Rental Depot Inc. & Party Station
They weren't very professional, and weren't exactly nice, either. But the price was decent, so we went ahead with them, anyway
Pretty decent vendor, we were able to get the items that we wanted at the time we needed them. Likewise we were able to add in more items at the last minute, and thankfully they had the items in stock for us to rent. All in all, we rented: Dance floor, mirror ball and lights, pipe and drape, bass candle aisle candle holders, and a wishing well box for cards. All items were of good quality and functional for our purposes on the wedding day. Return policy was a little strict, as they want the items back pretty quickly, but all in all, not a bad vendor to work with. We didn't shop around, so I'm not too sure on the prices, how they would compare to competition (if there is any in the Rochester area).