Petonios Pastry

I chose Petonios because my mom and dad had gotten their wedding cake from them 40 years ago! When we went there to taste cakes and I told the owner that, he said wait a minute and walked in the back. He came out with a book and showed me my mothers cake order from 40 years ago! He blew my mind and made my heart so happy that he had cared to save those memories for so many years. Beyond the family feel they gave us, the cake was absolutely AMAZING!!! It was georgous and tasted as good as it looked! We highly recommend you get your wedding cake from Petonios and I look forward for my child to pick their cake out for their wedding from Petonios in another 40 years :) Thank you so much Petonios for such an extra special memory you gave us xoxoxo Love, The Sabo/Girardi Family Cheers to another 40 years :)

This is the best bakery there is for wedding cakes. I asked for a castle cake to go with my cinderella theme wedding and they did an awesome job. They have never done a cake like this before and it was terrific. I would recommend them for all your cake and pastries needs. There pastries are awesome also.

I was very impressed by Petonios Pastry! My fiance and I could not decide on a flavor so they made us a multi-flavored cake! It was amazing and our guests loved the choice of chocolate cake or vanilla with rasberry! Also I went there once and explained my vision of a white 4 tier cake with cascading silver stars. I never went back to check on the cake and I never needed to. When I saw my cake at the reception, it was my exact vision. I recommend them to all brides!

5 Stars all across! They were great and our cake was great!

This is the bakery in East Haven, CT that did our wedding cake. When my husband and I went to the tasting, we were very impressed by the friendly demeanor of the staff and by how good all the cake tasted! We had a difficult time choosing which flavor we wanted.

At the wedding we had many compliments about our cake (can you believe it? Who usually remembers the cake?). We were very happy with this bakery and would definitely recommend them.

Our experience with this bakery was wonderful. They were very helpful in choosing our cake and let us try all different kinds to find one we liked. The owner is very easy to work with and we had great compliments on our cake—it was delicious!