Elizabeth's Cakes

Elizabeth’s Cakes is a small, independent bakery without an actual store location, so we had to meet at a Starbucks in order to sample her cakes. The cake we tried was amazing! We placed an order that day without even trying another bakery. I received so many compliments from our wedding guests on the presentation and taste of the cake that I would recommend her over anyone else.

It was important for me to have a baker bake the wedding cake, and not order a cake through the caterer. This was because I wanted something special, beautiful, and really tasty, and I find that caterers who don’t specialize in desserts can’t really accomplish this. Elizabeth’s Cakes came highly recommended from a co-worker who bought a cake for her daughter’s birthday. The pictures of the cake were beautiful, so I got the contact information and made an appointment right away. Elizabeth was great! She’s a really wonderful person, you can tell right away that she’s an artist! She explained to us during a consultation what she does, how she creates the cakes, the ingredients she uses. We also arranged to taste cakes, and every flavor was great. Even though she has made some really elaborate cakes, our cake design was simple, we wanted fondant flowers and butterflies, and when we finally saw our cake on our wedding day we loved it! It was almost painful to cut it, it was so pretty! It looked like a really wedding cake! And it tasted perfect! I was so happy with how it turned out. Each slice had a small flower or butterfly on it, it was cute for each person.

Elizabeth runs her own bakery. She consulted with us personally. The cake was out of this world!!! She used all of our ideas and she even matched the frosting of our main tiered cake to match our bridesmaids dresses!!! We ordered A LOT of cake and the price was very reasonable.

Let me say she did an amazing job. My cake was perfect, she is very talented and very creative. I explained what I wanted and she made it perfect. She helped give me ideas, such as sheet cakes for cutting and a cake for pictures to save on cost and to keep from cutting the cake right away. The cheesecake is amazing. We froze the top piece for our one year and it was just as moist and yummy as it was on our wedding day.

I would highly recommend Elizabeth's Cakes. Elizabeth was very reliable, and helpful. The cake tasted amazing! She designed the cake exactly how I wanted.

Of all of the aspects of our wedding, we probably received the most compliments on the cake we ordered from Elizabeth's Cakes. It was often described by guests as the best wedding cake they'd ever had. It was absolutely amazing. Elizabeth was happy to work with us to make sure that we got exactly what we wanted. Our cake was an excellent value compared with other high-end bakeries in the area. I would absolutely recommend Elizabeth's Cakes - especially the tuxedo cake with cookies and cream filling and buttercreme frosting!

The cake is the best wedding cake I ever tasted. She can do anything you ask. I wasn't all that happy with the cake on my wedding day as it was leaking coffee and tilted to the side a bit. When I told her after the wedding, she was responsive to try to make it as right as she could. The cake was still good and I thought it was a good value.

First, Elizabeth is one of the top pastry chefs in Milwaukee WI and her cakes are very popular!! She is very courteous and professional and even opened her store on a Sunday for cake testing. Our wedding cake was out-of-this-world beautiful! She delivered and set up the entire cake table and I didn't have to think twice about how it would go, based on my dealings with her I knew she would take care of it perfectly. My cake was also on a display stand that had to be returned and she comes to get that the next day on her own - you literally do not need to do a thing except pick it out and pay for it!! Oh ...and tha cake itself was to die for....I purchased extra cake for the gift opening the next day but there was none left at the end of the night!! The top of the cake froze and preserved beautifully for 1 year and tasted exactly the same when sealed correctly. I will always do business with Elizabeth's Cakes.