Heavenly Sweets Cakes

We received more complements on our cake than our dinner! Everyone loved it! Tanya knew exactly what we wanted and she made it happen within our budget. We had a butter cake with a caramel filling and a chocolate cake with a raspberry filling. The homemade buttercream icing really set the cake off! It was just spectacular. The cost of delivery was slightly more expensive due to my wedding date (a Sunday) but it was definitely worth it!

The cake was awesome. I received a ton of compliements.

Heavenly Sweets is absolutely the best tasting cake in town. My wedding cake was one of the main highlights of my entire wedding weekend. Tanya and her team listened to what I wanted for my cake and it turned out absolutely perfect! We had order enough for 20 or 30 more than our final count but every piece was eaten as some guests had seconds because it tastes like heaven in your mouth!

What can I say but beautiful and delicious!!! Tanya was awesome to work with. She let us design the cake anyway we wanted. My colors were navy and lime green. I gave them samples of the colors and they matched them perfectly. Another awesome thing they do is give you another top layer of your cake a year later for our 1 year anniversary. The wedding is so busy you barely have time to eat or do anything. It was nice because after we got back from the honeymoon we were able to enjoy our delicious cake and will have a fresh one for our one year. I would recommend them to anyone not only for weddings but for any special events!!!

This is by far the best tasting and looking cake I have ever had. I would highly recommend this place for your wedding and other events needs.

Heavenly Sweets recently made our wedding cake for our May 2nd wedding. We had learned of Heavenly Sweets at my very first bridal show - my mother, maid of honor, and I tasted their cake as soon as we walked in the door. Though we visited many booths, we never forgot Heavenly Sweets' cake. No other cakes came anywhere close to Heavenly Sweets, so after we went to our tasting, we were absolutely hooked. They did such an beautiful job with our wedding cake and a ton of my guests complimented and reiterated how beautiful & AMAZING the cake was. They did an amazing job - from the aesthetics of the cake to the actual taste of the cake, I think that was one of the things we've received the most compliments on since the wedding!!!! It was absolute perfection! Their staff also went above and beyond by going out of their way over the last year and a half to help answer all of my questions and helping with everything (such as being there when our extra ribbon was delivered to their shop, etc.) along the way. Most importantly, my husband and I agree that it made our wedding ceremony extra special! I seriously cannot thank them enough for everything they did. We couldn't have asked for a greater experience for our cake!

If you don't mind spending a little extra for your wedding cake, you will absolutely, positively not regret it! We had so many people say the wedding cake was one of the best they have ever tasted - we are very much looking forward to ordering a cake in a year to celebrate our one-year anniversary!

Heavenly Sweets provided the best cake for a good price! Very professional. Highly recommended!

Although their prices were slightly high; the people were very friendly and had the absolute best testing cake ever! It was so awesome that for my husbands graduation I got the same exact kind of cake that we had at our wedding! (butter cream cake with butter cream icing and raspberry filling).

We were very pleased with Heavenly sweets. The taste testing was great. It allowed us to taste many different possibilities. But the owner had very quickly recommended two combinations: 1) the almond cake with white choclate mousse filling and apricot jam and 2) the choclate cake with raspberry filling. It was delicious. We are about an hour away so we went to pick up the cake the day before. it was ready on time and tasted very fresh. We received MANY compliments regarding the cake and it is now all gone :( We also ordered the cake only 2 months before the wedding. I would definitely recommend this vendor!

I loved my wedding cake! It was beautiful and one of the best tasting cakes I've ever eaten. I ordered white cake with chocolate ganache filling and my husband got a spice cake for his grooms cake. Both were exceptional and our guests loved them. This is an exceptional baker and I would recommend them to anyone needing a special occasion cake. The only slightly negative comment I have is that the tasting was a little bit confusing. However, the owner apologized that she was having a bad day and we were able to get everything straightened out to choose the perfect cake.

What can I say? The cake was amazing!!! Everyone still tells me how good it was.

At the tasting you are able to sample several different cakes and fillings. I'll admit they seem a little pricey to me but the cake is soo good that I can't really complain. The staff delivered the cake on-time and it was exactly the way we ordered it. Yum!

Absolutely fabulous cake with beautiful designs. It is a little expensive, but well worth it.

They were marvelous! I had so many people tell me how beautiful the cake was! I had one groomsmen claim that it had to be fake and almost stick his finger in it! I had so many people compliement me on how incredible it tasted. They definitely do have the best cakes in Indianapolis. It was a great price too! The only thing that I thought was expensive was that my 8x8 grooms cake was $100.

I forgot to send my ribbon in for the cake (I wanted a black ribbon with rhinestones and they don't provide that as rhinestones are expensive) and they even called me a couple of days before it was due to remind me. And suggested where I go to get it.

Several of our guest said that it was the best wedding cake they'd ever had, and we would have to agree! it was the perfect addition to our meal!

The best place to get wedding cakes! I'm not much of a cake eater myself but this place was by far excellent and the taste and flavor of the cake itself was exquisite. A little pricey than I would like for my cake but not too bad than most places for wedding cakes and actually very affordable and is willing to work on your budget for a wedding cake. Overall I enjoyed the visit to their wedding cake shop and tasting the cakes and fillings they had. Very delicious! Bon apetite~!

Delicious cakes-lots of examples in the store for you to see immediately, sampling of flavors, icings, and fillings is helpful. The wedding cake was a little expensive, but worth it-offer a deal for free cakestand rental with refundable deposit. I had so many compliments from friends and family about how tasty the cake was. My reception planner moved the cake table to the center of the dance floor because of Heavenly Sweets' decorating expertise.

The cake from Heavenly Sweets was really fabulous. It is the best fondant frosting I have ever tasted. We had fresh fruit as our cake topper and they did find excellent fresh fruit. Their cakes are pricey and they have very specific rules on displaying the cake, but it is worth it. Our guests raved about the cake and asked me who the baker was. I would highly recommend them.

Heavenly Sweets made the very best wedding cake! After several different tastings, their's was the most professional, imaginative and tasty! They provided a wide variety of tastes and options during the tasting. The staff were very helpful in the planning process and willing try whatever I wanted. They had the most moist cake and the best buttercream of anyone in the Indy area! I highly recommend their cake and their service to any bride and groom!

We searched everywhere for a cake made from scratch with great ingredients since I am a total food snob. :) We found the best was at Heavenly Sweets -- no one else compared in taste and quality. We were so happy with the cake....we cannot wait until our 1-year anniversary to eat the top.

The only reason I gave them a 4 for flexibility is because you have to pay for almost every little change, even for separating the layers. The taste and quality of the cake were out of this world. They are really pricing at $750 for 132 for the low end cake. However, even people who don't like cake much said they thought this was delicious!

The cake was the best, they use buttercream and its delicious!

We received more complements on our cake than our dinner! Everyone loved it! Tanya knew exactly what we wanted and she made it happen within our budget. We had a butter cake with a caramel filling and a chocolate cake with a raspberry filling. The homemade buttercream icing really set the cake off! It was just spectacular.

The cake was beautiful and amazing. Our guests said it was the best wedding cake they had ever had.

If you're looking for a baker in the Indianapolis area, the best tasting cakes come from Heavenly Sweets. So if best tasting is your first priority then I would recommend this bakery. The down side is that they aren't terribly creative with the cake design. Because they don't use fondant (which does hurt the taste of the cake), they can't make really extravagant looking designs. So I'd keep it simple with the look of the cake if you want it to taste really good.

The taste of the cake was wonderful. The only downside to Heavenly Sweets was we felt that they were not quite as flexible in what they would do/wouldn't do. If you go with Heavenly, your cake will taste good, however, if you want something a little more unique, they will nickle and dime you.

Tanya (the owner of the shop) was very enthusiastic when helping us order our cake. We are going on our 1 year anniversary and they give us a free 6" cake, the same as the top on our original wedding cake, for free. That was a major plus! Also, the cake was DELICIOUS!

Beautiful cakes, that taste amazing. A little pricey.

Heavenly sweets has by far the best wedding cake I have ever tasted! I received so many compliments on the cake! My only issue with them was that I ordered my cake almost a full year in advance and wanted a monogram topper. They called me 3 weeks before my wedding and told me they would not be able to have my monogram in and so i needed to pick another topper. My florist was able to leave some extra flowers during her delivery to use for the top of the cake, and Tanya of heavenly sweets did a great job using them to make the cake look beautiful.

Everyone we talked to enjoyed our cake. They were able to make our wedding cake wishes come true. They even answered their phone number and met us at the shop on a day they were closed because we had ribbon for them. The day before the wedding they called me to tell me that they did not have enough of our ribbon. After they looked at the cake contract they saw that they would have enough ribbon. I do not understand why they did not look at the wedding contract while they were making the cake, or why they did not check it before they called me. The cake looked beautiful on the day of the wedding.

The cake was good, but I would not say that it was the best I ever tasted. Even if the owner feels otherwise. I don't believe the cake was worth the money we spent, but they were accomodating to our last minute order when the original plans fell through.

Though our wedding cake was very tasty and pretty, I was very unhappy with our vendor. During our tasting our representative was unprofessional and spent more time talking to my mother-in-law than to me or the groom! When describing what I wanted she tried to talk us into a totally different idea. She then talked us into buying more than we even needed. We were then told we would have to pick up our own wedding cake due to having our wedding on a Sunday. After finding this out, I called and they agreed to deliver it for $125. When they brought the cake- they had no directions to set it up and were not going to set it up were it not for my bridesmaids.

Over all- the cake was good and I would reccomend their service for smaller events but not large weddings. They are also way over priced.

It was more expensive than we planned. The woman who runs this business is not very easy to communicate with. I didn't mind putting up with her being rude because the cakes they make are the BEST in Indiana. Minus a few stars for loosing the cake topper, and for the flexibility. They are so delicious, but if you plan on hiring them, send a mother in-law to do your "dirty work". That would make it much easier :)

If you want a great tasting cake this is the place to go with. The only downside is it's pretty expensive. They aren't very flexible with change. Also, I had a problem with the last payment they wanted in cash rather than a check. Unfortunately I don't have a bank in the area so I had to scramble to find a way for cash. I've heard of other people having similar problems. Also, they would not make my cake smaller for me when I found that I wasn't going to have as many guests. Something I feel they should have been understanding about. However, the cake was beautiful and delicious.

The cake was second to none. It was the most delicious cake I have ever tasted. However, Heavenly Sweets is unable to do anything creative from a decorating perspective. The owner is less than personable. Also, she will not deliver the cake until the very last minute. It was interesting because the owner of the site where we had our wedding confirmed that Heavenly Sweets has the best cake, but it is always an unsettling experience dealing with them because the cake is always delivered at the last minute. If you ask around, you'll find others will say the same thing.

First, I want to say that our cake tasted great. However - lots of bakeries make great tasting wedding cakes.

I wanted to do my best to use as many small, local businesses as possible for our October 2010 wedding, and one thing I wish I had changed was our baker selection.

We scheduled an appointment for a tasting, and first we were locked out of the building. We were right on time, but another appointment was inside and the mother of the bride had LOCKED THE DOOR so no one could interrupt their appointment. Winter in Indiana - I don't want to be locked outside. Finally after us knocking and peering in the windows, said mother of bride (who at the time we thought was staff, we didn't realize everything until after we were in) opened the door and siad "Oh. The wind must have blown it locked." Now - I know the baker herself wasn't the one who locked us out, but why was she not even aware enough to know it happened?

Next, we had to stand and wait for 20 minutes while the appointment in front of us ran over. I was very clear on the phone that we were coming from out of state, and would not be able to reschedule this appointment, so we had to just wait it out. Finally, 25 minutes after our starting appointment time we were ushered in to sit down and start out tasting.

She was very rude and kept rushing the appointment. Then, her next appointment came early, so she SUPER rushed through ours and then WHAM BAM no thank you ma'am, we were done and out the door.

In the end, our cake tasted great, but the service was TERRIBLE. If we were living in state and had the time to meet with more bakers we would have, but in the end we didn't have the time to be driving back and forth from MI to IN just for cake.

The rest of her staff is friendly, but the actual baker/owner came off as very cocky, arrogant, and as if we weren't worth her time because we weren't going to spend $1k+ on a...

The entire experience was anything but Heavenly. If you have had these cakes and love the taste (they are delicious!) I suggest getting a small cake for a birthday or something. Getting a cake from a place with as little customer service and flexibility as this place is a mistake--- it added a huge amount of stress to my wedding day. I will not get into the crazy details-- but the cake came in a completely wrong shape and in a terribly wrong color-- I also had to have a friend pick it up because they would not deliver. The entire ordering process was rushed and pressured, but because it tasted so good, we went with them. I WOULD NOT use this vendor for your wedding.

We've worked with Heavenly Sweets on several different occasions, and they have always been professional . Not only are their cakes delicious but they are also beautiful.

Heavenly Sweets Cakes truly loves sitting down with the Bride & Groom giving you what you want for you and your guests to see, smell, taste and smile about! They can cater to your traditional wedding cake or something trendy too!

Heavenly Sweets is the place for cakes!!!

Heavenly Sweets is a phenomenal cake company that we love to work with. Their cakes are gorgeous and delicous!
Kim King Smith Events