Extraordinary Desserts

I chose to do the smaller wedding cake option instead of the per-person cake because of the price. The decor is whatever the cake is normally in the store, but all of their cakes are gorgeous, so I didn't care. I was so happy with our decision to go with Extraordinary Desserts. We had our main cake which was an 8" on top of a 10", and then 3 additional cakes around it in different flavors. The cake, as always, was absolutely delicious and better than any other wedding cake I have tried. You are sacrificing (if you can call it that) a large, personal wedding cake, but I didn't care much about that. I would rather have a delicious cake than one that you have 2 pictures of and tastes like cardboard. The only issue I had was that they didn't call me back the first time, but my persistence paid off and was well worth it.

I've frequented this establishment on many occasions. My wedding cake, I had known for many years, would be from Extraordinary Desserts. Our wedding was non-traditional so we opted for 3 different cakes rather than having one 3-tiered cake. I made a call to put in an order for the moroccan, blood orange ricotta, and shangri-la. All appropriate choices for my bohemian theme. Well when I had made the order the girl on the phone, Julie, told me that the Moroccan would be unavailable. Like a good customer service rep, called the other location to see if they had any in stock. At first they said no. As she was apologizing for the let down, they called her back a minute later saying they had enough ingredients to make one. It was like magic! 3 days prior to the wedding, Julie called again, to let me know that they couldn't arrange for the size I had requested. Instead it went 2 sizes smaller, which was fine. I just wanted my cake! Which I got and was tasty without a doubt. Everyone enjoyed it and there was not a piece or crumb left behind. Thank you for making my day even more extraordinary, with those divine sweet treats.

For our vow renewal in August of 2011 my mother surprised us by providing two very delicious cakes for our vow renewal. I was very happy with them and they were both very delicious. I did feel that the presentation was not very "wedding" but that is ok with me and probably had to do with what my mother ordered for us. Overall I was pleased with it all. Beautiful and tasty.

I've been going to Extraordinary Desserts for years and was so excited to incorporate them into our wedding. We actually got a few of their standard cakes for the wedding and it was no surprise that everyone raved about the cakes during and after the wedding! Lauren was incredibly helpful in helping us decide which cake types would be able to withstand sitting out at the reception as well as helping us setup the delivery of the cakes.

Extraordinary Desserts did a great job with the cakes for my wedding! We didn't do a wedding cake, we chose 5 of our favorite flavors and got two regular-sized cakes of each (way too much for our 130 people by the way we had half left over), so all I had to do was go in, taste, order (only a couple months in advance, and even then I'm sure I could have ordered them a couple of weeks in advance; for the normal cakes, they do them every day), tell them I wanted one decorated so that we could cut one cake, and ask for delivery. They at first told me a Saturday delivery would be hard because they get very busy, but they called me a little later and said they would be happy to deliver, probably because I ordered so early. I totally forgot about the delivery on the day of the wedding, as did everyone else, but on the day of the wedding there they were, on time, waiting for use to make space in the refrigerator. And, all the cakes were beautiful! Even the ones that I hadn't asked to be decorated. One was more decorated than the others, but really, what they call not decorated is what I call beautiful. And of course they were really delicious, of course, like any cake you get from their storefront. Wedding cakes can be pretty, but not that good, and I didn't want that. This way, there was a flavor for everyone! It worked out perfectly.

Instead of getting a "traditional" wedding cake, we decided to buy four standard 10-inch cakes from Extraordinary Desserts (The Viking, Roasted Coconut, Lemon Riccota, Ivoire Imperial). We paid the extra money for matching decor. Unfortunately, The Viking did not come with matching decor. The other three did. We did not notice until our wedding day. It still looked nice, it was just a bummer that it did not match the others. Nobody noticed but us. Everyone loved the cake, but we bought too much! Our 40 person wedding only consumed about 2 cakes. So, they are big, rich, and go a long way. That being said, a few people said it was the best wedding cake they have ever had!

This was the best bridal shower. I didn’t want anything over the top. We enjoyed some really good food and fun with friends.