Reuters Bakery

Our wedding cake was tasty and looked exactly like the inspiration photo we emailed. At the tasting, it was clear that they cared about our business and wanted us to get the combination of flavors that we wanted. There was a minor mix-up with the flavor of the groom's cake, but we're not sure if that was on the catering or bakery side. Overall, a good experience.

We LOVE Reuters! The cake we chose was so delicious and beautiful at the same time. The price was a great value, they even delivered for us! The only thing (which I didn't know about until two days after the wedding) was the butter cream frosting with purple piping was a bad combination. The purple bled a little onto the ivory frosting. However, I never knew this because once the cake was brought on site, they fixed it for us! When I got to see the cake for the first time it looked so perfect I couldn't even see what the problem had been. The cake itself was delicious and moist. We went with alternating layers of chocolate cake with vanilla custard filling and yellow cake with chocolate custard filling. Our guests loved it! Since all of the cake was eaten (it was THAT good!) we are going to have them recreate the top tier for our 1 year anniversary. Highly recommend these guys for any of your baked goods!!

We had a terrific experience with Reuters. Dropped by one Saturday morning for a tasting (without an appointment) and were greeted warmly by Nancy and offered the book and choices of cake and filling samples. We ordered the cake through our caterer (Twomaytoz), and it looked great and tasted superb! Did not have choose any monograms or bridal adornments but the cake was gorgeous nonetheless. Many wedding cakes look far better than they taste, but this was a notable exception. Love this place and wouldn't hesitate recommending it.

The professionalism at first was great but after placing my order i called back to make the cake square and not round, first the message never got to the baker and i still ended up with a round cake and the the "red" ribbons that were suppose to outline the cake turned out to be orangy but they replaced it to the right color but that lead to lots of imperfections around the cake. the tastes of the red velvet was good but what i paid for the cake "$500" for only 90 people was not worth the quality or appearance. i was greatly disapponted....

Reuters Bakery is THE place to get your wedding cake. The staff were very attentive when we first walked in to do our tasting, they weren't pushy and the cake was GREAT! I had plenty of time planning my wedding so when i went in to make my FINAL purchase they were very pleased that i came back and i was not disappointed. I have been to so many weddings where no one touches the cake... but alas EVERYONE had a piece of cake! It was decorated exactly as i had asked and more. Thank you Reuters!

Many kudos were received on the cake! Reuters did a fantastic job and we planned the wedding from where we live in Baltimore, so did a weekend of meeting vendors in Chicago and tasted cakes from three places; Reuters not only tasted the best, but we felt great about their friendly customer service and reliability. We ended up ordering via phone and the cake was delivered just exactly as we wanted it to look without a single other effort then the one phone call. Highly recommend them... and the cake tasted fabulous!!

The cake looked and tasted great. The only complaint I have is that they were supposed to put our monogram on the top of our cake, and they forgot to do it. We went through the trouble of sending them a copy of our monogram, but it never got done. Aside from that, we were pleased with their service.

Two words: YUM! B-E-A-UTIFUL!!!!!

Reuter's Bakery of Chicago created our gorgeous and delicious wedding cake. At the reception, we barely had time to eat it, but the few bites we snagged were amazing. When we selected our cake, we were provided with a huge selection and they worked within our budget. The day of the wedding, the icing was done beautifully with detailed embellishments. It was a work of art!