Would you rather have a public or private proposal?

[state which one and why, and ask your own "would you rather"]

Public! Because I would love to see a proposal in action myself! And it would also be cool if someone snapped a picture for you!

Would you rather have a simple or elaborate proposal?

Private. It is about us and only us in my opinion. Like on the beach or on a balcony above the city...something along those lines. If I can get someone to take a picture directly afterwards though that would be nice!

<3

ooooo what i would like is a very elaborate planned proposal, but, letting his emotions get the best of him, he shortcuts for a simple, last minute "i can't stand another minute without asking you" proposal :)

but for now, any proposal would be nice! hah!

ok, proposal mishaps:

***would you rather swallow the ring on accident (if it was in food) or have the centerstone fall out as he places it on your finger (just to the floor-not lost forever)??

haha Gina I don't know what part of your post is funnier, your "elaborate planned proposal turned must-get-it-out-now simple one" or the fact that you are thinking about swallowing the ring or having the centerstone fall out!!! haha I am laughing out loud here!!

For obvious reasons, I would NOT want to swallow the ring! haha

Knowing Joe, he will go for a private proposal.  I don't care either way, but to get a picture of him proposing to me would be awesome!  I would frame it!

Oh!  And a simple proposal.  I already told him I don't want him to spend no more than $1500 on a ring, so why spend a ton of money on asking me the question?  He knows I'll say yes!

i agree Dani, i want Sean to put the money toward our wedding, or a down payment for a house, not on my finger! plus, i am a laboratory geek, and a ring too big will probably bust through my latex gloves, hee hee!

nadine, didn't you see that clip on the news of a guy who proposed to his gf in a Wendy's frosty?

hahah! he challenged her to a frosty eating contest and she ate such big bites she swallowed it without even knowing! she got an x ray and it was a huge ring too! then they had this silly picture of them holding "fiber one" cereal, haha!

here's the link:http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/29462344/

OMG that is hilarious!!! I hadn't heard about it!

would you rather...

have an ugly ring with a big center stone or the most beautiful ring ever with a smaller center stone?

The most beautiful ring ever with a smaller center stone.

The bigger the center stone, the more likely I'll get mugged!  No thanks!