If I had to do it again, I would use Garry's Grill for my wedding caterer, but I do have a few comments.
I worked with Eddie and he was incredible the entire time. He helped me create the menu and stay within budget.
The food was INCREDIBLE. We had steak and chicken on a hot-dog budget. Garry's also came all the way out to Frederick, MD on Memorial Day weekend, which was pretty awesome.
The only negative thing I have to say is that they left an hour and a half earlier than I had paid them for and left a lot of trash that my wedding planner had to clean up. Eddie was very apologetic and compensated me for the hours that he and his staff left early, but I still had to address this issue post-wedding. I would hire him again because I think it may have been a miscommunication.