Penny Steele

Best cake ever! Don't even bother looking any further than Penny Steele. We tried several of Penny's cakes and they were all delicious. We ended up chosing caramel apple cake and death by chocolate- both delicious! Penny is great to work with- very responsive and reasonably priced. She is also great at decorating the cake too!

Penny makes the BEST cake I have ever eaten. It is really that good!She is a bit on the expensive end but I think she can charge that because the cake tastes amazing.

Carmel Apple Cake. Enough said. Our photographer has raved about it, our guests have raved about it. 2 weeks after the wedding, our families had orfdered 2 more of the same cakes from Penny for other occasisions. She is amazing and it is delicious. Just perfect!!

We absolutely LOVED Penny's cakes. I ordered a suprise groom's cake from her, as well as our wedding cake. I wanted the groom's cake to be in the same of the Mac symbol with caramel apple filling. I was so amazed by how great it looked and how wonderful it tasted. My groom was so impressed that he felt bad cutting it open! Our wedding cake had two flavors: white chocolate raspberry and baily's chocolate fudge. We ordered way more cake than the number of guests invited, hoping that we could take the rest home with us. I was wrong! Our guests we back for multiple pieces of cake, saying it was the best cake they had ever eaten. It wouldn't call Penny's cake...cake...I would seriously call it a dessert experience. Truly amazing. The buttercream was delicious and the fondant decorating was breathtaking.She is expensive, but if you can afford to splurge a little, it is well worth it. We certainly plan on going back on our anniversary and getting another cake from her.

The best cake I have ever had in my life. My groom who does not like cake even liked the cake! We got rave reviews from all of our guests. We had extra cake servings put out and there was absolutely nothing left at the end of the night!Not only was the cake great, but she has some of the best prices around and our cake looked fantastic! I would highly recommend her, and I will be looking for an excuse to use her again.

Ok honestly, don't waste any time trying other cakes. I will guarantee you that Penny Steele's cakes are the best you've ever tried. Or you can call all of my guests at my wedding, they will tell you the same thing. Because that's what they were telling me all night at the wedding, and afterwards! She has different types of flavors available, all are out-of-control delicious. We had the chocolate baileys and the caramel apple. Even some of the guys were telling me about how they don't care about cake but the cake was amazing. And the cake decoration was flawless, Penny makes yummy and beautiful cakes. If you take any of my reviews to heart, take this one! You won't be disappointed!


 I was referred here through Janet Wilcox, a good friend of mine. When we first started the cake process I did not realize how expensive everything would cost, and I almost said forget it but we got an alcohol cake (the filling was made with bailey’s) and it had a chocolate crème filling. To die for, it was the best cake I have ever had!