You will no longer have access to your Project Wedding account on or after March 30, 2017. Save any photos or information you'd like to keep and join WeddingWire for your all of your wedding planning needs today. Learn more »
Nophoto 130

Simple Simon Bakery

Appleton , WI

LOCATION

218 E Wisconsin Avenue
Appleton, WI 54911 US

PHONE

920-733-4351
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Wedding Cake

REVIEWS

4.8
out of 5.0
4.9/5.0
4.8/5.0
4.7/5.0
4.8/5.0
4.9/5.0
Sort by
Default vendor profile pic
Anonymous
Wedding:
Recently Married
5.0/5.0
AMAZING! We got a variety of four different cupcake flavors along with a cutting cake and cookies. Everything was delicious!
AMAZING! We got a variety of four different cupcake flavors along with a cutting cake and cookies. Everything was Read more...
AMAZING! We got a variety of four different cupcake flavors along with a cutting cake and cookies. Everything was delicious! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Andrea
Wedding:
10/1/2016
4.4/5.0
Simple Simon was an absolute delight to work with. I started out with not much of a vision other than "I need cake", and they were super helpful in offering a variety of ideas for shape, style, and flavor. The woman I worked with for both my initial and final consultation was very warm and friendly, and I felt like valued customer throughout our exchanges. My only qualm is that when I called to make appointments or when I had to stop in (basically just whenever I had to work with anyone that wasn't the primary consult), the staff in the main bakery sometimes seemed confused about why I was there and were not always very helpful with what I needed, but this was pretty minor. Our cupcakes were delicious, and they really went out of their way to make an adorable steampunk-themed cutting cake to go with our overall theme. I would definitely hire Simple Simon again!
Simple Simon was an absolute delight to work with. I started out with not much of a vision other than "I need cake", and Read more...
Simple Simon was an absolute delight to work with. I started out with not much of a vision other than "I need cake", and they were super helpful in offering a variety of ideas for shape, style, and flavor. The woman I worked with for both my initial and final consultation was very warm and friendly, and I felt like valued customer throughout our exchanges. My only qualm is that when I called to make appointments or when I had to stop in (basically just whenever I had to work with anyone that wasn't the primary consult), the staff in the main bakery sometimes seemed confused about why I was there and were not always very helpful with what I needed, but this was pretty minor. Our cupcakes were delicious, and they really went out of their way to make an adorable steampunk-themed cutting cake to go with our overall theme. I would definitely hire Simple Simon again! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Brianna
Wedding:
9/30/2016
4.6/5.0
My husband and I are all about dessert and wanted our wedding dessert to be high-end, but affordable. After getting some cake prices from a few places, we met with Simple Simon. We shared what we were hoping to spend and ended up with the recommendation to do cheesecake (if it's a dessert we enjoy). It happens to be a dessert we both LOVE and we were ecstatic to hear that Simple Simon had a couple of different options for us to serve cheesecake at our reception. We also wanted to offer another dessert for those that don't like cheesecake, so Simple Simon recommended cupcakes. We also wanted to do the traditional cake cutting at the reception, so they told us we had the option to have a small cake made for just us to cut at the ceremony and then keep - which we also did. We ended up with 300 pieces of dessert (150 cheesecake and 150 cupcakes) and it was the perfect amount! The best part was that it ended up being below budget for us. We were so happy with everything Simple Simon had to offer - from a variety of dessert options to the ease of them coming and setting up the dessert table. I highly recommend Simple Simon to anyone looking for an affordable bakery!
My husband and I are all about dessert and wanted our wedding dessert to be high-end, but affordable. After getting some Read more...
My husband and I are all about dessert and wanted our wedding dessert to be high-end, but affordable. After getting some cake prices from a few places, we met with Simple Simon. We shared what we were hoping to spend and ended up with the recommendation to do cheesecake (if it's a dessert we enjoy). It happens to be a dessert we both LOVE and we were ecstatic to hear that Simple Simon had a couple of different options for us to serve cheesecake at our reception. We also wanted to offer another dessert for those that don't like cheesecake, so Simple Simon recommended cupcakes. We also wanted to do the traditional cake cutting at the reception, so they told us we had the option to have a small cake made for just us to cut at the ceremony and then keep - which we also did. We ended up with 300 pieces of dessert (150 cheesecake and 150 cupcakes) and it was the perfect amount! The best part was that it ended up being below budget for us. We were so happy with everything Simple Simon had to offer - from a variety of dessert options to the ease of them coming and setting up the dessert table. I highly recommend Simple Simon to anyone looking for an affordable bakery! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Nicole
Wedding:
9/16/2016
5.0/5.0
Simple Simon Bakery did a dessert table for our wedding and it was beautiful and super affordable. We did cupcakes (3 flavors), mini cupcakes (2 flavors), cheesecake (2 flavors), cookies (3 flavors) and mini pies (3 flavors) for 200 people and received nothing but compliments on everything. They delivered and set up with their equipment and we didn't have to do anything...and even got $40 back when returning their equipment!! Frosting on cupcakes was coral and gray to match our wedding colors.. beautiful! Couldn't have been any happier with the results!

Thank you for helping make our day so beautiful and special!!
Nicole & Josh
Simple Simon Bakery did a dessert table for our wedding and it was beautiful and super affordable. We did cupcakes (3 Read more...
Simple Simon Bakery did a dessert table for our wedding and it was beautiful and super affordable. We did cupcakes (3 flavors), mini cupcakes (2 flavors), cheesecake (2 flavors), cookies (3 flavors) and mini pies (3 flavors) for 200 people and received nothing but compliments on everything. They delivered and set up with their equipment and we didn't have to do anything...and even got $40 back when returning their equipment!! Frosting on cupcakes was coral and gray to match our wedding colors.. beautiful! Couldn't have been any happier with the results!

Thank you for helping make our day so beautiful and special!!
Nicole & Josh Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Charlie
Wedding:
8/27/2016
4.0/5.0
we ordered a naked cake and cupcakes. Hands down theeee best cake and cupcake we have ever tasted. If we have gotten a bigger cake I think people would have gone up for thirds. The topper of the cake did not last in our house because we couldn't resist eating it. The tasting went great. We got to sample multiple choices. After that the email responsiveness wasn't as fast as we wanted but still able to communicate our wants and needs before the wedding. They did not provide a box to take cake home. I am not sure if we were supposed to request one. They have multiple stands to choose from. Again, the cake was sooo awesome. I would definitely give them a taste.
we ordered a naked cake and cupcakes. Hands down theeee best cake and cupcake we have ever tasted. If we have gotten a Read more...
we ordered a naked cake and cupcakes. Hands down theeee best cake and cupcake we have ever tasted. If we have gotten a bigger cake I think people would have gone up for thirds. The topper of the cake did not last in our house because we couldn't resist eating it. The tasting went great. We got to sample multiple choices. After that the email responsiveness wasn't as fast as we wanted but still able to communicate our wants and needs before the wedding. They did not provide a box to take cake home. I am not sure if we were supposed to request one. They have multiple stands to choose from. Again, the cake was sooo awesome. I would definitely give them a taste. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Hannah
Wedding:
6/11/2016
4.8/5.0
Our cake was absolutely gorgeous! (not to mention delicious!) We were working with the bakery from out of town while we planned and they were always so flexible to meet with us whenever we were in town and were able to create exactly what we envisioned. Even my mom, who doesn't care much for cake, loved their cake - we highly recommend their lemon raspberry flavor :)
Our cake was absolutely gorgeous! (not to mention delicious!) We were working with the bakery from out of town while we Read more...
Our cake was absolutely gorgeous! (not to mention delicious!) We were working with the bakery from out of town while we planned and they were always so flexible to meet with us whenever we were in town and were able to create exactly what we envisioned. Even my mom, who doesn't care much for cake, loved their cake - we highly recommend their lemon raspberry flavor :) Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Nate
Wedding:
6/3/2016
4.6/5.0
Simple Simon has the best cake in the Fox Valley Area! If not the state! We loved the cake. Service was great, they were very accomodating!
Simple Simon has the best cake in the Fox Valley Area! If not the state! We loved the cake. Service was great, they were Read more...
Simple Simon has the best cake in the Fox Valley Area! If not the state! We loved the cake. Service was great, they were very accomodating! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Kimberly
Wedding:
3/12/2016
5.0/5.0
The ladies at Simple Simon were absolutely wonderful to work with. Very open to what we were looking for, offered great suggestions and information, and provided just a beautiful display. We had cupcakes as well as our cutting cake and all turned out perfectly!! They were even able to create edible cala lillies to accent our display to go perfectly with our theme. We were worried about cupcakes drying out after sitting for a little while at the reception, but they were all really moist and very delicious. We had some left over and after putting in the freezer for a week, enjoyed them upon our return from our honeymoon! There is a reason they are voted Best of the Bay! We would highly recommend them for any bakery needs!
The ladies at Simple Simon were absolutely wonderful to work with. Very open to what we were looking for, offered great Read more...
The ladies at Simple Simon were absolutely wonderful to work with. Very open to what we were looking for, offered great suggestions and information, and provided just a beautiful display. We had cupcakes as well as our cutting cake and all turned out perfectly!! They were even able to create edible cala lillies to accent our display to go perfectly with our theme. We were worried about cupcakes drying out after sitting for a little while at the reception, but they were all really moist and very delicious. We had some left over and after putting in the freezer for a week, enjoyed them upon our return from our honeymoon! There is a reason they are voted Best of the Bay! We would highly recommend them for any bakery needs! Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Heather
Wedding:
12/12/2015
4.7/5.0
We worked with Simple Simon to provide the dessert for our wedding. We got to meet with them to talk about how many people would be attending, what types of desserts we wanted, etc. The only thing we were frustrated with was that it took us 2+ weeks to get our samples of the flavors we wanted to try. Overall the desserts turned out great! We did 3 types of mini(individual) pies and cheesecakes. We also had a small cake for us to do the traditional cake cutting. We got many compliments on the setup and the flavors.
We worked with Simple Simon to provide the dessert for our wedding. We got to meet with them to talk about how many people Read more...
We worked with Simple Simon to provide the dessert for our wedding. We got to meet with them to talk about how many people would be attending, what types of desserts we wanted, etc. The only thing we were frustrated with was that it took us 2+ weeks to get our samples of the flavors we wanted to try. Overall the desserts turned out great! We did 3 types of mini(individual) pies and cheesecakes. We also had a small cake for us to do the traditional cake cutting. We got many compliments on the setup and the flavors. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Default vendor profile pic
Alicia
Wedding:
12/11/2015
4.8/5.0
I have been going to this bakery since I was a child. Simple Simon provided a small 2 tier cake and assorted 50 dozen cookies for our wedding. They were absolutely delicious. The delivery fee was a bit much ($50), but our wedding was in Green Bay. The price of the cake and cookies were EXTREMELY AFFORDABLE and much cheaper than all other options in the Fox Valley.
I have been going to this bakery since I was a child. Simple Simon provided a small 2 tier cake and assorted 50 dozen Read more...
I have been going to this bakery since I was a child. Simple Simon provided a small 2 tier cake and assorted 50 dozen cookies for our wedding. They were absolutely delicious. The delivery fee was a bit much ($50), but our wedding was in Green Bay. The price of the cake and cookies were EXTREMELY AFFORDABLE and much cheaper than all other options in the Fox Valley. Read less
Services Used: Wedding Cake
Thanks for visiting the vendor listing for Simple Simon Bakery
Please let this vendor know that you found them on the WeddingWire Network.
Ww logo
Nophoto 220