ Cake for our Read more...
My father had a Coach bag cake made for my stepmother’s birthday, and recommended that I went to Piece O’ Cake for our wedding. We chose a cake from their website and requested a few changes to be made in color over the phone. When the cake was delivered, it was more beautiful than we could have imagined. Not only did the cake look beautiful, but it was also delicious, and we received so many compliments. Piece O’ Cake does a phenomenal job and truly takes pride in their work and I absolutely recommend them for any occasion! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Michael
Wedding:
7/21/2012
5.0/5.0
Our reception venue included the cake within our reception package which sometimes can make you a bit reluctant with following others suggestions. But I am glad we had a reception venue with our best interests in mind by choosing Piece O Cake. We dealt with Piece O Cake from the beginning and they were great to deal with, provide samples to make our choices easier, and we got to sample their delicious treats. They enable us to accommodate multiple tastes but creating a multiple teir cake with a different taste to each level, along with decorating the outside of the cake with our theme of "beach"

Definitely recommend Piece o Cake whether you use our venue (Windows On The Water) or another, we were definitely please with quality and delivery of the cake.....Deliciousness.

Kelly and Michael Sweeney
Our reception venue included the cake within our reception package which sometimes can make you a bit reluctant with Read more...
Our reception venue included the cake within our reception package which sometimes can make you a bit reluctant with following others suggestions. But I am glad we had a reception venue with our best interests in mind by choosing Piece O Cake. We dealt with Piece O Cake from the beginning and they were great to deal with, provide samples to make our choices easier, and we got to sample their delicious treats. They enable us to accommodate multiple tastes but creating a multiple teir cake with a different taste to each level, along with decorating the outside of the cake with our theme of "beach"

Definitely recommend Piece o Cake whether you use our venue (Windows On The Water) or another, we were definitely please with quality and delivery of the cake.....Deliciousness.

Kelly and Michael Sweeney Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Annalisa
Wedding:
5/19/2012
5.0/5.0
Best cake ever!! Even though it was smashed in my face! Cannoli filled with yellow cake it was outrageous.
Best cake ever!! Even though it was smashed in my face! Cannoli filled with yellow cake it was outrageous.
Best cake ever!! Even though it was smashed in my face! Cannoli filled with yellow cake it was outrageous. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1309175238803-p7301663
Erica
Wedding:
5/19/2012
5.0/5.0
Piece O' Cake was the preferred vendor at my venue so the venue handled most of the details, but the cake looked exactly like the picture I submitted and tasted amazing. They have loads of icing, filling and cake flavors so there is definitely something for everyone!
Piece O' Cake was the preferred vendor at my venue so the venue handled most of the details, but the cake looked exactly Read more...
Piece O' Cake was the preferred vendor at my venue so the venue handled most of the details, but the cake looked exactly like the picture I submitted and tasted amazing. They have loads of icing, filling and cake flavors so there is definitely something for everyone! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
manderyn20
Wedding:
11/11/2011
5.0/5.0
Joely did an amazing job- my cake was tasty and beautiful. She created exactly what I wanted!! Thank you!
Joely did an amazing job- my cake was tasty and beautiful. She created exactly what I wanted!! Thank you!
Joely did an amazing job- my cake was tasty and beautiful. She created exactly what I wanted!! Thank you! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Marie
Wedding:
9/4/2011
5.0/5.0
My cake was included with my package at the reception site, but I cannot thank Joely enough!!! The cake tasting was absolutely fabulous and it made me want more! I thought about my cake from that day on and now I can't wait for my anniversary cake! The design was absolutely flawless and exactly what we wanted, which was a little different for a wedding cake but Joely did not fret! The icing looked just like fondant but it was real buttercream! And it wasn't just US who loved the cake, we heard raves about it all night long - from the look to the taste, everyone was pleased! ABSOLUTELY WONDERFUL. I will definitely be back to visit her :)!
My cake was included with my package at the reception site, but I cannot thank Joely enough!!! The cake tasting was Read more...
My cake was included with my package at the reception site, but I cannot thank Joely enough!!! The cake tasting was absolutely fabulous and it made me want more! I thought about my cake from that day on and now I can't wait for my anniversary cake! The design was absolutely flawless and exactly what we wanted, which was a little different for a wedding cake but Joely did not fret! The icing looked just like fondant but it was real buttercream! And it wasn't just US who loved the cake, we heard raves about it all night long - from the look to the taste, everyone was pleased! ABSOLUTELY WONDERFUL. I will definitely be back to visit her :)! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Stephanie
Wedding:
8/7/2011
4.9/5.0
my cake was excellent! we got marble cake with cannoli filling, and it was beautiful also! my only wish is that I had more than a bite!! :(
my cake was excellent! we got marble cake with cannoli filling, and it was beautiful also! my only wish is that I had more Read more...
my cake was excellent! we got marble cake with cannoli filling, and it was beautiful also! my only wish is that I had more than a bite!! :( Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
lizzelynch
Wedding:
6/11/2011
5.0/5.0
Everyone LOVED this cake. Beautiful, personal and tasty. We had peanutbutter cream filling inside and every guest said it was the best cake they've ever had at a wedding!
Everyone LOVED this cake. Beautiful, personal and tasty. We had peanutbutter cream filling inside and every guest said it Read more...
Everyone LOVED this cake. Beautiful, personal and tasty. We had peanutbutter cream filling inside and every guest said it was the best cake they've ever had at a wedding! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Rachel
Wedding:
5/29/2011
5.0/5.0
Joely is a busy woman but let me tell you...she knows what she's doing. Our cake tasting was so much fun and both our wedding and groom cake were amazing in look and taste. I couldn't have imagined anything better and her friendly personality was just icing on the cake - haha.
Joely is a busy woman but let me tell you...she knows what she's doing. Our cake tasting was so much fun and both our Read more...
Joely is a busy woman but let me tell you...she knows what she's doing. Our cake tasting was so much fun and both our wedding and groom cake were amazing in look and taste. I couldn't have imagined anything better and her friendly personality was just icing on the cake - haha. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Cs525
Wedding:
5/21/2011
5.0/5.0
I have to say the cake was the most fun planning and most complimented on the day of our wedding! Our guests could not get over how beautiful the cake was and then how delicious. A pleasure from the first moment to the day of. Thank you! We will be back!
I have to say the cake was the most fun planning and most complimented on the day of our wedding! Our guests could not get Read more...
I have to say the cake was the most fun planning and most complimented on the day of our wedding! Our guests could not get over how beautiful the cake was and then how delicious. A pleasure from the first moment to the day of. Thank you! We will be back! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1302237696786-sandyhook
Sandra
Wedding:
5/13/2011
5.0/5.0
We absolutely loved our wedding cake! It looked perfect, we received a lot of compliments on the detail, and it tasted absolutely delicious! Thank you so much for adding to our special day!!!
We absolutely loved our wedding cake! It looked perfect, we received a lot of compliments on the detail, and it tasted Read more...
We absolutely loved our wedding cake! It looked perfect, we received a lot of compliments on the detail, and it tasted absolutely delicious! Thank you so much for adding to our special day!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Erica
Wedding:
10/17/2010
4.5/5.0
Although the actual cake designer is not always at the shop she usually gets back to you pretty quickly through e-mail. It was a no fuss process. We were able to get a beautiful and delicious cake for a great cost. We weren't looking for anything over the top (although it seems like she does that as well) and she was able to help us immediately. The cake was delicious!!! I never am impressed by wedding cakes but this one was great! She also offered to make us a fresh cake for our anniversary which was a nice plus! Very laid back shop which was just my style!
Although the actual cake designer is not always at the shop she usually gets back to you pretty quickly through e-mail. It Read more...
Although the actual cake designer is not always at the shop she usually gets back to you pretty quickly through e-mail. It was a no fuss process. We were able to get a beautiful and delicious cake for a great cost. We weren't looking for anything over the top (although it seems like she does that as well) and she was able to help us immediately. The cake was delicious!!! I never am impressed by wedding cakes but this one was great! She also offered to make us a fresh cake for our anniversary which was a nice plus! Very laid back shop which was just my style! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Tara
Wedding:
10/10/2010
5.0/5.0
My venue uses Piece O Cake to provide their wedding cakes and they did a gorgeous job! Our cake was absolutely beautiful and delicious! Several people told us that it was the best wedding cake they ever had! If your venue does not provide a cake and you have to choose a bakery on your own, check out Piece O Cake in Shrewsbury, NJ.
My venue uses Piece O Cake to provide their wedding cakes and they did a gorgeous job! Our cake was absolutely beautiful Read more...
My venue uses Piece O Cake to provide their wedding cakes and they did a gorgeous job! Our cake was absolutely beautiful and delicious! Several people told us that it was the best wedding cake they ever had! If your venue does not provide a cake and you have to choose a bakery on your own, check out Piece O Cake in Shrewsbury, NJ. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Josie
Wedding:
10/2/2010
5.0/5.0
Joely, thank you for the beautiful cake. It was absolutely stunning and it tasted just as good as it looked. Efrin & Josie
Joely, thank you for the beautiful cake. It was absolutely stunning and it tasted just as good as it looked. Efrin & Josie Read more...
Joely, thank you for the beautiful cake. It was absolutely stunning and it tasted just as good as it looked. Efrin & Josie Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
LL2002
Wedding:
9/25/2010
5.0/5.0
Piece O' Cake was an amazing experience from start to finish. The cakes we so beautiful and they were very easy to work with. Joely helped us to customize our cake so that we could afford the cake of our dreams. The cake was a huge hit at our wedding. It was beautiful and scrumptous! A must use!!!!
Piece O' Cake was an amazing experience from start to finish. The cakes we so beautiful and they were very easy to work Read more...
Piece O' Cake was an amazing experience from start to finish. The cakes we so beautiful and they were very easy to work with. Joely helped us to customize our cake so that we could afford the cake of our dreams. The cake was a huge hit at our wedding. It was beautiful and scrumptous! A must use!!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
2+ years ago
5.0/5.0
Our venue, Eagle Ridge Golf Club, works with Piece O' Cake. Our cake was delicious! We received many compliments on how good it was, and we loved it ourselves! I know we're supposed to save the top tier, but once they sent it home with us, we ate it ourselves while it was still fresh! They really accommodated our requests (chocolate cake with key lime filling and vanilla buttercream icing) and the cake was decorated beautifully and simply with trailing sugar pearls. LOVED IT!!!
Our venue, Eagle Ridge Golf Club, works with Piece O' Cake. Our cake was delicious! We received many compliments on how Read more...
Our venue, Eagle Ridge Golf Club, works with Piece O' Cake. Our cake was delicious! We received many compliments on how good it was, and we loved it ourselves! I know we're supposed to save the top tier, but once they sent it home with us, we ate it ourselves while it was still fresh! They really accommodated our requests (chocolate cake with key lime filling and vanilla buttercream icing) and the cake was decorated beautifully and simply with trailing sugar pearls. LOVED IT!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1281975733622-143
xblinkgurlx
Wedding:
7/30/2010
4.8/5.0
I had Joely make my wedding cake and it was beautiful and delicious. I had a 3 tier chocolate cake with cannoli and chocolate mousse filling iced in a very smooth buttercream. It was so smooth my husband said that it looked fake. The gumpaste flowers were turquoise and while they were bluer than the aqua swatch I gave her it wasnt that big of a deal. Also, the icing around the base of the layers was supposed to be aqua but it was white. The pearlized fondant swag was lovely. The cake tasted great. I had two slices at the reception. I cant wait to order another cake from Piece O Cake in the future. The service and responsiveness was also good. Joely responded to my emails in a very timely manner. The cost was a little expensive but I think its about average for wedding cakes. Its definitely alot cheaper than Carlos Bakery or Palermos and the cake tasted way better than Palermos. Overall I was very satisfied.
I had Joely make my wedding cake and it was beautiful and delicious. I had a 3 tier chocolate cake with cannoli and Read more...
I had Joely make my wedding cake and it was beautiful and delicious. I had a 3 tier chocolate cake with cannoli and chocolate mousse filling iced in a very smooth buttercream. It was so smooth my husband said that it looked fake. The gumpaste flowers were turquoise and while they were bluer than the aqua swatch I gave her it wasnt that big of a deal. Also, the icing around the base of the layers was supposed to be aqua but it was white. The pearlized fondant swag was lovely. The cake tasted great. I had two slices at the reception. I cant wait to order another cake from Piece O Cake in the future. The service and responsiveness was also good. Joely responded to my emails in a very timely manner. The cost was a little expensive but I think its about average for wedding cakes. Its definitely alot cheaper than Carlos Bakery or Palermos and the cake tasted way better than Palermos. Overall I was very satisfied. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
jennifer
Wedding:
7/23/2010
5.0/5.0
Our location for our wedding used Piece O"cake to supply the cake. I contacted them (Joely specifically) and she was absolutely fabuolous. They provided us with samples and created a cake for that was wonderful. We asked for a few minor changes and Joely made us a spectacular cake. All of our guests enjoyed the cake so much they gave it all out (some people wanted seconds)! However, Piece O'Cake will make you an anniversary cake so you have a fresh cake to enjoy on your first anniversary. I can't say enough about Piece O'Cake and Joely....I would highly recommend their services to everyone!!
Our location for our wedding used Piece O"cake to supply the cake. I contacted them (Joely specifically) and she was Read more...
Our location for our wedding used Piece O"cake to supply the cake. I contacted them (Joely specifically) and she was absolutely fabuolous. They provided us with samples and created a cake for that was wonderful. We asked for a few minor changes and Joely made us a spectacular cake. All of our guests enjoyed the cake so much they gave it all out (some people wanted seconds)! However, Piece O'Cake will make you an anniversary cake so you have a fresh cake to enjoy on your first anniversary. I can't say enough about Piece O'Cake and Joely....I would highly recommend their services to everyone!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jennybabes
Wedding:
10/10/2009
5.0/5.0
Our caterer recommended Piece O' Cake to do our cake. We were so pleased that we chose them to do our cake. I have never heard such raves at a wedding about the look and the taste of the cake. Thank you Piece O' Cake! You made our day even better then expected.
Our caterer recommended Piece O' Cake to do our cake. We were so pleased that we chose them to do our cake. I have never Read more...
Our caterer recommended Piece O' Cake to do our cake. We were so pleased that we chose them to do our cake. I have never heard such raves at a wedding about the look and the taste of the cake. Thank you Piece O' Cake! You made our day even better then expected. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
130x130_sq_1245010975318-dscn1346
alexranraa
Wedding:
10/10/2009
4.6/5.0
The perfect wedding cake!! Unlike so many other wedding cakes, this was delicious and uniquely flavored.
The perfect wedding cake!! Unlike so many other wedding cakes, this was delicious and uniquely flavored.
The perfect wedding cake!! Unlike so many other wedding cakes, this was delicious and uniquely flavored. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Meghan
Wedding:
9/26/2009
2.4/5.0
The taste of the cake was wonderful, they have beautiful designs and were really helpful when I wanted to suprise my groom with a grooms cake. However, they sent me the the wrong wedding cake, it was the same flavor but wrong design. I wasn't really good with confrontation and called to inform them that they sent me the wrong cake and they apologized but never offered to cover for their mistake. It didn't ruin my day but it was disappointing.
The taste of the cake was wonderful, they have beautiful designs and were really helpful when I wanted to suprise my groom Read more...
The taste of the cake was wonderful, they have beautiful designs and were really helpful when I wanted to suprise my groom with a grooms cake. However, they sent me the the wrong wedding cake, it was the same flavor but wrong design. I wasn't really good with confrontation and called to inform them that they sent me the wrong cake and they apologized but never offered to cover for their mistake. It didn't ruin my day but it was disappointing. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Piece O' Cake responded with the following comments:

When I spoke with Meghan I was so embarrased of the mistake I had made. I offered to make her a tiered cake for her anniversary or for any other special occasion that she would need a cake for. Again I profusely appologized and asked if my offer was acceptable. Until I read this review I was under the impression we were ok. I am very sorry and wish she had let me know what she wanted. My offer does still stand if she would like.
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Lee
Wedding:
9/4/2009
5.0/5.0
They were AWESOME!!! Great selections and generous samples! First class!!!
They were AWESOME!!! Great selections and generous samples! First class!!!
They were AWESOME!!! Great selections and generous samples! First class!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
BrookeLayne2
Wedding:
5/9/2009
5.0/5.0
the cake was absolutely delicious and gorgeous. Everyone truly enjoyed!
the cake was absolutely delicious and gorgeous. Everyone truly enjoyed!
the cake was absolutely delicious and gorgeous. Everyone truly enjoyed! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Katie
Wedding:
3/27/2009
5.0/5.0
Our cake was awesome! It was exactly what we wanted! I would highly recommend them to everyone!!!
Our cake was awesome! It was exactly what we wanted! I would highly recommend them to everyone!!!
Our cake was awesome! It was exactly what we wanted! I would highly recommend them to everyone!!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jennifer
Wedding:
11/7/2008
5.0/5.0
Well...our cake was part of the wedding package at McLoones in Sea Bright. To be honest, the cake wasn't one of my top priorites but once I got around to it, we were so pleased! The cake was beautiful and they really were accommodating. Our cake was chocolate and the icing was white buttercream. In addition, Bonnie at Petal Peach supplied some daisies for the top...it really was so pretty! I can't say went to the bakery, but I can say that it really came out beautiful...I would most certainly check it out.
Well...our cake was part of the wedding package at McLoones in Sea Bright. To be honest, the cake wasn't one of my top Read more...
Well...our cake was part of the wedding package at McLoones in Sea Bright. To be honest, the cake wasn't one of my top priorites but once I got around to it, we were so pleased! The cake was beautiful and they really were accommodating. Our cake was chocolate and the icing was white buttercream. In addition, Bonnie at Petal Peach supplied some daisies for the top...it really was so pretty! I can't say went to the bakery, but I can say that it really came out beautiful...I would most certainly check it out. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Catherine
Wedding:
10/4/2008
4.2/5.0
Wedding cake was delicious! Wasn't exactly what I had envisioned but it was still beautiful and included everything I asked for. It was 3 square tiers that were supposed to be turned each level but it wasn't as drastic as I had envisioned.. like I said it was still beautiful and everyone enjoyed it. Except when my husband promised that he would behave and then I had it on my face and dress, but that was his first dog house experience as my husband!
Wedding cake was delicious! Wasn't exactly what I had envisioned but it was still beautiful and included everything I Read more...
Wedding cake was delicious! Wasn't exactly what I had envisioned but it was still beautiful and included everything I asked for. It was 3 square tiers that were supposed to be turned each level but it wasn't as drastic as I had envisioned.. like I said it was still beautiful and everyone enjoyed it. Except when my husband promised that he would behave and then I had it on my face and dress, but that was his first dog house experience as my husband! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Karly
Wedding:
9/13/2008
5.0/5.0
My wedding cake from Piece O' Cake turned out amazing. It was beyond delicious and absolutely beautiful. The selection process of the cake was also a lot of fun. You get something of a cake making kit to help you decide. Three cupcakes are made of the flavor of your choice and fillings are placed on the side. You mix and match the fillings with the cupcakes--a very tasty and fun way to decide!

My reception place gave me credit at Piece of Cake for a basic cake and then I paid for any upgrade in special flavors or decoration.
My wedding cake from Piece O' Cake turned out amazing. It was beyond delicious and absolutely beautiful. The selection Read more...
My wedding cake from Piece O' Cake turned out amazing. It was beyond delicious and absolutely beautiful. The selection process of the cake was also a lot of fun. You get something of a cake making kit to help you decide. Three cupcakes are made of the flavor of your choice and fillings are placed on the side. You mix and match the fillings with the cupcakes--a very tasty and fun way to decide!

My reception place gave me credit at Piece of Cake for a basic cake and then I paid for any upgrade in special flavors or decoration. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
leezac
Wedding:
8/23/2008
5.0/5.0
Piece O' Cake was exceptional from the first phone call. The samples you get to take home in a neat lttle bundle! They were sooooo good that it was hard to choose from. Joely did all she could to help us with ideas on design and color scheme for the cake. They are really a small family business that does a "Big" and awesome job. We loved everything from start to finish. The cake was beautiful!
Piece O' Cake was exceptional from the first phone call. The samples you get to take home in a neat lttle bundle! They Read more...
Piece O' Cake was exceptional from the first phone call. The samples you get to take home in a neat lttle bundle! They were sooooo good that it was hard to choose from. Joely did all she could to help us with ideas on design and color scheme for the cake. They are really a small family business that does a "Big" and awesome job. We loved everything from start to finish. The cake was beautiful! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Jeanette1468
Wedding:
8/23/2008
5.0/5.0
My Husband & I were very please with our Wedding cake from Piece O Cake... when deciding which flavors to choose from, we were able to pick as many samples as we liked & take them with us to try... we actually made a day of it... picked them up... went to the beach & had lunch... then for dessert, we sampled each variety & made notes along the way!

Most importantly... Joely was able to recreate the design of my Wedding dress on the cake.. this was VERY special! The only thing I would have done different was add edible glitter/sparkles to the flower design to make it identicle to my dress... this wasn't their fault, however. I didn't think of it @ this time... :) Thank you!

Sincerely,
Jeanette & Craig Harris
Wedding Date:
August 23, 2008
My Husband & I were very please with our Wedding cake from Piece O Cake... when deciding which flavors to choose from, we Read more...
My Husband & I were very please with our Wedding cake from Piece O Cake... when deciding which flavors to choose from, we were able to pick as many samples as we liked & take them with us to try... we actually made a day of it... picked them up... went to the beach & had lunch... then for dessert, we sampled each variety & made notes along the way!

Most importantly... Joely was able to recreate the design of my Wedding dress on the cake.. this was VERY special! The only thing I would have done different was add edible glitter/sparkles to the flower design to make it identicle to my dress... this wasn't their fault, however. I didn't think of it @ this time... :) Thank you!

Sincerely,
Jeanette & Craig Harris
Wedding Date:
August 23, 2008 Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Robert
Wedding:
8/9/2008
3.9/5.0
Piece O' Cake was actually part of the McLoone's pacakge deal, but we intended to use another bakery instead. However, after seeing their scrollwork and designs and then TASTING the cakes options, we were sold. We knew someone else who had done a choclate ganache cake and were unimpressed, but our combination of chocolate cake, raspberry preserves filling and whip cream icing went over GREAT for the summer wedding. The location is not much to look at and often gets crowded in the small "lobby," but their service and quality are beyond reproach. I smell future birthday cakes coming from there...
Piece O' Cake was actually part of the McLoone's pacakge deal, but we intended to use another bakery instead. However, Read more...
Piece O' Cake was actually part of the McLoone's pacakge deal, but we intended to use another bakery instead. However, after seeing their scrollwork and designs and then TASTING the cakes options, we were sold. We knew someone else who had done a choclate ganache cake and were unimpressed, but our combination of chocolate cake, raspberry preserves filling and whip cream icing went over GREAT for the summer wedding. The location is not much to look at and often gets crowded in the small "lobby," but their service and quality are beyond reproach. I smell future birthday cakes coming from there... Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
jcapello
Wedding:
7/25/2008
5.0/5.0
Our cake was delicious!!
Our cake was delicious!!
Our cake was delicious!! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
njbride
Wedding:
7/20/2008
5.0/5.0
Our wedding cake was amazing! We had chocolate cake with chocolate ganache and raspberry filling. All of our guests loved it-even my mom who thought it was untraditional. The designer did an amazing job and the trial cupcakes were fun. Would highly recommend.
Our wedding cake was amazing! We had chocolate cake with chocolate ganache and raspberry filling. All of our guests loved Read more...
Our wedding cake was amazing! We had chocolate cake with chocolate ganache and raspberry filling. All of our guests loved it-even my mom who thought it was untraditional. The designer did an amazing job and the trial cupcakes were fun. Would highly recommend. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
jules
Wedding:
7/12/2008
5.0/5.0
My wedding cake was the highlight of our day! No only was our cannnoli cake delicious, but absolutely gorgeous. It was a 5 tier floral masterpiece! Everyone still tells us how delicious the cake was. They are very busy for a small shop, but worth the wait to see! AWESOME
My wedding cake was the highlight of our day! No only was our cannnoli cake delicious, but absolutely gorgeous. It was a 5 Read more...
My wedding cake was the highlight of our day! No only was our cannnoli cake delicious, but absolutely gorgeous. It was a 5 tier floral masterpiece! Everyone still tells us how delicious the cake was. They are very busy for a small shop, but worth the wait to see! AWESOME Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
Melissa
Wedding:
5/29/2008
5.0/5.0
Amazing! When you step into this boutique type bakery you smell their wonders of baking! First they have so many pictures you can choose from and if you are not happy with any of the pictures they are completely customizable. I fell in love with a beach themed cake. But in the picture it had a blue color to the icing - I didn't want the blue color, so they took it out! It was a beautiful ivory cake with white chocolate starfish and shells over the butter cream icing, fresh strawberries in the filing and a really super moist yellow butter cake. When you decide you want to try them out, they give you a cake! They give you a high cake with all the layers of cake that you want to try, chocolate, red velvet, what ever you want. And in between each layer is a different filling. So you can really choose something that you want. When you order your cake they deliver it for you to the place as well as set it up and set up the cake topper for you. The best part is that on your 1 year anniversary, they give you a new cake! It is a mini replica of the cake that you had for your big day! Then you don't have the eat the freezer burnt cake! It is wonderful, I have since used them for showers and other oocasions. They are wonderful!
Amazing! When you step into this boutique type bakery you smell their wonders of baking! First they have so many pictures Read more...
Amazing! When you step into this boutique type bakery you smell their wonders of baking! First they have so many pictures you can choose from and if you are not happy with any of the pictures they are completely customizable. I fell in love with a beach themed cake. But in the picture it had a blue color to the icing - I didn't want the blue color, so they took it out! It was a beautiful ivory cake with white chocolate starfish and shells over the butter cream icing, fresh strawberries in the filing and a really super moist yellow butter cake. When you decide you want to try them out, they give you a cake! They give you a high cake with all the layers of cake that you want to try, chocolate, red velvet, what ever you want. And in between each layer is a different filling. So you can really choose something that you want. When you order your cake they deliver it for you to the place as well as set it up and set up the cake topper for you. The best part is that on your 1 year anniversary, they give you a new cake! It is a mini replica of the cake that you had for your big day! Then you don't have the eat the freezer burnt cake! It is wonderful, I have since used them for showers and other oocasions. They are wonderful! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
r1634
Wedding:
8/25/2007
5.0/5.0
Our cake was part of a package deal at The English Manor. It was exactly what I wanted and incredibly delicious! It had fresh friuits and creamy frosting with delicate designs. We saved the top tier of the cake and froze it. One year later....we actually ate it and I cannot even express how delicious it still was. I wish I had a piece right now.
Our cake was part of a package deal at The English Manor. It was exactly what I wanted and incredibly delicious! It had Read more...
Our cake was part of a package deal at The English Manor. It was exactly what I wanted and incredibly delicious! It had fresh friuits and creamy frosting with delicate designs. We saved the top tier of the cake and froze it. One year later....we actually ate it and I cannot even express how delicious it still was. I wish I had a piece right now. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
rweinstein6
Wedding:
8/19/2007
5.0/5.0
Our wedding cake was simple, yet elegant, and the taste was out of this world. We went with a yellow cake with fudge filling, and it was delicious. I liked it so much, that my husband decided to get my birthday cake from there. We will be using Piece O' Cake for all of our specialty cakes from now on!
Our wedding cake was simple, yet elegant, and the taste was out of this world. We went with a yellow cake with fudge Read more...
Our wedding cake was simple, yet elegant, and the taste was out of this world. We went with a yellow cake with fudge filling, and it was delicious. I liked it so much, that my husband decided to get my birthday cake from there. We will be using Piece O' Cake for all of our specialty cakes from now on! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default-vendor-profile-pic
BrideNJ2007
Wedding:
7/14/2007
5.0/5.0
The cake was great an they even made two to accomonadate for the brides allergies! Highly recommend
The cake was great an they even made two to accomonadate for the brides allergies! Highly recommend
The cake was great an they even made two to accomonadate for the brides allergies! Highly recommend Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake

MAP

 
717 broad street, Shrewsbury, NJ 07702 See On Map
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for Piece O' Cake
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww_logo
 
220x220_1399474388908-screen-shot-2014-05-07-at-10.46.46-a