Which to buy??

I posted a custom request for a photocard box on etsy and had a very nice lady respond saying that she can make me one and that she is new to etsy and has not made one of these before, but can do it for 25 and if I don't like it I don't have to buy it. 

Then I found this website and I can get a scratch and dent for 55 and I know its what I want and I can paint over it to fix the paint/scratches. http://www.theperfectcardbox.com/hugesalescratchdent.html

Should I splurge or take a chance?

I'd personally buy from etsy, but I like to support people who hand-make items. I only have great things to say about that website, and the price is right....

I agree with pp, id buy from etsy too. especially since you get to see if before you commit

Etsy it is! Thanks ladies!

If you don't like the box she makes, you can just not buy and get the other one