Reverend Jeremy Myers
It's an old church in our hometown and isn't used as much these days because they opened up the new one across the street (so ask ahead if you want the AC on and running for a while), but it holds a special place in our hearts. It's also very lovely and traditional.
This is a great Catholic priest. He really repsects the union of marriage and has a pretty proven pre marital program. He is strict on his marriage regulations but he will work with you if there is something you really want. Sorry, at least one of you has to be Catholic to get married by him.